Neil Entwistle

Victims
2 murdered, his wife and infant daughter, Hopkinton, 2006. Convicted June 25, 2008, of two counts of first-degree murder and two arms-law counts; life without parole, affirmed 2012.
Years active
January 20, 2006
Location
Hopkinton, Massachusetts; Worksop, England
Method
Murder in the first degree of his wife and their infant daughter
Status
Two concurrent terms of life without parole, imposed June 26, 2008; affirmed by the Supreme Judicial Court August 14, 2012; U.S. Supreme Court review declined January 2013

Neil Entwistle was convicted in June 2008 of murdering his wife, Rachel Entwistle, and their infant daughter, Lillian, in Hopkinton, Massachusetts, a suburb west of Boston. Both died on January 20, 2006. The next day Entwistle left for England. By the middle of February he was back in Massachusetts in the custody of United States marshals, and a little more than two years later a Middlesex County jury found him guilty of two counts of murder in the first degree. Massachusetts law allowed only one sentence for that verdict, and he received it: life in prison without the possibility of parole.

He denied the killings from the first hearing to the last. His lawyers fought the case on two fronts: the two times the police had gone in without a warrant, and the volume of publicity that surrounded the case on both sides of the Atlantic. Those arguments carried the case to the state's highest court. In August 2012 the Supreme Judicial Court affirmed the convictions in full, and in January 2013 the United States Supreme Court declined to hear the case. A decade later, representing himself, he asked the state's highest court for a new trial once more.

Entwistle came from Worksop, a market town in Nottinghamshire. He met his future wife at the University of York in 1999, and they married in 2003. Their daughter was born in England in 2005, and a few months later the family moved to Massachusetts. In January 2006 they settled in Hopkinton, days before the deaths.

January 2006

The deaths occurred on Friday, January 20, 2006. On January 21 Entwistle left for England.

That same day the Hopkinton police went to check on the family, who could not be reached. Officers entered twice without a warrant, on January 21 and again on January 22, while they were still trying to learn whether anyone inside needed help. The second visit established that the mother and the baby were dead. The lawfulness of those two entries would become the main question in every appeal that followed.

Entwistle was by then an ocean away. Within a week the Hopkinton police, the Massachusetts State Police and the Middlesex District Attorney's office were working the case with Scotland Yard. On January 28 the District Attorney publicly described him as a person of interest, though not a suspect, and said no one had been ruled in or out. By the next day he was declining to be interviewed by police. In the same period a Massachusetts State Police sergeant spoke with him by telephone across the Atlantic, and the conversation was recorded. In it he denied harming his family.

Arrest and return

The investigators in Massachusetts tied him to the deaths by evidence early in February, and a warrant was issued for his arrest. Police in London arrested him on Thursday, February 9, 2006.

He did not fight extradition. Brought before a district judge at Bow Street Magistrates' Court, he signed a form consenting to his return to the United States, and the judge told him the decision could not be withdrawn. Bail was refused, and he was held in custody in England while the transfer was arranged. On February 15, 2006, he was handed over to United States marshals and returned to Massachusetts.

Back in the Commonwealth he needed a lawyer, and the state's public defender agency, the Committee for Public Counsel Services, appointed a Boston defense lawyer to represent him.

Arraignment and indictment

On Thursday, February 16, 2006, Entwistle was arraigned in Framingham District Court on two counts of murder in the first degree. He did not speak. His lawyer entered pleas of not guilty on his behalf, and the court ordered him held without bail. A further hearing was set for March 15. From that first appearance the defense made the volume of publicity about the case a central complaint.

A Middlesex County grand jury indicted him on March 28, 2006. The indictments charged two counts of murder and two counts under the Commonwealth's arms law, and they moved the case from the district court to Middlesex Superior Court in Cambridge.

On April 11, 2006, he was arraigned in Superior Court. Again he stood silent while his lawyer entered not guilty pleas to every count. He remained held without bail in Cambridge. The Superior Court judge set a goal of starting the trial by April 2007 and scheduled a further hearing for May 23.

Pretrial fights

Two issues dominated the long run-up to trial, and the same judge who would preside over the trial decided both.

The first was the entry by the police. The defense moved to suppress everything gathered during the two warrantless visits of January 21 and 22, 2006. The judge heard testimony from the officers and credited the account of the officer who said he had believed the occupants might need help. She denied the motion. She held that the emergency aid exception to the warrant requirement covered the entries, and she gave two further, alternative grounds as well: that the evidence would inevitably have been discovered, and the police role known as community caretaking.

The second was publicity. The defense moved to dismiss the indictments or, in the alternative, to move the trial out of Middlesex County, arguing that coverage in the United States and in Britain had made a fair trial impossible there. On Friday, May 30, 2008, three days before jury selection was due to begin, the judge refused to move the trial. She denied the motion without prejudice, saying she would take it up again once prospective jurors had been questioned.

Jury selection ran for four days in early June 2008. Every prospective juror filled out a written questionnaire of twenty-seven questions, and those who said they had read or heard anything about the case were then questioned one at a time. The defense wanted the judge to ask each of them directly whether they thought Entwistle was guilty. She asked that question of some prospective jurors and not of others, and she denied the defense's challenges for cause to thirteen people who had not been asked it. Five of the thirteen were seated. The judge also excused many prospective jurors for cause on her own motion.

The defense renewed its motion to dismiss or move the trial at least three times during those four days. At the start of the fourth day the judge ruled that the jury pool had not been "infected" by the publicity and denied the motion for good. Of the twelve jurors who would decide the case, three had never heard of it before they reported for service, and five recalled only its basic facts.

The trial had not begun in April 2007, as first hoped. It opened in June 2008, more than two years after the indictment, in the Superior Court at Woburn.

The trial

The Commonwealth's case was circumstantial, and it rested on his conduct and his circumstances. Prosecutors described his conduct after the deaths, above all his departure for England without calling the police or seeking help.

On June 20, 2008, jurors heard the recorded transatlantic call with the state police sergeant. In the recording Entwistle denied the killings.

Entwistle did not testify. The defense rested without calling any witnesses. His lawyer told the jury that the Commonwealth carried the burden of proving its case beyond a reasonable doubt and that a defendant is not required to present any evidence. In the final days of the trial the defense offered the jury an alternative account of the deaths that cleared Entwistle of murder, and it argued that the police had fixed on him from the start without seriously considering any other explanation. The prosecution answered that nothing in the evidence supported that account.

Closing arguments were given on Monday, June 23, 2008. The jury began its deliberations the next day.

Verdict and sentence

On Wednesday, June 25, 2008, the jury returned its verdicts in Middlesex Superior Court. It found Entwistle guilty of two counts of murder in the first degree, on the theory of deliberate premeditation, and guilty of the two counts under the arms law.

He was sentenced the next day, Thursday, June 26, 2008. For murder in the first degree Massachusetts law fixed a single sentence, and the Superior Court judge imposed it twice: life in prison without the possibility of parole on each count, the two terms to run concurrently. On the arms-law convictions she imposed probation, with a condition that he never profit from the sale of his story. Because the convictions were of murder in the first degree, the case went next, by right, to the Supreme Judicial Court.

The appeal to the Supreme Judicial Court

The appeal, docketed as SJC-10788, came on for argument on Friday, April 6, 2012, before a panel of five justices. Entwistle's appellate lawyer, working with the Committee for Public Counsel Services, argued that the police had no authority to search without a warrant and that what they found should have been suppressed. An assistant district attorney told the justices that the officers had acted within what their duties required. The court took the case under advisement.

The decision came on Tuesday, August 14, 2012. In Commonwealth v. Entwistle, 463 Mass. 205, one justice wrote for the panel, and no justice dissented. The court affirmed both convictions of murder in the first degree.

It took the warrantless entries first, treating the Fourth Amendment and article 14 of the Massachusetts Declaration of Rights together. The emergency aid exception, the court explained, lets the police enter without a warrant when they have an "objectively reasonable basis to believe that there may be someone inside who is injured" or in imminent danger. The test looks only at the circumstances known to the officers at the moment they go in. They need not have probable cause to believe a crime has been committed, because the exigency is the immediate need for aid, whatever its cause.

Measured that way, the first entry on January 21 stood. The family had been out of contact for two days, and the court found "an objectively reasonable basis to fear for the health and safety of the Entwistle family." The court did find that one step the officers took during that first visit went beyond what lay in plain view. It did not decide whether that step was unconstitutional. It assumed that it was and held the error harmless beyond a reasonable doubt, because the information it produced duplicated other testimony at trial.

The second entry on January 22 was harder, and the court upheld it on a footing different from the one the officers had in mind. They had believed the first search was complete and had gone back to look for clues to where the family had gone. The court held that an officer's private purpose does not matter. Judged objectively, the first search had been only partial, and with another day gone and still no word from the family, that partial search "had not reasonably eliminated the risk" that someone inside needed help. The court concluded that "the second entry was justified under the emergency aid exception" and that "the motion to suppress was correctly denied." It left open whether a search made only to learn a missing family's whereabouts would be lawful, and it did not reach the trial judge's alternative grounds of inevitable discovery and community caretaking.

The court then turned to the jury. It held that presumptive prejudice from publicity "exists only in truly extraordinary circumstances," and that coverage, however heavy, does not by itself meet that standard. Jurors had been drawn from Middlesex County, the most populous county in New England. Most of the coverage had come in early 2006, and the trial did not begin until June 2008. The court found that the judge had "conducted a careful, balanced, and thorough voir dire" and that she "did not abuse her discretion in concluding that the jury selected were fair and impartial." There was no actual prejudice either.

On the question the defense had wanted put to every prospective juror, the court sided with the trial judge. She had asked three written questions and similar oral ones aimed at impartiality, and she "was not required to ask prospective jurors to commit themselves during voir dire." The court held that "the judge did not abuse her discretion in refusing to ask the question framed by defense counsel."

Last came the plenary review that Massachusetts law requires in every first-degree murder appeal, under chapter 278, section 33E, of the General Laws. The court reviewed the whole trial record. "None of the defendant's claims on appeal warrants reversal of the convictions," it wrote, and "the interests of justice do not require the entry of a verdict of a lesser degree of guilt on the murder convictions or a new trial."

The United States Supreme Court and after

Entwistle then asked the United States Supreme Court to hear the case. On Monday, January 14, 2013, the Court declined. That ended his direct appeal.

Ten years later he returned to the state's highest court on his own. In a petition filed in August 2023 with the Supreme Judicial Court, under docket number SJ-2023-0325, he sought a new trial without a lawyer. The petition concerned the jury's deliberations in June 2008. During those deliberations a juror had acted out a scenario connected with the defense's account of the deaths. Entwistle argued that this reenactment brought something extraneous into the jury room, was not "governed by the rules of evidence" and violated his rights. As of October 2023 the petition was pending.

As of October 2023 Entwistle, then 44, was serving his life sentence without the possibility of parole in a Massachusetts state prison, where he had been held for more than a decade.

Disputed and unproven points

Entwistle has never admitted the killings. He denied them to the state police sergeant in January 2006, through his lawyers at every hearing, and in his appeals. The jury rejected the defense's alternative account of the deaths, the Supreme Judicial Court affirmed the verdicts after reviewing the entire case, and the United States Supreme Court declined review. The convictions are final.

The 2023 petition raised a question the direct appeal had not: whether something that happened inside the jury room, rather than anything put before the jury in open court, had shaped the verdicts.

Timeline

1999: Entwistle meets his future wife at the University of York, England.

2003: The couple marry.

2005: Their daughter is born in England; a few months later the family moves to Massachusetts.

January 2006: The family settles in Hopkinton, Massachusetts.

January 20, 2006: His wife and their daughter die in Hopkinton.

January 21, 2006: Entwistle leaves for England; the Hopkinton police make a first warrantless entry to check on the family.

January 22, 2006: A second warrantless entry establishes the deaths.

January 28, 2006: The District Attorney names him a person of interest; Scotland Yard is assisting the inquiry.

Late January 2006: A recorded telephone call with a state police sergeant; he denies harming his family.

February 9, 2006: Arrested in London on a Massachusetts warrant.

February 2006: At Bow Street Magistrates' Court he consents to return to the United States; bail refused.

February 15, 2006: Handed to United States marshals and returned to Massachusetts.

February 16, 2006: Arraigned in Framingham District Court; pleas of not guilty entered; held without bail.

March 28, 2006: Indicted by a Middlesex County grand jury on two counts of murder and two arms-law counts.

April 11, 2006: Arraigned in Middlesex Superior Court; pleads not guilty to all counts.

May 30, 2008: The trial judge refuses to move the trial out of Middlesex County.

June 2008: Four days of jury selection; the motion to dismiss or move the trial is renewed and finally denied; trial opens at Woburn.

June 20, 2008: Jurors hear the recorded call with the state police sergeant.

June 23, 2008: Closing arguments.

June 25, 2008: Found guilty of two counts of murder in the first degree and two arms-law counts.

June 26, 2008: Sentenced to two concurrent terms of life without the possibility of parole, with probation on the arms-law counts.

April 6, 2012: The Supreme Judicial Court hears argument on his automatic appeal (SJC-10788).

August 14, 2012: The Supreme Judicial Court affirms the convictions, Commonwealth v. Entwistle, 463 Mass. 205.

January 14, 2013: The United States Supreme Court declines to hear the case.

August 2023: Representing himself, he petitions the Supreme Judicial Court for a new trial (SJ-2023-0325).