On October 12, 1960, the leaders of Japan's three main parties shared a stage at Hibiya Public Hall in Tokyo for a joint public meeting that opened the campaign for the general election due the following month. Prime Minister Hayato Ikeda of the Liberal Democratic Party sat on the platform with Suehiro Nishio of the Democratic Socialist Party, and television cameras were trained on the speakers. When Nishio finished, the chairman of the Japan Socialist Party, Inejiro Asanuma, rose to speak. Minutes into his address a 17-year-old youth ran up onto the stage and fatally assaulted him in front of the audience and the cameras. The chairman died the same day. The youth, Otoya Yamaguchi, was arrested on the spot.
He never stood trial. After questioning by the Tokyo police he was moved into juvenile custody in the capital, and about three weeks after his arrest he died there by suicide. No court ever ruled on the killing. In law he died an accused person, arrested in the act, whose case ended with his death.
The man at the lectern was born in 1898 on Miyakejima, an island under the administration of Tokyo. At Waseda University he belonged to the oratory society and took part in sumo and rowing. He was a towering figure on the platform, and two popular names followed him through politics: the "human locomotive" and the "speech-giving farmer."
He graduated from Waseda's School of Political Science and Economics in 1923 and went straight into the prewar proletarian movement. In December 1925 he helped found the Farmer-Labor Party, Japan's first single nationwide proletarian party, and served as its secretary-general; it was banned on the day it was formed. He went on to head the organization departments of the Labor-Farmer Party and the Japan Labor-Farmer Party, and in 1936 he won a seat in the House of Representatives for the Social Masses Party.
After the war he was among the founders of the Japan Socialist Party. He became its secretary-general in 1948, and in March 1960 the party chose him as its chairman. He belonged to the party's right wing. In March 1959 he led a Socialist delegation to Beijing and there described the United States as the shared enemy of China and Japan, at a time when neither Tokyo nor Washington recognized the government in Beijing. He came back wearing a suit cut in the style worn by Mao Zedong, and members of his own party criticized him for it.
His months as chairman coincided with the fiercest political struggle of postwar Japan. On January 19, 1960, the cabinet of Prime Minister Nobusuke Kishi signed a revised Japan-U.S. Security Treaty. Kishi presented it as a correction of the inequalities in the 1951 agreement and a step toward fuller independence. The chairman led the campaign against ratification inside the Diet and on the streets.
On May 19 the ruling party forced through a 50-day extension of the Diet session while police guarded its members, and the treaty passed the lower house in the early hours of May 20. Socialist members resolved to resign their seats en masse and demanded Kishi's resignation and the dissolution of the lower house. On June 16, a day after a student died in a demonstration at the Diet, the government asked President Dwight Eisenhower to postpone a planned visit, and the visit never took place. On June 23, the day the treaty was ratified, Kishi announced that he would step down. Hayato Ikeda formed a new cabinet on July 19.
The struggle had already turned to violence. Before the Hibiya meeting, Kishi and the Socialist politician Jotaro Kawakami had each been attacked by right-wing assailants.
Yamaguchi was 17 in October 1960 and enrolled as a student in the Chinese literature department of Daito Bunka University. On May 10, 1959, he had joined the Greater Japan Patriotic Party, the small ultranationalist group led by Bin Akao. Two members quit the party at the end of May 1960, and he left after them.
The Hibiya meeting was no party rally. It was organized jointly by the Tokyo Metropolitan Election Administration Commission, the Fair Election League and NHK. Members of right-wing groups were in the audience that day, and they heckled the Socialist chairman as he spoke against the security treaty.
The assault took place on the stage, a few minutes into the chairman's address, in full view of the prime minister, the other party leaders and the audience. The national public broadcaster was recording the meeting.
Yamaguchi was arrested in the act. The chairman was taken from the hall and died that day.
Yamaguchi was taken straight to Metropolitan Police headquarters, where officers of the Public Security Second Division of the Tokyo Metropolitan Police Department questioned him. He gave them his name and his age, 17, and told them he had acted alone. The police kept digging all the same. On October 13 a joint special investigation headquarters was set up, combining the Public Security Second Division with the Marunouchi police station and backed by the department's Fourth Investigation Division, and witnesses were asked to come in voluntarily to be interviewed. The question that drove the inquiry was whether anyone stood behind the youth.
On October 14 the police handed the case to the Tokyo District Public Prosecutors Office, and Yamaguchi was held in detention while prosecutors and police worked the case together. Prosecutors investigated it as murder under Article 199 of the Penal Code. Their work was aimed squarely at possible accomplices, and it turned up none. Reporting to the House of Councillors on December 1, the head of the Justice Ministry's Criminal Affairs Bureau said no evidence of an accomplice relationship had been found, and on December 22 he told the House of Representatives that the position was the same.
Because he was a juvenile, the case went next to the Family Court. On November 2, 1960, prosecutors sent it there under the Juvenile Act, attaching their opinion that criminal punishment was appropriate. The court ruled the same day and ordered him held at a juvenile classification home in Tokyo for examination.
He died there that evening, by suicide, three weeks after his arrest. With the suspect dead, the murder case had to be closed. No juvenile hearing and no criminal trial ever took place, and no court made any finding about what he had done.
The killing of an opposition leader at an election meeting brought the case onto the floor of both houses. Iwao Yamazaki, Minister of Home Affairs and chairman of the National Public Safety Commission, resigned, as the prime minister confirmed to the House of Councillors on October 22, and by October 24 Hideo Shuto held both posts.
On October 24 both houses adopted resolutions on the elimination of violence by standing vote.
Under the Juvenile Act, which came into force in 1949, Japanese newspapers still sometimes printed the names of young offenders. In December 1958, after a protest from the Ministry of Justice, the Japan Newspaper Publishers and Editors Association set out a policy of reporting juvenile cases anonymously. Yamaguchi's case was handled differently. Less than two years after that policy was adopted, the national press named him in full, an unusual departure from it.
Because Yamaguchi died before any hearing, nothing about the killing was ever tested in court. His statement that he acted alone was never examined by a judge, and no court considered whether anyone else shared responsibility. The joint inquiry by police and prosecutors found no evidence of an accomplice, but that conclusion was an investigative one, reached without a hearing.
March 1959: The future Socialist chairman leads a party delegation to Beijing.
January 19, 1960: The Kishi cabinet signs the revised Japan-U.S. Security Treaty.
March 1960: The Japan Socialist Party chooses a new chairman.
May 20, 1960: The treaty passes the lower house after the session is extended.
June 16, 1960: The Japanese government asks for President Eisenhower's visit to be postponed.
June 23, 1960: The treaty is ratified; Kishi announces his resignation.
July 19, 1960: Hayato Ikeda forms his first cabinet.
October 12, 1960: At a joint election meeting at Hibiya Public Hall in Tokyo, the Socialist chairman is killed; Otoya Yamaguchi, 17, is arrested in the act.
October 13, 1960: A joint special investigation headquarters is set up within the Metropolitan Police.
October 14, 1960: The police hand the case to the Tokyo District Public Prosecutors Office, which investigates it as murder.
October 24, 1960: A joint committee meeting of the House of Representatives examines the case; both houses adopt resolutions on the elimination of violence.
November 2, 1960: Prosecutors refer the case to the Family Court, which orders him held at a juvenile classification home in Tokyo; he dies by suicide there that evening, untried.
December 1 and 22, 1960: The Justice Ministry reports to the Diet that no evidence of an accomplice has been found.