Perry Wacker

Victims
58 Chinese nationals died in his truck's container, Dover, 2000. Convicted at Maidstone Crown Court, April 5, 2001, of 58 counts of manslaughter and of conspiring to smuggle immigrants
Years active
June 18, 2000 (deaths found, Dover); November 30, 2000 (pleas); February 26 to April 5, 2001 (trial); July 31, 2002 (Court of Appeal).
Location
Rotterdam (Netherlands); Dover and Maidstone, Kent (England).
Method
Manslaughter by gross negligence of 58 people he was carrying into the United Kingdom; conspiracy to facilitate illegal entry.
Status
14 years (April 5, 2001); appeal dismissed and each manslaughter term raised from six to 14 years, Court of Appeal, July 31, 2002; released in 2007.

On June 18, 2000, Customs officers at Dover opened the container of a truck that had just come off a ferry from Zeebrugge in Belgium. Inside were 60 people. Fifty-eight of them, 54 men and four women, were dead. Two men were still alive and were taken to the hospital. The driver was Perry Wacker, a Dutchman of 32 from Rotterdam. Ten months later a jury at Maidstone Crown Court convicted him of 58 counts of manslaughter and of conspiring to smuggle illegal immigrants into Britain, and he was sentenced to 14 years.

Wacker's appeal turned on a single question: whether a man engaged in a criminal enterprise owed any duty of care to the people who had joined it with him. In July 2002 the Court of Appeal answered that he did, rejected his appeal, and raised the sentence on each count of manslaughter from six years to 14.

The 60 people in the container were Chinese nationals. The Court of Appeal later described the journey as the facilitation of the illegal entry of 60 Chinese nationals into the United Kingdom, and that is how the courts have recorded it. None of the 58 who died was named in the court reporting.

Kent Police took charge of the investigation, which ran under the name Operation Mallard, and Wacker was held at the port. The next day the Home Secretary reported the deaths to the House of Commons. Kent Police officers worked with the Chinese authorities to identify the dead. Prosecutions of other people followed in the Netherlands, separately from the English case. In 2001 the Rotterdam District Court convicted ten people over the smuggling operation, among them its leaders, and passed terms of up to nine years; it did not find manslaughter proven against them, but it did find them guilty of causing the deaths through negligence. Eight of those cases went on appeal to the Court of Appeal in The Hague, where the hearings began in January 2002, and a man prosecuted in the Netherlands as a co-organizer of the smuggling was sentenced to ten years.

On June 22, 2000, four days after the deaths, Wacker was charged with 58 counts of manslaughter and with conspiracy to smuggle immigrants into Britain. A second defendant, Ying Guo, was charged with conspiring to facilitate the illegal entry of immigrants.

Both pleaded not guilty at Maidstone on November 30, 2000. The trial opened at Maidstone Crown Court on February 26, 2001, and lasted six weeks. The prosecution's case was that Wacker had taken a knowing part in the smuggling and that his gross negligence had caused the 58 deaths. His defense was that he had not known there were people inside.

Before the case went to the jury, Wacker's lawyers made a submission of no case to answer. They argued that no duty of care could arise between people who were jointly engaged in a crime, so that the law of negligence, and with it the offense of manslaughter by gross negligence, could not apply to the driver of a smuggling truck and the people he carried. The trial judge accepted that the principle they relied on did apply in the criminal law, but ruled that there was still a case for the jury to decide. The trial went on.

The two survivors gave evidence on March 1, 2001. Wacker went into the witness box in his own defense. He told the jury that he had taken the driving job through a friend of a friend, had asked no questions because he needed the money, and had not known the people were in the container.

On April 5, 2001, the jury returned unanimous verdicts: Wacker was guilty of all 58 counts of manslaughter and of conspiracy to smuggle illegal immigrants into Britain, and Guo was guilty of conspiring to smuggle illegal immigrants. Sentence was passed the same afternoon. Wacker, by then 33, received 14 years. On the manslaughter counts the judge imposed six years for each death, the terms to run concurrently with one another. Guo was sentenced to six years.

Wacker appealed against his conviction, and the Court of Appeal, Criminal Division, gave judgment on July 31, 2002. The appeal rested on the argument the trial judge had heard at the close of the prosecution case. English civil courts apply a rule, expressed in the Latin maxim ex turpi causa non oritur actio, under which one participant in a criminal enterprise generally cannot sue another for negligence arising out of that enterprise. Wacker's case was that the same rule should operate in the criminal court, so that he could owe no duty of care to the people he was smuggling, and without a duty of care there could be no manslaughter by gross negligence.

The Court of Appeal rejected the argument. It held that the criminal law takes a different approach from the civil law here. A civil court that refuses a claim between two wrongdoers is withdrawing a private remedy, and that has no bearing on whether the state may prosecute. The criminal law exists to protect citizens and to let the state punish those who deprive others of life, limb or property, and there was no public policy reason for it to decline to hold a man responsible for deaths merely because he and those who died had been engaged together in an unlawful activity.

The court also dealt with the contention that the people in the container had chosen to take the risk because it served their common aim of getting into Britain undetected. It held that the duty to take care for their safety could not, as a matter of public policy, be affected by the competing demands of the criminal enterprise, so what served the smuggling was not to be weighed in deciding whether Wacker had acted reasonably. The verdicts of manslaughter stood, and the court increased the sentence on each count of manslaughter from six years to 14.

Wacker was released from prison in 2007. In June 2017 he was back in a courtroom, this time before the Rotterdam District Court, as the main suspect in a case over six million cigarettes brought into the Netherlands without payment of excise duty. He denied knowing what the cargo was. On June 22 the court found only his possession of the cigarettes proven and ordered him to do 200 hours of community service.

Wacker denied throughout the trial that he had known there were people in the container. The jury rejected that account by its unanimous verdicts, and the Court of Appeal upheld them.

Timeline

June 18, 2000: Customs officers at Dover stop a truck arriving by ferry from Zeebrugge; 58 people in its container are dead and two men survive. Wacker is held.

June 19, 2000: The Home Secretary reports the deaths to the House of Commons.

June 22, 2000: Wacker is charged with 58 counts of manslaughter and with conspiracy to smuggle immigrants.

November 30, 2000: Wacker and his co-defendant plead not guilty at Maidstone.

February 26, 2001: The trial opens at Maidstone Crown Court.

March 1, 2001: The two survivors give evidence.

April 5, 2001: The jury convicts Wacker of 58 counts of manslaughter and of conspiracy to smuggle illegal immigrants; he is sentenced to 14 years, and his co-defendant to six.

2001: The Rotterdam District Court convicts ten people over the smuggling operation of offenses including causing the deaths through negligence, with terms of up to nine years.

January 2002: Appeals by eight of the Dutch defendants open before the Court of Appeal in The Hague.

July 31, 2002: The Court of Appeal dismisses Wacker's appeal against conviction and raises the sentence on each manslaughter count from six to 14 years.

2007: Wacker is released from prison.

June 22, 2017: The Rotterdam District Court finds Wacker in possession of smuggled cigarettes and orders 200 hours of community service.