One Goh

Victims
7 people murdered in Oakland, California, April 2, 2012; three others wounded; pleaded no contest, May 2, 2017, to seven counts of first-degree murder and three of attempted murder
Years active
April 2, 2012
Location
Oakland, California (killings); Alameda, California (arrest); Oakland, California (court); Napa, California (state hospital); Sacramento, California (death in custody)
Method
Shot with a handgun
Status
Found incompetent 2013 and 2015; restored April 2017; seven consecutive life terms without parole plus 271 years to life, July 14, 2017. Died in custody, Sacramento, March 20, 2019.

On the morning of April 2, 2012, seven people were killed and three others were wounded at Oikos University, a small Christian vocational college near Oakland International Airport in Oakland, California. The man who did it, One L. Goh, had studied in the school's nursing program until a few months earlier. Within an hour he was in custody in the neighboring city of Alameda, and he admitted what he had done almost at once. Six of the dead were women. The seventh was a man.

No killing at an American college had taken more lives since 2007. Yet the prosecution that followed never turned on who was responsible. It turned on whether the accused was fit to stand trial at all. For five years the case moved between a courtroom in Oakland and Napa State Hospital. He was found incompetent in January 2013 and again in December 2015. In April 2017 a judge found his competency restored, and in May he pleaded no contest to seven counts of first-degree murder. In July 2017 he was sentenced to seven consecutive terms of life without the possibility of parole plus 271 years to life. He died in custody less than two years later, on March 20, 2019, at the age of 50.

Goh was born in South Korea and was 43 at the time of his arrest, living in Oakland. Public records traced a restless decade before that. An Oakland address was listed for him in 2004, but he spent most of the 2000s in Virginia, with a few months in suburban Richmond in late 2005 and about three years in Gloucester County, where he was evicted in 2009 for unpaid rent.

Money troubles followed him. The records showed tens of thousands of dollars in liens and judgments: a debt of more than $10,000 to a bank in 2006, federal tax liens filed in 2006 and 2009 that together topped $23,000, and a small credit-card judgment entered against him in December 2011.

He paid $6,000 in tuition to Oikos. By the end of 2011 he was no longer in the program, and prosecutors said he had wanted the money refunded and been refused.

Lydia Sim was born in San Francisco and spent her whole life in the Bay Area. She grew up in Hayward in a long-established church community, where she was remembered as an outgoing, caring young woman who often looked after the children. Sonam Choedon had come to the United States two years before, and people who knew her through the Tibetan community in the East Bay remembered her devotion to that community and her wish to give her life to helping other people.

Grace Eunhea Kim graduated from Foothill High School in 2007. A friend called her the most vivacious person she knew, and the people around her remembered her singing and the way she made others smile. A friend described Doris Chibuko as one of the nicest, sweetest and most thoughtful people she had known.

Tshering Bhutia was born in Sikkim, in India, and lived in San Francisco. A friend remembered him as one of the gentlest people she knew, and perennially upbeat. Judith Seymour and Katleen Ping died that morning too. Three other people were wounded and survived.

The arrest came quickly. Goh was taken into custody in Alameda, a few miles away, about an hour after the killings, and he admitted them to Oakland police.

On April 4, 2012, the Alameda County District Attorney's Office charged him with seven counts of murder and three counts of attempted murder, along with robbery, carjacking, kidnapping and other counts. The complaint carried special-circumstance allegations: seven for multiple murder, and one each for murder during a robbery, during a carjacking and during a kidnapping. He pleaded not guilty and was held without bail. In August 2014 an Alameda County grand jury indicted him on the same murder and attempted murder counts, so that he could go straight to trial if he were ever found fit for one.

On January 7, 2013, an Alameda County Superior Court judge ruled: "The defendant is not competent to proceed." The ruling rested on the reports of two court-appointed psychiatrists, who found that he had paranoid schizophrenia and could not cooperate in his own defense. The case was suspended, and a few months later he was moved to Napa State Hospital, where the aim of treatment was to restore his competence so that he could be tried.

The reports from Napa were slow to change. In 2015 the prosecution asked for his competence to be reviewed, and a forensic psychologist at the hospital, and then its doctors, concluded that he could stand trial. The defense disputed that, and the question went to a contested hearing in December 2015 before a judge of the Alameda County Superior Court.

On December 17, 2015, the judge ruled that Goh was still incompetent. She found that he could not assist his lawyers in a rational manner. The ruling did not end the case; it meant only that a trial could not yet take place. He stayed at Napa.

Treatment continued for more than a year. In April 2017 court-appointed doctors concluded that his competency had been restored, and on April 24 an Alameda County Superior Court judge found him competent to stand trial.

On May 2, 2017, Goh pleaded no contest to seven counts of first-degree murder and three counts of premeditated attempted murder. He admitted the special-circumstance allegations of murder during a kidnapping and multiple murders. The district attorney's office did not seek the death penalty, and the agreed sentence was life without parole.

The sentencing took place in Oakland on July 14, 2017. The judge imposed seven consecutive terms of life without the possibility of parole, plus 271 years to life in state prison. Goh did not speak. In a statement read on his behalf, he apologized, said he understood the devastation he had caused to the families and the community, and said he hoped that spending the rest of his life in a maximum-security prison would bring them some degree of closure.

Goh was committed to the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation to serve his sentence. He was held at California State Prison, Sacramento, and died there on March 20, 2019, at the age of 50. The department announced the death a week later.

How Goh came to leave Oikos was never settled in court. In the first days after the killings, the Oakland police chief said he had been expelled; prosecutors and later court reporting described a man who had left the program and then fought over a refund. Because the case ended in pleas, no trial tested either account.

His mental condition was described in several ways over the years by court-appointed psychiatrists, hospital doctors and his own lawyer. The only court findings were the competency rulings of January 2013 and December 2015 and the restoration finding of April 2017.

Timeline

2004: An Oakland address is listed for Goh; he lives mostly in Virginia over the following years.

2009: Evicted in Gloucester County, Virginia, for unpaid rent.

Late 2011: Leaves the nursing program at Oikos University in Oakland.

April 2, 2012: Seven people are killed and three wounded at Oikos University; Goh is taken into custody in Alameda the same morning and admits the killings.

April 4, 2012: Charged with seven counts of murder with special circumstances, three of attempted murder and other counts.

January 7, 2013: Found not competent to proceed; later moved to Napa State Hospital.

August 22, 2014: Indicted by an Alameda County grand jury.

December 17, 2015: After a contested hearing, a judge rules he remains incompetent.

April 24, 2017: A judge finds him competent to stand trial.

May 2, 2017: Pleads no contest to seven counts of first-degree murder and three of premeditated attempted murder; the death penalty is not sought.

July 14, 2017: Sentenced to seven consecutive terms of life without parole plus 271 years to life.

March 20, 2019: Dies in custody at California State Prison, Sacramento, aged 50.