Otto Ohlendorf

Victims
About 90,000 people killed by Einsatzgruppe D. His testimony, adopted by Military Tribunal II, which found him guilty on counts one, two and three, April 1948.
Years active
June 1941 to June 1942
Location
Chernivtsi and Bukovina, Ukraine (killings); Bessarabia, Moldova (killings); Mykolaiv, Ukraine (killings); Kherson, Ukraine (killings); Berdiansk, Ukraine (killings).
Method
Mass shooting; gassing in mobile gas vans (prosecution's case and his own 1946 testimony)
Status
Death sentence April 10, 1948, US Military Tribunal II, Nuremberg; affirmed March 1949; clemency refused January 31, 1951. Executed at Landsberg am Lech, Bavaria, Germany, June 7, 1951.

Otto Ohlendorf was a trained lawyer and economist who spent most of the Nazi years behind a desk in Berlin, writing reports on the mood of the German public and the workings of German trade. For one year, from June 1941 to June 1942, he left that desk to command Einsatzgruppe D, a unit of the Security Police and the SD that followed the German army into the southern Soviet Union. Asked under oath at Nuremberg in January 1946 how many people the unit had killed under his direction, he answered that "the Einsatzkommandos reported 90,000 people liquidated" in that year, and that the number included men, women and children.

That answer, given as a witness for the prosecution before the International Military Tribunal, made him the central figure of the next great case. In the Einsatzgruppen Trial, the ninth of the twelve American trials that followed, he was the first-named defendant, and the case carried his name: United States of America v. Otto Ohlendorf et al. On April 8 and 9, 1948, US Military Tribunal II found him guilty of crimes against humanity, war crimes and membership in the SS and the SD. On April 10, 1948, it sentenced him to death. Nearly three years of review, clemency petitions and appeals to American courts followed. On June 7, 1951, he was executed at Landsberg am Lech in Bavaria.

Hoheneggelsen, Leipzig and Göttingen

Ohlendorf was born on February 4, 1907, in Hoheneggelsen, a village in the Hildesheim district of Lower Saxony. The tribunal that later tried him put his origins simply: he was born on a farm.

He joined the Nazi Party in 1925 and the SS in 1926. In his own testimony at Nuremberg he first gave 1926 for his entry into the SA, then corrected it to 1925. Before 1933 he served as a local party leader in the Northeim district.

From 1928 to 1931 he studied law and economics at the universities of Leipzig and Göttingen, and he passed the first state law examination in 1931. He spent about a year in Italy studying how the Fascist state was organized, and afterward broke off his training as a court clerk. He practiced as a barrister at the courts of Alfeld on the Leine and Hildesheim. In October 1933 he became an assistant at the Institute for World Economics in Kiel, and in April 1935 he moved to Berlin as a department head at the Institute for Applied Economic Science at the city's commercial college.

The SD and Office III

In 1936 Ohlendorf entered the SD, the intelligence service of the SS, as an economic consultant. He rose quickly. In 1937 he took charge of the SD's whole domestic intelligence service under Reinhard Heydrich. In the autumn of 1939, when the SS and police offices were merged into the Reich Security Main Office, the RSHA, he became head of its Office III. That office studied how government measures affected the German population and produced the confidential "Reports from the Reich" until the summer of 1944. He described himself as its part-time chief from 1939 to 1945.

He kept a second career in the economy alongside the first. In June 1938 he became manager of the Reich Group Trade, the official organization of German commerce, and in November 1939 its chief manager. In November 1943 he was appointed deputy to the state secretary in the Reich Economics Ministry, and in January 1944 he was made a ministerial director there. In November 1944 he was promoted to SS-Gruppenführer and lieutenant general of police.

Einsatzgruppe D

When Germany invaded the Soviet Union in June 1941, four Einsatzgruppen went in behind the army: units of the Security Police and the SD that together numbered about 3,000 men. Their tasks included seizing important sites, preventing sabotage, recruiting collaborators and building intelligence networks. They were also sent to kill.

Heydrich gave Ohlendorf command of Einsatzgruppe D, the smallest of the four. Its men trained in Saxony, at Pretzsch, Düben and Bad Schmiedeberg, in May and June 1941. By Ohlendorf's own account he had about four weeks' notice of the campaign, and his group numbered about 500 men, not counting local auxiliaries. It left on June 21, 1941. He served as the representative of the Chief of the Security Police and SD with the 11th Army, within Army Group South.

The orders, he testified, had been given by word of mouth before the campaign began, at a meeting where an RSHA department head passed on instructions from Heydrich and Heinrich Himmler: the Jews and the Soviet political commissars were to be killed. He said Himmler repeated the order in person at Nikolaiev, now Mykolaiv, in the late summer of 1941.

The group's area ran, in his description, from Cernauti, now Chernivtsi, through Mohilev-Podolsk and Yampol, now Mohyliv-Podilskyi and Yampil, and Melitopol to Rostov and the Crimea. It worked first in Bukovina and Bessarabia, lands that now lie in Ukraine, Moldova and Romania, then across southern Ukraine and onto the Crimean peninsula. It was held in reserve for the Caucasus, and its zone was later extended there. The group killed people in Nikolayev, Kherson, Berdiansk and Taganrog, among other places.

The people the unit killed

The victims of the Einsatzgruppen were Jews of any age or sex, Roma, and officials of the Communist Party and the Soviet state. Under the orders as they were widened from the middle of 1941, women, children and the elderly were among them. Einsatzgruppe D's killing of Roma began at Nikolayev in September 1941.

The unit's reports to Berlin counted them as totals. Ohlendorf told the International Military Tribunal that he read those reports himself, and the figure he gave from them, 90,000 people in one year, became the figure on which the tribunal that tried him judged his command.

The Einsatzgruppen indictment spoke of persecution, murder and extermination of civilians, and of the murder of prisoners of war and civilians under military rule. The prosecution put the total killed by all four Einsatzgruppen at more than one million people.

By his own account Ohlendorf led Einsatzgruppe D until Heydrich's death on June 4, 1942. He returned to the RSHA in Berlin in the summer of 1942 and to Office III, and in 1943 he went back to economic work at the Reich Economics Ministry. The tribunal later rejected his claim that he had gone east as an employee of the Reich Group Trade: he had headed Office III before he went to Russia, it noted, and he headed it when he came back.

Flensburg and surrender

When Germany collapsed in the spring of 1945, Ohlendorf joined the short-lived government formed by Admiral Karl Dönitz after Hitler's death, first at Plön and then at Flensburg, as a senior economic official. He hoped, after the defeat, to carry on the SD's reporting work as a kind of public opinion research. He surrendered to British authorities on May 23, 1945, and was held along with members of the Dönitz government.

British intelligence officers questioned him at length that summer. In an interrogation dated July 7, 1945, he described the last days of the war and a plan, in Himmler's circle, to seek a separate peace, in which Himmler might lead a new government and the Allies would be allowed to advance as far as the Elbe without resistance. He also described a letter of May 9, 1945, from Himmler to Field Marshal Bernard Montgomery, which he said he had edited because its text was "unfortunately worded." A second interrogation in August 1945 covered corruption in the Nazi state. He gave his questioners information on the SS's policy of annihilation.

Witness at the International Military Tribunal

On January 3, 1946, Ohlendorf took the stand before the International Military Tribunal at Nuremberg, the court trying the major war criminals. He appeared voluntarily, as a witness called by the American prosecution.

He described his career, his command and the orders he said he had received. He gave the 90,000 figure for the year from June 1941 to June 1942 and confirmed that it took in men, women and children. He said the numbers reported by the other Einsatzgruppen were "considerably larger," and that he believed those figures were exaggerated. Questioned by defense counsel about the men who carried out the orders, he said it was inconceivable that a subordinate leader would refuse orders from the leaders of the state, that a refusal would have meant a court-martial, and that for men who had sworn obedience "the question of legality could not arise." He could not remember one concrete case of a man asking to be relieved, he said, though he had sent some men home whom he thought unsuited to the work.

Case 9

After the International Military Tribunal, the United States held twelve further trials at Nuremberg before American judges, under Allied Control Council Law No. 10. Case 9, against leaders of the Einsatzgruppen, named 24 defendants and charged them with the killing of between 723,661 and one million people as part of a systematic program of genocide.

Each defendant faced three counts covering June 1941 to July 1943. Count one charged crimes against humanity: persecution, murder and extermination of civilians. Count two charged war crimes: the mistreatment and murder of prisoners of war and of civilians under military rule. Count three charged membership in organizations that the International Military Tribunal had declared criminal: the SS, the SD and the Gestapo.

Ohlendorf was one of four defendants who had commanded an entire Einsatzgruppe. The rest had commanded or served as deputy commanders of the smaller Einsatzkommandos and Sonderkommandos beneath them. Twenty-two of the 24 stood trial, before US Military Tribunal II at the Palace of Justice in Nuremberg. At his arraignment on September 15, 1947, Ohlendorf pleaded not guilty, as every defendant did.

The trial

The prosecution opened on September 29, 1947. Its case rested almost entirely on documents: the operational reports the Einsatzgruppen had sent to Berlin during the war, which recorded the killings unit by unit. It called no witnesses. The defendants who admitted taking part denied that they were criminally responsible: they had acted lawfully, they said, and under superior orders.

Ohlendorf testified in his own defense. With one minor exception, he confirmed what he had told the International Military Tribunal two years earlier. He made no attempt to deny the killings. His defense was legal. He argued that he had acted on superior orders, that Germany had been compelled to attack the Soviet Union as a defensive measure, and that the security of the army to which his group was attached had required the operations he admitted. His counsel also argued that he had not been a member of a criminal organization, and that he had gone east as an employee of the Reich Group Trade rather than as an officer of the RSHA.

Defense affidavits described another man: an economist who had wanted to make the SD a fact-gathering body, who had clashed with Himmler and with Gestapo chief Heinrich Müller, and who had opposed totalitarian tendencies in the state.

Judgment and sentence

The tribunal delivered its judgment on April 8 and 9, 1948. A general opinion dealt with the defenses the defendants shared, among them superior orders and the claim that the killings had been self-defense or a necessity of war. Individual findings followed for each man.

The finding on Ohlendorf was short. The court noted that he never denied the facts of the killings and sought to be cleared only by the legal argument that he had acted under superior orders, and it said those defenses had been dealt with in the general opinion. It held that it could rule only on the Ohlendorf who, "by his own word, headed an organization which, according to its own reports, killed 90,000 people," and it found that the killings by Einsatzgruppe D violated the laws and customs of war, general international law and Control Council Law No. 10. Those charges, it held, "have been proved before this Tribunal beyond a reasonable doubt."

"The Tribunal accordingly finds Otto Ohlendorf guilty under counts one and two of the indictment," the judgment reads. On count three, it rejected his counsel's argument and found that he had been a member of the criminal organizations SS and SD under the conditions defined by the International Military Tribunal's judgment, and that he was "therefore, guilty under count three of the indictment."

Of the 22 defendants tried, 20 were convicted on counts one and two, and all 22 on count three.

The tribunal pronounced sentence on April 10, 1948, and sentenced Ohlendorf to death. Thirteen other defendants received the same sentence, and the rest were given lesser terms. In March 1949 the Military Governor of the US Zone affirmed the sentences.

Review, clemency and execution

The condemned men were held at Landsberg am Lech, in Bavaria, with the other war criminals the American authorities had convicted. The US High Commissioner for Germany set up an Advisory Board on Clemency for War Criminals to review their cases, and leaders of the West German government pressed the American authorities to re-examine them.

The High Commissioner announced his decisions on January 31, 1951. He reduced the sentences of most of the 89 prisoners from the Nuremberg Military Tribunals still held at Landsberg. Of the 15 death sentences before him, he commuted ten and affirmed five. Ohlendorf's was among the five. So were those of Paul Blobel, Werner Braune and Erich Naumann from his own trial, and of Oswald Pohl, who had headed the concentration camp system.

Ohlendorf and six other men awaiting execution in American custody then turned to the courts of the United States. On February 13, 1951, the federal district court in Washington rejected their petitions, and in April 1951 the US Supreme Court refused to review the case. A last appeal in Washington in late May won a further stay.

The reprieve was brief. Otto Ohlendorf was executed at Landsberg am Lech on June 7, 1951, together with Naumann, Blobel and Braune from his own trial, with Pohl, and with two other men condemned by American courts. The four Einsatzgruppen commanders were the only defendants in Case 9 whose death sentences were carried out.

Disputed and unproven points

The 90,000 figure is Ohlendorf's own, drawn from the Einsatzkommando reports he said he read, and the tribunal relied on it in those terms: the toll of an organization he headed "by his own word" and "according to its own reports." The prosecution's estimate for all four Einsatzgruppen was more than one million people, and the indictment charged the defendants together with killing between 723,661 and one million. Ohlendorf told the International Military Tribunal that he believed the other groups' reports were exaggerated.

His account of how the orders reached him, by word of mouth at a meeting before the campaign and then again from Himmler at Nikolaiev, is his testimony. The tribunal did not need to settle its details. It noted that superior orders were the only ground on which he sought to be cleared, and it convicted him.

The defense picture of a principled economist who had quarreled with Himmler and Müller rested on affidavits from people who knew him. The tribunal did not adopt it. It said it could judge only the man who had headed Einsatzgruppe D.

Timeline

February 4, 1907: Otto Ohlendorf is born in Hoheneggelsen, Lower Saxony.

1925: He joins the Nazi Party and the SA; he joins the SS in 1926.

1928 to 1931: He studies law and economics at Leipzig and Göttingen and passes the first state law examination.

October 1933: He joins the Institute for World Economics in Kiel.

1936: He enters the SD as an economic consultant.

Autumn 1939: He becomes head of Office III of the Reich Security Main Office.

June 21, 1941: Einsatzgruppe D, under his command, sets out for the Soviet Union.

Late summer 1941: By his account, Himmler repeats the killing order in person at Nikolaiev.

June 1942: His command of Einsatzgruppe D ends; he returns to Berlin.

November 1943: He becomes deputy to the state secretary in the Reich Economics Ministry.

November 1944: He is promoted to SS-Gruppenführer and lieutenant general of police.

May 23, 1945: He surrenders to British authorities.

January 3, 1946: He testifies before the International Military Tribunal at Nuremberg.

September 15, 1947: He pleads not guilty at his arraignment.

September 29, 1947: The trial opens before US Military Tribunal II.

April 8 and 9, 1948: The tribunal finds him guilty under counts one, two and three.

April 10, 1948: He is sentenced to death.

March 1949: The Military Governor of the US Zone affirms the sentence.

January 31, 1951: The US High Commissioner refuses him clemency.

February 13, 1951: A federal district court in Washington rejects the condemned men's petitions.

April 1951: The US Supreme Court refuses to review the case.

June 7, 1951: Otto Ohlendorf is executed at Landsberg am Lech.