Paul Touvier

Victims
7 Jewish hostages killed at Rillieux-la-Pape, 1944; accomplice. Convicted April 20, 1994, of complicity in crimes against humanity; life; death sentences in absentia, 1946 and 1947.
Years active
June 29, 1944 (Rillieux-la-Pape); death sentences in absentia September 1946 (Lyon) and March 1947 (Chambéry); pardon November 1971
Location
Lyon; Rillieux-la-Pape; Chambéry; Nice; Versailles; Fresnes
Method
Complicity in crimes against humanity: seven "homicides volontaires commis avec préméditation" against hostages chosen as Jews, carried out for Nazi Germany
Status
Life imprisonment ("réclusion criminelle à perpétuité"); Cour de cassation rejected his appeals June 1, 1995; died in custody, July 1996

On June 29, 1944, seven Jewish men held as hostages in Lyon were taken to Rillieux-la-Pape, a small town just north of the city, and murdered by the Milice, the paramilitary force of the Vichy regime. Five decades later a jury at Versailles found that the man who had chosen them, the head of the Milice intelligence service in Lyon, had acted as an accomplice to a crime against humanity. The cour d'assises des Yvelines sentenced Paul Touvier to life imprisonment on April 20, 1994. He was the first Frenchman convicted of that crime.

The verdict closed one of the longest pursuits in French legal history. Touvier had been condemned to death twice in absentia after the Liberation, slipped out of custody in 1947, and lived for most of the next 42 years under false names, moving from one religious house to another. A president pardoned him in 1971. Fresh complaints, a ruling that crimes against humanity could never lapse, a warrant, a long manhunt and his arrest in Nice in 1989 followed, and then three more years of rulings that nearly ended the case before it reached a jury. In the end only Rillieux-la-Pape survived the courts. The seven men killed there were the whole of the charge on which he was convicted.

The Milice in Lyon

Touvier was born in 1915 and came from a devout Catholic family in Chambéry, in Savoie. He had served in the French army and been discharged before the Vichy government created the Milice by a law of January 30, 1943, a force of some 30,000 members raised to keep order, fight the Resistance and persecute Jews. He joined, rose quickly to a post of administrative authority, and was given charge of its Second Service, the intelligence branch, in Lyon.

In that post he worked alongside the German security police in the city, then commanded by Klaus Barbie, who would himself be tried in France for crimes against humanity and sentenced to life in 1987. Touvier's service gathered information on Jews and Resistance members across the Lyon region. Other cases later laid against him never ended in a conviction.

Rillieux-la-Pape

On June 28, 1944, Resistance fighters in Paris killed Philippe Henriot, the Vichy government's propaganda minister. Henriot was one of the regime's best-known voices, and his death set off a wave of reprisals. In Lyon, the reprisal fell to Touvier's service.

By his own later account, the Gestapo commander for the Lyon area, Werner Knab, wanted 100 hostages killed. Touvier testified that he bargained the figure down to 30 and then to seven, and that he chose the seven himself. He always admitted that last point. What he denied, in different ways at different stages of the case, was the purpose: he said at one stage that he had acted under German orders and at another that the Gestapo never ordered the killings at all and that he acted alone.

The seven were Jewish men already held as hostages in Lyon. On June 29 they were taken to Rillieux-la-Pape and killed there. The court that convicted Touvier named six of them: Léo Glaeser, Louis Krzyzkowski, Maurice Schlusselman, Claude Benzimra, Emile Zeizig and Siegfried Prock. The seventh man could not be identified. They had been chosen, in the words the court put to the jury, because of their membership of a racial or religious community. Lyon was liberated about two months later.

Two death sentences and an escape

The police had been investigating Touvier since September 1944, and his name was on the list of those to be prosecuted at the Liberation. He was not in the dock when his cases were heard. On September 10, 1946, the court of justice at Lyon sentenced him to death in absentia for treason. In March 1947 the court of justice at Chambéry passed the same sentence for collaborating with the enemy.

In 1947 he was taken into custody in Paris and held at a police headquarters there, and he walked out. From then on he lived as a fugitive.

The shelter years

For the next quarter century Touvier was kept out of reach by members of the Catholic clergy. A commission of historians appointed by the Archbishop of Lyon later found that the help came from across French Catholicism rather than from any single decision at the top: parish priests, the charities Société Saint Vincent de Paul and Secours Catholique, and Jesuit, Benedictine, Dominican and Carmelite houses had all assisted him at one point or another.

The death sentences lapsed under the statute of limitations, the Lyon judgment on September 10, 1966, and the Chambéry judgment on March 4, 1967. That did not end every consequence of the convictions: some legal restrictions remained, including one affecting an inheritance. Touvier asked President Georges Pompidou for clemency, and in November 1971 Pompidou granted him a partial pardon that allowed him to recover his property. The decision was not published in the official journal.

The pardon and the first complaints

The pardon became public in 1972, and the reaction was immediate. Former members of the Resistance in the Lyon region discovered it, Jewish organizations protested, and witnesses from the war years came forward. On December 5, 1972, the International League Against Racism and Anti-Semitism announced that it would ask the Minister of Justice to reopen the case, alleging that important material had been removed from his file before it went to the president.

Because war crimes could no longer be prosecuted, the complaints turned to a different charge. A French law of December 26, 1964, had made crimes against humanity imprescriptible: they could be prosecuted at any time. The first complaints accusing Touvier of crimes against humanity were filed in 1973, and with them came the case's first great legal question, whether the acts of a Frenchman in Vichy service could be crimes against humanity at all.

The question first reached the courts in Lyon. A civil-party complaint filed there accused Touvier, as a Milice chief, of designating seven hostages to the occupying authorities for political, racial and religious motives. The prosecutor asked the investigating judge to decline the case, on the ground that the acts, if proven, amounted to intelligence with the enemy, an offense for the State Security Court, and the judge did so. On May 30, 1974, the indicting chamber of the Lyon Court of Appeal confirmed that order and added that the facts might also belong before the military courts as war crimes. Either way, the complaint was dead in Lyon.

The complainant appealed, and on February 6, 1975, the criminal chamber of the Cour de cassation revived it. A judge who received such a complaint, the court held, had a duty to investigate it, and he could not decline the case without first asking whether the crime the complaint alleged could be made out. The elements of a crime against humanity, defined by the Nuremberg charter, to which the 1964 law referred, were not those of a war crime or of intelligence with the enemy. The law had created no special court for such crimes: they were ordinary offenses, committed in particular circumstances and for particular motives. The ruling distinguished crimes against humanity from war crimes and confirmed that they existed in French law. The Cour de cassation quashed the Lyon decision and sent the case to the indicting chamber of the Paris Court of Appeal. Touvier had tried to join the appeal himself; the court ruled that, not being a party to it, he could not.

An official investigation opened in 1977. In 1981 a warrant was issued for his arrest, and Touvier went back into hiding.

Arrest in Nice

The pursuit lasted eight more years. The investigating judge, suspecting that Touvier was being protected, took the case away from the criminal police and gave it to the gendarmerie's research section in Paris. On May 24, 1989, a unit of gendarmes entered a priory in Nice belonging to the traditionalist movement of Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre and found Touvier there living under the name Paul Lacroix. He was flown to Paris and charged with crimes against humanity; the government later gave May 29, 1989, as the date of the formal charge. He had met Lefebvre in Switzerland during his years in hiding, though the commission found that the traditionalist movement as a whole had not supported him.

Cardinal Albert Decourtray, Archbishop of Lyon, appointed a commission of seven historians chaired by René Rémond to examine the Church's conduct, and placed the archbishopric's archives at its disposal. Its report was published in January 1992. It concluded that clergy from monks to archbishops had gone out of their way to hide and help him while finding that the Church as an institution had not organized the cover. The commission said it was not sitting in judgment on Touvier's guilt.

The case narrows

Touvier spent two years in custody before he was released on bail in July 1991.

By then the investigation in Paris had gathered some forty civil parties and eleven sets of allegations. On October 29, 1991, the investigating magistrate found that five of them could go forward, declared the rest inadmissible, and sent the case to the Paris Court of Appeal. On April 13, 1992, the indicting chamber of that court went further and dismissed the case altogether. On the Basch deaths, the raids and the other allegations it found no grounds to send him for trial. On Rillieux-la-Pape it found sufficient evidence that Touvier had been an accomplice to the killings, by the instructions he gave and by aid and assistance, and still refused to send him for trial. The killings, it held, could not be classed as crimes against humanity: they had not formed part of a methodical plan of extermination and had not been decided on German orders. They were war crimes, and war crimes had long since lapsed. Part of its reasoning was that Vichy had not pursued an ideologically hegemonic policy of its own of the kind the law required. The chamber held that Vichy had not been a totalitarian state and that the Milice had been only one of the forces that made it up.

The ruling caused an uproar across France. The procureur général appealed it to the Cour de cassation, and so did the civil parties, among them federations of deportees and Resistance veterans, the Ligue des droits de l'homme, the Consistoire central and the LICRA. On November 27, 1992, the criminal chamber of the Cour de cassation annulled the Paris decision, but only as it concerned the murder of the seven Jewish men at Rillieux. Applying the charter of the Nuremberg tribunal, which makes instigators and accomplices answerable for acts committed in carrying out a common plan, it held that crimes committed at German instigation and carried out by Touvier could be crimes against humanity. The Paris chamber, the court said, had contradicted itself. It had found that the killings were committed at the instigation of a Gestapo official, and the Gestapo, an organization declared criminal at Nuremberg, belonged to a country that had practiced a policy of ideological hegemony. The charter punished the authors and accomplices of crimes against humanity only if they had acted on behalf of a European Axis country, and that link was enough. It upheld the dismissal of everything else, including the Basch deaths, and sent the Rillieux charge to the Court of Appeal of Versailles.

The prosecution at Versailles asked for a trial, and the indicting chamber deliberated in closed session in the spring of 1993. On June 2, 1993, it ordered that Touvier stand trial before the cour d'assises des Yvelines for complicity in crimes against humanity on that single charge. Its findings set out the case he would face. After the killing of Henriot, a member of the Milice as well as a secretary of state, the head of the German Einsatzkommando in Lyon, whose services came under the Gestapo and the SD, demanded that Jewish hostages be killed in reprisal. Touvier chose seven Jewish men from among the hostages the Milice held and gave the orders to the Milice men who carried out the killings. The chamber found that the victims had been chosen for their racial or religious membership, held him an accomplice by instructions, aid or assistance, and rejected his pleas that he had acted under German constraint or out of necessity.

Touvier took the referral to the Cour de cassation and lost on October 21, 1993. His appeal argued that the 1946 conviction at Lyon for intelligence with the enemy barred a second trial for the same acts. The court held that the imprescriptibility of crimes against humanity governed their prosecution in every respect and ruled out any plea that the matter had already been judged, even after a conviction under another heading. The appeal argued too that a reprisal for Henriot's death could not be part of a concerted plan. The court answered that murders committed at the instigation of a Nazi official, against victims chosen because they were Jewish, formed part of the concerted plan of extermination and persecution, whatever the occasion for them. It found that the Versailles chamber had properly established both the act and the intent, and that Touvier had acted free of any constraint. The referral became final.

The trial at Versailles

The trial opened before the cour d'assises des Yvelines at Versailles on March 17, 1994, under heavy police guard. Three judges and nine jurors heard the case. The trial was recorded for the historical archives of French justice.

The first day turned on a technical point. The defense argued that the civil claims of most of the 23 plaintiffs were barred by a 30-year limitation period in the new penal code. The judges ruled that the international treaties on crimes against humanity prevailed over national law, and the plaintiffs could go on. The plaintiffs were Jewish and Resistance organizations and relatives of the men killed at Rillieux.

Touvier admitted again that he had picked the seven men, and he denied that he had acted out of hatred of Jews.

The legal structure of the case shaped every argument. Under the law as the Cour de cassation had stated it, the jury could convict only if Touvier had acted on behalf of an Axis power pursuing a hegemonic policy of persecution. The principal question put to the jurors asked exactly that: whether the acts had been committed as part of a concerted plan, on behalf of a hegemonic state, in this case Nazi Germany, against persons chosen because of their membership of a racial or religious community. The others concerned the seven premeditated homicides of June 29, 1944.

The jury returned its verdict on the night of April 19 into April 20, 1994, at the end of a trial of a little over a month. It found Touvier guilty on every question put to it, with no extenuating circumstances, and fixed the maximum penalty by a majority of eight votes. The court sentenced him to "réclusion criminelle à perpétuité," life imprisonment, "pour complicité de crimes contre l'humanité." The judgment found him "guilty of having knowingly been accomplice to a crime against humanity on 28 and 29 June 1944 in Lyon," the crime consisting of seven premeditated murders. A separate civil judgment was given the same day.

The final appeal

Touvier's lawyers lodged appeals against the conviction, against the rulings made during the trial and against the civil judgment. French law allowed a challenge only on points of law, not a fresh look at the facts. The Cour de cassation joined the appeals and rejected all of them on June 1, 1995.

The court answered each ground in turn. The Nuremberg charter, annexed to the London Agreement, had been in force from its signature and was promulgated in France by decree on October 6, 1945. The civil claims followed the rule of the criminal action and so could not lapse either. No rule required the presiding judge to tell the accused of his right to remain silent. The court had been entitled to refuse to call the sitting prime minister, who had served at the presidency when the 1971 pardon was granted, because the defense had not shown what his evidence would add. The trial timetable had been agreed by all parties and had not limited the defense. By imposing the maximum sentence by a majority of eight, the cour d'assises had implicitly rejected any reduction for superior orders. The new penal code, in force since March 1, 1994, did not apply retroactively and had not repealed the specific texts punishing crimes against humanity committed on behalf of the Axis powers, and the penalty itself fell within the old penal code provisions on murder that applied to the facts. With that ruling Touvier had exhausted every remedy French law allowed.

In May 1994 the court at Versailles refused a request for his release while the appeal was pending. Touvier remained in custody after the final appeal. Later requests for his release were rejected too. He died in custody at Fresnes, outside Paris, in July 1996.

Context: crimes against humanity in French law

The case turned on the gap between two categories of crime. War crimes committed during the occupation were subject to the ordinary limitation periods, which is why the 1946 and 1947 death sentences lapsed in 1966 and 1967 and why the Paris court's ruling that Rillieux was a war crime would have ended the prosecution. Crimes against humanity, defined by the Nuremberg charter, had been made imprescriptible by the law of December 26, 1964. The Cour de cassation recognized the category in French law in the Touvier case in 1975, and the Barbie rulings of January 26, 1984, and December 20, 1985, set out the specific motive the crime required.

That requirement was the point on which the Touvier case nearly failed. The Paris court found no Vichy policy of the hegemonic kind the law demanded. The Cour de cassation avoided the question by tying Touvier's acts to the German plan, holding that a Frenchman who carried out a crime instigated by the Gestapo could be an accomplice to a crime against humanity. The new penal code that took effect in March 1994 defined crimes against humanity afresh and punished them with life imprisonment, but the Cour de cassation held that it could not be applied backward to 1944.

Disputed and unproven points

Touvier's central defense was that he had saved lives. He said the German commander had demanded 100 hostages and that by bargaining he had reduced the toll to seven. The only evidence for the bargaining was his own account, and the jury convicted him without extenuating circumstances. The Versailles indicting chamber had already rejected the argument as a legal defense: it held that it was not possible to decide whether the lives he said he had saved represented a higher interest, and so refused to treat the killings as an act of necessity.

His account of who gave the order also shifted. He said at times that he had followed German orders and at the trial that the Gestapo never ordered the killings and that he had acted alone. The verdict rested on the finding that the crime was committed on behalf of Nazi Germany.

The other charges against him were never proven in court. The 1972 government report found evidence that he took part in the arrest of Victor and Hélène Basch, while finding that he had not caused their deaths himself; he denied any part in it, and the charges were dismissed for lack of evidence in 1992. The charges over raids, arrests and deportations were declared inadmissible or dismissed and never reached a jury. Among them was an attack on the synagogue on the quai de Tilsitt in Lyon on December 10, 1943; the Paris chamber held that the testimony of a single witness was not sufficient evidence against him, and the Cour de cassation upheld that finding.

The Nice priory where he was arrested is called Saint-François in most accounts and Saint-Joseph in a few.

Timeline

1915: Paul Touvier is born.

January 30, 1943: A Vichy law creates the Milice; Touvier joins and later heads its intelligence service in Lyon.

January 1944: Victor and Hélène Basch are killed near Lyon; charges against Touvier over their deaths are later dismissed.

June 28, 1944: Philippe Henriot is killed by the Resistance in Paris.

June 29, 1944: Seven Jewish hostages are murdered at Rillieux-la-Pape.

September 1944: Police begin investigating Touvier.

September 10, 1946: The court of justice at Lyon sentences him to death in absentia for treason.

March 1947: The court of justice at Chambéry sentences him to death in absentia for collaborating with the enemy.

1947: He escapes from custody in Paris and goes into hiding.

December 26, 1964: France makes crimes against humanity imprescriptible.

September 10, 1966: The Lyon death sentence lapses.

March 4, 1967: The Chambéry death sentence lapses.

November 1971: President Georges Pompidou grants a partial pardon.

1973: The first complaints for crimes against humanity are filed.

May 30, 1974: The Lyon indicting chamber confirms that the complaint there will not be investigated.

February 6, 1975: The Cour de cassation quashes the Lyon ruling, recognizes crimes against humanity in French law and sends the case to Paris.

1977: An official investigation opens.

1981: A warrant is issued; Touvier goes back into hiding.

May 24, 1989: Gendarmes arrest him at a priory in Nice.

October 29, 1991: The investigating magistrate lets five of eleven sets of allegations go forward.

January 1992: The Rémond commission's report on the Church's role is published.

April 13, 1992: The Paris Court of Appeal's indicting chamber dismisses the case.

November 27, 1992: The Cour de cassation reinstates the Rillieux charge as a crime against humanity.

June 2, 1993: The Versailles indicting chamber orders him to stand trial.

October 21, 1993: The Cour de cassation rejects his appeal against the referral.

March 17, 1994: The trial opens before the cour d'assises des Yvelines.

April 20, 1994: He is convicted of complicity in crimes against humanity and sentenced to life imprisonment.

June 1, 1995: The Cour de cassation rejects his appeals.

July 1996: He dies in custody at Fresnes.