On the evening of Thursday, March 9, 2023, a meeting of a Jehovah's Witnesses congregation in the Groß Borstel district of northern Hamburg ended in the killing of seven people: four men and two women, all German citizens, and an unborn girl of 28 weeks' gestation. Eight others were hurt, four of them critically. The man the police named as responsible, Philipp F., was a 35-year-old former member of the same congregation. He died by suicide within minutes of the first officers' arrival, and no court ever heard the case.
The questions that followed were less about what had happened than about what had been known beforehand. Philipp F. had held his permit for only three months. In January a warning about his state of mind and his anger toward religious believers had reached the city's licensing authority, and in early February two officials had visited him unannounced and found nothing that allowed them to act. Within seven weeks of the killings, prosecutors were investigating one of those officials and three members of the club that had certified his competence.
Philipp F. came from Memmingen in Bavaria and grew up in Kempten, in the Allgäu region in the south of the country. He studied in Munich, and in 2015 he registered as a resident of Hamburg. He presented himself as a business consultant, and the warning that later reached the authorities spoke of anger toward a former employer as well as toward religious believers.
He had no criminal record and was not known to the security services as an extremist. His name appeared in official databases only because he had applied for an ownership permit under the arms law, and prosecutors said he had never come to police attention before.
For some years Philipp F. belonged to the Hamburg congregation that met in Groß Borstel. About a year and a half before the killings he left it. Police said he went voluntarily but apparently not on good terms, and whether the departure had truly been his own choice or had been forced on him remained an open question for investigators in the weeks after the killings. The church said only that he had left of his own accord.
Investigators found indications of a possible dispute within the religious community, but in the first days after the killings nothing in the files bore it out.
Philipp F. took up marksmanship as an amateur sport and sat the examination of a Hamburg marksmanship club, whose certificate of expert knowledge the licensing authority required before it would issue a sporting permit. The prosecutors who later investigated the club alleged that a three-member examination board issued him a blank certificate dated April 28, 2022, although he had failed the practical part of the test. No proper re-examination followed, they alleged. A board member later recorded a supposed re-test on October 24, 2022, and the April certificate was what reached the licensing authority as proof of his competence.
On that basis the authority issued him an ownership permit in December 2022. Without the false certificate, prosecutors alleged, he would not have received it.
At the end of December 2022 he self-published a book of close to 300 pages on God, Jesus Christ and Satan. It was freely available through an online retailer. Investigators would later read it closely. Before the killings, no official did.
On January 24, 2023, the Hamburg licensing authority received a letter. It was anonymous. It said that Philipp F. might be suffering from an untreated mental illness, that he was a former member of the Jehovah's Witnesses who had left about a year and a half earlier, and that he harbored a particular anger toward religious believers, the Jehovah's Witnesses above all, and toward a former employer. The letter also mentioned his book.
The authority treated the letter as an anonymous tip. On February 7, 2023, two of its officials made an unannounced visit to inspect how he stored what he owned. He was cooperative. They saw no sign of mental illness and gave him only a verbal caution over a minor storage point. They also searched the internet for his name together with the word "book" and found nothing. The case was closed. Police said afterward that even the book, had it been found, would not have given grounds to revoke the permit at once.
Prosecutors later took a different view of what one official had known. They alleged that the warnings had not been anonymous to him at all. Information about Philipp F.'s state of mind had reached him through a member of the club, and the official, prosecutors said, had himself suggested that the club member send it in anonymous form. He then neither recorded the warnings properly nor passed them on within the authority, and did not disclose that he knew where the letter came from. Because of that, prosecutors said, his superior ordered only the unannounced storage inspection, rather than taking away the permit and everything held under it.
The congregation's meeting that Thursday began in the evening. It had just ended, and some 50 people were still present, when the killings began. Over the following minutes Philipp F. killed four men, two women and an unborn child. Eight people were injured, four of them in a life-threatening condition, and about 20 others got out unhurt.
Police were there within minutes, and their arrival separated him from the congregation. He died by suicide moments later.
Residents of Groß Borstel and neighboring Alsterdorf received emergency warnings on their phones, and for several hours the police treated the possibility of a second attacker as open. By the early hours of Friday they had concluded that he acted alone. The warning was lifted.
The six adults who died were four men and two women, all German citizens. Their names were not released. The seventh death was that of an unborn girl at 28 weeks. None of the dead was related to Philipp F.
Two of the wounded women were not German citizens; one held Ugandan citizenship and the other Ukrainian. Five days after the killings, six people were still in the hospital and one remained in danger of death.
There was no one to arrest and no one to try. The investigation, led by the Hamburg prosecutor's office with the state security unit of the Hamburg police, set out to reconstruct the night and to understand the man. Investigators examined his website and the book.
The day after the killings, the police, the prosecutor's office and the interior authority briefed the press together and named him only as Philipp F., in line with German privacy practice. Prosecutors said there was no indication of a terrorist background, and drug use was ruled out. By the following week the senior prosecutor in charge said hatred of the religious community could not be ruled out as the motive, but that it had not been established.
Investigators also commissioned two expert assessments of the book, one from a psychiatrist and one from an extremism researcher, and both became public on March 22, 2023. The book did not name the Jehovah's Witnesses.
On April 27, 2023, the Hamburg prosecutor's office announced that it was investigating four people in connection with the case. The first was an official of the city's licensing authority, against whom prosecutors said there were sufficient factual grounds for suspicion of negligent homicide and of negligent bodily injury in office. The other three were the members of the club's examination board, suspected of false certification in office over the April 2022 certificate. None of the four was named, and each was entitled to the presumption of innocence.
No court examined the killings. The account police and prosecutors gave was never tested by a defense.
The count of the dead shifted in the first days. Police at first gave eight deaths, a figure that included Philipp F. and the unborn child; several international reports spoke of six dead, counting only those born. The figure the Hamburg authorities settled on was seven victims, the unborn girl among them. The number of injured was later given as nine, seven of them wounded directly.
The circumstances of his departure from the congregation were never fully settled in public. Police described it as voluntary but not amicable; some early reports said he had been excluded.
His motive was never established. Prosecutors could not rule out hatred of the religious community, but they did not prove it, and the book never named the congregation he attacked.
The licensing inquiry turned on allegations. The official and the three examination board members were suspects, not defendants, when prosecutors announced it.
2015: Philipp F. registers as a resident of Hamburg.
About a year and a half before the killings: he leaves the Hamburg congregation of Jehovah's Witnesses.
April 28, 2022: date on the certificate of expert knowledge issued by a club examination board, which prosecutors later alleged was false.
October 24, 2022: a supposed re-test is recorded by a board member.
December 2022: the Hamburg licensing authority issues him an ownership permit.
Late December 2022: he self-publishes a book of close to 300 pages.
January 24, 2023: an anonymous letter about him reaches the licensing authority.
February 7, 2023: two officials make an unannounced storage inspection and find no grounds to act.
March 9, 2023: seven people, including an unborn girl, are killed at a congregation meeting in Groß Borstel, Hamburg; Philipp F. dies by suicide minutes after police arrive.
March 10, 2023: police, prosecutors and the interior authority name him as Philipp F. at a joint press conference.
March 14, 2023: six of the injured remain in the hospital, one in danger of death.
March 22, 2023: two expert assessments of his book become public.
April 27, 2023: prosecutors announce inquiries against a licensing official and three club examiners.