Ogün Samast

Victims
1 murder, Hrant Dink, Istanbul, January 19, 2007. Convicted in 2011 of premeditated murder and an offense under the arms law.
Years active
January 19, 2007
Location
Istanbul (Şişli), Turkey (killing); Samsun, Turkey (detention); Istanbul, Turkey (trials); Trabzon, Turkey (birth).
Method
Shot (he confessed; convicted of premeditated murder, 2011).
Status
22 years 10 months, July 25, 2011; upheld March 2012; extra terms for offenses in custody. Conditionally released in Turkey, November 15, 2023.

Ogün Samast was 17 years old on January 19, 2007, when he killed Hrant Dink, the founder and editor-in-chief of the bilingual weekly Agos, in the Şişli district of Istanbul. A Turkish citizen of Armenian origin, the editor was one of the best-known voices in Turkey for reconciliation between Turks and Armenians. Samast was detained the following day in Samsun, on the Black Sea coast, and confessed. Because he was a minor at the time of the offense, he was tried in a juvenile court. On July 25, 2011, the Istanbul 2nd Juvenile Heavy Penal Court convicted him of premeditated murder and of an offense under the arms law and sentenced him to 22 years and 10 months. The Court of Cassation upheld the judgment in 2012.

The conviction of the young man who carried out the killing settled only the first and narrowest question in the case. Over the next fourteen years Turkish courts tried the man who sent him, the circle around them in Trabzon, and finally the police and gendarmerie officers who had been warned of the plot. In 2010 the European Court of Human Rights found that Turkey's security forces had been told an assassination was being prepared, had not acted, and had failed to protect the editor's life. Samast himself was released on conditional release in November 2023, after almost seventeen years in custody, and was then drawn into a new prosecution that ended in January 2025 when the court ruled that the time limit for the charge had run out.

Samast was born in 1990 in Trabzon, the largest city on Turkey's eastern Black Sea coast, and left high school without finishing. In Trabzon he fell in with Yasin Hayal, an older man who had already served a prison sentence. At trial Samast said that a poor education had left him open to being led, and that Hayal had taken advantage of that and directed him. In later testimony he described a gathering in 2006 at which he heard plans discussed, and he said that Hayal threatened him with serious consequences if he tried to back out and that he was afraid of the older man.

Agos had been published in Istanbul since 1996, in Turkish and Armenian, and as its publication director and editor-in-chief he wrote about what it meant to be an Armenian citizen of Turkey, about the events of 1915, and about the possibility of Turks and Armenians speaking openly to each other. He was a public figure well beyond the readership of his own paper.

That writing drew open hostility long before 2007. Between November 2003 and February 2004 Agos published a series of eight of his articles on the identity of Turkish citizens of Armenian origin, and a complaint about one of them became a prosecution under Article 301 of the Turkish Penal Code, the offense of denigrating "Turkishness." On October 7, 2005, a court in Şişli convicted him and imposed a suspended six-month sentence. In February 2006 he received a threatening letter posted from Bursa and took it to the Şişli Chief Prosecutor's Office. No action followed.

Samast killed him on Friday, January 19, 2007. In his later testimony Samast said that he had hesitated many times that day and that Hayal had reassured him that powerful people stood behind them.

After prosecutors released images of the young man they were looking for, Samast was detained in Samsun on January 20, 2007, in a joint police and gendarmerie operation. He was questioned there and then taken to Istanbul, and prosecutors announced that he had confessed. In his first statements he said that he had acted on Hayal's orders. Police detained twelve people, and on January 24, 2007, Samast was formally arrested together with Hayal and three others. His time in custody would be counted from that date.

Within days, photographs emerged of Samast in custody posing with police and gendarmerie officers in front of a Turkish flag. In March 2008 prosecutors in Trabzon opened an investigation into members of the provincial gendarmerie, including its regiment commander.

Samast's case was separated from that of the adult defendants and heard by the Istanbul 2nd Juvenile Heavy Penal Court, on charges of premeditated murder and an offense under the arms law. He again placed much of the blame on Hayal, telling the court that the older man had exploited him and steered him toward the act. A separate charge of membership of an illegal organization was still pending when the murder case ended.

On July 25, 2011, the court found him guilty on both counts. For the murder it started from a sentence of life imprisonment and reduced it because he had been a minor at the time, arriving at 21 years and 6 months. For the offense under the arms law it added one year and four months. The total was 22 years and 10 months. The court also halved a judicial fine, from 600 to 300 Turkish lira.

In March 2012 the 1st Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation upheld the verdict, making the conviction final. Under the law on the execution of sentences he had to serve two-thirds of the term before release could be considered; with the years already spent in pretrial detention deducted, that left a little under eleven years still to serve at the time of the appeal ruling.

The adults were tried separately in Istanbul. On January 17, 2012, the court sentenced Hayal to aggravated life imprisonment for instigating the killing, convicted two co-defendants of aiding it and acquitted another co-defendant; the Court of Cassation overturned the acquittals on organization charges in 2013, and a merged trial that took in the police and gendarmerie officers who had been warned of the plot ended on March 26, 2021 with 26 of 77 defendants convicted, among them the former head of Istanbul police intelligence and his deputy, who received aggravated life sentences, and two former gendarmerie intelligence officers, sentenced to life.

In those merged proceedings Samast was tried for membership of an armed organization. On July 17, 2019, the Istanbul 14th Heavy Penal Court sentenced him to 3 years and 9 months, reduced by a third to 2 years and 6 months because he had been between 15 and 18 at the time. He had asked to be acquitted of that charge.

During his sentence Samast was convicted of further offenses committed in custody, including threatening prison staff; in all, those further sentences came to more than five years. He had been due to move into the last phase of his sentence, under probation outside custody, on August 6, 2020, but a 29-month term in a case finalized on August 3, 2020 kept him inside. He became eligible for conditional release on February 19, 2022, but reviews on January 19, 2023 and July 13, 2023 found him unsuitable, and five requests he made from 2015 onward to move to an open prison, and two requests for probation, were refused.

On November 15, 2023, after one year of observation in which the prison administration judged his conduct good, Samast was released on conditional release, nearly seventeen years after his detention in January 2007.

When the court issued its 2021 verdict, it also filed a criminal complaint against Samast and three others over the killing's alleged link to the movement led by Fethullah Gülen. On November 17, 2023, two days after his release, the Istanbul 2nd Juvenile Heavy Penal Court accepted an indictment charging him with committing a crime on behalf of an armed terrorist organization without being a member of it. The indictment itself stated that there was no concrete evidence he had been a direct member of the organization. His case was joined to the trial of other defendants before the 14th Heavy Penal Court.

On March 6, 2024, Samast gave his first statement in that case. He said he had already answered the accusation years earlier and did not remember some details. He repeated his account of the 2006 gathering, in which he said he heard Erhan Tuncel, a co-defendant who had worked as a police informant, tell Hayal that two senior police intelligence officials would back them, and he said he had never met those officials or received instructions from them.

On January 10, 2025, the Istanbul 14th Heavy Penal Court dismissed the charge against Samast and six co-defendants, including Hayal and Tuncel, because the statute of limitations had expired. The travel ban on them remained.

Samast has said from his first statements that he acted on Hayal's orders, and the courts accepted that Hayal instigated the killing. His later claims went further: that he had been told the police and the state were behind the plan, and that he heard two named senior police intelligence officials invoked as protectors. He also said he had not known those officials. His last prosecution, in which those statements were part of the indictment, ended without a verdict on the merits when the time limit ran out, so no court has tested his account as it bears on his own guilt.

The courts' own conclusions about the wider plot have shifted. The 2012 verdict found no organization behind the killing; the Court of Cassation overturned that in 2013; and the 2021 judgment held that the killing served the aims of the Gülen movement, whose leader, a fugitive defendant, was never tried.

Timeline

2003 to 2004: Agos publishes the editor's series of eight articles on Armenian identity in Turkey.

October 7, 2005: A court in Şişli convicts the editor under Article 301 and imposes a suspended six-month sentence.

January 19, 2007: Samast, aged 17, kills the editor of Agos in Şişli, Istanbul.

January 20, 2007: Samast is detained in Samsun.

January 24, 2007: Samast, Hayal and three others are formally arrested.

September 14, 2010: The European Court of Human Rights finds that Turkey failed to protect the editor's life and violated his freedom of expression.

July 25, 2011: The Istanbul 2nd Juvenile Heavy Penal Court sentences Samast to 22 years and 10 months.

January 17, 2012: Hayal is sentenced to aggravated life imprisonment for instigating the killing.

March 2012: The Court of Cassation upholds Samast's conviction.

March 15, 2013: The Court of Cassation overturns acquittals on organization charges.

July 17, 2019: Samast receives 2 years and 6 months for membership of an armed organization.

August 3, 2020: A further 29-month term for an offense in custody is finalized, delaying his move to probation.

March 26, 2021: The main verdict convicts 26 defendants, including former police and gendarmerie officials.

February 19, 2022: Samast becomes eligible for conditional release; it is refused.

November 15, 2023: Samast is released on conditional release.

November 17, 2023: A new indictment against him is accepted.

March 6, 2024: Samast gives his first statement in the new case.

January 10, 2025: The Istanbul 14th Heavy Penal Court drops the charge against him because the time limit has expired.