Patrick Mahon was a married man living in London when he met Emily Kaye in 1923 and began a relationship with her under a name that was not his own. In April 1924 the two spent a weekend together in the Langney area of Eastbourne, on the Sussex coast, and she did not leave it alive. Mahon was arrested in London after his wife, who suspected him of another affair, hired a private inquiry agent. He denied murder. A jury at Lewes took 45 minutes to find him guilty, and he was sentenced to death. His appeal failed, and he was executed at Wandsworth, in London.
Mahon did not come to the events of 1924 with a clean record. Eight years before them he had been convicted of a violent attack on a woman in Surrey, who survived, and he was sent to prison for five years. His wife took him back when he was released, though she knew of both his offenses and his affairs. By 1923 the couple had moved to London.
His marriage had already been tested by his conduct, and his wife's suspicion of him would in the end decide how the case came to light.
She met Mahon in London in 1923, after he and his wife had settled there. He introduced himself to her as Derek Patterson, and within weeks the two were in a relationship. She had put by savings of about 500 pounds, roughly 30,000 pounds in today's money.
The relationship moved quickly. Mahon gave her a diamond ring, and the two became engaged. She told her friends that they planned to start a new life together in South Africa. In the months before her death she withdrew most of her savings, and much of that money passed to Mahon, who spent it freely.
In April 1924 Mahon went to the Langney area of Eastbourne and took a place there for the two of them. They met there on the weekend of April 12 and 13, 1924. She died there that weekend or in the days that followed.
The police did not come to Mahon through any report of her death. They came to him through his marriage. His wife, fearing that he was once again being unfaithful, hired a private detective. What the detective found led to Mahon's arrest in London.
At first he was evasive. Then he admitted that he had been involved in her death, while insisting that he had not murdered her. The police found evidence that contradicted parts of his account, and he was charged with her murder.
The Crown's case against him, Rex v Patrick Mahon, came to trial at Lewes, in East Sussex, before a judge and jury. He pleaded not guilty and held throughout the trial to his account that her death had followed a quarrel and was not murder.
The prosecution's case rested in part on timing. Evidence put before the jury showed that items he said he had acquired only after her death had in fact been bought several days before it, which undercut the account he gave from the witness box. The jury retired and returned after 45 minutes with a verdict of guilty of murder. He was sentenced to death.
Mahon appealed against his conviction. While he waited, he refused food for a time. The appeal did not save him. He was executed at Wandsworth, in London, and a report on his execution was later kept among the case papers of the pathologist who had examined her death.
The one disputed question in the case was how she died. Mahon's position, from his first admissions to the end of his trial, was that her death was not murder. The jury rejected that account, and the conviction stood on appeal.
The exact day of her death, within that April weekend or the days after it, was never fixed beyond doubt. The verdict of the jury, and the sentence that followed it, were not disturbed.
Before 1924 (eight years before the events at Eastbourne): Mahon is convicted of an attack on a woman in Surrey and sent to prison for five years.
1923: Mahon and his wife are living in London; he meets the woman he will become engaged to, introducing himself as Derek Patterson, and the two become engaged.
April 12 and 13, 1924: Mahon and his fiancée meet in the Langney area of Eastbourne; she dies there that weekend or in the following days.
1924: A private detective hired by Mahon's wife gives the police a lead; Mahon is arrested in London and charged with murder.
After his arrest: Mahon is tried at Lewes, pleads not guilty and is convicted of murder by a jury that deliberates for 45 minutes; he is sentenced to death.
After the trial: His appeal fails, and he is executed at Wandsworth, London.