On the afternoon of Thursday, October 6, 2022, 36 people died in the subdistrict of Uthai Sawan, in Na Klang district of Nong Bua Lamphu province, about 500 kilometers northeast of Bangkok. Twenty-four of them were children, most of them preschoolers enrolled at the local child development center. The Royal Thai Police held one man responsible: Panya Kamrab, a 34-year-old former police sergeant who had been dismissed from the force that year over a drug charge and who had spent the morning in court in that case. By the middle of the afternoon he was dead by his own hand, and with him died any chance of a charge, a trial or a verdict. He is the person police named for the deadliest killing of civilians by a single attacker in Thailand's history, and he was never convicted of anything.
The dead were counted by the police, the health ministry and the provincial government together. Their figure, settled the next day, was 36 people plus the man himself: 24 children and 12 adults. A police breakdown issued on the day gave six men, six women, 21 boys and three girls. Among the dead were members of the center's staff, people in the surrounding area, and, last of all, his own wife and young son. About a dozen more people were wounded, several of them critically, children among them.
Panya was born on June 4, 1988, and joined the Royal Thai Police in 2012; his appointment to the force is dated November 1 of that year. His early years were spent in Bangkok, where he served in two police districts in the city's commercial center, Yan Nawa among them, and rose from lance corporal to corporal and then, in 2019, to sergeant. At the Yan Nawa station he held the post of squad leader.
On June 30, 2019, an order of Provincial Police Region 4 moved him to the northeast, to the police station in Na Wang district of Nong Bua Lamphu, where he served as a squad leader in crime prevention and suppression. He stayed there until the end of his career, and it was in Na Wang that his service began to come apart.
In Na Wang he was reprimanded more than once by his superiors for drug use.
In January 2022 he was suspended from duty after admitting to drug use. On January 20, 2022, a drug suppression investigation unit of the Nong Bua Lamphu Provincial Police searched his residence on a tip and seized a Category 1 narcotic. He told the officers that it was his, and he said the same again when he was questioned. He was charged with illegal possession, and the case went to the Nong Bua Lamphu Provincial Court.
The suspension ran from that day, and the provincial police appointed a committee of inquiry to decide whether he had committed a disciplinary offense. The committee found unanimously that he had: the criminal charge, it concluded, amounted to a serious breach of discipline that had done grave harm to the service. A review committee met on June 15, 2022, agreed without dissent and found no grounds to lighten the penalty. Two days later, on June 17, the commander of the Nong Bua Lamphu Provincial Police signed an order dismissing him from government service with effect from the day of his arrest. The order rested on the National Police Act of 2004 and on a 1999 regulation of the Prime Minister's Office barring state officials from involvement with drugs, and it gave him 30 days to appeal to the Police Commission.
The criminal case outlived his career in uniform. In October it was still before the provincial court, and the Royal Thai Police later said a verdict in that case was expected on Friday, October 7.
On the morning of Thursday, October 6, he attended a hearing in the case and was told to return the following day. The court's business was unfinished when he left the building. Within hours the drug case had become the least of the matters that would never be decided against him.
His son had been enrolled at the Uthai Sawan child development center, a nursery run by the subdistrict's local administration. Police held him responsible for what happened there in the early afternoon.
The deaths at the center accounted for most of the toll. Members of the staff were among the dead, and so were 22 of the children. In the hours that followed, more people died elsewhere in the subdistrict, before he reached the village in Na Klang district where his family lived, a few kilometers from the nursery. Police said that his wife and their son died there. Then he died by suicide.
The children who died that day, two dozen in all, were mostly of preschool age, and the official breakdown counts his son among the 24.
The Central Investigation Bureau, the national police's criminal investigation arm, issued a wanted notice with his photograph while he was still alive and at large. By the time police reached him in Na Klang district, the killing was over.
On Friday, October 7, the health ministry, the police and the provincial authorities gave a single figure of 36 dead, not counting the man himself, and that number has stood since. A dozen others survived their wounds.
The investigation that followed belonged to the Central Investigation Bureau, with the national police leadership on the ground in Na Klang. On Friday officers interviewed witnesses and the families of the dead, and investigators set about reconstructing his movements over the previous days and the course of the afternoon.
What investigators could not establish was a reason. Police said publicly within two days that no clear motive had been found, and none was ever settled in any court. A year after the deaths his motive had still never been established. Because the man police held responsible had died before he could be questioned, charged or tried, no prosecutor ever put a case against him and no judge ever weighed the evidence. A year later no prosecution or court ruling had followed.
The child development center at Uthai Sawan was a nursery attached to the Uthai Sawan Tambon Administrative Organisation, the local administration of the subdistrict, and its young pupils were mostly of preschool age. Uthai Sawan lies in rural Na Klang district in the northeast, about 500 kilometers from the capital, in one of the country's poorest regions.
Nothing about October 6 was tested in a court. Every statement of what happened, and of who caused it, comes from the police and from the people who survived, and none of it was ever put to the man police named. He was never charged with any of the 36 deaths, and the Royal Thai Police described him as the person allegedly responsible.
The drug case that had brought him to court that morning was still pending at his death, and no court ever ruled in it. He had admitted to the arresting officers that the narcotic was his, and a police disciplinary inquiry had found against him, but the criminal charge itself was never decided.
No motive was established. Police offered working explanations in the first days, but none was tested, and the inquiry closed no question about why the deaths happened.
June 4, 1988: Born.
November 1, 2012: Appointed to the Royal Thai Police; serves in two Bangkok police districts, among them Yan Nawa.
2019: Promoted to sergeant.
June 30, 2019: Transferred by order of Provincial Police Region 4 to the police station in Na Wang district, Nong Bua Lamphu.
January 20, 2022: Arrested after a search of his residence; charged with possession of a Category 1 narcotic; suspended from duty, and a committee of inquiry appointed. The criminal case goes to the Nong Bua Lamphu Provincial Court.
June 15, 2022: A review committee upholds the inquiry's finding of a serious disciplinary offense.
June 17, 2022: An order of the Nong Bua Lamphu Provincial Police dismisses him from government service, with effect from January 20.
October 6, 2022, morning: Attends a hearing in the drug case and is told to return the next day.
October 6, 2022, afternoon: 36 people die in Uthai Sawan and nearby, 24 of them children, among them his wife and son; police name him as the person responsible.
October 6, 2022: The Central Investigation Bureau issues a wanted notice; he dies by suicide in Na Klang district the same afternoon.
October 7, 2022: The health ministry, police and provincial authorities give the death toll as 36 plus the attacker; the hearing set for that day in his drug case never takes place.
October 2023: A year on, no prosecution or court ruling has followed, as the man police held responsible died on October 6, 2022.