In the spring of 1915 the leader of the Gophers, the gang that held Manhattan's West Side, stood trial in the Court of General Sessions for the first-degree murder of a man known as Patsy Doyle. The case rested on the word of young women who had kept company with him and his men, and it ended on June 2, 1915, when a jury that had deliberated for seven hours returned the lesser verdict of manslaughter. He went to Sing Sing on a term of 10 to 20 years.
The conviction was the only one ever entered against him for a killing. Madden served eight years, came out on parole in 1923 and, over the following decade, became one of the wealthiest figures in New York's underworld. In July 1932 the state sent him back to Sing Sing for violating his parole. Released in 1933, he left New York for Hot Springs, Arkansas, where he lived for three decades and died in April 1965.
Owen Vincent Madden was born on December 18, 1891, in Leeds, England, and grew up in Hell's Kitchen on the West Side of Manhattan.
He joined the Gophers as a boy and in time rose to lead the gang.
The man at the center of the 1915 trial was known on the West Side as Patsy Doyle.
Nothing more is known of his life. He died in Manhattan, and three members of the Gophers were charged with murder in the first degree for his death: Madden and two of his men.
The state tried the two other Gophers first. Their case, The People of the State of New York against John McArdle and James Ward, also known as Arthur Bieler, was tried in the Court of General Sessions in March 1915 on a charge of murder in the first degree. Its transcript runs to 445 pages. Bieler was sent to Sing Sing after admitting his own part in the killing. One of the young women who later testified against Madden had already given evidence at that earlier trial.
Madden's turn came in late May, and the state set out to prove its case against him through witnesses who had been close to him.
The People of the State of New York against Owen Madden opened in the Court of General Sessions on May 24, 1915, before a judge of that court, with two assistant district attorneys for the state and a defense lawyer. The charge was murder in the first degree. The record of the trial fills 635 pages.
The state's main witnesses were two young women who had been close to the gang. One of them gave an account that differed from the one she had given at the earlier trial.
Madden testified in his own defense and denied the murder, and the defense offered an alibi.
The jury returned its verdict on June 2, 1915: not murder in the first degree, as charged, but the lesser crime of manslaughter. Madden was found guilty of manslaughter.
He faced a term of up to 20 years.
The court sentenced him to Sing Sing, at Ossining, on a term of 10 to 20 years.
The case did not end with the sentence. In October 1915 the defense, with a second lawyer now beside the first, brought proceedings in the Court of General Sessions on a motion for a new trial. Those proceedings, before the same judge, ran to 297 pages of transcript. The ground was that the women whose evidence had convicted him were now retracting it.
The motion failed. In November 1915 the court refused a new trial, and Madden stayed in Sing Sing. The court found nothing to fault in the conduct of the prosecution. The women who had recanted were held on charges of perjury.
He is not known to have appealed the conviction to a higher court.
Madden served his time at Sing Sing and was released on parole in early 1923, after about eight years.
In the years that followed he built a large business in Prohibition-era New York.
His parole remained in force through all of it. On July 7, 1932, he was sent back to Sing Sing for violating its conditions, after leaving the state without permission. He served about seven months more.
Madden's sentence of 10 to 20 years meant that, once paroled in 1923, he remained under the supervision of the New York parole authorities for the rest of the term, and could be returned to prison for any breach of its conditions without a new trial. That is what happened in 1932: the violation that sent him back was an unauthorized trip out of New York, not a new crime.
He had first visited Hot Springs, Arkansas, in 1931, and his release in 1933 has been tied to a condition that he settle there permanently. The full terms of that move remain unknown. He handed over his New York interests and moved to Hot Springs in 1935.
He lived in Hot Springs for the rest of his life.
Madden died in Hot Springs on April 24, 1965.
Patsy Doyle's death is the only killing for which Madden was ever convicted, and even that verdict was manslaughter, not the murder charged. By the end of his life he had been charged in six killings and convicted in only one. The other five charges, their dates and their outcomes are not known, and none of them was ever proven in court.
The conviction itself rested heavily on two young women who had been close to the gang, one of whom changed her account between the first trial and Madden's. After the verdict both recanted. The court refused to accept the recantations, held the women for perjury and left the verdict standing.
The defense offered an alibi. The jury rejected the murder charge but convicted him of manslaughter.
The terms on which he left New York in the 1930s remain unsettled, including whether settling in Hot Springs was a condition of his 1933 release.
December 18, 1891: Owen Vincent Madden is born in Leeds, England.
March 1915: Two other Gophers are tried in the Court of General Sessions on a charge of murder in the first degree for the killing.
May 24, 1915: Madden's trial for murder in the first degree opens in the Court of General Sessions.
June 2, 1915: The jury finds him guilty of manslaughter.
1915: He is sentenced to Sing Sing on a term of 10 to 20 years.
October 1915: The defense moves for a new trial on the ground that two witnesses have recanted.
November 1915: A new trial is refused; the recanting witnesses are held for perjury.
Early 1923: Madden is released on parole.
July 7, 1932: He is returned to Sing Sing for parole violations.
1933: He is released.
1935: He settles in Hot Springs, Arkansas.
April 24, 1965: He dies in Hot Springs.