On August 14, 1980, in West Los Angeles, Paul Snider met his estranged wife, Dorothy Stratten, born Dorothy Ruth Hoogstraten in Vancouver, to talk about money and the end of their marriage. Neither of them left alive. Los Angeles police concluded that Snider, 29, killed his wife and then died by suicide. He was never charged or tried. The Los Angeles County coroner entered a hedged ruling on his own death: "questionable suicide/possible homicide."
The case drew attention far beyond Los Angeles because of whom she had become in the two and a half years since Snider first noticed her in East Vancouver. He had sent her photographs to Playboy, steered her to Los Angeles and married her. By the summer of 1980 the magazine had named her its Playmate of the Year, she had worked with the director Peter Bogdanovich in New York, and she had decided to leave her husband. Snider, who had built his hopes and much of his income on her success, was losing both.
Snider grew up in Vancouver's East End. He left school after the seventh grade and had to look after himself from an early age. In his late teens he took up bodybuilding, which he credited with filling out a frame that had been thin.
By his twenties he was a promoter. He staged automobile and motorcycle shows at the Pacific National Exhibition, the city's annual fairground showcase, and he cultivated the look of a man on the way up: a groomed mustache, a mink coat, a black Corvette. He favored tailored suits, floppy hats and flashy cars.
He spent a period in Los Angeles in the mid-1970s, then returned to Vancouver around 1977. He had already tried, without success, to turn other young women into Playboy prospects, including one in 1974.
Early in 1978 Snider saw the young woman who would become his wife in East Vancouver. She was shy and still in school, and she had no particular ambitions beyond ordinary work. "That girl could make me a lot of money," he said. He got her telephone number from one of her co-workers and called her.
The courtship that followed was built on attention and gifts. He bought her clothes and a topaz ring, took her to her senior prom and presented himself as someone who would look after her. She said in 1979 that she had been "really shy."
Within weeks he was talking to her about posing for photographs. She agreed after about two weeks. He took her first to one Vancouver photographer and then to another photographer who had a history of placing pictures with Playboy. His photographs went to the magazine in Los Angeles, and a finder's fee was paid. In August 1978 she flew to Los Angeles for a test shoot. It was her first flight.
Playboy took her up quickly. The magazine trimmed her hair and shortened her surname. She was among the leading contenders for the magazine's 25th anniversary centerfold, which went to another woman, and she was chosen instead for the August 1979 issue.
Snider followed her to Los Angeles and pressed her to marry him. Friends warned her that a husband could hurt her prospects, and Playboy's photo editor and its founder, Hugh Hefner, opposed the match. She went ahead because she felt she could not back out. The two married in Las Vegas on June 1, 1979, and Playboy asked that the marriage be kept quiet.
Hefner never warmed to the husband. Snider was rarely invited to the Playboy Mansion, which stung him. The couple settled in West Los Angeles, sharing quarters with a young internist who rented a room from them, and later with a young woman whom Snider was also hoping to promote. Snider kept close watch on his wife. He coached her on which men to avoid at the mansion, monitored her habits and wanted control of her finances and of the offers that began to come her way. He urged her to put her earnings into property. He predicted that she would be the next Playmate of the Year and the next Marilyn Monroe.
The first prediction came true. A television special in October 1979 impressed Hefner, small parts in television and film followed, and Hefner chose her as Playboy's Playmate of the Year for 1980, the first Canadian to hold the title. The announcement came in April 1980.
As her prospects grew, Snider's own position shrank. Hefner connected her with a professional manager and a business manager, and much of her income went into a company set up for her career, of which her husband was not an officer. His own ventures, promoting dancers and wet T-shirt contests, brought in little. He sold exercise benches for $200 apiece. A poster project with partners that he hoped would bring in about $300,000 collapsed when his wife changed her mind. He drove a Mercedes bearing the license plate STAR 80.
In the spring of 1980 she went to New York to work on Peter Bogdanovich's comedy They All Laughed. Snider drove her to the airport in late March. In New York she and the director fell in love. Snider, who suspected the affair, hired a Los Angeles private investigator to follow her in New York and, later, to gather proof of the relationship.
In May 1980 husband and wife met in Vancouver. She told him, in words he repeated to friends, "Let the bird fly." Snider believed afterward that they had reconciled. They had not. In late June he received a letter telling him that the two of them were "separated physically and financially." She closed their joint bank accounts and began paying him through her business manager.
Friends who saw Snider in the weeks that followed found him increasingly desperate. He wept on the telephone and in front of the internist who lived with them. He wrote notes to his wife that he never sent. He worked with his lawyer on a letter to Bogdanovich. "Maybe this thing is too big for me," he told one acquaintance, and he spoke of going back to Vancouver. A friend urged him to take his wife there. The private investigator spent the summer on his behalf, tracing her assets and following her movements.
On August 8, 1980, the couple had lunch. Snider's friends said he had gone into it giddy with hope. She told him that she loved Bogdanovich and that she wanted a financial settlement. She collected the clothes she wanted and left the rest.
On August 14, 1980, she drove to West Los Angeles to meet Snider and settle the terms of the separation. Hefner and Bogdanovich had both warned her against seeing him alone. She went anyway. The settlement she had in mind was about $7,500, roughly half of what she had left after taxes. Snider had told her that he believed she owed him something for bringing her to Hollywood, and she agreed that some payment was fair.
The private investigator was watching on Snider's behalf, and as the day went on his calls to Snider went unanswered. That evening the housemates grew uneasy at the long silence. Late that night the housemates discovered that both of them were dead. Los Angeles police officers arrived in the early hours of August 15.
Detectives from the Los Angeles Police Department's West Los Angeles area took the case. Their conclusion was that Snider had killed his wife and then died by suicide.
The Los Angeles County coroner examined both deaths. Police treated her death as a homicide. On Snider's own death the coroner hedged, ruling it a "questionable suicide/possible homicide." No other person was ever named as a suspect or charged, and the police conclusion that Snider was responsible stood.
There was no charge and no trial. Snider was dead, and the only questions that remained open were the ones the coroner's ruling had recorded.
No court ever tested the police conclusion, and Snider was never charged. The coroner's ruling on his death left open, in form, the possibility that he had not died by his own hand, and the detectives conceded in late 1980 that they could not settle that point beyond doubt. Neither the police nor the coroner ever identified anyone else as involved.
1974: Snider tries, without success, to promote another young woman as a Playboy prospect.
Around 1977: He returns to Vancouver from Los Angeles.
Early 1978: He meets his future wife in East Vancouver.
August 1978: She flies to Los Angeles for a test shoot arranged through photographs he had sent to Playboy.
June 1, 1979: The couple marry in Las Vegas.
August 1979: She appears in Playboy's August issue.
October 1979: A Playboy television special brings her to Hefner's notice.
Late March 1980: She leaves for New York to work on They All Laughed.
April 1980: Playboy announces her as its Playmate of the Year for 1980.
May 1980: The couple meet in Vancouver; she tells him to "let the bird fly."
Late June 1980: Snider receives a letter declaring the couple separated physically and financially.
Summer 1980: Snider has a private investigator gather evidence of her relationship with Bogdanovich.
August 8, 1980: At lunch she tells him she loves Bogdanovich and wants a financial settlement.
August 14, 1980: She meets Snider in West Los Angeles to settle the separation; police conclude that he killed her and then died by suicide.
August 15, 1980: Los Angeles police arrive in the early hours after the deaths are discovered.
November 1980: West Los Angeles detectives have not formally closed the case; the coroner's ruling on Snider's death stands as "questionable suicide/possible homicide."