Novislav Djajic

Victims
14 Bosnian Muslim prisoners killed, 1992; convicted as an accessory to murder in 14 cases and of one attempted murder.
Years active
June 22, 1992
Location
Trnovace, Bosnia and Herzegovina (killings); Munich, Germany (residence and trial); Budapest, Hungary (other, place of deportation)
Method
Shot (by members of a Bosnian Serb unit, as the court's findings were reported; Djajic was convicted as an accessory)
Status
Five years' imprisonment, May 23, 1997; acquitted of accessory to genocide; status not on record after May 1999. Released and deported to Budapest, Hungary, May 1999.

On May 23, 1997, the Bavarian Supreme Court in Munich, the Bayerisches Oberstes Landesgericht, convicted Novislav Djajic, a 34-year-old Bosnian Serb, on 14 counts of accessory to murder and one count of attempted murder. The charges arose from a single day in the Bosnian war, June 22, 1992, when 14 Bosnian Muslim prisoners were killed at Trnovace, the village Djajic came from, and a fifteenth man survived. Djajic had been an armed member of a Serb militia unit there. The prosecution had also accused him of being an accessory to genocide. The court acquitted him of that charge, and sentenced him to five years in prison.

The verdict ended the first trial in Germany for crimes committed in the wars of the former Yugoslavia, and the first war crimes trial held in the country under international auspices since Nuremberg. It also left behind a finding that later reached the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia in The Hague: the Munich court held that acts of genocide had been committed in June 1992 within the administrative district of Foča, even though it could not establish that Djajic himself had acted with the intent to destroy the Muslim group.

Trnovace, in Bosnia and Herzegovina, was Djajic's home village. He was a tiler by trade. In the summer of 1992 he was an armed member of a Serb civilian militia, a Bosnian Serb military unit in his home area.

On June 22, 1992, members of that unit took 15 Bosnian Muslims prisoner at Trnovace. Fourteen of them were killed that day by Bosnian Serb soldiers. One man lived. The names of the 14 who died are not on record.

What the court had to decide was not whether the killings happened, which he did not dispute, but what part Djajic had played in them. He admitted that he had been present and had seen the prisoners killed. He denied that he had taken part. The court did not accept that account. It found that he had helped the killers, and convicted him under the German law on aiding a crime, as an accessory to each of the 14 murders, and of the attempted murder of the one prisoner who survived.

By 1993 Djajic was living in Munich, and it was there, in Bavaria, that German authorities brought the case against him. He was held in pretrial detention while the investigation and the indictment went forward. The date of his arrest was not made public.

The case was prosecuted by the federal prosecution service, the Bundesanwaltschaft. Djajic's case was the first of its kind to reach a verdict in Germany, and he became one of four Bosnian Serbs against whom German courts delivered judgments for crimes in the Bosnian war.

The main hearing opened in Munich on February 5, 1997, and ran until May 23, 1997, a little over three months. The charges were accessory to murder, attempted murder and accessory to genocide. The prosecution's case rested on the evidence of what happened at Trnovace on June 22, 1992, and on the account of the man who survived. That man, a Bosnian Muslim, testified at the trial as the only survivor of the group.

Djajic's defense on the facts was the one he had given from the start: he had been there, he had seen it, and he had not taken part. On the genocide charge the question was different. The genocide offense in German law then required the intent to destroy a national, racial or religious group, or a group defined by its ethnicity, as such, in whole or in part. The court had to decide both whether that intent had driven the killings in the area, and whether Djajic had shared it.

On May 23, 1997, the Bavarian Supreme Court found Djajic guilty on 14 counts of accessory to murder and one count of attempted murder, and sentenced him to five years in prison.

He was acquitted of being an accessory to genocide. The court held that it could not establish with sufficient certainty that he had acted with the intent to destroy the group, the mental element the genocide offense requires. It found no evidence that he had acted as part of a wider plan by Serb leaders to kill Bosnia's Muslims.

That acquittal did not amount to a finding that genocide had not occurred. In the same judgment the court found that acts of genocide had been committed in June 1992, confined within the administrative district of Foča. The distinction mattered beyond Munich. In August 2001 the Trial Chamber of the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia, in its judgment against the Bosnian Serb general Radislav Krstić, cited the Djajic judgment, by its case number and section, as one of two German rulings holding that genocide could be committed within a limited geographic area.

Djajic did not serve the whole sentence in Germany. In May 1999 he was released, the rest of the sentence was waived on deportation, and he was deported to Budapest. By November 1999 he was 36 years old.

The English name of the court that convicted him varies. Contemporary wire copy called it the Bavarian state supreme court; later legal summaries call it the Court of Appeal of Bavaria or the Bavarian Appeals Court. All refer to the Bayerisches Oberstes Landesgericht in Munich, which tried him.

Some 1997 headlines described Djajic as convicted of genocide. That was wrong: the court acquitted him of accessory to genocide and convicted him as an accessory to murder.

His whereabouts after his deportation in 1999 are not on record.

Timeline

June 22, 1992: 14 Bosnian Muslim prisoners are killed at Trnovace, Bosnia and Herzegovina; a fifteenth man survives.

1993: Djajic is living in Munich, Germany.

February 5, 1997: The main hearing opens before the Bavarian Supreme Court in Munich.

May 23, 1997: Djajic is convicted on 14 counts of accessory to murder and one count of attempted murder, acquitted of accessory to genocide, and sentenced to five years.

May 1999: He is released and deported to Budapest.

August 2, 2001: The ICTY Trial Chamber cites the Djajic judgment in its genocide ruling against Radislav Krstić.