Nikola Jorgić

Victims
8 murders and genocide, Doboj region, Bosnia, 1992; final after 22 further murder counts for Grabska were reopened and discontinued in 2004
Years active
June 17, 1992 to September 1992
Location
Sevarlije, Doboj, Bosnia and Herzegovina (killings); Doboj, Bosnia and Herzegovina (killing); Grabska, Doboj, Bosnia and Herzegovina (other, counts discontinued 2004).
Method
Shooting and beating (court findings: six men in Sevarlije shot on his order, a seventh died in a fire; a detainee at Doboj prison beaten to death by him)
Status
Life imprisonment, particular gravity of guilt (September 26, 1997); upheld as recast, April 30, 1999; Strasbourg found no violation, July 12, 2007. Imprisoned in Germany as of July 2006.

Nikola Jorgić spent more than twenty years of his adult life in Germany before he went back to the part of northern Bosnia where he was born. In the spring and summer of 1992, as Bosnian Serb forces drove the Muslim population out of the Doboj region, he led a paramilitary group of his own there. Three years later he flew back into Germany, and he was arrested at Düsseldorf airport on suspicion of genocide.

On September 26, 1997, the Düsseldorf Higher Regional Court found him guilty of eleven counts of genocide, together with murder and a long list of lesser offenses, and sentenced him to life imprisonment with a finding that his guilt was particularly grave. He was the first person a German court had convicted of genocide under the provision added to the Criminal Code in 1955. The Federal Court of Justice recast the verdict in 1999 as a single offense of genocide in concurrence with thirty counts of murder, and the Federal Constitutional Court refused to take up his complaint the following year. A later reopening removed the twenty-two murder counts that rested on a single eyewitness from the village of Grabska, but it left the life sentence standing on genocide and eight counts of murder. In July 2007 the European Court of Human Rights ruled unanimously that Germany had been entitled to try him and that its reading of the crime of genocide had been foreseeable.

Kostajnica and Germany

Jorgić was born in 1946 in Kostajnica, a village belonging to the town of Doboj in northern Bosnia. In 1969 he moved to the Federal Republic of Germany, and he lived there lawfully from May of that year until early 1992. He trained as a locksmith. He married a German woman; his wife and their daughter still lived in Germany after the war, and in 2006 three of his six children were living there.

Early in 1992 he returned to Kostajnica. Even after he left, he stayed registered as a resident in Germany, and after the events of that year he came back to visit his wife and daughter there. Those ties would decide where he was tried.

The Doboj region in 1992

The findings of the Düsseldorf court, as the Federal Court of Justice summarized them, place his acts inside a wider campaign. From April 1992, Serb forces and paramilitary units carried out a campaign of "ethnic cleansing" against the Muslim population of the Doboj region. Villages were destroyed, residents were killed, property was looted, and men were taken to camps where food was short and forced labor was common. The court counted at least four camps in the region.

According to the trial court, Jorgić had taken up the ideology of a Greater Serbia, and he formed a uniformed volunteer group that worked alongside the army, the political leadership and the local police. With it, the court found, he took part in the ethnic cleansing ordered by the Bosnian Serb political leaders and the Serb military in the Doboj region.

The court found that in early May and again in the first half of June 1992 he took part in arresting Muslim men from Grabska, Mala Bukovica and Sevarlije, and in detaining them amid repeated mistreatment. These arrests, the mistreatment that came with them, and the conditions in which the detained men were held formed the core of the genocide case. Grabska, the largest of the villages, had a population of nearly 3,000 before the war. After its capture in May 1992, about 400 of its men were taken to Kostajnica, his own village, where they were separated from the women, children and elderly people, who were expelled. From there the men were moved through a series of camps, and the last of them were not exchanged until December 1995.

Sevarlije and the prison in Doboj

The two incidents that became the lasting murder convictions took place in June and September 1992.

On June 17 and 18, 1992, Jorgić and the paramilitary group he led drove some forty to fifty men out of Sevarlije, a village near Doboj. On his orders the men were mistreated, and seven of them were killed. The Düsseldorf court counted those deaths as seven murders. They were residents of Sevarlije, Muslim men taken from their own village by his group.

In September 1992, at the central prison in Doboj, a detainee who had already been mistreated by soldiers was killed by Jorgić himself, by the court's findings. That death was the eighth murder count.

The third incident, the one that drew the most attention at trial, happened in Grabska in mid-June 1992. Twenty-two residents of the village were killed, among them women, disabled people, older men and a child, and the trial court in 1997 counted those deaths against Jorgić and one other man as twenty-two murders. That finding rested on the testimony of a single eyewitness, and it did not survive. In 2004 the Düsseldorf court reopened the Grabska counts and discontinued the proceedings on them, and the deaths no longer form part of his conviction.

Arrest at Düsseldorf

He knew, the trial court later found, that German investigators were looking into his conduct in Bosnia. On December 16, 1995, he entered Germany by air and was arrested at Düsseldorf airport on suspicion of genocide. He was held in custody in Düsseldorf from then until the trial.

He carried with him papers from the prison in Doboj, which he said showed that he himself had been a prisoner there during the months in which the crimes were alleged. He claimed to have been held on suspicion of illegal trading and smuggling from May 14 to August 15, 1992.

The question of where he should be tried was answered in Germany. Neither the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia, sitting in The Hague, nor Bosnia and Herzegovina sought to take the case over, and the Tribunal stated that it was not willing to prosecute him itself.

The trial

The trial opened before the Fourth Criminal Senate of the Düsseldorf Higher Regional Court on February 28, 1997. The indictment accused him of genocide in the Doboj region between May and September 1992.

Witnesses came from Bosnia. More than twenty of them testified that they had seen him at various places outside the prison during the period in which he claimed to have been locked up, and some of them had known him from before the war. Two of the witnesses were journalists who had not been victims of any of the crimes charged. Both had dealt with him during the summer of 1992, when, by his own account, he was in custody. He told the court that he had been let out under guard only to spy on them because he spoke good German; they testified that they had noticed nothing of the kind and that he had been in uniform and moving freely.

The court also viewed a Serbian television broadcast from the war in which he appeared and urged Serbs living abroad to return to Bosnia.

The defense built its case around the alibi and around jurisdiction. It asked the court to summon more than two dozen further witnesses from Kostajnica and Doboj to confirm that he had been held in the Doboj prison from mid-May to mid-August 1992, and the court refused. Their evidence, it found, would add little: in the light of the testimony already heard, it was convinced that he had not been in custody at the time of the crimes, and the documents he produced to show the dates of his detention could not change that conclusion.

Throughout the trial Jorgić maintained his innocence. In his final statement he said he had become the victim of orchestrated testimony and mistaken identity.

Verdict and sentence

On September 26, 1997, the court found Jorgić guilty of eleven counts of genocide under the German Criminal Code, of the murder of twenty-two people in one case, seven in another and one in a third, and of numerous counts of dangerous bodily harm and deprivation of liberty. In all the court found him guilty of thirty murders, fifty counts of dangerous bodily harm and 355 counts of deprivation of liberty. He was 50 years old.

He was sentenced to life imprisonment, and the court found that his guilt was particularly grave.

The court found that he had acted as a co-perpetrator within the meaning of the genocide provision, and that he had acted with intent to destroy a group, the Muslims of northern Bosnia or of the Doboj region. It read the "destruction of a group" in the Criminal Code to mean the destruction of the group as a social unit, in its distinct character and its sense of belonging together; a biological and physical destruction, it held, was not required. It rejected his alibi, finding that the release papers he had carried were certificates written as a favor by someone he knew well, and that he had known of the investigation against him.

On jurisdiction the court held that German criminal law applied to genocide committed abroad under Section 6, No. 1, of the Criminal Code, and that there was a legitimate link to Germany because the events bore on Germany's military and humanitarian missions in Bosnia and Herzegovina and because he had lived in Germany for more than twenty years and had been arrested there. It found that international law did not bar a German court from trying the case: neither Article VI of the 1948 Genocide Convention nor Article 9 of the 1993 Statute of the Yugoslavia Tribunal excluded the jurisdiction of German courts over genocide committed outside Germany by a foreigner against foreigners, and the Tribunal's refusal to take the case confirmed that view.

The Federal Court of Justice

The Third Criminal Senate of the Federal Court of Justice heard the appeal and gave judgment on April 30, 1999, in case 3 StR 215/98. It changed the verdict itself rather than sending the case back. Jorgić was now convicted of genocide in concurrence with murder in thirty cases and sentenced to life imprisonment, with the finding that his guilt was particularly grave restated. The rest of the appeal was dismissed.

The Senate's main correction concerned the count of offenses. The trial court had treated the eleven counts of genocide as separate crimes. The Federal Court of Justice held instead that the arrests, mistreatment and detentions formed a single offense of genocide, because they were directed at one part of the group limited in place and time. The murders, it held, did not merge into that genocide; murder protects individual life and is an equally grave crime, so the thirty killings remained in concurrence with the genocide.

On jurisdiction it went further than the trial court. It held that the principle of universal jurisdiction in Section 6, No. 1, of the Criminal Code allowed German courts to try genocide committed abroad, and that Article VI of the Genocide Convention, which names the courts of the state where the crime was committed and an international criminal court, did not forbid prosecution elsewhere. Any other reading, it said, would conflict with the duty owed to all states to prevent and punish genocide that the parties had accepted in the Convention's first article. It found a legitimizing link with Germany in his long residence there, his family there and his arrest on German soil, noting that residence alone would not have been enough. It also relied on Section 7(2), No. 2, of the Criminal Code, because extradition, though lawful, was not going to happen: Bosnia and Herzegovina had no intention of asking for him, and the German government would not have surrendered him to Yugoslavia.

His procedural complaints failed, among them his complaints about the refused witnesses from abroad, which the Senate held inadmissible.

On the meaning of genocide it confirmed the trial court. Relying on the parts of Section 220a that cover measures to prevent births and the forcible transfer of children, it held that an intent to destroy a group physically was not required; an intent to destroy it as a social unit was enough.

The Federal Constitutional Court

Jorgić then brought a constitutional complaint. On December 12, 2000, a chamber of the Federal Constitutional Court decided unanimously not to admit it, and set out why it had no prospect of success.

It held that applying Section 6, No. 1, of the Criminal Code together with Article VI of the Genocide Convention did not violate the Basic Law. Germany needed a sensible connection with acts committed abroad, and universal jurisdiction supplied that connection for crimes that threaten the international community. The absence of a rule on universal jurisdiction in the Convention, it reasoned, meant only that the parties were not obliged to prosecute, not that they were forbidden to do so, and genocide was the classic case for universal jurisdiction. Bosnia and Herzegovina's sovereignty had not been infringed, since it had expressly declined to ask for his extradition. It found no constitutional error in assuming that German courts and the Yugoslavia Tribunal held concurrent jurisdiction.

On the meaning of genocide, the chamber held that the reading of "intent to destroy" adopted in Düsseldorf and by the Federal Court of Justice complied with the rule in Article 103(2) of the Basic Law that no one may be punished under a law that was not clear before the act. The intent to destroy had a broader meaning than physical and biological annihilation and could extend to a part of a group defined by territory. Systematic expulsions could be a means of carrying out the intent to destroy a group, but expulsions alone did not establish it. The interpretation, it found, lay within the possible meaning of the provision as it had to be read in the light of Article II of the Genocide Convention, and it was consistent with United Nations practice, including General Assembly Resolution 47/121 of December 18, 1992. It also found no breach of his right to a fair trial in the rules that let a court refuse to call witnesses from abroad.

The witness from Grabska

The conviction for the Grabska deaths depended on one man. He was the only witness who said he had seen Jorgić kill the twenty-two villagers, and after the trial he came under suspicion of perjury. Jorgić applied to reopen his case.

The Düsseldorf Higher Regional Court first refused in 2002, reasoning that even if the witness had invented his accusations, Jorgić would still be serving life for genocide and eight counts of murder. The Federal Court of Justice held the application admissible insofar as it concerned the twenty-two deaths in Grabska, while stating that the conviction for genocide and eight murders, and with it the life sentence and the finding of particularly grave guilt, would stand whatever became of those counts.

On June 21, 2004, the Düsseldorf court reopened the proceedings on the Grabska counts. It found that the only witness who claimed to have seen the killings had pleaded guilty to perjury over at least some of his other statements, and it could not rule out that the judges who had tried the case would have acquitted Jorgić on those counts had they known how many false statements the witness had made. In the same decision it discontinued the reopened proceedings, on the ground that any sentence for the Grabska deaths, had he been convicted again, would not have been much more severe than the final sentence for genocide. The judgment of September 26, 1997, remained in force for genocide, for eight counts of murder, and for the finding that his guilt was particularly grave.

Strasbourg

On May 23, 2001, while the German proceedings were still running their course, Jorgić lodged an application with the European Court of Human Rights. At the time he was held in a prison in Germany. He argued that German courts had no jurisdiction to try him, so that his conviction and detention violated Articles 5 § 1 (a) and 6 § 1 of the European Convention on Human Rights; that the refusal to summon defense witnesses from abroad denied him a fair trial; that the wide reading of genocide applied to him had no basis in German or international law and breached the principle in Article 7 § 1 that no one may be punished without law; and that the finding of particularly grave guilt had been arbitrary.

The Fifth Section delivered its judgment in Jorgic v. Germany on July 12, 2007. All seven judges agreed on every point.

The complaint about the witnesses was declared inadmissible. On jurisdiction, the court found that the German reading of the Genocide Convention and the German courts' assumption of jurisdiction over genocide were widely confirmed by the statutes and case law of numerous other Contracting States and by the Statute and case law of the Yugoslavia Tribunal. Article 9 § 1 of that Statute, providing for concurrent jurisdiction of the Tribunal and national courts without restricting it to the courts of particular countries, supported the German view. The German interpretation was not arbitrary, and the courts had reasonable grounds for establishing jurisdiction. Jorgić had therefore been tried by a "tribunal established by law" and lawfully detained after conviction "by a competent court." There was no violation of Article 6 § 1 or Article 5 § 1.

The Article 7 question was harder, because Jorgić was the first person German courts had found guilty of genocide under Section 220a since it entered the Criminal Code. The court accepted that in 1992 most legal writers took a narrow view of the crime and did not treat the ethnic cleansing by Serb forces in Bosnia as genocide, while a considerable number held that it plainly was. It also noted that after 1992 the Yugoslavia Tribunal, in the Krstić and Kupreškić cases, had expressly rejected the wider reading of "intent to destroy" adopted by the United Nations General Assembly and the German courts. Those later decisions, however, could not have told Jorgić in 1992 how German courts would read German law. Because several authorities had already read genocide the wider way, he could reasonably have foreseen, with a lawyer's advice if needed, that he risked being charged with and convicted of genocide for his acts. The court gave weight to the gravity and duration of what he had been found guilty of as the leader of a paramilitary group carrying out a policy of ethnic cleansing: the killing of several people and the detention and mistreatment of a large number over several months. The German interpretation was consistent with the essence of the offense and reasonably foreseeable, and once that was so, it was for the German courts to choose their reading. His complaint about the finding of particularly grave guilt amounted to an allegation of errors of fact and law and disclosed no violation. There was no violation of Article 7.

At the time of his application to Strasbourg in 2001, Jorgić was serving his life sentence in a German prison, and in July 2006 he was still serving it there. His conviction for genocide and eight counts of murder, with the finding of particularly grave guilt, is final.

Disputed and unproven points

Jorgić denied the charges from his arrest onward. His central defense was an alibi: that from May 14 to August 15, 1992, he had been a prisoner of the Serb authorities in Doboj, held on suspicion of illegal trading and smuggling, and so could not have committed the crimes. He produced release papers from that prison. The Düsseldorf court rejected the alibi, relying on more than twenty witnesses who said they had seen him at liberty during those months, and it refused his requests to summon further witnesses from Bosnia. No higher court disturbed that ruling.

The deaths of twenty-two people in Grabska in June 1992 were part of the 1997 verdict and the 1999 judgment, but the only eyewitness who placed Jorgić at those killings later pleaded guilty to perjury over at least some of his other statements. The reopened proceedings on the Grabska counts were discontinued in 2004 without a new verdict, so those deaths no longer form part of his conviction. The conviction for genocide, for the seven deaths in Sevarlije and for the death of the detainee in Doboj stands.

The legal question that ran through his appeals, whether the intent to destroy a group as a social unit is enough for genocide or whether the law requires an intent to destroy it physically, was answered differently by different courts. The German courts and the European Court of Human Rights accepted the wider reading for his case; the Yugoslavia Tribunal, in decisions given after 1992, rejected it.

Timeline

1946: Nikola Jorgić is born in Kostajnica, part of the town of Doboj, Bosnia.

May 1969: He moves to the Federal Republic of Germany, where he lives lawfully until early 1992.

Early 1992: He returns to Kostajnica.

April 1992: Serb forces and paramilitary units begin the campaign against the Muslim population of the Doboj region.

May and June 1992: He takes part in arresting and detaining Muslim men from Grabska, Mala Bukovica and Sevarlije.

Mid-June 1992: Twenty-two residents of Grabska are killed; the 1997 verdict counts these deaths against him, but those counts are reopened and discontinued in 2004.

June 17 to 18, 1992: Seven men from Sevarlije are killed after his group drives them from the village.

September 1992: He kills a detainee at the central prison in Doboj, by the court's findings.

December 16, 1995: He is arrested at Düsseldorf airport on suspicion of genocide.

February 28, 1997: His trial opens before the Düsseldorf Higher Regional Court.

September 26, 1997: He is convicted of eleven counts of genocide, murder and other offenses and sentenced to life imprisonment, with a finding of particularly grave guilt.

April 30, 1999: The Federal Court of Justice recasts the verdict as genocide in concurrence with murder in thirty cases and upholds the life sentence.

December 12, 2000: The Federal Constitutional Court declines to admit his constitutional complaint.

May 23, 2001: He applies to the European Court of Human Rights.

2002: The Düsseldorf court refuses his application to reopen the case; the Federal Court of Justice later holds it admissible as to the Grabska deaths.

June 21, 2004: The Düsseldorf court reopens the Grabska counts and discontinues the proceedings on them; the conviction for genocide and eight murders stands.

July 12, 2007: The European Court of Human Rights finds no violation of the Convention, unanimously.