Oskar Gröning

Victims
300,000 murders aided at Auschwitz, 1944. Convicted as an accessory by the Lüneburg Regional Court, July 15, 2015, of aiding murder in 300,000 cases; final September 20, 2016
Years active
Service at Auschwitz from September 1942 to October 1944; offenses found for May to July 1944
Location
Nienburg an der Weser; Auschwitz (occupied Poland); Hannover region; Lüneburg; Karlsruhe
Method
Aiding and abetting murder, through service in the camp's administration of prisoners' money and property; never found to have killed anyone himself
Status
Four years; appeal dismissed September 20, 2016; constitutional complaint not accepted December 21, 2017; clemency refused January 2018; died March 9, 2018

On July 15, 2015, the Regional Court of Lüneburg convicted Oskar Gröning, a 94-year-old former member of the SS, of aiding murder in 300,000 legally concurrent cases and sentenced him to four years' imprisonment. The murders were those committed at Auschwitz during the operation against the Jews of Hungary in the spring and summer of 1944, and Gröning had served in the camp's administration of prisoners' money and property. No one at the trial claimed that he had personally killed anyone. The case turned on whether a man in his position could be held criminally responsible at all, and on September 20, 2016, Germany's Federal Court of Justice answered that he could.

That ruling made the verdict final, and it gave the case a weight well beyond one defendant. For the first time, the country's highest criminal court upheld an accessory conviction for service in a Nazi extermination camp, in a decision later printed in the court's official reports. Gröning never began his sentence. The courts found him fit to serve it, the Federal Constitutional Court declined to intervene, and the public prosecutor's office in Lüneburg refused his plea for clemency. He died on March 9, 2018, at the age of 96, while a final petition to the justice ministry of Lower Saxony was still undecided.

Nienburg and the SS

Gröning was born on June 10, 1921, in Nienburg an der Weser, a town in Lower Saxony. He trained as a savings bank clerk.

In October 1940 he volunteered for the SS. The trial court found that he wanted to belong to what he regarded as an elite, and that he did not want to serve with a combat unit. He was assigned first as a paymaster in SS pay offices. In September 1942, holding the rank of SS-Sturmmann, he was transferred to Auschwitz in occupied Poland; the Federal Constitutional Court later dated his service there from September 25, 1942. He was later promoted to SS-Unterscharführer, a junior noncommissioned rank, and he would stay at the camp for about two years.

His post was in the camp's money administration, a subdivision of the office that took charge of the property of prisoners and of the people deported there. The trial court found that he sorted, recorded and managed the money taken from deportees and carried it to Berlin, where it was delivered to the SS economic administration or paid into an SS account at the Reichsbank. Throughout his service, the court found, he was also responsible, like the other SS men there, for guarding the deportees and for preventing resistance or escape by armed force. The Federal Court of Justice described him as 22 or 23 years old during the period for which he was convicted.

The trial court also made findings about what he knew. It found that he understood in detail how the camp operated, that he knew the people brought there were being killed in great numbers by exploiting their defenselessness, and that he knew his work supported that machinery. He accepted this, the court found, at least conditionally, because a post in the camp kept him away from front-line service. In October 1944 he was transferred out of Auschwitz to a combat unit.

The case is reopened

Prosecutors in Frankfurt am Main investigated him from 1977 and discontinued the proceedings in March 1985. In the years before his trial he lived in the Hannover region.

The case that finally reached a courtroom began with preliminary investigations by the Central Office of the State Justice Administrations for the Investigation of National Socialist Crimes in Ludwigsburg, the office the German states maintain to investigate Nazi crimes. In 2013 that office recommended that state prosecutors pursue about 30 former Auschwitz staff members. The file on Gröning was taken up by the public prosecutor's office in Hannover, which would carry the case from the indictment to the end of the enforcement proceedings.

The indictment

On September 15, 2014, the Hannover prosecutors announced that they had charged Gröning, then 93, with aiding murder in 300,000 cases. The indictment, filed with the Regional Court of Lüneburg, was limited for legal reasons to a single, defined operation: the murder of Jews deported from Hungary to Auschwitz between May 16 and July 11, 1944, which the court would later call the "Ungarn-Aktion." The prosecutors alleged that he had helped the regime profit from the killings by handling the money and property of the deported and forwarding it to his SS superiors in Berlin, and that through this work he had supported the systematic murders.

In those eight weeks the SS brought the deported Jews of Hungary to Auschwitz-Birkenau and killed most of them on arrival.

Twenty survivors and relatives of people killed at the camp joined the case as joint plaintiffs at the outset, as German criminal procedure permits. By the time the trial opened their number had grown to more than 60, and by the verdict to more than 70. A conviction for aiding murder in these cases carried a minimum sentence of three years.

The trial in Lüneburg

The trial opened on April 21, 2015, before the Fourth Major Criminal Chamber of the Regional Court of Lüneburg, sitting as a jury court for the gravest crimes, under case number 27 Ks 9/14. The court had set aside 27 days of hearings through the end of July. Gröning was 93 when it began.

He did not contest that he had served at Auschwitz. Over the weeks that followed, survivors who had traveled to Lüneburg gave evidence, and written statements from others were read into the record.

Hearings were interrupted on May 6 and 7, 2015, on health grounds. On May 11 the court announced that a medical opinion on the defendant was now available and that the trial could continue as planned, and it resumed the next day.

Closing arguments were heard in early July. The prosecution asked for a sentence of three and a half years. Several joint plaintiffs asked for more. Some of their lawyers argued that he should be convicted not as an accessory but as a co-perpetrator of murder. The defense asked for acquittal, arguing that in law he had not furthered the killings.

Verdict and sentence

On July 15, 2015, after a trial of almost three months, the court found Gröning guilty of aiding murder in 300,000 legally concurrent cases and sentenced him to four years' imprisonment, six months more than the prosecution had requested. The court treated the conduct as a single act in law, which is why the 300,000 cases produced one sentence. Murder itself carries a mandatory life sentence in Germany; for an accessory the range runs from three to fifteen years, and the four years the court imposed sat at the lower end of it.

The figure of the dead was itself a finding made in the defendant's favor. Of the people deported from Hungary in the operation, those killed on arrival had never been registered, so the court could not establish an exact number. It assumed at least 300,000 deaths. That was the figure on which the indictment, the conviction and the appeal all rested.

The court found no evidence that he had taken part in any specific killing. It held instead that he had known what was being done at the camp and had supported it through his own work there, and that this support was enough to make him an accessory to the murders committed during the operation. He remained free after the verdict, and it was left open for the time being whether, at his age, he would ever be made to serve the sentence. The parties had a week to lodge an appeal on points of law.

The written judgment

The chamber's written reasons were published on September 21, 2015. They held that the murders of the operation met two of the aggravating elements that define murder in German law: they were committed treacherously, by exploiting the victims' defenselessness, and cruelly. The court ruled out a conviction as a co-perpetrator and rested the verdict on aiding alone.

The reasons also dealt with sentencing. The chamber examined the possible mitigating grounds and rejected them. Two defense arguments failed in particular. The first was that his evidence as a witness in earlier proceedings against SS men should count in his favor. The second was that the long delay before he was charged, after he had been questioned by investigators in 1978, should reduce the sentence.

The publication of the written reasons started the clock for the appeals. Gröning's two defense lawyers lodged an appeal on points of law, and so did lawyers for several joint plaintiffs. The prosecution waived its right to appeal. The defense sought a lower sentence; some of the joint plaintiffs sought a conviction as a co-perpetrator, while others joined the appeal to remain parties to the proceedings and to guard against a reduction.

The appeal to the Federal Court of Justice

Two sets of appeals reached the Third Criminal Senate of the Federal Court of Justice in Karlsruhe. Gröning challenged the application of the substantive law and raised several procedural objections. Ten joint plaintiffs also appealed. They wanted him convicted as a co-perpetrator rather than an accessory.

The Senate decided the case on September 20, 2016, under case number 3 StR 49/16, and announced the outcome on November 28, 2016. It dismissed his appeal against the Lüneburg judgment of July 15, 2015, and it dismissed the joint plaintiffs' appeals as well, rejecting further joint-plaintiff filings that had not been lodged properly. The procedural objections failed for the reasons the Federal Prosecutor General had given in his written application to the court, and a full review of the substantive law found no error to his disadvantage. He was ordered to bear the costs of his appeal, and the joint plaintiffs whose own appeals failed were left to bear their own expenses of that stage. With that, the Lüneburg judgment became final. The decision was later published in the court's official collection as BGHSt 61, 252.

The Senate's reasoning set out how far accessory liability reached. Under § 27 of the Criminal Code, aid means, in principle, any act that objectively promotes or eases the principal's crime. The aid need not cause the specific result, it may come before or during the crime, and it may take a psychological form, by strengthening the resolve of those who carry the crime out. Membership in a group was not enough on its own. Each person's acts had to be judged under the ordinary rules for perpetration, instigation and aiding.

Those rules, the Senate held, applied to crimes organized by a state as they did to any others, but the facts of such crimes had to be taken into account. In the murder of the Jews of Europe, many people held political, administrative or military posts without killing anyone themselves, and many others carried out the killings on orders within a chain of command. For a man at a lower level who had no control over the crime, the question was whether his acts had furthered the conduct of at least one of the perpetrators at any of those levels.

Applied to Gröning, those rules produced a conviction on two levels. The Senate accepted that he had not been present when every one of the victims arrived, and it did not find that his general service had supported the men who did the killing at the camp itself. His service aided someone else: the state and SS leaders who ordered and organized the operation. The murder of the Hungarian Jews depended on an organized killing apparatus, and Auschwitz-Birkenau and its staff were part of it. Only because that apparatus existed, staffed by obedient subordinates, could the leaders order the operation and carry it out in the form it took. Gröning belonged to the personnel serving at the camp when the order was given. He did not need to be known to those leaders personally. It was enough that they knew the posts were filled by reliable men.

He had also performed concrete duties tied to the killings, among them handling the victims' money and taking part in keeping control over them, and the exploitation of the victims' property brought the SS a profit even after each killing was complete.

The Senate then turned to his state of mind. He had known all of this from shortly after his arrival at the camp, it held, and had still fitted himself into its routine and carried out every order, in order to stay away from the front. He knew that by serving there, together with others, he helped create the conditions under which the leadership could order a killing operation at Auschwitz at any time and rely on its being carried out. Nothing more was needed, the Senate held, to establish his intent as an accessory to all the murders of the operation attributed to him.

The Senate addressed an older line of authority. In a judgment of February 20, 1969, the Second Criminal Senate had said that not everyone integrated into the Auschwitz program was automatically an accessory to every killing there. The Third Senate found that it did not need to resolve any conflict with that ruling. Gröning was not charged with everything that had happened at Auschwitz, only with murders within the defined operation, and specific acts with a direct connection to the organized killing had been found against him. On that basis the decision was consistent with the earlier case law.

One question the Senate left open. It did not decide whether the trial court had been right to treat all of his aid as a single act in law. Treating his separate duties as separate offenses could not have helped him, so the point made no difference to the outcome.

Fitness to serve

The final judgment left one question open: whether a man in his mid-90s would actually be imprisoned. His lawyers asked for the enforcement of the sentence to be deferred on health grounds under § 455 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, which allows a sentence to be postponed when imprisonment would endanger a person's life or seriously threaten his health. They submitted a certificate from his own doctor stating that he was unfit for custody.

The public prosecutor's office in Hannover, responsible for enforcing the sentence, obtained a statement from the district public health office and a supplementary psychiatric report. Both found him fit for custody, provided that his particular need for care was met. On July 14, 2017, the office refused the request, and it announced the decision on August 1, 2017. The defense objected that he had not been physically examined and went to court.

On August 17, 2017, the Regional Court of Lüneburg rejected his application for a judicial ruling. He lodged an immediate complaint with the Higher Regional Court of Celle and filed a psychiatric opinion from an expert of his own, who agreed that his physical condition did not prevent imprisonment but warned of the risks to his mental state. The Celle court obtained a further statement on that opinion. On November 7, 2017, under case number 3 Ws 491/17, it dismissed the complaint. It found that his health did not require a deferral under the mandatory provisions of § 455 and that the prosecutors had not misused their discretion under its third paragraph. His age-related needs, it held, could be met by suitable arrangements in custody, and the state's duty to protect the security of its citizens and their trust in state institutions weighed against him. The decision became known on November 29, 2017. The defense then asked the Celle court to reconsider on the ground that it had not properly taken one medical opinion into account.

He then filed a constitutional complaint, announced by his lawyer on December 19, 2017, arguing that enforcing the sentence would violate his right to life and physical integrity under Article 2 of the Basic Law, and asked for an interim order. Filing the complaint did not by itself suspend the sentence. On December 21, 2017, the Third Chamber of the Second Senate of the Federal Constitutional Court declined, unanimously, to accept the complaint for decision, which made the application for an interim order moot. The ruling was published on December 29, 2017, under case number 2 BvR 2772/17, and could not be appealed.

The chamber found that the complaint raised no question of fundamental importance and had no sufficient prospect of success. The state's duty to enforce final sentences served public safety, confidence in its institutions and the equal treatment of offenders, and it gave way only where imprisonment threatened life or serious harm to health. The lower courts had enough medical information before them, including official medical reports and an opinion he had commissioned himself. The absence of a physical examination did not make their inquiry inadequate, because the doctors had assessed him on a visit and on recent medical records, and every doctor agreed that his care needs could be met in custody. His age alone did not justify abandoning a sentence for an offense of that gravity, and the conviction in 300,000 cases gave particular weight to enforcing it. Serving it did not remove his realistic chance of regaining his freedom, since early release on probation remained possible. Medical staff in custody could meet his needs, and the sentence could be interrupted if his health worsened significantly. The Celle court had been entitled to require a high probability that imprisonment would endanger his life, and it had weighed the conflicting expert opinions in detail.

Clemency and death

With the courts exhausted, Gröning asked for clemency. In January 2018 the public prosecutor's office in Lüneburg refused the petition, giving no reasons, as a decision within its discretion and not open to review by a court. The Hannover prosecutors said they would send him a summons to begin his sentence promptly, though it had not yet gone out in mid-January.

He then took the matter to the justice ministry of Lower Saxony, the last authority able to grant clemency, and the ministry confirmed on March 1, 2018, that it had received the petition. It set no timetable; such petitions have no deadline but are always treated as urgent. The petition did not suspend enforcement, and the prosecutors in Hannover had still not sent the summons.

The decision was never needed. Oskar Gröning died on March 9, 2018, at the age of 96, without having served any part of his sentence. The Hannover prosecutors learned of the death from a letter from his lawyer and awaited the official death certificate. His death ended the enforcement proceedings, and the ministry no longer had to rule on his petition. The conviction itself, final since 2016, stands.

Disputed and unproven points

The only factual question about the scale of the crimes that the court left open was the exact number of the dead. The 300,000 figure is a minimum, adopted because those killed on arrival had never been registered. Every court that dealt with the case used it, and no court found a lower one.

The joint plaintiffs who appealed argued that Gröning should have been convicted as a co-perpetrator of murder. The trial court had ruled that out, the Federal Court of Justice rejected the argument, and the conviction stands as one for aiding murder only. The Federal Court of Justice also left open whether his aid was one act in law or several.

The clemency petition that reached the justice ministry of Lower Saxony was never decided. His fitness for imprisonment, upheld by three courts and found unobjectionable by the Federal Constitutional Court, was contested by his defense until his death.

Timeline

June 10, 1921: Oskar Gröning is born in Nienburg an der Weser.

October 1940: He volunteers for the SS.

September 25, 1942: He begins service at Auschwitz, in the camp's money administration.

May 16 to July 11, 1944: The operation against the Jews of Hungary, the period covered by his conviction.

October 1944: He is transferred from Auschwitz to a combat unit.

1977: Frankfurt prosecutors open an investigation, discontinued in March 1985.

2013: The Ludwigsburg investigators recommend prosecution of about 30 former Auschwitz staff members.

September 15, 2014: Hannover prosecutors announce charges of aiding murder in 300,000 cases.

April 21, 2015: The trial opens before the Regional Court of Lüneburg.

May 6 and 7, 2015: Hearings are interrupted on health grounds; the trial resumes on May 12.

July 15, 2015: He is convicted of aiding murder in 300,000 legally concurrent cases and sentenced to four years.

September 21, 2015: The written judgment is published; the defense and several joint plaintiffs appeal, and the prosecution waives its appeal.

September 20, 2016: The Federal Court of Justice dismisses all appeals (announced November 28, 2016); the verdict is final.

July 14, 2017: Hannover prosecutors refuse to defer the sentence (announced August 1).

August 17, 2017: The Regional Court of Lüneburg rejects his challenge.

November 7, 2017: The Higher Regional Court of Celle dismisses his complaint.

December 21, 2017: The Federal Constitutional Court declines to accept his complaint (published December 29).

January 2018: Lüneburg prosecutors refuse his petition for clemency.

March 1, 2018: The justice ministry of Lower Saxony confirms receipt of a further petition.

March 9, 2018: Oskar Gröning dies, before beginning his sentence.