Pavel Sudoplatov

Victims
1 killing admitted in his own memoir. Never charged with it; convicted in the USSR in 1958 on other charges; rehabilitated in 1992.
Years active
May 23, 1938
Location
Rotterdam, Netherlands (killing); Melitopol, Ukraine (birth); Moscow, Russia (death)
Method
Bomb (his own memoir account; no court tested it).
Status
Sentenced in 1958 to 15 years' imprisonment and served the full term; rehabilitated in 1992. Died in Moscow, September 26, 1996, untried for the Rotterdam killing.

On May 23, 1938, the exiled leader of the Organization of Ukrainian Nationalists, Colonel Yevhen Konovalets, was killed in Rotterdam. The Dutch police opened an inquiry that reached into Germany, Austria, Italy and Lithuania, and it never named a suspect. The man they were looking for had arrived under a false name and had already left the country. More than half a century later he told the story himself. Pavel Sudoplatov, by then a retired lieutenant general of Soviet intelligence, wrote in his memoir that he had carried out the killing on Stalin's personal order.

No court ever tested that account. Sudoplatov was never charged in the Netherlands or anywhere else with the Rotterdam killing. He did stand trial in the Soviet Union, years later and for different reasons: arrested after the fall of his chief, Lavrenty Beria, he was convicted in 1958 as Beria's accomplice and sentenced to 15 years' imprisonment. He served the full term, spent the rest of his life petitioning to clear his name, and was rehabilitated in 1992. He died in Moscow in September 1996, two years after the memoir appeared.

Pavel Anatolyevich Sudoplatov was born on July 7, 1907, in Melitopol, in the south of what is now Ukraine, to a Ukrainian father and a Russian mother. He came from a miller's family. He joined the Red Army in 1919, at the age of 12, and by 1921, at 14, he was working for the Cheka, the Bolshevik political police.

He stayed with the security services for the rest of his working life. In 1933 he went to Moscow to work for the OGPU, the body that preceded the NKVD, and it was from Moscow that he was sent abroad against the Ukrainian émigré movement. He was from eastern Ukraine and spoke Ukrainian, and that was the cover he would use.

The man he was sent to deceive was a soldier who had become the leading figure of Ukrainian nationalism in exile. He was born in Zashkiv, in Lviv county in Galicia. In the First World War he served as a second lieutenant in the Austrian army until the Russians captured him in 1915 and held him in a prisoner-of-war camp near Tsaritsyn. He escaped with other Galician officers to Kyiv, and in November 1917 he organized the Galician-Bukovynian Battalion of the Sich Riflemen, which he soon commanded.

The unit was disarmed and disbanded under the hetman's German allies, and he re-formed it in Bila Tserkva as the Separate Detachment of Sich Riflemen. In November 1918 it helped overthrow Hetman Pavlo Skoropadsky. It grew into a division and then a corps before it was demobilized in December 1919, and its commander was interned in Lutsk. He held the rank of colonel in the army of the Ukrainian People's Republic.

In the summer of 1921 he returned to Lviv to lead the Ukrainian Military Organization, the UVO, and build its network. He emigrated in December 1922. He lived in Berlin from 1922 to 1929, in Geneva from 1929 to 1936, and afterward in Rome. In 1929, in Vienna, he brought several groups of young nationalists together into the Organization of Ukrainian Nationalists, the OUN, and he led it for about ten years as head of its executive, the Leadership of Ukrainian Nationalists. From exile he consolidated the movement, oversaw Ukrainian organizations in the diaspora, and pressed the Ukrainian national question before the League of Nations. His work abroad, and his efforts to revive a nationalist underground inside Soviet Ukraine, were seen in Moscow as dangerous.

Sudoplatov's assignment was to get close to him. He presented himself as a Ukrainian nationalist under the name "Walouc," and over roughly eighteen months he met the colonel several times and won his trust. The OUN leader came to treat him as a trusted man.

In 1938, by Sudoplatov's own account, Stalin ordered the killing personally. The order came while Nikolai Yezhov still ran the NKVD. When Yezhov himself was purged in the autumn of 1938, Sudoplatov narrowly survived.

In May 1938 he made contact again, saying that he had valuable information, and proposed that they meet in Rotterdam. The Dutch police later established that he had reached the city two days before the meeting.

The two men met in Rotterdam on Monday, May 23, 1938. After the meeting the colonel was killed in the city center. Others nearby were hurt. Sudoplatov was gone before the police knew who the dead man was.

The dead man carried a passport in the name of "Josef Nowak" of Berlin, which turned out to be false. The identification came the next day through L.B., the colonel's companion from Rome, who had telephoned that day asking for "Nowak." Police detained him when he arrived in the city. He said nothing that day, and on the following day he told them who the dead man was.

Shortly after his death the movement he had led split into rival factions.

The Rotterdam police worked the case as an international investigation, with police in Germany, Austria, Italy and Lithuania. They learned that the man the colonel had come to see used a false name, which they recorded as "Walluch," and that he spoke Ukrainian. Witnesses had heard two men speaking a foreign language in the city center shortly before the killing.

The Dutch police and the Gestapo both suspected the Soviet secret police from the start, though neither had hard evidence. The man behind the false name was never identified. No one was charged, and the case stayed open for decades.

Sudoplatov's career rose after Rotterdam. Stalin replaced Yezhov with Lavrenty Beria at the head of the NKVD in 1938, and in early 1939 Sudoplatov was reinstated as head of the NKVD's Foreign Department. In his memoir he placed himself in overall charge of the operations against Leon Trotsky, who was killed in Mexico City in 1940.

In June 1941 Sudoplatov took charge of the NKVD's Administration of Special Tasks, and during the war he headed the NKVD's Fourth Directorate. After the war he ran sabotage operations abroad and worked on the security ministry's operations against the Ukrainian Insurgent Army. He rose to the rank of lieutenant general.

Beria was purged in the summer of 1953. Sudoplatov had worked under him since 1939, and he was arrested in turn and charged as Beria's accomplice. His case did not reach a court until 1958, when he was convicted and sentenced to 15 years' imprisonment.

He served the full term. He worked afterward as a translator and petitioned again and again for rehabilitation and for readmission to the Communist Party. In one appeal to the party's Central Committee, in 1982, he cited his wartime efforts to obtain atomic information from Western scientists.

Early in 1992 he was rehabilitated at last.

In 1994 he published his memoir, Special Tasks: The Memoirs of an Unwanted Witness, A Soviet Spymaster, written with his son Anatoli Sudoplatov. Two American writers, Jerrold and Leona Schecter, assembled the book from about twenty hours of taped interviews, from what he had written for the KGB archives, and from documents his son had gathered. The Dutch had waited more than fifty years for an answer to the Rotterdam case, and the memoir gave one: it named the Soviet state as the author of the killing and Sudoplatov as the man who carried it out.

The book's most contested claims had nothing to do with Rotterdam. He wrote that he had headed a wartime department that collected atomic intelligence, and that J. Robert Oppenheimer, Enrico Fermi, Niels Bohr and Leo Szilard had knowingly passed American atomic secrets to Moscow. Those claims were challenged as soon as the book appeared.

Pavel Sudoplatov died in Moscow on September 26, 1996. He was never tried for the killing in Rotterdam.

The account of the Rotterdam killing rests on his memoir and on later histories that follow it. No court heard evidence on it, and the Dutch police never identified the man they called "Walluch." The alias itself is spelled in more than one way, as "Walouc" and as "Walluch." The order from Stalin is known only from his own account. Accounts also differ on the day he died, September 26 or September 24, 1996.

His atomic espionage claims fared far worse. The FBI later found no credible evidence that Bohr, Fermi, Oppenheimer or Szilard had engaged in espionage. Specific statements in the book collided with the documentary record: he described receiving material from Szilard about work at Los Alamos, where Szilard never worked; a 1943 memo by the Soviet physicist Igor Kurchatov suggests that Moscow did not know about Fermi's 1942 experiment when the book says it did; and his description of a meeting with Bohr conflicts with other accounts of it.

The conviction of 1958 does not stand: he was rehabilitated in 1992.

Timeline

July 7, 1907: Pavel Sudoplatov is born in Melitopol.

1919: He joins the Red Army at 12.

1921: He begins work for the Cheka.

1929: The Organization of Ukrainian Nationalists is founded in Vienna under the colonel who will become Sudoplatov's target.

1933: Sudoplatov moves to Moscow to work for the OGPU.

Before May 1938: Posing as the nationalist "Walouc," he wins the trust of the OUN leader over about eighteen months.

May 23, 1938: The OUN leader is killed in Rotterdam; the Dutch inquiry identifies no one.

Autumn 1938: Sudoplatov narrowly survives the purge of the NKVD under Yezhov.

Early 1939: He is reinstated as head of the NKVD's Foreign Department.

1940: Trotsky is killed in Mexico City; in his memoir Sudoplatov places himself in overall charge of the operations against him.

June 1941: He takes charge of the NKVD's Administration of Special Tasks.

1953: After Beria's fall he is arrested as Beria's accomplice.

1958: He is convicted and sentenced to 15 years' imprisonment, a term he serves in full.

1982: He appeals to the Central Committee for rehabilitation.

Early 1992: He is rehabilitated.

1994: His memoir, Special Tasks, is published.

September 26, 1996: He dies in Moscow.