Pascal Simbikangwa

Victims
Genocide and complicity in crimes against humanity, Kigali, 1994. Convicted in Paris March 14, 2014; confirmed on appeal at Bobigny December 3, 2016; final May 24, 2018.
Years active
April to July 1994 (acts in Kigali)
Location
Kigali, Rwanda; Mayotte, Réunion and Paris, France
Method
Genocide and complicity in crimes against humanity, under French law applied to acts in Rwanda in 1994
Status
25 years' réclusion criminelle (2014), confirmed on appeal (2016); appeal on points of law rejected (2018); in custody in France since 2008

Pascal Simbikangwa was the first person tried in France for the genocide against the Tutsi in Rwanda. On March 14, 2014, after six weeks of hearings, the Cour d'assises de Paris found him guilty of genocide and complicity in crimes against humanity for his acts in Kigali between April and July 1994, and sentenced him to 25 years' réclusion criminelle. A second jury, sitting on appeal at Bobigny, reached the same verdict and imposed the same sentence on December 3, 2016. On May 24, 2018, the Cour de cassation rejected his last appeal, and the conviction became final.

He was not accused of killing anyone with his own hands. The case against him was that a man with standing in the security apparatus of the old regime had given material support, instructions and encouragement to the men who carried out killings in the capital, knowing that the people they targeted were Tutsi or civilians. He denied every part of it, from his first hearing to his last. Two juries, with different judges, heard the evidence and convicted him both times.

The trial came almost twenty years after the events and more than five years after his arrest. It was the first full trial of a Rwandan genocide suspect by a French court, brought under laws that allow French judges to try genocide and crimes against humanity committed abroad when the accused is found on French soil.

A captain and an accident

Simbikangwa was born on December 17, 1959, in Rambura, Rwanda. He joined the presidential guard in 1982 and rose to the rank of captain. In 1986 a car accident left him paraplegic and confined to a wheelchair, and his career moved from the army to the intelligence service. In 1988 he was assigned to internal intelligence, a service attached to the presidency, and he worked in intelligence until 1992, when he was relieved of his duties after a government led by an opposition prime minister took office.

The period that the courts examined began on April 6, 1994, when the plane carrying President Juvénal Habyarimana was brought down. The genocide against the Tutsi followed, and it lasted until July. By his own account, Simbikangwa spent those weeks in the capital. His position in those months, and what he did with it, was the whole of the case against him.

Flight and a new name

He left Rwanda after the genocide. He went first to Goma, in what was then Zaire, moved on to East Africa in October 1996, and reached the Comoros in 1998. In 2005 he crossed by boat to Mayotte, the French department in the Indian Ocean, and claimed asylum there under the name Safari Senyamuhara.

He lived in Mayotte under that name for about three years. In Rwanda, meanwhile, prosecutors had indicted him on March 3, 2008, for genocide, complicity in genocide, conspiracy and organized crime. He was placed on Interpol's wanted list. The Rwandan authorities had classed him in the first category of genocide suspects, the category that Rwandan law of 1996 reserved for the alleged planners, organizers and leaders of the genocide.

Mayotte, 2008

The end of his life under another name had nothing to do with 1994. On October 28, 2008, the police in Mayotte arrested him over the production and sale of false identity documents. While he was in custody his real identity came to light, along with the Interpol notice and the Rwandan warrant.

Kigali asked France to extradite him. The request covered complicity in genocide and conspiracy, crimes against humanity, and criminal association under ordinary law. In November 2008 the investigating chamber of the Tribunal supérieur d'appel in Mayotte refused. The court held that the sentence he would probably face in Rwanda, a life term with twenty years in solitary confinement, could not be accepted under international and French standards, and it accepted that there were serious doubts about whether he would receive a fair trial. France would keep him and try him itself, first for the document offenses and then, if the evidence held, for the genocide.

On February 13, 2009, the Collectif des parties civiles pour le Rwanda, an association that brings complaints against genocide suspects living in France, filed a complaint against him in Mayotte. On April 16, 2009, he was formally remanded in custody on the genocide counts. He was moved to Réunion in July 2009 and then, some months later, to mainland France, where he was held from 2009 onward. The identity-document case moved slowly. He spent about three years in pretrial detention on those charges before a court sentenced him in 2012 to two years for the offenses. By then the genocide inquiry was well under way, and he stayed in custody on it.

The investigation

The genocide inquiry passed to examining magistrates in Paris. In January 2012 a specialized unit for crimes against humanity and war crimes, created by a law of December 13, 2011, began work at the Tribunal de grande instance in Paris, with its own examining magistrates and prosecutors, and the Simbikangwa file became its first case to reach trial.

The power of a French court to try him at all rested on article 689 of the Code de procédure pénale and on the law of May 22, 1996, which adapted French law to the statute of the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda. That law allowed French courts to try genocide and crimes against humanity committed in Rwanda in 1994 by a person found on French soil, and his arrest in Mayotte met that condition. The definition of genocide the court would apply was the one in article 211-1 of the French penal code.

Over about four years the examining magistrates traveled to Rwanda four times and interviewed more than a hundred witnesses. Time pressed on them. French law sets a ceiling on pretrial detention for a crime committed outside France and punishable by more than twenty years, and Simbikangwa would reach his fourth year in custody on the genocide counts in April 2013. The investigation closed in February 2013 and went to the prosecutors to settle the charges.

On March 29, 2013, the examining magistrates issued their order sending him to trial. It reclassified some counts, dismissed others, and committed him to the Cour d'assises de Paris on two charges: complicity in genocide and complicity in crimes against humanity. He had at first been placed under investigation on a longer list of counts, including genocide itself, crimes against humanity, participation in a group formed to prepare those crimes, and torture and acts of barbarity. The magistrates found the evidence too weak to send several of those counts to trial. The torture counts, which covered the years 1990 to 1994, fell for a separate reason: under French law their limitation period had expired, while genocide and crimes against humanity have no limitation period at all.

The order set out what the prosecution would try to prove. Simbikangwa was accused of providing material support to the men who held positions in Kigali in the first weeks of the genocide, and of giving them instructions and encouragement that led to the killing of Tutsi.

On June 28, 2013, the prosecutor general's office in Paris announced the dates. The trial would open on February 4, 2014, and was expected to run until March 28.

The Paris trial

The trial opened on Tuesday, February 4, 2014, before the Cour d'assises de Paris. It was the first time a Rwandan genocide suspect had been tried before a French court. The court planned for six to eight weeks of hearings and gave the first two weeks to the historical background, so that the jurors could understand the country and the events before they heard about the man in the dock. The hearings were filmed for the historical record, an unusual step in French justice, over the objections of the defense.

Six jurors were drawn by lot that first morning, with five alternates, and took their seats on either side of the three professional judges. The presiding judge read out the list of witnesses: fifty-one in all, forty-one called by the prosecution and ten by the defense. They ranged from journalists and historians to farmers, security guards and former intelligence officers. Five organizations took part as civil parties, represented by nine lawyers: the Collectif des parties civiles pour le Rwanda, the International Federation for Human Rights (FIDH), the Ligue des droits de l'Homme (LDH), the LICRA and the association Survie.

The defense had filed a thirty-page memorandum the evening before, asking the court to annul the proceedings. Among its grounds was the argument that defense witnesses could not be properly heard in Rwanda. The court deliberated for about an hour and rejected the request.

For roughly the first two weeks the court heard context witnesses, many of them academic specialists on Rwanda. From Monday, February 17, it turned to witnesses who had known the accused in the years before 1994. One, a former head of Rwandan military intelligence who had served a sentence imposed by the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda, testified by video link from the tribunal's seat in Arusha, Tanzania. Another had headed the civilian intelligence service from 1992. Only after them did the court move on to the witnesses of the facts. By the end of the six weeks it had heard almost forty witnesses and expert witnesses.

Simbikangwa denied the charges.

The verdict of March 14, 2014

The closing phase began with the pleadings of the civil parties. On Wednesday, March 12, the prosecution delivered its closing submissions, and the defense pleaded on the morning of Thursday, March 13. In those submissions the prosecution asked the court to change the charge from complicity in genocide to genocide itself, and asked for life imprisonment, the maximum sentence for the crimes charged.

On Friday, March 14, 2014, the court gave its verdict. It found Pascal Simbikangwa guilty of genocide and complicity in crimes against humanity for his actions in Rwanda between April and July 1994. It sentenced him to 25 years' réclusion criminelle. The verdict belonged to a jury of six citizens drawn from the electoral rolls, deliberating with the three professional judges.

The jurors kept only the acts tied to Kigali. The prosecution had also accused him of acts in Gisenyi, in the north of the country, and on those the court acquitted him. In its written reasons it found that the dates given for the Gisenyi acts were incompatible and that the witness accounts were fragile, and that they suggested a degree of coordination among the witnesses that was hard to reconcile with the truth. It was the first conviction in France for participation in the genocide against the Tutsi, and the first conviction for genocide ever handed down by a French court.

He appealed. Under French procedure, an appeal from a cour d'assises is not a review of the record but a full new trial before a different court with a larger jury. The case had to be heard again from the beginning.

The appeal at Bobigny

The appeal trial opened on Tuesday, October 25, 2016, before the Cour d'assises de Seine-Saint-Denis, sitting on appeal in Bobigny, outside Paris. The bench was larger than in 2014: three professional judges and nine jurors. Thirty-two days of hearings were scheduled, and they ran for six weeks. Because an appeal in a French criminal court of this kind rehears the whole case, the case had to be argued again from the start. About fifty witnesses were presented on appeal, and with a few exceptions those heard in Paris came back to testify again. Some, held in custody in Rwanda, gave evidence by video link. The defense set out to undermine the credibility of each of them.

The prosecution again said that Simbikangwa had organized and supported the men who carried out killings in Kigali. The prosecution's case again took in both Kigali and Gisenyi. The defense again rested on the absence of any direct witness to the acts alleged against him, and asked the court to apply to the Kigali charges the same reasoning that had led the first court to acquit on Gisenyi. In the closing days the advocates general asked the court to confirm the conviction. The defense asked for a full acquittal.

Simbikangwa kept to his denial.

On Saturday, December 3, 2016, the court gave its verdict. It confirmed his conviction for genocide and complicity in crimes against humanity for his role in Kigali between April and July 1994, and imposed the same sentence of 25 years' réclusion criminelle. Like the first court, it convicted him only for his acts in the capital. The presiding judge read its findings from a written statement of reasons that ran to six pages, shorter than the first court's. The jurors found that he had provided material support and given instructions to men at several positions in Kigali, knowing that the victims were Tutsi or civilians. The proof of those acts rested on the testimony of three former guards who had worked near him in the capital, with several other witnesses corroborating parts of it. The court also took into account his closeness to the circle around the president.

The defense announced an appeal on points of law. The appeal was lodged on December 6, 2016.

The Cour de cassation, May 2018

The Cour de cassation does not rehear the facts. It decides whether the law was applied correctly. Simbikangwa's appeal raised several grounds, and the criminal chamber rejected all of them in a ruling handed down on Thursday, May 24, 2018.

The broadest ground was that the court of appeal had tried the genocide rather than the accused, and it failed. Two narrower grounds went to the heart of how the appeal had been tried. The defense complained that the court of appeal had refused to travel to the places in Kigali where the events were said to have happened. The court of appeal had answered that more than twenty years after the events the layout of those places had necessarily changed, and that such a visit would in any case be legally impossible on foreign territory, and the Cour de cassation let that answer stand. The defense also argued that the presumption of innocence had been breached because a civil-party association had published accounts of the hearings on its website. The Cour de cassation held that the website lay outside the trial and that nothing in it called into question the impartiality of the court.

In rejecting the appeal, the court left in place the finding that his willingness to take part in the abuses against the Tutsi and the civilian population was manifest. The sentence of 25 years' réclusion criminelle became final. Simbikangwa became the first person definitively convicted in France for the genocide against the Tutsi.

When the appeal verdict was given in December 2016, Simbikangwa had been in custody in France since 2009, after his arrest in Mayotte in October 2008. The ruling of May 2018 made his sentence final, and he remained in custody in France at that date.

Disputed and unproven points

Simbikangwa never admitted any part of the acts of which he was convicted. At both trials he maintained that he was innocent. His defense argued at each stage that the prosecution had no direct witness to his acts, that the testimony against him was isolated, uncorroborated or contradictory, and that it was given more than twenty years after the events. The second court's written reasons, six pages long, were shorter and less detailed than those of the first. Both juries nonetheless convicted him, and the Cour de cassation found no error of law in the second verdict.

The scope of the conviction is narrower than the case first opened against him. Several counts on which he was placed under investigation, including charges tied to events outside Kigali, were dismissed before trial for lack of sufficient evidence, and the torture counts fell to the limitation period. At trial the first court acquitted him of the acts alleged in Gisenyi, and the appeal court convicted him on Kigali alone. The conviction covers his acts in Kigali between April and July 1994 and nothing more.

Timeline

December 17, 1959: Pascal Simbikangwa is born in Rambura, Rwanda.

1982: He joins the presidential guard.

1986: A car accident leaves him using a wheelchair.

1988: He is assigned to internal intelligence, attached to the presidency.

1992: He is relieved of his intelligence duties after a government led by an opposition prime minister takes office.

April 6, 1994: The plane carrying President Juvénal Habyarimana is brought down; the genocide against the Tutsi begins.

April to July 1994: The period of the acts in Kigali for which he was later convicted.

2005: He reaches Mayotte and claims asylum as Safari Senyamuhara.

March 3, 2008: Rwandan prosecutors indict him for genocide, complicity in genocide, conspiracy and organized crime.

October 28, 2008: Police in Mayotte arrest him over false identity documents.

November 2008: The investigating chamber in Mayotte refuses Rwanda's extradition request.

February 13, 2009: The Collectif des parties civiles pour le Rwanda files a complaint against him.

April 16, 2009: He is remanded in custody on the genocide counts.

July 2009: He is moved to Réunion.

January 2012: The specialized unit for crimes against humanity and war crimes begins work in Paris.

2012: He is sentenced to two years for the identity-document offenses.

February 2013: The examining magistrates close their investigation.

March 29, 2013: The magistrates send him to the Cour d'assises de Paris on charges of complicity in genocide and complicity in crimes against humanity.

June 28, 2013: The prosecutor general's office in Paris announces the trial dates.

February 4, 2014: His trial opens in Paris; the court rejects the defense request to annul the proceedings.

February 17, 2014: The court begins hearing witnesses who knew him before 1994.

March 12, 2014: The prosecution asks for a conviction for genocide and a life sentence.

March 14, 2014: The court convicts him of genocide and complicity in crimes against humanity and sentences him to 25 years' réclusion criminelle; it acquits him of the acts alleged in Gisenyi.

October 25, 2016: His appeal trial opens before the Cour d'assises de Seine-Saint-Denis at Bobigny.

December 3, 2016: The appeal court confirms the conviction and the sentence.

December 6, 2016: He lodges an appeal on points of law.

May 24, 2018: The Cour de cassation rejects the appeal; the conviction becomes final.