For eight years Octavien Ngenzi ran Kabarondo, a rural commune of about 35,000 people in the Kibungo prefecture of eastern Rwanda. He was its bourgmestre, the appointed mayor who answered to the national government, from May 1986 until the middle of April 1994. In the second week of that April, as the genocide against the Tutsi spread across the country, the killing reached his commune. Militia and soldiers turned on thousands of Tutsi civilians who had sought refuge in the commune, and the killing went on through the round-ups of the days that followed.
Ngenzi left Rwanda that spring and spent the next sixteen years abroad. In June 2010 he was arrested in Mayotte, the French island department in the Indian Ocean, where he had asked for asylum under a false name. Six years later, on July 6, 2016, a jury at the Paris cour d'assises found him guilty of genocide and crimes against humanity and sentenced him to life imprisonment. His predecessor as mayor, Tito Barahira, was tried beside him and received the same verdict and the same sentence. A second assize court heard the whole case again in 2018 and reached the same result on July 6 of that year, and on October 16, 2019, the criminal chamber of the Cour de cassation rejected the last appeals. Through both trials Ngenzi denied every accusation, accepting only that he had failed to protect the people of his commune.
Ngenzi was born in Kabarondo; the French courts give his year of birth as 1958. He studied agronomy, trained in Kenya and later went back to his studies to qualify as an engineer, and he worked as a forestry engineer in charge of reforestation. The Ministry of Agriculture posted him to his native commune, where his work took him to every agricultural site in the district.
He was appointed bourgmestre by presidential decree in May 1986 and, by his own account, held the post until April 16, 1994. He succeeded Tito Barahira, who had led the commune for about ten years before him.
When Rwanda moved to a multiparty system in 1991, Ngenzi joined the MRND, the former single party. He described his membership to the court as devotion to the people of his commune rather than militancy. His defense later argued that the arrival of rival parties had weakened his authority over Kabarondo long before 1994. The prosecution on appeal took the opposite view: that he kept his authority throughout and that the militia in his commune obeyed him.
The genocide began the day after the plane carrying President Juvenal Habyarimana was brought down on April 6, 1994. Over roughly one hundred days, about 800,000 people were killed, most of them Tutsi, according to United Nations figures.
In Kabarondo, the period that mattered to the French courts was short: about two weeks in April. Ngenzi himself told the jury that extremists were active in his commune from April 8 to April 15, and he insisted that before then there had been "no racism or segregation" in Kabarondo. "It is not the population that changed," he said. "It is the situation."
The courts reached their own findings about those days. The first-instance court held that Ngenzi had taken part in the plan to destroy the Tutsi of Kabarondo actively, by organizing the assault of April 13, 1994, on the site where thousands of Tutsi had sought refuge, and that he was involved in the killings that followed at two other sites in the commune and in the round-ups of the days after. The same court found that the two former mayors had led and taken part in meetings to coordinate attacks on the Tutsi civilian population, had transported survivors for the purpose of extermination, had supervised killings across the area and had trained the Interahamwe militia.
The legal description of the crimes was the same for both men. The court found that in the commune of Kabarondo, in the Kibungo prefecture, in April 1994, each had committed, and caused others to commit, intentional attacks on life and serious attacks on the physical or mental integrity of persons, "en exécution d'un plan concerté tendant à la destruction totale ou partielle" of a national, ethnic, racial or religious group, and that each had "participé à une pratique massive et systématique d'exécutions sommaires," inspired by political, philosophical, racial or religious motives and organized under a concerted plan against a civilian population. The first was genocide. The second was the crime against humanity the French code calls "other than genocide."
Ngenzi's term as mayor ended on April 16, 1994, the date he himself gave. Soon after the genocide began, the forces of the Rwandan Patriotic Front reached the Kabarondo area, and both former mayors fled. Ngenzi's route, as he later described it, ran through Kenya and the Comoros before he reached Mayotte. He did not return to Rwanda after the war.
In Mayotte he applied to France's refugee office, OFPRA, for political asylum under a false name. The application was refused in March 2010.
By then Rwanda was looking for him. In 2009 the gacaca courts, the community tribunals Rwanda set up to try genocide cases, sentenced him in absentia to life imprisonment; Barahira received the same sentence. In April 2009 the Rwandan authorities issued an international warrant for his arrest. The office that handled his asylum request alerted the prefecture of Mayotte, and the prefecture reported the matter to the public prosecutor in Mamoudzou, the island's capital. A complaint had also been lodged there by the Collectif des parties civiles pour le Rwanda, a French association that presses for genocide prosecutions, on behalf of several Tutsi survivors.
Ngenzi was arrested in Mayotte on June 3, 2010. The prosecutor in Mayotte opened a judicial investigation that year, and in June 2010 Ngenzi was placed under formal investigation, "mis en examen," for genocide and crimes against humanity. He was then transferred to mainland France and held in pretrial detention in the Paris region. He has remained in custody ever since.
Rwanda asked France to extradite him. The Paris court of appeal rejected the request, and the case stayed in France, before the investigating judges of the Paris court who specialize in crimes against humanity.
In 2013 Tito Barahira was arrested in Toulouse, in southwestern France, where he had been living. The French inquiry had begun with Ngenzi's arrest, and in July 2013 Barahira's case was joined to it. Gendarmes of the national unit for crimes against humanity carried out the work on the ground, in Rwanda, accompanied by a Rwandan judicial police officer. The investigation took the French judges to Rwanda several times, with the prosecution present, to visit the places where the crimes were alleged to have taken place and to question witnesses.
On May 30, 2014, the investigating judges ordered the two men committed for trial before the cour d'assises for genocide and crimes against humanity. On September 25, 2014, the investigating chamber of the Paris court of appeal ordered their indictment, including the charge of having taken part in a massive and systematic practice of summary executions against "la population civile tutsi." Both men appealed that indictment to the Cour de cassation, and their appeals were rejected, which made the order final and fixed the charges the jury would hear.
The trial opened in Paris in May 2016 and lasted eight weeks, the second trial in France arising from the genocide against the Tutsi. About one hundred witnesses and experts were heard, many of them survivors who traveled from Rwanda. Ngenzi denied all of the accusations, and the defense argued that the contest was unequal because he was defended on legal aid.
The prosecution asked for life imprisonment for both men.
The jury deliberated for about nine hours. On the evening of Wednesday, July 6, 2016, the court found both Tito Barahira and Octavien Ngenzi guilty of genocide and crimes against humanity and sentenced each of them to "la réclusion criminelle à perpétuité," life imprisonment. It was the heaviest penalty a French court had imposed in a case arising from the genocide.
Both men appealed, and the case went to a second assize court to be heard again from the beginning.
The appeal opened in Paris on May 2, 2018. On May 4 the court rejected a defense request to annul the committal order and the hearings on the ground that equality of arms had been breached, and on June 4 it refused a defense request that it travel to Rwanda to see the sites, holding that the file's photographs, plans and recordings showed them clearly and that it could not guarantee the safety of the accused there.
The hearings ran for two months. Among the witnesses called by the prosecution were men already convicted in Rwanda for their own part in the genocide, as well as a French gendarme who had led the investigators' work in Rwanda; the defense called, among others, a former bourgmestre of another commune who had been acquitted by the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda. He denied the accusations, as he had in 2016.
The advocates general asked for life imprisonment for both men; the defense denied any part in the killings. On Friday, July 6, 2018, after eight hours of deliberation, the appeal court answered yes, by a majority, to every question put to it. It confirmed the convictions for genocide and crimes against humanity and the sentences of life imprisonment, and it did not impose the security period the prosecution had sought for Ngenzi.
Both men appealed to the Cour de cassation, France's highest court, in July 2018. The criminal chamber joined the two cases under a single number, heard them in public on September 4, 2019, and gave judgment on October 16, 2019.
Before the hearing, the defense had asked the court to send a priority question of constitutionality to the Conseil constitutionnel, challenging the way article 316 of the code of criminal procedure lets an assize court decide procedural disputes. On March 27, 2019, the Cour de cassation declined to refer the question.
The judgment then took the grounds of appeal one by one. On equality of arms, it held that the committal order had become final and could no longer be contested, that both men had been represented throughout by lawyers on full legal aid who had been able to put their case, and that complaints about hearings not yet held were necessarily hypothetical. On the procedural disputes, it held that the assize court had applied article 316 correctly. On the Kinyarwanda interview read before the witness was heard, it held that the presiding judge had used her discretionary power lawfully and had not breached either the oral character of the trial or the rights of the defense.
The two men also argued that they had been convicted twice for the same acts, once for genocide and once for crimes against humanity, and that the jury's reasoning had altered the indictment by describing the targeted civilians as Tutsi "but also Hutu of the opposition." The court answered from the appeal court's own question sheet and statement of reasons. Both men had been found guilty of genocide for attacks on life and on physical or mental integrity carried out under a concerted plan to destroy "le groupe ethnique tutsi," and of crimes against humanity for taking part in a massive and systematic practice of summary executions against "la population tutsi." On the genocide count the appeal court had found that more than 3,500 members of the Tutsi community had been gathered at the main place of refuge in Kabarondo, and that the order had been given to the army and the militia to exterminate the Tutsi while sparing the Hutu. The two convictions did not punish the same thing twice, the Cour de cassation held, because genocide requires proof of an intent to destroy a national, ethnic, racial or religious group in whole or in part, while a crime against humanity requires proof that the crime was committed as part of a widespread or systematic attack on a civilian population. The appeal court had set out both the elements of each crime and the active role of each accused.
The last grounds concerned the sentence. Both men argued that the appeal court had imposed the maximum penalty because they had denied the charges, when every accused has the right not to incriminate himself. The Cour de cassation disagreed. The statement of reasons had grounded the life sentences in the extreme gravity of organized mass crimes and in the positions of authority the two men had held in the commune, and it had not denied them the right to remain silent or to contest the case. The sentence, the court held, met the standard of reasoning the Conseil constitutionnel had set in its decision of March 2, 2018.
The court rejected the appeals in full. Its ruling, recorded as "REJET," made the convictions and the life sentences final.
Barahira, the older of the two former mayors, had governed Kabarondo for about ten years before Ngenzi. Also known as Tite Barahirwa, he was arrested in 2013 in Toulouse, where he had been living. He was convicted with Ngenzi of genocide and crimes against humanity in 2016 and sentenced to life imprisonment; the appeal court confirmed his conviction and sentence in 2018, and his appeal to the Cour de cassation was rejected in the same judgment of October 16, 2019. He died in France in 2024, at the age of 72.
Ngenzi has been held in France since his arrest in Mayotte on June 3, 2010. Since October 16, 2019, his conviction for genocide and crimes against humanity and his sentence of life imprisonment have been final.
The French courts tried Ngenzi under universal jurisdiction. Its basis in his case was the law of May 22, 1996, which adapted French law to United Nations Security Council resolution 955 creating the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda; it gave French courts jurisdiction over genocide and crimes against humanity committed in Rwanda between January 1 and December 31, 1994, when the suspect is found in France.
Cases of this kind are handled in Paris by investigating judges and prosecutors assigned to the court's specialized unit for genocide and crimes against humanity, which conducted the investigation in Ngenzi's case.
Ngenzi has never admitted any part in the killings. His position, in both trials, was that he had been a powerless witness who failed to protect the people of his commune out of fear, and that the witnesses against him had been pressured by the present Rwandan authorities, used by civil-party associations, or hoped for reductions of their own sentences. Two juries rejected that account, and the Cour de cassation found no error of law in the second verdict.
The defense's complaint that the trials were unequal, because the defense worked on legal aid while the prosecution and civil parties had larger means and had visited Rwanda without it, was argued at every stage and rejected at every stage.
May 6, 1986: Told that a presidential decree has named him bourgmestre of Kabarondo; takes office the next day.
1991: Joins the MRND after Rwanda moves to a multiparty system.
April 6, 1994: The president's plane is brought down; the genocide begins.
April 13, 1994: The assault on the place where thousands of Tutsi had sought refuge in Kabarondo; the courts later find that he organized it.
April 16, 1994: His term as mayor ends, by his own account; he later leaves Rwanda.
2009: Sentenced in absentia to life imprisonment by Rwanda's gacaca courts.
April 2009: Rwanda issues an international warrant for his arrest.
March 2010: His asylum application in Mayotte is refused.
June 3, 2010: Arrested in Mayotte after asking for asylum under a false name; placed under formal investigation that month.
2013: Tito Barahira arrested in Toulouse; in July his case is joined to Ngenzi's.
May 30, 2014: Investigating judges commit both men for trial.
September 25, 2014: Investigating chamber of the Paris court of appeal orders the indictment.
May 2016: First trial opens at the Paris cour d'assises.
July 6, 2016: Convicted of genocide and crimes against humanity; sentenced to life imprisonment.
July 7, 2016: One euro in damages ordered to each civil party; appeal announced.
May 2, 2018: Appeal trial opens in Paris.
July 6, 2018: Appeal court confirms the convictions and the life sentences.
March 27, 2019: Cour de cassation declines to refer a constitutional question.
October 16, 2019: Cour de cassation rejects the appeals; the conviction becomes final.
2024: Tito Barahira dies in France.