Omar Mateen

Victims
49 people killed in Orlando, June 12, 2016; never tried. The FBI and federal prosecutors attributed the deaths and 53 injuries to him; he died that morning during the police response
Years active
June 12, 2016
Location
Fort Pierce and Orlando, Florida
Method
Murder of 49 people and wounding of 53 (attributed; investigated by the FBI as an act of terrorism)
Status
No sentence. Died June 12, 2016. The only person charged, his wife, was found not guilty on all charges on March 30, 2018.

In the early hours of Sunday, June 12, 2016, 49 people were killed and 53 more were wounded in Orlando, Florida. The FBI and federal prosecutors attributed every one of those deaths and injuries to Omar Mateen, a 29-year-old security officer from Fort Pierce, on Florida's Atlantic coast. Mateen died the same morning when officers of the Orlando Police Department ended the incident. He was never arrested, never charged and never tried, and no court has ever ruled on what he did.

What the law could still do, it did in other forms. The FBI ran the case as a federal terrorism investigation and spent months reconstructing his life. The county medical examiner identified the dead and completed the examinations the law requires in every homicide. The Justice Department brought one prosecution, against his wife, and a federal jury acquitted her on every count. Behind all of it sat one fact: the FBI had investigated Mateen twice before, in 2013 and 2014, and had closed both inquiries.

Mateen was born in New York and was a United States citizen. He grew up in Martin and St. Lucie counties, on Florida's Atlantic coast. He had no criminal record.

From 2003 to 2006 he attended Indian River State College, known as Indian River Community College when he enrolled, and in 2006 he received an associate degree in criminal justice technology. The ambition the degree pointed to was law enforcement, and for the next eight years his public records trace a man trying, and failing, to get inside it.

In 2006 he took a law enforcement basic abilities test in Leon County. In October of that year he went to work for the Florida Department of Corrections as a trainee, and in January 2007 he entered the corrections academy that Indian River State College ran in Martin County under the department's sponsorship. He did not last. The department said later that he had been involuntarily dismissed and asked to leave in April 2007, that he had not completed his academic program, and that he had never been certified as a correctional officer. In its own words, he had been "unable to meet the basic requirements of the correctional officer academy."

On September 10, 2007, he began work as a security officer for a private security company, the job he still held in 2016. State records showed that he had passed a psychological evaluation in 2007 as part of his security licensing. He kept applying for the career he wanted. In September 2011 he applied to become a trooper with the Florida Highway Patrol. He applied to a police academy at Indian River State College and was not admitted, and he did not appeal. In 2014 he sat another law enforcement basic abilities test, this time at Indian River State College. None of it led anywhere. Among his security postings was the St. Lucie County courthouse, and by 2016 he was living in Fort Pierce.

Mateen first came to the FBI's attention in 2013, while he was working as a contract guard at the courthouse. Co-workers reported that he had made inflammatory and contradictory statements suggesting ties to terrorism, and the FBI opened a preliminary investigation.

The inquiry lasted about ten months, and agents interviewed him twice.

Officials could not verify what he had said, and in March 2014 the FBI closed the investigation without finding that he was a terrorist. He had been placed on a terrorism watch list while the inquiry was open, and he was removed from it when the case closed.

About two months later his name came up again, in a separate federal inquiry, and agents interviewed him a third time. They concluded that the contact had been minimal and that he posed no threat, and they closed that inquiry as well.

Two years later, on June 13, 2016, the day after Orlando, the director of the FBI publicly set out this history. On July 18, 2016, the St. Lucie County Sheriff's Office released about 70 pages of its own and the FBI's documents from the 2013 inquiry setting out in the inquiry's own papers how it had begun and why it had been closed.

The deaths in Orlando came early on a Sunday morning. When the incident ended, 49 people were dead and 53 were wounded, and Mateen was dead as well, having died during the police response. During the incident, the FBI said, he had claimed allegiance to the leader of the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant.

The FBI took the lead in a federal terrorism investigation, working with the Orlando Police Department and with state, local and federal partners.

The District Nine Medical Examiner's Office, which serves Orange and Osceola counties, identified all 49 of the dead by June 14, 2016, and began releasing its reports in August 2016.

Because Mateen was dead, the federal inquiry had no defendant to build a case against. Its questions were different: whether he had acted alone, whether anyone had directed or helped him, and how he had come to do what he did.

The day after the attack the director of the FBI gave the bureau's first assessment. Investigators had found no indication that Mateen had received direction from outside the United States, and no indication that he was part of any network. Agents went on working to learn whether anyone had helped him in any way.

By June 16 investigators were talking to hundreds of people, everyone who had dealings with him, and the FBI asked anyone with information to come forward so that agents could build the most complete picture possible of what he had done and why.

The scale of that work emerged later, in court papers. In August 2017 a federal court order in Orlando summarized what the government had turned over in the one prosecution that followed: tens of thousands of pages of law enforcement reports, records drawn from more than 300 grand jury subpoenas, and dozens of hours of video from businesses and private citizens.

The only criminal case arising from June 12 was brought against Mateen's wife. In January 2017 a federal grand jury in the Middle District of Florida indicted her on one count of aiding and abetting the attempted provision and provision of material support to a foreign terrorist organization, the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant, and one count of obstruction of justice. Her trial opened in the United States District Court in Orlando on March 1, 2018, and on March 30, 2018 the jury found her not guilty on all charges: not guilty of aiding and abetting the attempted provision and provision of material support, and not guilty of obstruction of justice.

No court has tested the case against Mateen. Every statement that he caused the deaths and injuries of June 12, 2016 is an attribution by the FBI and federal prosecutors, not a finding by a judge or jury. The FBI's early conclusion that he acted without direction from abroad was an assessment made the day after the attack, and in the months that followed the director told Congress only that further work was needed to settle whether a foreign organization had inspired him. Neither question was ever tested at a trial of his own.

The one trial that took place did not settle what anyone else knew. The government's theory at his wife's trial was that she had known of the attack in advance and had helped him; the jury rejected both charges.

The FBI's earlier contact with him is plain in outline: the bureau opened two inquiries, interviewed him three times, and closed both cases in 2014, two years before Orlando.

Timeline

1986 or 1987: Omar Mateen is born in New York.

2003 to 2006: Attends Indian River State College; receives an associate degree in criminal justice technology in 2006.

October 2006: Begins work with the Florida Department of Corrections as a trainee.

January 2007: Enters the corrections academy in Martin County.

April 2007: Is involuntarily dismissed; never certified as a correctional officer.

September 10, 2007: Begins work as a security officer for a private security company.

September 2011: Applies to become a Florida Highway Patrol trooper.

2013: The FBI opens a preliminary investigation after co-workers report his statements.

March 2014: The FBI closes the investigation; he is removed from a terrorism watch list.

2014: About two months later, a separate FBI inquiry interviews him and closes.

June 12, 2016: 49 people are killed and 53 wounded in Orlando; Mateen dies the same morning during the police response.

June 13, 2016: The FBI director publicly sets out the bureau's 2013 and 2014 inquiries.

June 14, 2016: The medical examiner's office completes the identification of all 49 of the dead.

July 18, 2016: The St. Lucie County Sheriff's Office releases about 70 pages of records from the 2013 inquiry.

January 2017: A federal grand jury in the Middle District of Florida indicts his wife.

March 1, 2018: Her trial opens in federal court in Orlando.

March 30, 2018: The jury finds her not guilty on all charges.