On the afternoon of June 22, 1954, Honora Mary Parker died in Christchurch, New Zealand. Within a day the police had charged her 16-year-old daughter, Pauline Yvonne Parker, and Pauline's closest friend, Juliet Marion Hulme, who was 15, with her murder. Neither girl ever denied the killing. The question a Christchurch jury had to settle that August was narrower and harder: whether two intelligent schoolgirls had been sane when they did it. The jury decided that they had been. Both were convicted of murder, and because both were under 18 the court could not pass the death sentence the law then carried for that crime. They were ordered detained during Her Majesty's pleasure.
The case did not end with the verdict. The two were held apart for more than five years, released in 1959 under new identities and sent into separate lives. Juliet Hulme became Anne Perry, a crime novelist whose books sold in the millions, and her past came out only in 1994. Pauline Parker lived quietly in Britain as Hilary Nathan until her death in Orkney in October 2026.
The girls met in their first year at Christchurch Girls' High School. Juliet, born in London in October 1938, had come to New Zealand in 1948; Pauline had grown up in Christchurch and had left school the year before the killing to attend a commercial college. The friendship grew into something consuming. The two lived for long stretches inside an invented world of their own, writing novels in exercise books that they planned to take to the United States and publish, and sketching out a play they believed would be filmed in Hollywood. They tried several ways of raising the money for the fare. As the months went on, the adults around them tried to loosen the friendship, and the girls resented every attempt. Pauline's mother, more than anyone, tried to break it apart.
Early in 1954 the Hulmes decided to leave New Zealand, and Juliet's departure was fixed for early July. Pauline wanted to go with her, and Juliet wanted her to come. Both girls knew that Pauline's mother would never agree. Pauline's diary for that year, which the Crown would later put at the center of its case, recorded the plan that followed.
The police moved quickly. On the evening of the killing detectives questioned the two girls, and Pauline admitted that she had killed her mother, though she would not say why. She was charged with murder that night. The next day Juliet gave the detectives a further statement in which she admitted taking part and said she had felt she had to help her friend. She was arrested and charged with murder as well. The two statements left the defense little room on the facts, and the diary, written in Pauline's own hand, left less.
The trial opened on August 23, 1954, in the Supreme Court at Christchurch. The two were jointly charged with murder, and both pleaded not guilty. The defense did not contest that the girls had caused the death; its answer was that they had been insane when they did it, and the doctors called by the two sides disagreed on that question. On August 28, the sixth day, the jury rejected the insanity defense and found both girls guilty of murder.
In 1954 murder in New Zealand carried the death penalty, but section 5 of the Capital Punishment Act 1950 made an exception for the young: a person under 18 convicted of an offense punishable by death was to be detained during Her Majesty's pleasure instead. After the verdict the jury was asked to rule on the girls' ages and found that both were under 18, and the judge passed that sentence. It set no fixed term. Release depended on the decision of the Crown's ministers.
The two were held in separate institutions in New Zealand and were not allowed to write to each other. The trial had been the last time they were together. In November 1959 both were released under new identities, and they were not to meet again.
Juliet left New Zealand within days of her release and went to England. Writing as Anne Perry, she published her first novel, set in Victorian London, in 1979, and over her career she published more than a hundred books. In July 1994 an Auckland newspaper revealed that the best-selling novelist was the former Juliet Hulme. That September she spoke publicly about the case, describing the decision to kill as gravely wrong and saying that she and Pauline had had no contact since their sentences. A feature film about the friendship and the killing appeared the same year. Anne Perry died in Los Angeles on April 10, 2023, aged 84.
Pauline stayed in New Zealand after her release and remained on probation there until the mid-1980s. She took the name Hilary Nathan and, once her probation ended, moved to Britain, living first in Kent and later in Orkney, in the far north of Scotland. She never returned to New Zealand and never saw Juliet again. She died in Orkney in October 2026, aged 88, and her death was made public later that month.
Which of the two first conceived the plan is also unresolved. The diary was Pauline's, and the jury found both guilty of murder without distinguishing between them.
Most accounts date the release to November 1959; one later report gives 1960.
1948: Juliet Hulme arrives in Christchurch.
Early 1954: The Hulmes decide to leave New Zealand; Juliet's departure is set for early July.
June 22, 1954: Pauline's mother dies in Christchurch; Pauline Parker is charged with murder that evening.
June 23, 1954: Juliet Hulme gives a statement to detectives and is arrested and charged with murder.
August 23, 1954: The trial opens in the Supreme Court at Christchurch; both girls plead not guilty.
August 28, 1954: The jury rejects the insanity defense and finds both girls guilty of murder; both are found to be under 18 and sentenced to detention during Her Majesty's pleasure.
November 1959: Both are released and given new identities.
1979: Juliet, writing as Anne Perry, publishes her first novel.
Mid-1980s: Pauline's probation ends, and she leaves New Zealand for Britain.
July to September 1994: Anne Perry is identified as Juliet Hulme and speaks publicly about the case.
April 10, 2023: Anne Perry dies in Los Angeles, aged 84.
October 2026: Pauline Parker, known as Hilary Nathan, dies in Orkney, Scotland, aged 88.