Phillip Carl Jablonski

Victims
3 California murders, 1978 and 1991, by final conviction. Also accused in the 1991 deaths of Fathyma Vann (Riverside County) and Margie Rogers (Utah); how those cases ended is not recorded.
Years active
July 16, 1978; April 22 to 27, 1991
Location
Highland and the Loma Linda area, California (1978); Indio, Riverside County (parole and the Vann killing); Burlingame and Millbrae, San Mateo County (1991); Wyoming.
Method
Linda Kimball died of asphyxiation; Fathyma Vann, Eva Petersen and Carol Spadoni were shot (stabbing and suffocation contributed to Spadoni's death).
Status
Sentenced to death August 12, 1994; judgment affirmed January 23, 2006. Died on San Quentin's death row December 27, 2019, aged 73; the cause awaited an autopsy and no result was reported.

Phillip Carl Jablonski spent most of the 1970s and 1980s in California prisons, first for a rape and then for killing Linda Kimball, the mother of his daughter. He was paroled in September 1990. His wife, Carol Spadoni, and her mother, Eva Petersen, had both said before his release that they were afraid of him, and his parole conditions barred him from Burlingame, where the two women lived. On April 23, 1991, both were killed in their home there. A San Mateo County jury convicted him of their first-degree murders in April 1994, rejected his insanity plea, and returned death verdicts. The California Supreme Court affirmed the judgment in 2006.

In the same week of April 1991, a classmate of his, Fathyma Vann, was found dead outside Indio, and a Utah store owner, Margie Rogers, was found dead in Thompson Springs. Utah prosecutors charged him with capital homicide in the Rogers case, and a case over Vann's death was pending in Riverside County in 1991. How either case ended was not reported. A tape found in his car, in his own voice, described those killings along with the two in Burlingame. He died on San Quentin's death row on December 27, 2019, at 73.

A violent household

His sister testified that their father was an abusive alcoholic who beat his wife and children. Other witnesses said the father carried a gun and was cruel to animals. By her account, Phillip was the child beaten most often, because he tried to protect their mother. She also said a neighbor had molested him when he was four or five; prosecution rebuttal witnesses disputed parts of the abuse account. Witnesses described him as a quiet, anxious child, and his sister remembered him as a "Goody-Two-Shoes."

The same sister told the jury of an attack on her. When she was 14 and he was 16, he attacked her and threatened her, then stopped, apologized and cried. Their father beat him after she told their parents.

The Army and a first marriage

Jablonski was in the cadet corps in high school and enlisted in the Army in 1966. He was sent overseas. He always said he had served in Vietnam, and his discharge papers list the Vietnam Service Medal, but the court found that his military records did not clearly show service there. An Associated Press account in 2019 called him a sergeant who had served two tours and said he was discharged in 1969 for a "schizophrenic illness." The court records that he left the service in July 1969.

After coming home from overseas in 1968 he married his first wife, who joined him in Texas, where he was stationed. She later testified that he tried repeatedly to strangle or smother her, and that he once nearly drowned her in the bathtub. After that incident, the court wrote, the military hospitalized him for psychiatric treatment rather than disciplining him.

1968 to 1972

In November 1968 he met another woman, who testified at his 1994 penalty trial. In July 1969, after he left the Army, they moved to California with her pregnant, living first with his parents and then in a house of their own. She described years of violence, including threats with a pistol and smothering. In 1972 she left him, taking their children.

At the time he delivered and trained dogs for a company that supplied guard dogs. On December 17, 1972, he raped a woman. He was held until police arrived. "I don't know why I did it," he said after his arrest, according to the court. He later told a psychiatrist that he planned to plead insanity because he hoped to beat the case with a psychiatric defense. He went to prison for the rape.

Linda Kimball

Jablonski met Linda Kimball in February 1977. By August they were living together, and in December 1977 their daughter was born.

On the night of July 6, 1978, Kimball's mother woke to find him attacking her. He stopped, saying he kept seeing her daughter's face, and she got away. Out of concern for her daughter she did not go to the police. She called the Veterans Administration hospital at Loma Linda instead and spoke to a doctor there, who told her not to call the police.

A few days later Kimball left him and moved in with her mother. On the Monday after the attack she drove him to the Loma Linda VA hospital, and the staff declined to admit him. Two days before her death she took him to a second appointment there, and again he was not admitted. Linda Kimball was found dead on July 16, 1978. She died of asphyxiation.

Jablonski was arrested in Arizona eleven days later. Police found a note in his handwriting that began "Killed to date" and gave her name and the words "commonlaw wife." The court records that in the same period, after Kimball's death and before his arrest, he went to a woman's home in Highland, California, on the pretext of answering an advertisement for a stove, threatened her young son with a knife, attacked her in front of her children, and took her wallet and purse.

In 1978 he pleaded guilty to second-degree murder, assault and attempted rape in the Kimball case, the Associated Press reported in 2019. The AP did not report his sentence.

Prison years

In prison Jablonski placed a personal advertisement in a newspaper. Carol Spadoni answered it, and in 1982 they married at San Quentin, where he was serving his sentence for Kimball's murder. The same year a San Quentin psychiatrist diagnosed him as schizophrenic. Jablonski told him that while rubbing his new wife's neck during a visit, he had felt troubling urges to wrap her hair around it.

In July 1985, during a 72-hour family visit at the California Men's Colony, he attacked his mother. He was angry that his wife had not come with his parents. He choked his mother and dragged her into the bedroom of the visiting trailer until his father came to help her. He later blamed the attack on a flashback to Vietnam. Associated Press accounts in 2019 and 2020 said he tried to strangle her with a shoelace, and that he was paroled in 1990 for good behavior despite the attack.

Warnings before release

In the summer of 1990, with his release near, both women in the Burlingame house said they were afraid of him. Eva Petersen telephoned a friend of his from prison and asked him to collect belongings Jablonski had sent to her home. She said she did not want him on her property because she was afraid he might harm her. Carol Spadoni told a friend she wanted to end the relationship, called her husband "weird," and said she was afraid of him. When his parole agent, Robert Paredes, asked whether Jablonski could live with her, she said no, because she was afraid of him.

A Department of Corrections release report classified him as a psychiatric inmate. It recorded a staff psychologist's view that although his illness was in remission, he "could become actively psychotic at any time."

Parole in Indio

Jablonski was released from the state prison at Vacaville in September 1990. The friend from prison picked him up and took him to Sacramento, and from there he went to Indio, in Riverside County, to report to Paredes. His conditions of parole forbade him to travel more than 50 miles from his residence without permission and forbade him to go to Burlingame at all. He was required to get mental health counseling.

On November 30, 1990, he saw Dr. Sylvia Winters for an intake examination at the Loma Linda VA. He told her he had been hearing voices and having nightmares, and that he had stopped taking the medication prescribed for him. She made a tentative diagnosis of schizophrenia and added a provisional diagnosis of posttraumatic stress disorder.

At Christmas 1990 he asked Paredes for permission to visit his friend in Sacramento and get a driver's license. Paredes called Carol Spadoni, who did not object, and approved the trip. Jablonski spent a week there and came back with a license and a 1965 Ford Fairlane. In January 1991 he enrolled in automotive classes at the College of the Desert. A classmate thought him very intelligent.

In February 1991 a second VA psychiatrist, Dr. Charles Sprague, saw him for a medication check. Jablonski said his mood was fine, denied any wish to hurt anyone, and said he was taking his medication. Sprague found nothing that would justify committing him against his will. A VA social worker saw him every two or three weeks for about four months; at their last meeting, on April 4, 1991, he reported more nightmares. After his arrest, searchers found his bottles of psychiatric medication still full.

The manager of the hotel where he lived that spring testified that he acted like a normal person and showed no sign of mental illness. In March 1991 he told her he planned to move north, and that he would have his wife write a "lying letter" saying she would move to Sacramento with him.

Around April 18, 1991, Jablonski asked a classmate to sell him a small gun. Two days later the classmate agreed and sold him a .22-caliber revolver. As a convicted felon, Jablonski knew he could not legally have one.

Fathyma Vann

Fathyma Vann was 38, a resident of Indio and a student at the same college. She also used the name Fanny Hansen.

On Monday, April 22, 1991, Jablonski told his instructor that he would miss the next day's class for a doctor's appointment. That evening the instructor saw him with Vann. Jablonski gave her a ride home from class. A classmate testified that he too would have been in the car, but because a videotape machine was broken, Jablonski dropped him at a restaurant about 7:30 p.m. Vann's body was found the next day, April 23, in the desert outside Indio. She had been shot. Jablonski never went back to class.

Burlingame, April 23

On April 23, 1991, Jablonski was in Burlingame, the city his parole forbade him to enter. That afternoon a Burlingame police officer cited him for failing to yield and saw no sign that he was drunk or nervous. The same afternoon, at a bank in Millbrae, he cashed a $200 check made out to him on Eva Petersen's account. The signature did not match the one on her bank card, and a teller later identified him. He also withdrew $500 from his own savings account.

Carol Spadoni was 46 and her mother, Eva Petersen, was 72. They lived together in Burlingame. Both were killed there on April 23. Both were shot. The jury later found true special circumstances that Petersen was killed during the commission of rape and sodomy.

A friend of the two women met them for coffee three times a week. He telephoned on April 24 and got no answer. On April 26 he drove to the house and saw several days of newspapers in the yard and the women's cats without food or water. He called the police, and an officer who arrived at about 7:20 that morning found both women dead.

By then Jablonski was driving east. On April 25, 1991, at a rest stop in Wyoming, he pointed a gun at a woman. She escaped when he dropped it, and she called the police from the next truck stop. An officer questioned him, accepted his explanation that the gun had fallen out of his car, and let him go. At trial the prosecution played part of his tape to show what he had intended at the rest stop. The San Mateo Daily Journal later reported that on the tape he could be heard saying that he needed a trucker to leave, and that the trucker stayed and the woman drove away.

Margie Rogers, 58, lived in Thompson Springs, in Grand County, Utah, where she and her husband ran a store. She was found dead in Thompson Springs on April 27, 1991. She had been shot, and money was missing, the Associated Press reported.

Arrest in Kansas

On April 28, 1991, Jablonski was arrested in Kansas. The San Mateo Daily Journal reported that a Kansas state trooper stopped him for a traffic violation. He had $710 in cash, a $90 check drawn on Eva Petersen's account and credit cards in her name. In his wallet was an address book listing his wife and her mother, and under their names the words "Death, April 23rd, 1991." The date of their deaths had not been made public.

In his car police found a loaded .22-caliber revolver and matching ammunition, a stun gun, other items, and an empty knife sheath. A belt bore the names and dates of victims, among them "4-23-1991, Burlingame, California" and "Fathyma N. Hansen, 4-22-91." A handwriting expert matched the writing to Jablonski. Vann's military identification card was in the car. So was a tape on which Jablonski, in his own voice, described the killings.

On May 1, 1991, Detective Mark Barfknecht of the Riverside County Sheriff's Department and Sergeant Eric Haseleu of the Burlingame police questioned Jablonski from about 10:30 a.m. to 2:30 p.m. Before they began, the two officers agreed that if he asked for a lawyer they would keep questioning him anyway, to gather material that could be used to impeach him if he testified and to develop leads. He asked for a lawyer 11 times. At one point Haseleu told him that the tape would never be heard by anybody except the two of them. The trial court later found some of his statements involuntary because of promises and improper influence, and set rules for any use of them if he testified. He did not testify.

Three cases in two states

A San Mateo County grand jury indicted Jablonski on June 14, 1991, for the murders of Carol Spadoni and Eva Petersen. The indictment alleged special circumstances: multiple murder, a prior murder, and, for Petersen, rape and sodomy. It also alleged that he personally used a firearm.

In July 1991 prosecutors in Grand County, Utah, filed a criminal complaint charging him with capital homicide in the death of Margie Rogers. The charges, filed in 7th Circuit Court in Moab, were first-degree murder, aggravated sexual assault and aggravated robbery. The Associated Press, reporting the Utah charges, called it the third death penalty case pending against him, after the San Mateo case and one in Riverside County, where Fathyma Vann had died. Authorities told the AP that all four women had been shot, and that three of the four knew him personally.

Proceedings in San Mateo County were suspended on June 3, 1993, so that a jury could decide whether Jablonski was competent to stand trial. Four experts testified. A defense psychiatrist found that he had schizophrenia, could not help in his defense, and was not malingering. Two court-appointed experts first thought he might be incompetent and then changed their views: one concluded he was competent and "without a doubt" malingering, and the other said there was not enough data to decide but strongly suspected malingering. The prosecution's expert found him competent and malingering. Over a defense objection, the court let the jury hear the Kansas tape, finding it highly probative on whether he was feigning. On November 10, 1993, the jury found him competent.

Jury selection began on January 25, 1994. The jury heard, among other things, the women's statements that they feared him, the address book, the check, the items from his car and the tape. On April 25, 1994, it convicted him of the first-degree murders of Carol Spadoni and Eva Petersen and found the special circumstances true. On April 26 it found true the special circumstance that he had committed a prior murder.

Jablonski had pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity, and the sanity phase ran from May 2 to May 10, 1994. Dr. Kormos, for the defense, diagnosed chronic schizophrenia and testified that Jablonski could not tell right from wrong at the time of the killings. Dr. Vitali Rozynko, appointed by the court, agreed that he was schizophrenic and psychotic but found him legally sane. He called the crimes "goal directed," pointing to the gun bought in advance, the drive to Burlingame and the items in the car, and to what Jablonski did afterward: he showered and shaved, went to a bank and cashed a check, and drove to Utah. A second court-appointed expert, Dr. Wilkinson, diagnosed posttraumatic stress disorder and sexual sadism, found that he was malingering, and testified that he understood right from wrong. On May 10 the jury found him sane.

The penalty phase

The penalty phase began on May 17, 1994. The prosecution put before the jury the violence of his earlier life: the attack on his sister, his first wife's account, the account of the woman he lived with from 1968 to 1972, the 1972 rape, the July 1978 attack on Linda Kimball's mother, the Highland attack, and the 1985 attack on his mother. A woman who had written to him through a prison letter program testified that when she visited him after his release, he told her he had dug a grave for her and then assaulted her; she survived by pretending to be dead. The prosecution also presented what the California Supreme Court called "evidence of two other murders defendant committed in the same time frame as the charged offenses," the deaths of Fathyma Vann and Margie Rogers, along with the Wyoming rest stop incident.

The defense answered with his childhood: his sister's account of the father's brutality, the molestation she described, other witnesses who described a lonely and anxious boy, and his psychiatric records, including Dr. Winters's diagnoses and the VA's refusal to hospitalize him before Kimball's death. Prosecution rebuttal witnesses disputed parts of the abuse account and described him as seeming normal to the hotel manager and to a VA psychiatrist. On June 17, 1994, the jury returned death verdicts on both counts.

On August 12, 1994, the court denied the automatic motion to modify the verdicts and sentenced Jablonski to death on each count. Five-year firearm enhancements were imposed and stayed, and the prior-conviction allegations were struck at the prosecution's request. He arrived on California's death row on August 19, 1994, according to the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation.

The appeal

The appeal was automatic and went directly to the California Supreme Court. In an opinion filed January 23, 2006, the court affirmed the convictions and the death sentences.

The court found that the presence of unauthorized deputy prosecutors before the grand jury was a technical violation of state law but caused no actual prejudice. It upheld the compelled competency examinations, the use of the Kansas tape at the competency trial, the competency standard and instructions, and the decision to keep a juror who had received a crank call.

Its sharpest words were for the May 1 interrogation. The court held that Jablonski's statement was voluntary: the questioning lasted about four hours with breaks, the tone was not harsh, he was a mature man with a long criminal record, and he gave the officers little of use. It added that any error was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt, since the evidence of premeditation was overwhelming and much of it came from his own taped account. But it said that its ruling did not excuse the officers' repeated refusal to honor his request for counsel. Deliberately violating Miranda in that way, the court wrote, was "unethical" and "must be strongly disapproved," and "respect for the rule of law is not advanced when the guardians of the law elect to deliberately violate it."

The court also held that the women's statements that they feared him should not have been admitted to show their state of mind, which was not in dispute, but that Petersen's statement could be considered for its effect on Jablonski, bearing on premeditation, and that any error was harmless. It held the stun gun and the other items found in the car relevant to premeditation.

Death at San Quentin

Jablonski spent the rest of his life on death row at San Quentin State Prison, where he was assigned a single cell, a corrections spokeswoman told the Associated Press. At 1:10 p.m. on Friday, December 27, 2019, staff found him unresponsive in his cell. He was pronounced dead at 1:30 p.m. He was 73. The Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation announced the death on December 30 and said the cause was pending the results of an autopsy. CBS San Francisco reported that the Marin County coroner would determine the cause. No result has been reported.

He was never executed. When he died, the department counted 728 people on California's death row.

After his death the San Mateo County district attorney, Steve Wagstaffe, told the San Mateo Daily Journal that his predecessor, Jim Fox, and the prosecutor who tried the case regarded Jablonski as the most evil criminal they had prosecuted, and that he agreed.

Disputed and unproven points

The Vann and Rogers cases. Utah charged Jablonski with capital homicide in Margie Rogers's death in July 1991, and a case over Fathyma Vann's death was pending in Riverside County that year, according to the Associated Press. CBS San Francisco reported in 2019 that he was "also convicted" of both killings. The Associated Press in 2019 and 2020 said only that he was "implicated" in the two deaths. No court record or official release confirming a conviction in either case has been reported; both remain killings he was accused of and described on his own tape, not convictions.

Vietnam. He claimed Vietnam service and his discharge papers list the Vietnam Service Medal, but the California Supreme Court found his records unclear. The AP's description of two tours as a sergeant is not confirmed by the court record.

Linda Kimball's name and status. The court record calls her Linda Kimball and quotes his note describing her as his "commonlaw wife." The Associated Press called her Melinda Kimball and his second wife, and CDCR described her as a previous wife.

How he met Carol Spadoni. The court record says she answered a personal advertisement he placed in a newspaper. The San Mateo Daily Journal called her a pen pal he met in prison.

The arrest. The San Mateo Daily Journal reported that he was on his way to Kentucky to kill again when a Kansas trooper stopped him, and that he wore a belt with a notch for each killing. The court record describes a belt with victims' names and dates written on it. The Kentucky claim remains unconfirmed.

His age at death. CDCR and the AP gave 73; CBS San Francisco gave 72.

Timeline

1966: Enlists in the Army.

1968: Marries his first wife; hospitalized by the military for psychiatric treatment after nearly drowning her.

July 1969: Leaves the Army and moves to California.

December 17, 1972: Rapes a woman; later imprisoned for the rape.

February 1977: Meets Linda Kimball; their daughter is born in December.

July 6, 1978: Attacks Kimball's mother in her bed.

July 16, 1978: Linda Kimball is found dead of asphyxiation.

July 1978: Arrested in Arizona eleven days later.

1978: Pleads guilty to second-degree murder, assault and attempted rape.

1982: Marries Carol Spadoni at San Quentin.

July 1985: Attacks his mother during a family visit at the California Men's Colony.

Summer 1990: Eva Petersen and Carol Spadoni say they fear him.

September 1990: Paroled from Vacaville; barred from Burlingame.

November 30, 1990: Tells a VA psychiatrist he hears voices and has stopped his medication.

January 1991: Enrolls in automotive classes at the College of the Desert.

About April 18 to 20, 1991: Buys a .22-caliber revolver from a classmate.

April 22, 1991: Gives Fathyma Vann a ride home from class; her body is found outside Indio the next day.

April 23, 1991: Carol Spadoni and Eva Petersen are killed in Burlingame; he cashes a forged check in Millbrae.

April 25, 1991: Points a gun at a woman at a Wyoming rest stop.

April 26, 1991: Police find the two women dead.

April 27, 1991: Margie Rogers is found dead in Thompson Springs, Utah.

April 28, 1991: Arrested in Kansas.

May 1, 1991: Questioned for four hours; asks for a lawyer 11 times.

June 14, 1991: Indicted in San Mateo County.

July 1991: Charged with capital homicide in Grand County, Utah.

November 10, 1993: Found competent to stand trial.

April 25, 1994: Convicted of two first-degree murders.

May 10, 1994: Found sane.

June 17, 1994: Jury returns death verdicts.

August 12, 1994: Sentenced to death.

August 19, 1994: Received on death row.

January 23, 2006: California Supreme Court affirms.

December 27, 2019: Found unresponsive in his San Quentin cell and pronounced dead, aged 73.