Pedro Hernandez

Victims
1 murder (felony murder) and kidnapping of a child, 1979; convicted February 14, 2017, of murder in the second degree and kidnapping in the first degree; acquitted of intentional murder
Years active
May 25, 1979
Location
SoHo, Manhattan, New York (kidnapping and killing); Camden County, New Jersey (questioning, 2012); Manhattan, New York (trials)
Method
Strangled (his own confessions, which he later disputed; no physical evidence was presented at either trial)
Status
25 years to life, April 18, 2017; reversed by the Second Circuit July 21, 2025; reinstated by the U.S. Supreme Court June 22, 2026. Imprisoned in New York as of June 2026.

On May 25, 1979, a six-year-old boy vanished in the SoHo district of lower Manhattan. For 33 years no one was charged. Then, in May 2012, a 51-year-old man from Maple Shade, New Jersey, who had been an 18-year-old stock clerk at a corner store in the boy's neighborhood that spring, told New York City detectives that he had killed the child. His name was Pedro Hernandez. His first jury could not agree on a verdict. His second, in February 2017, acquitted him of intentional murder and convicted him of murder in the second degree, on a felony murder theory, and of kidnapping in the first degree. He was sentenced to 25 years to life.

The conviction rests on his own words. No physical evidence and no eyewitness tied him to the boy, and whether those words can be trusted has been the question at the center of the case ever since. In 2025 a federal appeals court held that the trial judge's one-word answer to a jury question about the confessions had denied him due process, and ordered him retried or released. The Supreme Court of the United States reversed that decision and reinstated the conviction in June 2026.

The clerk from the corner store

In the spring of 1979 Hernandez was 18 and worked as a stock clerk at a small store in SoHo. He had left high school without finishing. After the boy vanished, police and the FBI spent thousands of hours on the case in its first week alone. In July 1979 detectives interviewed the employees of the corner store, Hernandez among them. He was not treated as a suspect. Not long afterward he moved to New Jersey, where he spent the rest of his adult life, and by 2012 he was 51 and had never been charged with any crime.

In the years after 1979 Hernandez told several people that he had killed someone in New York. At a church retreat in 1980 he told a member of his congregation that he had killed a child. In the early 1980s he made similar statements to a neighbor and to a woman he later married. The accounts differed widely from one telling to the next in who the victim was and how the death had come about. None of the listeners believed him, and none of them went to the police.

The case went on without him. Federal and state prosecutors spent years looking at another man, identified here by his initials, J.R. He denied any part in the boy's disappearance and was never charged in the case. In 2010 the Manhattan District Attorney reopened the investigation, and when the office drew up a list of its ten leading suspects, Hernandez was not on it.

Six hours in New Jersey

In the spring of 2012 the renewed investigation was back in the New York papers, and after seeing the coverage a relative of Hernandez's by marriage called the police with a tip. On May 23, 2012, two New York City detectives came to Maple Shade, told Hernandez that his name had come up in an old case, and asked him to talk with them. He agreed and went with them to the Camden County Prosecutor's Office in New Jersey. There he was questioned while an assistant district attorney from Manhattan watched on a monitor. The session was not recorded.

The questioning went on for hours. Hernandez told the detectives about his diagnoses and his medication. He said he had told them everything, that he wanted to leave, and that he was being held against his will; the detectives reminded him that he had come voluntarily. When a third detective took over, Hernandez broke down, sobbed and accused the detective of trying to trick him. He asked whether they were trying to pin what had happened to that child on him and said again that he wanted to leave. He was told there were a few more questions. After more than six hours, and before anyone had read him his rights, he told them he had done it.

Three confessions

Only then did the detectives give Hernandez the Miranda warnings. The video feed was switched to record, and on tape he agreed to answer questions and told the story again, in an account almost identical to the one he had given before the warnings. He signed a written apology, said he could not explain why he had done it, and denied any sexual motive. Later that day, with detectives in the room, he repeated the admission to members of his own family.

That night he was taken to the Manhattan District Attorney's Office, where the assistant district attorney read him his rights again and questioned him on video until morning. Hernandez confessed a third time, though some details had shifted from his earlier account, and several of his statements that night were inconsistent with one another. Near the end he described seeing a ghost and said he was not sure whether it had really happened or he had imagined it. Then he asked what it had meant when he was told he could have a lawyer. Told that he could have one now, he said no, because "I don't have nothing to hide no more."

Hernandez was arrested on May 24, 2012. The next day, the 33rd anniversary of the boy's disappearance, he was arraigned by video from a locked psychiatric ward in Manhattan on a charge of murder in the second degree. He did not speak or enter a plea. The court ordered him held without bail and examined to establish whether he was fit to stand trial. He was later charged in the Supreme Court of the State of New York, New York County, with two counts of murder in the second degree and one count of kidnapping in the first degree.

Two trials

The first trial opened in Manhattan in January 2015 and ran for more than three months. The prosecution's case was the confessions, played for the jury on video, and the testimony of people Hernandez had talked to over the decades. The defense disputed that the confessions could be relied on. No physical evidence of any kind was put before the jury. After 18 days of deliberations the jurors still could not agree, and on May 8, 2015, the judge declared a mistrial.

The retrial began in September 2016 and lasted about five months. Before it, the trial court denied his motion to suppress the confessions. It found that Hernandez had not been in custody during the hours of questioning before his first warnings, so that the Miranda rule did not yet apply, and that he had knowingly and voluntarily waived his rights before the two recorded confessions.

Under New York law the jurors were told that they could disregard any statement they found had been involuntarily made. In February 2017, on the second day of deliberations, they sent the judge their third note about the confessions. They asked whether, if they found that the first confession in New Jersey, the one made before the Miranda warnings, was not voluntary, they had to disregard the two later videotaped confessions, the admissions to his family and the statements to the doctors. The judge read the question back and said: "the answer is, no."

The jury deliberated for seven more days. On February 14, 2017, it acquitted Hernandez of intentional murder in the second degree and found him guilty of murder in the second degree on the felony murder count, a killing committed in the course of the kidnapping, and of kidnapping in the first degree. On April 18, 2017, he was sentenced to concurrent terms of 25 years to life. He did not address the court; through his lawyer he said that he was innocent.

The appeals

On March 26, 2020, the Appellate Division of the New York Supreme Court, First Department, affirmed the conviction. It agreed with the trial court that Hernandez had not been in custody before his first warnings and that his waivers were valid, and it held that, given the precise wording of the jury's note, the judge's brief answer had been correct. In the alternative, it held that any error was harmless, because the overnight confession to the assistant district attorney in Manhattan was fully attenuated from all of the confessions to the police. A judge of the New York Court of Appeals denied leave to appeal later in 2020, and on March 22, 2021, the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear the case.

In 2022 Hernandez petitioned the federal district court in Manhattan for a writ of habeas corpus. The magistrate judge who reviewed it concluded that the trial judge's answer to the third note had deprived Hernandez of due process, but that federal law required deference to the state court's finding that the error was harmless, and he recommended denial. On June 11, 2024, the district judge agreed. She held that the error was of constitutional magnitude, but that Hernandez could not meet the strict standard for overturning a state court's harmlessness finding, and she certified the question for appeal.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit decided that appeal on July 21, 2025, and reversed. Its panel held that the trial judge's one-word answer was contrary to clearly established federal law under the Supreme Court's 2004 decision in Missouri v. Seibert, which deals with confessions obtained by questioning a suspect first, warning him afterward and having him repeat what he has said. The panel found the answer clearly wrong and the error manifestly prejudicial, in a trial that hinged entirely on the confessions. It sent the case back with instructions to grant the writ conditionally: Hernandez was to be released unless New York retried him within a reasonable time.

By then he had been in custody for more than 13 years. In October 2025 the district court set a deadline: jury selection in a retrial had to begin by June 1, 2026, or he would be released. The Manhattan District Attorney's Office said it would retry him, and in December 2025 it also asked the Supreme Court to reinstate the 2017 verdict. On April 17, 2026, the state trial judge refused to dismiss the indictment over the decades of delay, finding that law enforcement had had no reason to suspect Hernandez before 2012. She also refused to admit expert testimony on memory and perception, to allow evidence that other people had killed the boy, and to reopen the hearing on the admissibility of the confessions. A third trial was being prepared.

The Supreme Court

It never began. On June 22, 2026, without hearing argument, the Supreme Court granted the state's petition and reversed the Second Circuit in an unsigned opinion, McCarthy v. Hernandez. The vote was 6 to 3; three justices would have denied the petition, and they wrote no dissent.

The Court held that the Second Circuit had exceeded its authority. Federal habeas relief for a state prisoner is available only where a state court's decision was contrary to, or an unreasonable application of, clearly established federal law, meaning the holdings of the Supreme Court itself. No such holding, the Court said, required the jury instruction the Second Circuit had demanded. The Constitution does not require that both a judge and a jury decide whether a confession was voluntary, so there was no federal right to have the jury reassess confessions the trial judge had already admitted. Seibert, even assuming that the concurring opinion of Justice Kennedy in that case states a binding rule, concerned a trial judge's ruling on suppression, not a jury's weighing of whether later confessions were tainted by an earlier one, and the Court had never applied it to a jury. Nor had it ever held that due process requires a judge to explain to jurors an issue they do not have to decide. Whatever doubts the Second Circuit had about the reliability of the confessions, the Court added, could not justify relief under the federal statute. The case was sent back for further proceedings consistent with the opinion.

The ruling restored the 2017 verdict. As of June 2026 Hernandez was serving his sentence of 25 years to life in a New York state prison.

Disputed and unproven points

Nothing outside Hernandez's own statements connects him to the boy's death. No physical evidence was presented at either trial and no eyewitness placed the two of them together. Prosecutors argued that the confessions were detailed, repeated several times on video and supported by the admissions he had made to others over the years. His lawyers have argued from the start that the confessions are false, the product of a lifelong mental illness and a very low intelligence, drawn out by hours of questioning before he was told his rights. According to the medical history set out in the Second Circuit's opinion, doctors had documented obsessive thoughts, hallucinations and borderline intelligence before 1979; he was later diagnosed with a psychotic disorder, schizophrenia, bipolar disorder and memory impairment; and intelligence tests between 1992 and 2014 put his IQ between 67 and 76. The two juries divided over what the confessions were worth: the first could not agree after 18 days, and the second convicted him of felony murder and kidnapping while acquitting him of intentional murder.

The accounts themselves vary. The stories Hernandez told in the early 1980s did not match one another or the confessions of 2012, and the statements he made to doctors after his arrest drifted further, until he placed crowds of figures at the scene and then said they had not been there and the act had happened in his mind. Since his sentencing in 2017 he has maintained that he is innocent.

The courts divided as well. The magistrate judge, the district judge and the Second Circuit panel all concluded that the trial judge's answer to the jury violated Hernandez's right to due process, and the panel concluded that the error demanded a new trial. The Appellate Division and the Supreme Court's majority concluded that the answer was either correct under New York law or beyond the reach of federal habeas review, and the conviction stands on that ground.

Timeline

May 25, 1979: A six-year-old boy vanishes in SoHo, Manhattan; Hernandez, 18, is a stock clerk at a nearby corner store.

July 1979: Detectives interview the store's employees, including Hernandez, who is not treated as a suspect.

1980 to early 1980s: Hernandez tells a church member, a neighbor and a woman he later married that he killed someone in New York; none of them goes to the police.

2010: The Manhattan District Attorney reopens the investigation.

Spring 2012: A relative of Hernandez's by marriage calls police with a tip after press coverage of the renewed investigation.

May 23, 2012: Detectives question Hernandez in New Jersey; after more than six hours he confesses, then repeats the confession on video after Miranda warnings.

May 24, 2012: A third videotaped confession in Manhattan; Hernandez is arrested.

May 25, 2012: Arraigned on a charge of murder in the second degree and held without bail.

January 2015: The first trial opens in Manhattan.

May 8, 2015: Mistrial after 18 days of deliberations.

September 2016: The second trial begins.

February 14, 2017: Acquitted of intentional murder; convicted of murder in the second degree (felony murder) and kidnapping in the first degree.

April 18, 2017: Sentenced to concurrent terms of 25 years to life.

March 26, 2020: The Appellate Division, First Department, affirms.

2020: A judge of the New York Court of Appeals denies leave to appeal.

March 22, 2021: The U.S. Supreme Court denies review.

2022: Hernandez files a federal habeas corpus petition.

October 10, 2023: A magistrate judge recommends denial while finding the answer to the jury's note deprived Hernandez of due process.

June 11, 2024: The district court denies the petition and certifies the question for appeal.

July 21, 2025: The Second Circuit reverses and orders him retried or released.

October 17, 2025: The district court sets June 1, 2026, as the deadline for jury selection in a retrial.

December 18, 2025: Manhattan prosecutors ask the Supreme Court to reinstate the conviction.

April 17, 2026: The state trial judge refuses to dismiss the indictment, clearing the way for a third trial.

June 22, 2026: The Supreme Court reverses the Second Circuit, 6 to 3, in McCarthy v. Hernandez, reinstating the conviction.