Pazuzu Algarad

Victims
1 murder and 1 accessory charge over 2009 deaths; died untried. Charged in 2014 over the deaths of Joshua Fredrick Wetzler and Tommy Dean Welch; he died in custody in 2015 before any trial.
Years active
July 2009 and October 2009 (dates in the arrest warrants).
Location
Clemmons and Salisbury, North Carolina.
Method
Murder and accessory after the fact to murder (charged only; never tried).
Status
Died in custody in North Carolina on October 28, 2015, before trial; the charges were never tried.

Pazuzu Algarad was charged in North Carolina with murder and with being an accessory after the fact to murder in the deaths of two men who died in 2009. Forsyth County Sheriff's deputies arrested him in Clemmons, a town on the western edge of Winston-Salem, on October 5, 2014, together with the woman who lived with him. Arrest warrants accused him of the murder of Joshua Fredrick Wetzler, a Salisbury man, in July 2009. The same warrants laid the October 2009 death of Tommy Dean Welch to his co-defendant and charged Algarad with helping her afterward.

He never stood trial. He was held without bond in Forsyth County, moved into state custody under a safekeeping order in May 2015, and died in custody in North Carolina on October 28, 2015. The case against him ended there, untested by a jury and without a verdict of any kind. The two women charged alongside him did go before a judge, and their guilty pleas in 2017 are the only convictions the deaths ever produced. Every statement about Algarad's part in the deaths is an allegation that no court ever weighed against him.

Algarad was born John Alexander Lawson in San Francisco. He was 35 when he was arrested in October 2014. In 2002 he changed his name to Pazuzu Illah Algarad, the name under which he was charged. By the time of his arrest he was living in Clemmons, in Forsyth County.

He was not unknown to the county's courts. In 2010 he was convicted of being an accessory after the fact in connection with a death in Forsyth County that year. He was placed on probation rather than sent to prison.

The arrest warrants placed the first of the two deaths in July 2009 and the second in October 2009, a little more than three months apart. The first man came from Salisbury, in Rowan County.

For five years after 2009 no one was charged in either death. The investigation that ended in the October 2014 arrests was carried out by the Forsyth County Sheriff's Office under warrants issued that fall.

Deputies arrested Algarad and the woman who lived with him on Sunday, October 5, 2014. Each was charged with murder and with accessory after the fact to murder. In Algarad's case the murder charge concerned the July 2009 death and the accessory charge the October 2009 death; in his co-defendant's case the arrangement was reversed. Both were held without bond. A third person, a Winston-Salem woman, was charged as an accessory after the fact in the July 2009 death.

The first court date came quickly. The three defendants were scheduled to appear in Forsyth County District Court on October 23, 2014. From there his case never moved beyond the pretrial stage.

Algarad spent the first months after his arrest in the Forsyth County jail. In May 2015 a judge's safekeeping order moved him out of the county's custody and into a state prison unit, where he was held as a pretrial prisoner.

The case had not come to trial by October 2015.

Algarad died in custody in North Carolina on October 28, 2015, a little more than a year after his arrest. The North Carolina Department of Public Safety announced the death the same day and said he had been a pretrial inmate from Forsyth County facing murder charges.

His death ended the prosecution against him before any evidence had been tested at a trial.

The case continued against the two women. In October 2015, when Algarad died, the woman who had lived with him was still awaiting trial in Forsyth County, and the Winston-Salem woman's charge then stood as accessory after the fact to first-degree murder. Neither case went to a jury. Both women resolved their charges by guilty pleas in Forsyth County Superior Court, about eight years after the two deaths.

On March 9, 2017, the woman who had lived with Algarad pleaded guilty to second-degree murder in the October 2009 death, to robbery with a dangerous weapon, and to accessory after the fact to murder in the July 2009 death, and was sentenced to 30 years and eight months to 39 years and two months in prison. She pleaded under an agreement with the state, and the judge sentenced her at the same hearing. At that hearing the Winston-Salem woman's case was still pending, with her next appearance in Forsyth County Superior Court set for April 3, 2017.

Her case was settled on a Monday in early June 2017, when the Winston-Salem woman pleaded guilty to conspiracy to accessory after the fact to first-degree murder, which prosecutors tied to the July 2009 death, and was sentenced to about three to five years in prison.

At the March 2017 hearing prosecutors set out their account of the two deaths. In that account the July 2009 death was Algarad's act and the October 2009 death was his co-defendant's, with each of them helping the other afterward. Algarad was by then dead, and the account was given at a hearing in which he was not a party. It matched the warrants of 2014, but it was never put to him or to a jury.

Algarad was never convicted of either death, and the charges against him remained accusations when he died. The murder charge in the July 2009 death and the accessory charge in the October 2009 death rested on arrest warrants and on the evidence the Forsyth County Sheriff's Office had gathered by October 2014, none of which was tested at a trial.

The prosecutors' account at the March 2017 hearing, which placed the July 2009 death on Algarad, was given at a hearing for his co-defendant after his death. Her guilty pleas established her own guilt in the offenses she admitted. They did not establish his, and no court made a finding about his part in either death.

Timeline

2002: Changes his name to Pazuzu Illah Algarad.

July 2009: The first death, of a Salisbury man, as dated in the later arrest warrants.

October 2009: The second death, as dated in the same warrants.

2010: Convicted in Forsyth County of being an accessory after the fact in an unrelated death that year; placed on probation.

October 5, 2014: Arrested in Clemmons by Forsyth County Sheriff's deputies with the woman who lived with him; both are charged with murder and accessory after the fact to murder and held without bond. A third woman is charged as an accessory after the fact.

October 23, 2014: Scheduled first appearance of the three defendants in Forsyth County District Court.

May 2015: Moved into state custody under a safekeeping order.

October 28, 2015: Dies in custody in North Carolina before trial.

March 9, 2017: The co-defendant who lived with him pleads guilty in Forsyth County Superior Court to second-degree murder and two further offenses and is sentenced to 30 years and eight months to 39 years and two months.

April 3, 2017: Next scheduled Superior Court appearance for the third defendant.

June 2017: The third defendant pleads guilty to conspiracy to accessory after the fact to first-degree murder and is sentenced to about three to five years.