Nathaniel Brazill

Victims
1 teacher killed in Lake Worth, Florida, May 26, 2000. Charged at 13 and tried as an adult; acquitted of first-degree murder, convicted of second-degree murder and aggravated assault, 2001
Years active
May 26, 2000
Location
Lake Worth, Florida; West Palm Beach, Florida
Method
Second-degree murder (Florida); aggravated assault on a second member of staff
Status
28 years for murder and 5 for aggravated assault, concurrent (July 27, 2001), then 2 years of community control and 5 years of probation; release scheduled for May 18, 2028

On May 26, 2000, the last day of the school year, Barry Grunow died in Lake Worth, Florida, a coastal city in Palm Beach County. He was a teacher at Lake Worth Middle School, and the boy convicted of his murder, Nathaniel Brazill, was his seventh-grade pupil. Brazill was 13. A Palm Beach County grand jury indicted him for first-degree murder, and he went on trial as an adult the following spring. On May 16, 2001, a jury acquitted him of first-degree murder and convicted him of second-degree murder, along with aggravated assault on a second member of staff. On July 27, 2001, the circuit judge in West Palm Beach sentenced him to 28 years, followed by two years of community control and five years of probation.

The case drew national attention to violence in schools and to the prosecution of juveniles as adults. The prosecution sought a verdict that would have meant a mandatory life sentence. The defense asked for manslaughter. The jury chose the middle ground, and the judge chose a term three years above the legal minimum.

Brazill was an honor student with no previous criminal record when he was charged. Earlier on that last day of school he had been suspended for throwing water balloons and sent off the campus. He came back to the school before the day was out, and the death followed. He did not dispute that his act caused it. From the start his account was that he had meant only to frighten, and that the outcome was an accident. That account became the whole of his defense, and it is the one he still gives.

The indictment did more than name the charge. Under Florida law, a child of any age charged with an offense punishable by death or by life imprisonment stayed under the juvenile court unless a grand jury indicted. Once it did, the child had to be "tried and handled in every respect as an adult" on that offense and on every related charge in the indictment. For a boy of 13, indictment was the only road into adult court. The grand jury returned one charging Brazill with first-degree murder and aggravated assault.

That indictment carried the highest stakes the Florida courts could offer a defendant of his age: a conviction as charged meant a mandatory sentence of life in prison without parole. Before trial, prosecutors offered a plea. Brazill would plead guilty to second-degree murder and receive 25 years in prison. The offer was turned down, and the case went to a jury.

At trial in the circuit court in West Palm Beach, Brazill testified in his own defense. He admitted that he had caused the death but told the jury that he had not intended it. He had meant, he said, only to scare. The prosecution asked for first-degree murder; the defense argued for manslaughter, a verdict that would have treated the act as culpable negligence rather than the product of a depraved mind. The jury found him not guilty of first-degree murder and guilty of second-degree murder, and it also convicted him of aggravated assault on a second member of the school's staff.

Under Florida law as it applied to the case, second-degree murder carried a range of 25 years to life. On the day before sentencing, Brazill spoke to the court and apologized. It was the first public expression of remorse he had made. "Words cannot really express how sorry I am," he said, "but they're all I have."

On July 27, 2001, the circuit judge sentenced him to 28 years in prison for the murder and five years for the aggravated assault, the two terms to run concurrently. The murder sentence sat three years above the minimum, and three years longer than the plea offer that had been rejected. The judge ordered that after his release he spend two years under community control and then five years on probation, and that he take anger management classes. The judgment designated the whole 28-year murder term a mandatory minimum, and the five-year assault term carried a three-year minimum of its own. The minimum-term law that governed the jury's findings set a floor of 25 years and a ceiling of life, and it barred gain-time and any form of discretionary early release until the minimum had been served. There is no parole for the sentence.

Brazill appealed to Florida's Fourth District Court of Appeal, and the appeal went to the statute that had put him in adult court. His lawyers argued that the statute denied him due process, because a prosecutor's decision to seek an indictment had cut him off from the rehabilitative side of the juvenile system with no hearing on whether adult sanctions suited him. They argued that it denied equal protection, because it gave prosecutors no criteria to guide that choice and because children 13 and younger could reach adult court only by indictment. They also argued that it breached the separation of powers.

On May 14, 2003, the appeals court rejected every challenge and affirmed. It held that no right, at common law, under the constitution or otherwise, required that Brazill be dealt with in the juvenile system; that the statute was rationally related to the state's legitimate interest in deterring crime and promoting public safety; and that he was not entitled to any hearing on his suitability for adult sanctions. The statute, the court wrote, applied to a child of any age charged with an offense punishable by death or life and did not set one age group against another. The narrower route for children 13 and under was not a suspect classification. The requirement of an indictment, the court found, protected the accused child, because grand jurors had to agree with the prosecutor's charging decision before the case could leave juvenile court.

Brazill then asked the Florida Supreme Court to take the case. Under the state constitution, that court may review a district court decision that expressly declares a state statute valid, and his petition argued that the Fourth District had done exactly that. The state answered that the appeals court had only applied settled precedent in turning his challenges aside, without expressly declaring the statute valid, and that the court should decline. On May 21, 2004, the Florida Supreme Court denied review.

He went back to the circuit court in 2006 with a motion for postconviction relief, filed on May 11 of that year. The circuit judge denied it without a hearing as untimely, counting the two-year filing period from the appeals court's mandate of May 30, 2003. Representing himself on appeal, Brazill won that round. On September 13, 2006, the Fourth District reversed: the two years had begun to run on May 21, 2004, when the Supreme Court ruled on his petition, so the motion was on time. The court sent it back to the circuit court for further proceedings.

The convictions and the 28-year sentence stand, and Brazill has served his term in the Florida prison system. He earned his GED at 16. At 18 he qualified as a paralegal, and three years after that he received a law certification. Other inmates, he says, have come to him for help with their own cases. He hopes to attend law school after his release.

He maintains that he never meant to kill. He has also said that he carries the guilt of what happened and expects to carry it for the rest of his life. His release has been scheduled for May 18, 2028, after which the court's terms of community control and probation begin.

Intent was the one question in the case that Brazill contested. He has always said the death was an accident and that he meant only to frighten. The jury did not accept it: it acquitted him of premeditated murder but convicted him of second-degree murder, not manslaughter.

Timeline

May 26, 2000: On the last day of the school year in Lake Worth, Florida, the death occurs; Brazill is taken into custody.

2000: A Palm Beach County grand jury indicts Brazill for first-degree murder and aggravated assault; the indictment sends him to adult court.

Before trial: a plea offer of 25 years for a guilty plea to second-degree murder is rejected.

Spring 2001: Trial in the circuit court in West Palm Beach; Brazill testifies that the death was an accident.

May 16, 2001: The jury acquits him of first-degree murder and convicts him of second-degree murder and aggravated assault.

July 26, 2001: Brazill apologizes to the court.

July 27, 2001: Sentenced to 28 years for murder and 5 years for aggravated assault, concurrent, followed by 2 years of community control and 5 years of probation.

May 14, 2003: The Fourth District Court of Appeal affirms, rejecting due process, equal protection and separation of powers challenges to the statute that sent him to adult court.

May 21, 2004: The Florida Supreme Court denies review.

May 11, 2006: Brazill files a motion for postconviction relief; the circuit court denies it as untimely.

September 13, 2006: The Fourth District reverses, holding the motion timely, and remands.

May 18, 2028: Scheduled release date.