Pam Hupp is serving life without parole in Missouri for the 2016 murder of Louis Gumpenberger in O'Fallon, a city in St. Charles County. She never admitted the killing. In June 2019 she entered an Alford plea, under which a defendant maintains her innocence while conceding that the state's evidence would likely produce a guilty verdict, and on August 12, 2019, a circuit judge in St. Charles County sentenced her to life in prison with no eligibility for parole.
That conviction sits beside a second case that has not been tried. In July 2021 the prosecuting attorney of Lincoln County, the county north of St. Charles, charged Hupp with first-degree murder and armed criminal action in the 2011 death of her friend Elizabeth "Betsy" Faria. Hupp pleaded not guilty. More than five years later the charge is still pending, now set for a trial before a judge alone in January 2028, and nothing in the 2011 death has been proved against her in any court.
The death in Lincoln County in 2011 was first prosecuted as a case against the victim's husband: Russ Faria was convicted and sentenced to life in prison in 2013, the conviction was set aside in 2015, and he was acquitted at a retrial. Hupp had been a key witness at his trial, and she was not charged when the retrial ended. Within a year her name stood at the center of a separate prosecution in the neighboring county.
Hupp lived in O'Fallon. The death for which she is now serving life took place there in August 2016, and on August 23, 2016, Hupp was arrested. The St. Charles County prosecuting attorney charged her with first-degree murder and armed criminal action. In 2017 she pleaded not guilty.
The prosecution then took the shape of a capital case. In 2017 the prosecuting attorney announced that the state would seek the death penalty if Hupp were convicted of first-degree murder, and the case was prepared for a jury. The trial date was moved again and again. In January 2019 the court ruled that the 2011 death in Lincoln County could be mentioned at her trial, a ruling that would have placed the unsolved case in front of the jury that heard the O'Fallon one.
The jury was never sworn. On Wednesday, June 19, 2019, Hupp came before the St. Charles County Circuit Court, waived her right to a jury trial and entered an Alford plea to first-degree murder and armed criminal action under an agreement with the state. The plea admitted no facts. It conceded only that the state held enough evidence to convict her. In exchange the prosecution withdrew its plan to seek the death penalty, and the sentence on the murder count was fixed at life in prison without parole.
The formal sentencing followed on August 12, 2019, at the St. Charles County Courthouse. The circuit judge imposed life in state prison without the possibility of parole, a term from which Missouri law allows release only by an act of the governor. Hupp was 60 years old. She made no statement before sentence was passed.
The plea closed the O'Fallon case. It left untouched the question that prosecutors had tied it to: who was responsible for the 2011 death in Lincoln County.
By August 2019 the new Lincoln County prosecuting attorney had reopened the 2011 case and hired an investigator to go back through it.
On Monday, July 12, 2021, the prosecuting attorney's office charged Hupp, then 62, with first-degree murder and armed criminal action in the 2011 death. The charging papers allege that a few days before the death Hupp had been made the beneficiary of a $150,000 life insurance policy.
On Tuesday, July 27, 2021, she was brought from state prison to the Lincoln County Justice Center in Troy for her first appearance on the new charges, and a plea of not guilty was entered. At the same time the prosecuting attorney announced that he would seek the death penalty if she were convicted of first-degree murder.
The defense sought a change of venue, and the case was moved to Springfield, in Greene County, about four hours from Lincoln County. The distance became its own problem. In late October 2023 the prosecuting attorney dismissed the case and refiled the same first-degree murder charge in order to petition for a venue closer to Lincoln County.
The refiled case came before a circuit judge in St. Charles County. In January 2025 that judge set the trial for 2026, more than four years after the original charge. That date did not hold.
Early in 2026 Hupp waived her right to a jury trial and elected to have the case decided by a judge alone, the same choice she had made in the O'Fallon case seven years before, though this time without a plea. On Monday, October 19, 2026, the court approved moving the trial to St. Louis County and set it to begin on January 24, 2028.
Hupp is held in a Missouri state prison under the 2019 sentence of life without parole. As of October 19, 2026, she was awaiting a bench trial in St. Louis County on the first-degree murder charge in the 2011 death, set for January 24, 2028. She has pleaded not guilty, the charge has not been tried, and no verdict has been reached.
The Lincoln County charge is an accusation. Hupp has pleaded not guilty to it, it has not been tried, and the allegation that she was responsible for the 2011 death has not been proved in any court. The account of the insurance policy is a claim set out in the charging case.
Prosecutors contended that the O'Fallon killing was staged to divert attention from the reinvestigation of the 2011 death; that theory was never tested at a trial. The Alford plea admitted no facts.
The 2013 conviction of the victim's husband was set aside, and he stands acquitted of the 2011 death.
2011: Death in Lincoln County, Missouri, that is the subject of the pending charge.
2013: The victim's husband is convicted in Lincoln County and sentenced to life in prison.
2015: His conviction is set aside; he is acquitted at a retrial.
August 2016: Death in O'Fallon, St. Charles County.
August 23, 2016: Hupp is arrested and charged with first-degree murder and armed criminal action.
2017: Hupp pleads not guilty; the St. Charles County prosecuting attorney announces that the state will seek the death penalty.
January 2019: The court rules that the 2011 death may be mentioned at her trial.
June 19, 2019: Hupp waives a jury and enters an Alford plea to first-degree murder and armed criminal action; the death penalty is withdrawn.
August 12, 2019: Sentenced in St. Charles County Circuit Court to life without parole.
August 2019: The Lincoln County prosecuting attorney has reopened the 2011 case and hired an investigator to review it.
July 12, 2021: Lincoln County charges her with first-degree murder and armed criminal action in the 2011 death.
July 27, 2021: First appearance at the Lincoln County Justice Center in Troy; a not-guilty plea is entered; the state says it will seek the death penalty.
Late October 2023: The case, by then moved to Springfield, is dismissed and refiled to seek a closer venue.
January 2025: A St. Charles County circuit judge sets the trial for 2026.
Early 2026: Hupp waives a jury and elects a bench trial.
October 19, 2026: The court moves the trial to St. Louis County and sets it for January 24, 2028.