On October 29, 1997, Ronnie Greene Jr. died in Pontiac, Michigan, killed by a boy he did not know. Nathaniel Abraham was 11 years old. Under a state law that had taken effect only that January, prosecutors in Oakland County could charge a child of any age as an adult for the gravest felonies, and they did: Abraham became the first youth in Michigan charged with first-degree murder and tried as an adult under the new statute. In November 1999 a jury in Pontiac rejected the first-degree charge and convicted him of second-degree murder. The judge declined to send him to an adult prison and ordered him held in the state's juvenile system until his twenty-first birthday, and in January 2007 he walked free.
The conviction survived every challenge, including an attack on the statute that had put him in front of a jury. What came after the release was a second record, built in the adult courts of the same county: a drug conviction within two years, a conviction for assaulting corrections officers, and a new prison term imposed in 2019.
The young man who died had no connection to the boy who took his life. The courts later treated the day as a single chain of events. Within a couple of hours, in the same neighborhood, a second man was injured, and that incident became a separate count of assault with intent to commit murder, tried together with the murder charge.
Two days later, on October 31, 1997, police took Abraham from school to the station for questioning, and his mother joined him there within minutes. Officers advised them both of his rights under Miranda v. Arizona. Both said he did not want a lawyer, and both signed a form waiving his right to remain silent. In the investigating officer's account, Abraham first gave a series of innocent explanations of his part in the day's events and then implicated himself in the death. He was held in juvenile detention from that point on, and he stayed there for more than two years while the case moved through the courts.
The prosecution did not leave the case in juvenile court. Under the new law it designated the matter as one in which the boy would be tried in the same manner as an adult, and a probable cause hearing on that petition was held in November 1997. Friends of the boy testified. Among the things they described, as the Court of Appeals later summarized, were his statements before the death that he meant to go after people who had been bothering him, and his boasting afterward that he had done it. At the end of the hearing Abraham was bound over on one count of first-degree premeditated murder, one count of assault with intent to commit murder, and two further felony counts.
The defense moved to quash the charges and to suppress everything Abraham had told the police. The trial court refused to quash but granted the suppression motion, finding that the boy could not have understood his rights or what it meant to give them up. The prosecution appealed. On March 30, 1999, the Michigan Court of Appeals reversed the suppression order in a published decision, People v. Abraham, 234 Mich App 640, and affirmed the denial of the motion to quash. The first-degree charge stood, the statements could be used against him, and the case went back to Pontiac for trial.
Whether a child of his development could be tried at all was tested along the way. Defense experts presented him as developmentally, mentally and emotionally impaired. His competency to stand trial was nevertheless evaluated and confirmed three separate times: by two clinical psychologists who examined him, and by the trial court itself.
The trial was held in the Family Division of the Oakland County Circuit Court in Pontiac, and because the case had been designated for adult treatment, it ran as an ordinary criminal jury trial. The prosecution's case rested on what Abraham had said before and after the death and on his statements to the police. Witnesses testified that he had announced beforehand that he was going to go after "someone," and that he told people about it afterward. Abraham pleaded not guilty. His lawyers argued that he had been developmentally incapable of the malice that second-degree murder requires and that the evidence fell short of proving intent.
On November 16, 1999, the jury returned its verdict. It rejected first-degree murder and found Abraham guilty of the lesser offense of second-degree murder. It acquitted him of assault with intent to commit murder in the second incident and of the two further felony counts.
The verdict did not settle his fate. Michigan law gave the judge three choices for a child convicted in a designated case: an adult sentence, a juvenile disposition ending no later than age twenty-one, or a blended sentence that delayed an adult prison term pending a review at twenty-one. The prosecution asked for the blended sentence. On January 13, 2000, the judge rejected both the adult and the blended sentence and committed Abraham to juvenile detention until the age of twenty-one, with his placement supervised by the state's Family Independence Agency. He was sent to a state-run training school for boys. The trial court later denied the defense motions for a new trial and to vacate the conviction.
Abraham appealed. On April 10, 2003, a three-judge panel of the Michigan Court of Appeals affirmed in a published opinion, People v. Abraham, 256 Mich App 265, and rejected each claim in turn. The verdict was not against the great weight of the evidence: the general intent that second-degree murder requires did not have to be aimed at any particular person, and the testimony was enough to let the jury find the "very high risk of death" the law demands. The murder and assault counts had properly been tried together, because the two incidents formed part of a single set of events. One sentence in the prosecution's rebuttal argument misstated the law, but the error was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt.
The heaviest issue was the statute itself. The defense argued that the Michigan law allowing the adult designation violated due process because it let prosecutors move a child into adult proceedings at their own discretion, without a prior judicial hearing, and because it set no minimum age. The panel disagreed. Under existing law, it held, juveniles had no constitutional right to be treated differently from adults in criminal matters, and whether that should change was a question for the Michigan Supreme Court or the legislature. Abraham had received every protection of an ordinary criminal trial. His claim that he had been incompetent to stand trial had not been preserved, and in any case his competency had been confirmed three times.
He served the juvenile disposition in full. While he was confined he earned his high school equivalency diploma and began taking college classes. He was released from state supervision in January 2007, the day before his twenty-first birthday.
The release lasted little more than a year. In May 2008, police in Pontiac arrested him, and he was charged with possession with intent to deliver a controlled substance. He pleaded guilty later in 2008. This time there was no juvenile court to receive him: in early January 2009, the Oakland County Circuit Court sentenced him to four to twenty years in an adult prison. In 2010 he was convicted of assaulting corrections officers and sentenced to probation. He was released from prison on June 28, 2017, and discharged from parole on June 28, 2018.
Within weeks he was back before the courts. In August 2018 he was charged in Pontiac with indecent exposure, a misdemeanor. When he missed a court date in that case, Oakland County sheriff's deputies went to arrest him on the warrant; he resisted, three deputies were hurt, and he was charged with assaulting a police officer and resisting arrest. In April 2019 he pleaded guilty to indecent exposure and was sentenced to thirty days in jail, time he had already served.
By then a larger case was under way. In late February 2019, Abraham was arrested on allegations that he had sold controlled substances to undercover officers in Pontiac and Farmington Hills, and he was charged in both cities with delivering a controlled substance, with an added count of maintaining a drug house in Pontiac. After a psychiatric evaluation he was found competent, and in May 2019 he pleaded guilty to the delivery counts. On June 25, 2019, the Oakland County Circuit Court sentenced him to at least six years in prison. He told the court he took "full responsibility" and that he knew he had disappointed people again. He also pleaded no contest to resisting arrest in the 2018 case, with sentencing on that count set for July 2019.
Abraham pleaded not guilty and denied murder. His defense held that he was developmentally, mentally and emotionally impaired, that he could not have formed the malice second-degree murder requires, and that the evidence of intent was weak. The jury accepted part of that case, rejecting first-degree murder and acquitting him on every count connected with the second incident, but it convicted him of second-degree murder, and the Court of Appeals found the verdict supported by the evidence. The account of his statements before and after the death came from witnesses whom the jury chose to believe over the defense experts.
His competency to stand trial was contested by the defense and confirmed three times. The validity of his waiver of rights in the police interview was disputed in the trial court, which suppressed his statements, and settled in the prosecution's favor by the Court of Appeals in 1999. The victim's surname appears as Green in the 2003 Court of Appeals opinion and as Greene in most news reports.
October 29, 1997: The killing in Pontiac, Michigan; a second man is injured the same day.
October 31, 1997: Police question Abraham, with his mother present, after both sign a waiver of his rights.
November 1997: Probable cause hearing on the prosecution's petition to try him as an adult; bound over on first-degree murder and three further counts.
March 30, 1999: The Michigan Court of Appeals reverses the suppression of his statements and upholds the charges.
November 16, 1999: A jury in Pontiac convicts him of second-degree murder and acquits him of the other counts.
January 13, 2000: Sentenced as a juvenile to detention until his twenty-first birthday.
April 10, 2003: The Court of Appeals affirms the conviction in People v. Abraham, 256 Mich App 265.
January 2007: Released from state supervision.
May 2008: Arrested in Pontiac and charged with possession with intent to deliver a controlled substance.
January 2009: Sentenced in Oakland County Circuit Court to four to twenty years in prison.
2010: Convicted of assaulting corrections officers; sentenced to probation.
June 28, 2017: Released from prison on parole.
June 28, 2018: Discharged from parole.
August 2018: Charged with indecent exposure; later charged with assaulting and resisting deputies.
February 2019: Arrested on new drug delivery charges in Pontiac and Farmington Hills.
April 2019: Pleads guilty to indecent exposure; thirty days in jail, already served.
June 25, 2019: Sentenced in Oakland County Circuit Court to at least six years in prison.