On the afternoon of Friday, July 28, 2006, Naveed Afzal Haq, a 30-year-old man from Pasco in eastern Washington, entered the Seattle offices of the Jewish Federation of Greater Seattle, a Jewish charity. By the time he gave himself up to police that afternoon, one woman was dead and five other women who worked there were wounded. A teenage girl had also been held. Within days the King County Prosecuting Attorney's office charged him under Washington's hate-crime statute alongside the murder counts.
What he had done was never in doubt; the case turned on his mind. Haq had been treated for bipolar disorder for about a decade, and he asked two juries to find him not guilty by reason of insanity. The first, in 2008, could not agree, and the judge declared a mistrial. The second, in December 2009, rejected the insanity defense and convicted him on all eight counts, including aggravated first-degree murder and malicious harassment. He was sentenced in January 2010 to life without the possibility of release, and the Washington Court of Appeals affirmed the convictions two years later.
Haq grew up in the Tri-Cities area of south-central Washington. He had earned a degree in electrical engineering, but steady work never followed. He moved to Seattle in the summer of 2004, could not find a job there, and by 2006 he was living in Pasco again.
Pamela Waechter was the woman who died. She grew up in Minneapolis as a Lutheran, later converted to Judaism, and over the following decades Jewish communal life became the center of her own. She moved to Seattle in 1979 and made her life there. She belonged to Temple B'nai Torah in Bellevue from the year she arrived, worked her way up from secretary of the congregation to its president, and led it from 1988 to 1990. She served for eight years on the national board of the Union of American Hebrew Congregations and once addressed a convention of 6,000 people in Dallas. For nine years she volunteered with families at the Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center, and she made lunches for a women's shelter. Jewish Family Service gave her its Jesse Danz Outstanding Volunteer Award in 1993.
On August 2, 2006, the King County Prosecuting Attorney's office filed nine felony counts in King County Superior Court: aggravated first-degree murder for the woman who was killed, five counts of attempted first-degree murder for the five wounded women, first-degree kidnapping for the girl, first-degree burglary, and malicious harassment, the offense defined by Washington's hate-crime law. That last count put the hate-crime question before the court from the first day.
At his arraignment on August 10, his court-appointed lawyer told the judge that Haq wanted to plead guilty to everything. The judge postponed the plea so that his competence to enter it could be assessed, and the guilty plea was never accepted. Haq pleaded not guilty, and in May 2007 he changed his plea to not guilty by reason of insanity.
Aggravated first-degree murder in Washington carried only two possible sentences, death or life without the possibility of release. On December 20, 2006, the prosecutor announced that the state would not seek death, citing Haq's long history of mental illness as mitigating. From then on the only question was whether he would spend the rest of his life in a prison or in a state psychiatric hospital.
The first trial ran about six weeks in the spring of 2008 in King County Superior Court in Seattle, on 15 counts. The defense argued that he was legally insane on July 28, 2006; the prosecution accepted that he was mentally ill but argued that he understood what he was doing and knew it was wrong. On June 4, 2008, after the jurors reported that they were hopelessly deadlocked, the judge declared a mistrial. The jury had agreed on a single count, finding Haq not guilty of attempted first-degree murder as to one of the wounded women, though it could not agree on the lesser alternative on that count or on any of the other 14. The state announced the same week that it would try him again.
Between the trials the case changed. While awaiting trial Haq had made several hundred telephone calls from jail, all of them recorded, and by July 2008 the Washington Supreme Court had ruled that inmates' calls are not private. The retrial was put back by several months so that both sides could work through the recordings.
The second trial took nearly nine weeks of testimony in the fall of 2009. The prosecution narrowed its case to eight counts: aggravated first-degree murder, five counts of attempted first-degree murder, unlawful imprisonment of the girl, and malicious harassment. Haq again pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity and again did not deny what he had done. This time the jurors heard the jail recordings, which the first jury never had.
On Tuesday, December 15, 2009, after about two and a half days of deliberation, the jury found Haq guilty on all eight counts: aggravated first-degree murder, five counts of attempted first-degree murder, unlawful imprisonment and malicious harassment. It had rejected the insanity defense. The murder conviction carried a mandatory sentence, and on Thursday, January 14, 2010, the judge sentenced him to life in prison without the possibility of release.
Haq appealed to the Washington Court of Appeals, Division I. Among other claims, he argued that the recording of his jail calls and their use at trial had violated his rights, and he challenged the rejection of his insanity defense. On January 30, 2012, a three-judge panel affirmed the convictions and the sentence, finding no error at trial and holding that he had not established that he was insane at the time of the crimes. As of January 2012 he was serving life without the possibility of release in Washington state custody.
Haq never disputed that he caused the death and the injuries. What remained contested, through two trials, was his state of mind: the first jury could not decide whether he was legally insane, and the second decided he was not.
His early wish to plead guilty to all charges, voiced through his lawyer at his arraignment in August 2006, was never tested, because the judge delayed the plea to assess his competence and he later pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity. The first jury's one verdict, an acquittal of attempted first-degree murder on a single count, remains the only charge on which a jury found the state's case unproven.
Summer 2004: Haq moves to Seattle, finds no steady work and later returns to the Tri-Cities.
July 28, 2006: One woman is killed and five women are wounded at the Seattle offices of the Jewish Federation of Greater Seattle; Haq surrenders to police.
August 2, 2006: Nine felony counts filed in King County Superior Court, including aggravated first-degree murder and malicious harassment.
August 10, 2006: At arraignment his lawyer says Haq wants to plead guilty; the plea is postponed for a competency assessment.
December 20, 2006: The prosecutor announces the state will not seek the death penalty.
May 2007: Haq pleads not guilty by reason of insanity.
June 4, 2008: Mistrial after the first jury deadlocks; it acquits him of attempted first-degree murder on one count.
July 2008: Retrial postponed by several months so recordings of his jail calls can be reviewed.
December 15, 2009: Second jury convicts him on all eight counts, including aggravated first-degree murder and malicious harassment, rejecting the insanity defense.
January 14, 2010: Sentenced to life without the possibility of release.
January 30, 2012: Washington Court of Appeals, Division I, affirms the convictions and sentence.