Patrick Eugene Prendergast

Victims
1 murder: Chicago Mayor Carter H. Harrison Sr., October 28, 1893; found guilty December 29, 1893, the jury fixing the death penalty
Years active
October 28, 1893
Location
Chicago, Illinois, United States (killing, October 28, 1893; trial; execution, July 13, 1894); Ireland (birth, 1868)
Method
Shot with a revolver (coroner's jury finding and trial record)
Status
Guilty, jury fixing death, December 29, 1893; new trial denied February 24, 1894; stayed March 22, 1894; found sane by a jury July 3, 1894. Executed in Chicago, Illinois, July 13, 1894.

On the evening of October 28, 1893, two days before the World's Columbian Exposition was due to close, Carter Henry Harrison Sr., the mayor of Chicago, was killed in Chicago by a young newspaper distributor named Patrick Eugene Prendergast. Within about half an hour Prendergast had walked into a city police station and told the desk sergeant what he had done. He gave a single reason, and he repeated it in the county jail that night: the mayor, he claimed, had promised to make him corporation counsel, the city's chief lawyer, and had broken his word. Prendergast had no legal training of any kind.

There was never any question about who had caused the death. Everything that followed turned on the state of Prendergast's mind. A Cook County jury heard the evidence on his sanity in December 1893 and on December 29 found him guilty of murder, fixing the penalty at death. The night before his execution in March 1894, a judge stayed it under an old Illinois statute that forbade the execution of a prisoner who had gone insane after judgment, and a second jury was empaneled in June to decide that narrower question. On July 3, 1894, it found him not insane. He was executed in Chicago ten days later, on July 13, 1894.

The trial became a contest between medical experts and lay witnesses over a single mind. It was also the first murder case for a young Chicago lawyer, later a nationally known defense attorney, who joined the defense after the conviction.

The man who died that evening was born in Fayette County, Kentucky, on February 15, 1825. He graduated from Yale College in 1845, traveled widely in Europe and the Near East, finished a law course at Transylvania University in Lexington, and moved to Chicago in 1855. He made his fortune in real estate and never practiced law.

His public life began on the Cook County board. He served two terms in Congress as a Democrat from Illinois in the 1870s, and in 1879 he was elected mayor of Chicago for the first time. He won again in 1881, 1883 and 1885, ran unsuccessfully for governor of Illinois in 1884, and left office after his fourth term. In 1893, with the city preparing to host the fair, he sought the office a fifth time and won. He was elected on April 4, 1893, and inaugurated on April 17.

He governed in the open. At City Hall he gave up the private office his predecessors had used and worked from a desk in the middle of the large reception room, where any visitor could reach him. His political strength lay with the city's working people. On the day he died he spoke at the fairgrounds to welcome the visiting mayors of other American cities. He was engaged to be married in November.

Prendergast was born in Ireland in April 1868 and was educated by the Christian Brothers at a Catholic academy. The defense at his trial built its case on his history, and the prosecution did not seriously contest the account of it that the defense put to its medical witnesses. He had suffered a severe head injury in a fall at the age of four that left him unconscious for a long period. As a child he was described as solitary, irritable and excitable, a backward pupil with a poor memory who did not join in the games of other children, and by 18 he was voicing grand ideas of his own abilities.

By 1893 he was barely supporting himself by distributing newspapers. His mind ran on two public causes. The first was the single tax, the land-value tax advanced by the economist Henry George. He spoke at labor meetings, though he belonged to no union, stopped strangers to try to convert them, and urged his former teachers among the Christian Brothers to teach the doctrine to young children. The second was track elevation. Railroad lines crossed Chicago's streets at grade, raising them was a long-running issue in city politics, and Prendergast lobbied for it with the same fervor.

He wrote constantly to prominent people. In the two weeks before the killing he sent a letter nearly every day to a United States senator from Idaho who led the silver forces in the Senate during the fight over repeal of the Sherman silver purchase law; the letters argued the repeal fight in close detail. Others went to Henry George, who also met him in Chicago in the summer of 1893.

In the spring of 1893 Prendergast campaigned for the mayor's return. He came to believe that his efforts had decided the election and that the reward would be the office of corporation counsel. The appointment went to an experienced lawyer, and Prendergast did not accept it. At some point that year he walked into the corporation counsel's office at City Hall and demanded the keys to the desk, announcing that the mayor had sent him to take possession. The corporation counsel defused the moment by agreeing to hand over the office once he had finished some important business, and Prendergast left content. A few days before the killing he mailed the same official a postcard demanding the job and telling him to resign. On another occasion, sitting uninvited at a restaurant table with the mayor's secretary and another man, he denounced the mayor over track elevation and said he would kill him if the tracks were not raised.

On the evening of October 28, a few hours after the ceremony at the fairgrounds, Prendergast killed the mayor in Chicago. Within about half an hour he gave himself up at a city police station, gave his name and said he had killed the mayor, repeating his claim about the promised office. He was moved under guard to the county jail that night.

In the jail Prendergast seemed indifferent to his surroundings. He asked for the newspapers, read the accounts of the killing, and said several times that he had done his duty. He told questioners that most people would be on his side once they understood and that he expected to go free. In a later police interview he conceded that the mayor had never actually promised him the post.

The coroner's inquest was held the next day, October 29. Asked whether he wished to say anything, Prendergast refused to answer. The coroner's jury found that the mayor had died of injuries inflicted by Patrick Eugene Prendergast and held him to the grand jury.

On November 2, 1893, a Cook County grand jury indicted Prendergast for murder, and he was arraigned the same day. The trial opened on December 6, and testimony began on December 13. The state's witnesses established the killing, and the defense did not contest it. The only real issue was his mind.

The medical evidence produced the trial's sharpest exchange. Before the trial the prosecution had engaged six physicians to examine the prisoner. After repeated examinations, only one would testify that he was sane and responsible, and the state called him alone. The defense then subpoenaed four of the other five, and three of them testified that Prendergast was insane and not responsible for his act. The jury was not told that these men had first been retained by the state. Six more physicians testified for the defense, among them two former asylum officers and the physician at the county jail.

The prosecution answered expertise with acquaintance. It called about thirty lay witnesses, many of them casual acquaintances, to describe their dealings with Prendergast and to say he had seemed rational. Among them was the corporation counsel, who described the visit in which Prendergast had demanded his office. The state also pointed to Prendergast's visible fear in the jail on the day of the mayor's funeral, and showed that letters the defense offered as proof of a disordered mind had first been written in pencil and then traced over in ink.

On December 29, 1893, the jury found Prendergast guilty of murder, the jury fixing the death penalty.

On February 24, 1894, the judge denied a motion for a new trial and sentenced Prendergast to be executed on March 23, 1894. A reviewing court declined to interfere with the judgment.

With no appeal left, the defense turned to a section of the Illinois Criminal Code, in substance on the books since 1845, that required a capital sentence to be stayed if the prisoner became insane after judgment and before execution, until a jury tried the question. On March 22, 1894, the day before the execution, a petition was filed stating that Prendergast had become insane since the verdict. Late that night a Cook County judge found that good cause had been shown, postponed the execution and ordered a hearing under the statute. An appeal for clemency made the same week to the lieutenant governor, then acting in the governor's absence, failed.

The court papers called it the "Insane Proceedings." After a series of delays it opened on June 20, 1894, before a different judge and a jury. The defense was now led by three lawyers, among them the young lawyer trying his first murder case. The question was narrower than at the trial. The jury was not asked whether Prendergast had been sane in October 1893, only whether he was insane at the time of the inquiry. The judge told the jurors the test was whether Prendergast understood that he had been tried and found guilty of murder, understood the nature of the proceeding, and was sane enough to prepare for death.

On July 3, 1894, the jury found Prendergast not insane. A motion for a new trial was denied, and the execution was reset for July 13.

On July 11 two of the defense lawyers traveled to Springfield to ask the governor to spare Prendergast's life. He refused. A petition for a writ of habeas corpus to a judge of the United States Circuit Court in Chicago was denied.

Patrick Eugene Prendergast was executed in Chicago on Friday, July 13, 1894.

His sanity has never been settled. At the trial, three physicians first retained by the state and six others called by the defense said Prendergast was insane and not responsible, against a single state expert and some thirty lay witnesses, and the jury sided with the state.

The promise behind his grievance had no basis outside his own claim. He told police on the night of the killing that the mayor had promised him the office of corporation counsel; in a later interview he said there had been no actual promise.

Timeline

April 1868: Patrick Eugene Prendergast is born in Ireland.

October 1893: Prendergast mails a postcard to the corporation counsel demanding his office.

October 28, 1893: The mayor of Chicago is killed; Prendergast gives himself up to police the same evening.

October 29, 1893: The coroner's jury holds Prendergast to the grand jury.

November 2, 1893: A Cook County grand jury indicts him for murder; he is arraigned the same day.

December 6, 1893: The trial opens; testimony begins on December 13.

December 29, 1893: The jury finds him guilty of murder and fixes the death penalty.

February 24, 1894: The motion for a new trial is denied, and he is sentenced to be executed on March 23, 1894.

March 22, 1894: A petition claims he has become insane since the verdict; the execution is stayed that night and a statutory inquiry ordered.

June 20, 1894: The sanity inquiry opens before a judge and jury.

July 3, 1894: The jury finds him not insane; a new execution date is set.

July 11, 1894: Defense lawyers ask the governor in Springfield for a reprieve; he refuses. A federal habeas corpus petition is also denied.

July 13, 1894: Prendergast is executed in Chicago.