Ghislaine Marchal died in Mougins, on the French Riviera, on June 23, 1991. Her gardener, a young Moroccan named Omar Raddad, was arrested two days later, and on February 2, 1994, the Cour d'assises des Alpes-Maritimes in Nice found him guilty of her murder and sentenced him to eighteen years of réclusion criminelle. He has denied the killing from the start, and he denies it still.
The conviction has never been quashed, and it has never settled the case. In 1996 President Jacques Chirac granted Raddad a partial pardon, and in September 1998 he left detention on conditional release. The pardon shortened his sentence; it left the conviction untouched. Raddad has spent the decades since seeking a second trial. The Cour de révision rejected his first request in 2002. A second request, built on genetic traces of unidentified men found by later testing, was declared inadmissible in October 2022. In law, the verdict of 1994 stands.
Raddad was a Moroccan immigrant who worked as a gardener on the Riviera, and he had no criminal record. His employer was a wealthy and educated widow, and her education would become part of the case.
She was found dead on June 24, 1991, and investigators dated her death to the previous day. Words written at the scene pointed at once to the gardener: "Omar m'a tuer," with the infinitive "tuer" where correct French requires "tuée." To the investigators, and later to the prosecution, they were the victim's own last words, naming the man who had killed her. The handwriting experts of the original investigation, between 1991 and 1993, attributed the writing to her.
Raddad was arrested on June 25, 1991, and charged with murder. He denied it, and he has denied it at every stage since. The prosecution located the motive in money: three days before her death, it said, he had argued with his employer over an advance on his wages.
The defense attacked the inscription from the first. A woman of her education, it argued, would not have made so elementary a grammatical error, and someone else must have written the words to steer suspicion toward the gardener. It challenged the time of death as well. All of it went before the trial court, and none of it persuaded the court.
Raddad was held in custody until his trial in Nice before the Cour d'assises des Alpes-Maritimes, the department's court for the most serious crimes, sitting with a jury. The prosecution built its case on the inscription, on the motive and on Raddad's place in the victim's working life. The defense maintained his innocence.
On February 2, 1994, the court found Omar Raddad guilty of murder and sentenced him to eighteen years of réclusion criminelle. No appeal on the facts was open to him at the time, so the jury's decision was the end of the ordinary road. What was left was revision, the narrow procedure by which French courts reopen a final conviction.
The king of Morocco, Hassan II, asked the French president for leniency. In 1996, during his visit to France, President Chirac granted Raddad a partial pardon, which shortened the time he had to serve and did nothing to the conviction. On September 4, 1998, Raddad left detention on conditional release after more than seven years in custody, and he settled in the Toulon area of southern France.
His first request to revise the verdict was filed in January 1999. The test then was whether a new element, unknown to the trial court, was of a kind to raise a doubt about his guilt. New expert work followed. The handwriting experts of 2000 contradicted the original investigation, concluding that handwriting could not settle who had written the inscription, and new genetic analysis found a man's traces that did not come from Raddad. In June 2001 the Commission de révision, the panel of judges that screens such requests, sent the case on to the Cour de révision itself.
On November 20, 2002, the Cour de révision rejected the request. On the inscription, it held that the victim was indeed the author: the latest expert report could neither confirm nor exclude her hand, and a closer examination of the writing was, in the court's words, far from supporting the theory of another writer. On the genetic traces, the court accepted that they were new but found that they raised no doubt, because "il est impossible de déterminer à quel moment, antérieur, concomitant ou postérieur au meurtre, ces traces ont été laissées." Before the murder, during it or after it, the court could not say, and without that it would not set aside a jury's verdict. It rejected the remaining arguments too, and the pardon and the conditional release stayed in place.
"Je vais combattre jusqu'à la fin de ma vie," Raddad said afterward: he would fight to the end of his life.
A change in the law opened the way back. In June 2014 Parliament relaxed the conditions for revising a final criminal conviction and placed a commission d'instruction in front of the court, to screen each request and decide whether it goes on to the Cour de révision et de réexamen, the only body that can order a new trial. Relying on the new law, the defense obtained fresh sampling, and the analysis found genetic traces of four unidentified men, none of them his. In 2019 an expert retained by the defense concluded that one of those profiles had more likely been left at the time of the crime than through later contamination, which fit the argument the defense had made since 1991, that someone other than the victim wrote the words.
On June 24, 2021, thirty years to the day after the victim was found, Raddad's lawyer filed a second request for revision, arguing that the new elements could raise a doubt about his guilt. "Je demande juste, comme tout le monde, d'avoir un second procès," Raddad said that year: he was asking only, like anyone, for a second trial. On December 16, 2021, the commission d'instruction ordered further investigation to weigh the defense expert's conclusions, the first step toward a possible retrial, and in May 2022 it ordered additional information on further elements the defense had put before it.
On October 13, 2022, the commission declared the request inadmissible. The case would not go forward to the Cour de révision, and there would be no new trial.
Omar Raddad was living in the Toulon area of southern France in 2021. His conviction for murder stands. The 1996 pardon shortened his sentence and the 1998 release gave him back his freedom, but neither reached the verdict, and no court has quashed it. As of January 2026 the case had not been reopened, and he has never stopped denying the killing.
Raddad's guilt is the central dispute, and no court has resolved it in his favor. The Cour d'assises convicted him in 1994; the Cour de révision refused in 2002 to reopen the verdict, holding that the victim herself wrote the inscription; and the commission d'instruction declined in 2022 to send his second request forward. He has always denied the killing.
Who wrote the inscription is still contested. The original investigation attributed it to the victim; the experts of 2000 found that handwriting could not settle the question; the 2002 court held that she was the author. The prosecution put the grammatical error down to the victim's condition when she wrote, and the defense has read it as the mark of another hand.
The genetic traces of unidentified men are established; their meaning is not. The Cour de révision held in 2002 that traces of that kind could not be dated against the murder. The defense's expert favored deposit at the time of the crime. No court has accepted that conclusion, and no one else has been charged.
June 23, 1991: The victim is killed in Mougins, Alpes-Maritimes.
June 25, 1991: Omar Raddad is arrested and charged with murder.
February 2, 1994: The Cour d'assises des Alpes-Maritimes in Nice convicts him of murder and sentences him to 18 years' réclusion criminelle.
1996: President Jacques Chirac grants a partial pardon.
September 4, 1998: Raddad leaves detention on conditional release.
January 1999: First request for revision filed.
June 2001: The Commission de révision refers the case to the Cour de révision.
November 20, 2002: The Cour de révision rejects the request.
June 2014: A new law relaxes the conditions for revision.
June 24, 2021: Second request for revision filed.
December 16, 2021: The commission d'instruction orders further investigation.
October 13, 2022: The commission declares the request inadmissible.