In April 1994 Philippe Hategekimana was a chief warrant officer, an adjudant-chef, in the gendarmerie company at Nyanza, a town in Butare prefecture in southern Rwanda. Twenty-nine years later, on June 28, 2023, a French assize court sitting in Paris found him guilty of genocide, crimes against humanity, complicity in crimes against humanity and participation in a group formed to prepare those crimes. The court convicted him on nearly all the charges he faced and sentenced him to life imprisonment, the heaviest penalty French law allows. An assize court of appeal, also sitting in Paris, upheld the verdict and the sentence on December 17, 2024, and the Court of Cassation was reported in June 2026 to have rejected his final appeal.
The case against him covered a few weeks of the genocide in and around Nyanza: roadblocks that he was found to have ordered and supervised to control and kill Tutsi civilians, the killing of the bourgmestre of the neighboring commune of Ntyazo, who had resisted the genocide there, and massacres on the hills of Nyabubare and Nyamure and at the agricultural research institute at Songa. Between those weeks and the trial lay a long second life. He left Rwanda in the exodus of July 1994, changed his name in a refugee camp in Congo, reached France in 1999 with an invented account of his past, became a French citizen in 2005 as Philippe Manier and worked for years as a security guard at a university in Rennes. He was found only after an anonymous letter reached a group of civil parties in France, and he was arrested only after he had left France for Cameroon.
He has denied every charge from the beginning. Through both trials he insisted that he had not been in Nyanza during the massacres, that he had never taken part in the killing and that the witnesses against him were mistaken, coached or lying. He stayed silent through most of the evidence. Two juries heard him out and rejected his account.
Hategekimana grew up in Nyagisozi, in southern Rwanda. He was 66 when his first trial opened in May 2023 and 67 when the appeal verdict was returned in December 2024. Witnesses who knew him in 1994 called him Biguma, and the name followed him through every stage of the French case. He told the first court that it was his own childhood nickname.
He made his career in the Rwandan gendarmerie, the force later renamed the Rwanda National Police. By his own account he spent a year in 1990 fighting the Rwandan Patriotic Front on the northern front. By April 1994 he held the rank of chief warrant officer in the Nyanza company. He described his role there to the court as that of the company's head of human resources, a man who assigned units and rarely went into the field.
United Nations figures put the dead of the genocide, between April and July 1994, at more than 800,000, most of them Tutsi. The French prosecution placed the massacres in the Nyanza area from about April 23 into May 1994, and that period was the core of both trials.
The case presented in Paris was that Hategekimana had used his authority as a gendarme to set the killing in motion in the Nyanza region and to coordinate it with the Interahamwe militia and other armed men. Roadblocks were raised across the territory covered by the Nyanza gendarmerie to stop Tutsi who were trying to flee. The prosecution charged that he ordered these roadblocks and supervised them, and that he took part directly in the killing of several dozen people at two of them. The court found him responsible for killings at roadblocks in the Nyanza area.
On April 23, 1994, the prosecution charged, he ordered or carried out the murders of Tutsi gendarmes and of the bourgmestre of Ntyazo, and took part the same day in the massacre on Nyabubare hill, where about 300 people were killed. Four days later, on April 27, the charges placed him at Nyamure hill, where thousands of Tutsi had gathered to seek refuge and where a massacre followed. The charges also accused him of taking part, on April 29, in preparing the massacre at the Institute of Agronomic Sciences of Rwanda, known by its French initials as ISAR, at Songa, where the dead were counted in the tens of thousands.
Narcisse Nyagasaza was a Tutsi and one of the very few elected Tutsi officials in the region. He graduated from the National University of Rwanda. When Rwanda opened to multiparty politics he joined the Liberal Party, in 1991, and the party put him forward in the 1993 elections, which made him bourgmestre of Ntyazo commune. He took office after a long period of hostile local government and set about drawing back together a commune that years of division had split.
When the genocide reached the area in April 1994, he organized local patrols and encouraged the men of Ntyazo to stand against the militia arriving from the neighboring Bugesera region, and for a few days they held them off. As the violence grew he refused to leave the people of his commune. He was seized by Interahamwe and gendarmes from Nyanza and killed in April 1994. The French courts found that Hategekimana had played a key part in his death.
Hategekimana's own account of these weeks was that he had refused to join the massacres, that he had tried to calm the extremist gendarmes and that a sub-prefect had forced him out for it. He said he was transferred in late April 1994 to the gendarmerie headquarters in Kigali, where he was assigned to an officer's close protection unit, and that he spent the following weeks helping refugees fleeing the capital. He gave the investigators varying dates for that departure.
The prosecution's case was that his accounts of when he left did not match one another or the evidence. Several witnesses who had no connection with each other placed his departure in mid-May at the earliest, after the massacres charged against him. A former colleague told the appeal court that he had sought the transfer to Kigali in May 1994.
When the Rwandan Patriotic Front advanced in July 1994, Hategekimana fled into what is now the Democratic Republic of the Congo. He spent about six months in the Kashusha refugee camp under a new name, Philippe Hakizimana. He later explained that former soldiers could be picked out in the camps and that it was safer to change his name. When the camp was attacked he fled again. His route over the next years was never made clear: in court he mentioned Congo-Brazzaville and Cameroon and a congregation of nuns who had helped him, whose name he said he no longer remembered.
He reached France in 1999 and applied for asylum near Rennes under the name Hakizimana. He told the French authorities that he had been a physical education teacher in Kigali and said nothing of a military career. The French refugee office accepted the account and granted him refugee status in 1999. At his trial he admitted that he had been "not very truthful," and defended the lie on the ground that people with military careers either did not get asylum or waited a very long time for it.
In 2005 he became a French citizen and took the name Philippe Manier. He settled in Mordelles, near Rennes, in Brittany. For about 15 years he worked as a security guard at the University of Rennes 2, until he was dismissed for too many unjustified absences. After that he moved between fixed-term contracts with security firms and periods of unemployment until 2015.
The case against him began with a letter. In 2012 an anonymous letter naming him reached the founders of the Collectif des parties civiles pour le Rwanda, an association that brings complaints in France against people suspected of taking part in the genocide. They passed it to the court and traveled to Rwanda to interview survivors from the Nyanza region. In 2015 the association filed a complaint in Paris, and a judicial investigation was opened at the Paris court.
The complaint became public, and Hategekimana knew that he was the target. In 2017 he left France for Cameroon on a three-month humanitarian visa and did not return when it ran out. In court he said that he had meant to go back to France later, and he admitted that the reason given for the visa was untrue.
An international arrest warrant was issued in 2018, and Cameroonian authorities arrested him that year in Yaoundé. Cameroon granted France's request for his extradition in February 2019. In Paris he denied the charges, was formally indicted and, on February 15, 2019, was placed in pre-trial detention. He remained in custody for more than four years before his trial opened. He was sent for trial in 2021 for genocide, complicity in genocide, crimes against humanity and participation in a group formed to prepare these crimes, and in January 2022 the Paris Court of Appeal added the massacre at ISAR Songa to the charges.
He was tried in France under universal jurisdiction, in the fifth trial there arising from the genocide against the Tutsi. It opened before the Paris assize court on May 10, 2023, and the court heard 106 witnesses and civil parties. Most of the evidence came from Rwanda: survivors, former neighbors and colleagues, and men already convicted in Rwanda of taking part in the genocide, several of whom testified by video link from Kigali. Several of those convicted men from the Nyanza region placed the accused at the center of what happened there.
Hategekimana did not give evidence in the ordinary way. He refused to answer the prosecution's questions, saying only that he was not Biguma, and otherwise declined to comment. He had not disputed the name until the final days of the trial. On June 20 he told the court: "The genocide did take place, I witnessed it. But I have nothing to reproach myself for." He also said that he sincerely sympathized with the suffering of the victims.
The defense contested the testimony as hearsay and challenged the credibility of the convicted witnesses. The prosecution asked for a life sentence; the defense asked for acquittal on every count.
On June 28, 2023, the court found Hategekimana guilty of genocide, crimes against humanity, complicity in crimes against humanity and participation in a group formed to prepare these crimes, on nearly all the charges. On the massacre at ISAR Songa, the court found him guilty as an accomplice but not as a perpetrator. It sentenced him to life imprisonment, réclusion criminelle à perpétuité. He appealed.
The appeal was heard by the assize court of appeal sitting in Paris from November 4 to December 17, 2024, and the court heard some 100 witnesses. The defense renewed its alibi, that he had been in Kigali and not in Nyanza during the massacres.
Survivors and former colleagues testified again. A woman who had served in the gendarmerie with him described how the mood in the Nyanza company had changed in April 1994 and how the bourgmestre of Ntyazo had come to be held there. Survivors from Songa told the court of the part played by gendarmes from Nyanza in the massacre at the institute. Before the court retired, Hategekimana told it that his life was ruined.
On December 17, 2024, the appeal court found him guilty of genocide, crimes against humanity and complicity in crimes against humanity, and confirmed the sentence of life imprisonment. He took the case to the Court of Cassation, France's highest court for criminal matters, which was reported in June 2026 to have rejected his appeal, leaving the convictions and the life sentence in place. As of June 2026 he was serving his sentence in France.
Hategekimana has never admitted any part in the killings. His central defense, in both trials, was that he was not in Nyanza when the massacres took place, having been transferred to Kigali in late April 1994. Both courts rejected that account, and the dates he gave for his departure changed over the course of the investigation.
His lawyers argued before the first trial that there was doubt about whether he was the man witnesses called Biguma, pointing to other names that had surfaced in other proceedings. The court refused to postpone the trial on that ground, and both juries found the identification proved. In court he admitted that the account he gave to obtain asylum in France, the reason given for his visa to Cameroon and his description of his past were untrue in important respects.
The massacre at ISAR Songa is the one charge on which the first court did not find him a perpetrator. It convicted him as an accomplice in that massacre, and the defense maintained that no eyewitness had placed him there.
The defense also contended that the witnesses had been coached and that the case grew out of political tension between France and Rwanda. Both courts convicted him on the evidence.
1990: By his own account, Hategekimana serves a year with the gendarmerie on the northern front against the Rwandan Patriotic Front.
1993: The Liberal Party candidate is elected bourgmestre of Ntyazo commune.
April 23, 1994: Date charged for the murders of Tutsi gendarmes and the bourgmestre of Ntyazo and for the massacre on Nyabubare hill.
April 27, 1994: Date charged for the massacre at Nyamure hill.
April 29, 1994: Date charged for the preparation of the massacre at ISAR Songa.
Mid-May 1994: Earliest departure from the Nyanza area given by several witnesses.
July 1994: Hategekimana flees to Congo and lives for about six months in the Kashusha camp as Philippe Hakizimana.
1999: He arrives in France and is granted refugee status.
2005: He becomes a French citizen as Philippe Manier.
2012: An anonymous letter naming him reaches the Collectif des parties civiles pour le Rwanda.
2015: The association files its complaint in Paris, and a judicial investigation opens.
2017: He leaves France for Cameroon.
2018: He is arrested in Yaoundé on an international warrant.
February 15, 2019: After extradition, he is indicted in Paris and placed in pre-trial detention.
2021: He is sent for trial before the Paris assize court.
January 2022: The Paris Court of Appeal confirms the referral and adds the ISAR Songa massacre.
May 10, 2023: The trial opens before the Paris assize court.
June 28, 2023: He is convicted of genocide and crimes against humanity and sentenced to life imprisonment.
November 4, 2024: The appeal trial opens in Paris.
December 17, 2024: The appeal court upholds the convictions and the life sentence.
June 2026: The Court of Cassation is reported to have rejected his appeal.