On May 21, 1924, Nathan Leopold and Richard Loeb, two young Chicagoans who had both moved through school and university far ahead of their age, kidnapped a boy from their own South Side neighborhood and killed him. Neither had turned twenty. A demand for $10,000 in ransom went to the boy's family, but by the next morning he had been identified, and no money was ever paid. Within ten days the two young men were under suspicion, and before the month was out both had confessed. The reason they gave was closer to curiosity than to greed: in their own words, a wish to know what it was to kill, and to show that they could carry out a perfect crime and walk away from it.
They did not walk away. Indicted for murder and kidnapping, they pleaded guilty in the Criminal Court of Cook County in July 1924, which left one man, the presiding judge, to decide whether they would hang. On September 10, 1924, after a hearing that ran from late July into September, he sentenced each of them to confinement in the penitentiary at Joliet for the term of his natural life for the murder, and for ninety-nine years for the kidnapping. Loeb died in custody in 1936. Leopold was paroled in 1958 after more than thirty-three years, went to Puerto Rico, and died there in 1971.
Both young men grew up in Kenwood, on Chicago's South Side. Leopold was born in Chicago in 1904. He was frail as a boy and spent long stretches alone, and an early fascination with birds became an absorption in ornithology that lasted the rest of his life. He was educated at the Harvard School for Boys, a college preparatory school in Kenwood, and entered the University of Chicago at fifteen, where he read widely in philosophy, law and medicine and studied fifteen languages. Loeb had studied at the University of Michigan, whose alumni records hold a card in his name dated 1923, and by the spring of 1924 he was enrolled in law at the University of Chicago. The two met at the University of Chicago in 1920 and became close friends. By the spring of 1924 Leopold was preparing to go east to Harvard.
The boy they took on May 21, 1924, came from the same neighborhood, and he was killed in Chicago that day. In their confessions the two men agreed on almost everything except the central fact: each said the other had done the killing. Neither ever admitted to it.
Suspicion settled on them quickly. Physical evidence recovered by the police was traced to a short list of people in the Chicago area, Leopold among them, and the ransom letter gave investigators a second line of inquiry. Within about ten days of the kidnapping both men were being questioned by the Cook County state's attorney. The account of their movements that evening, which the two had agreed between themselves, did not hold, and first one and then the other confessed, to the authorities and to the press. They said that they had killed for the thrill of it, and they spoke of themselves in the language of Nietzsche, as supermen to whom ordinary morality did not apply.
Neither showed remorse. Loeb later said that he knew he ought to feel sorry for having killed the boy, but that he did not feel it.
On June 5, 1924, a Cook County grand jury indicted Leopold and Loeb for murder and for kidnapping, and at first they pleaded not guilty. Before trial the defense had them examined at length by physicians and psychologists. Then, on July 21, 1924, defense counsel withdrew the pleas of not guilty and entered pleas of guilty to both charges. The move removed the jury from the case. Under Illinois law the sentence on a guilty plea was for the judge to fix, and he could hear evidence in mitigation first. One judge, the court's chief justice, would now choose between death and imprisonment.
The hearing opened on July 23, 1924, in the Cook County Criminal Court Building, and the defendants began it by reaffirming their pleas. It ran through August and into September. The state's attorney asked for death. The defense called its psychiatric experts and asked for life imprisonment, and its closing plea for mercy, begun on August 22, lasted three days.
The judge announced his decision on September 10, 1924. For the murder, each defendant was to be confined in the penitentiary at Joliet for the term of his natural life. For the kidnapping, each was to be confined in the same penitentiary for the term of ninety-nine years. The sentence rested on the defendants' youth rather than on the psychiatric evidence, and it came with a strong recommendation that neither man ever be paroled. The two were taken to Joliet, and no appeal followed.
Loeb spent a little over eleven years in the Illinois penitentiary system. In 1936, at the age of thirty, he was killed by a fellow inmate at the state penitentiary near Joliet.
Leopold served his sentence as Prisoner 9306-D, and by every account he became a model prisoner. He worked as a clerk in the office of the prison's master mechanic, reorganized the prison library, taught in the prison school and volunteered in the prison hospital. During the Second World War he volunteered for the penitentiary's malaria experiments, in which inmates were inoculated so that new drugs could be tested.
He applied for parole three times and was refused each time, once in 1953. In late February 1958 the Illinois parole board approved his fourth application by a split vote. Parole in Illinois required a job, a place to live and a sponsor, and Leopold had submitted five offers of employment, among them a post as a laboratory technician at a hospital in Castañer, Puerto Rico, run by the Brethren Service Commission, the service arm of the Church of the Brethren. The commission agreed to take him. He was paroled on March 13, 1958, at fifty-three, after more than thirty-three years in custody, and began work at the hospital two days later.
He never returned to live in Chicago. He remained on parole in Puerto Rico until 1963, under a curfew and restrictions on drinking and driving. After his term with the Brethren he earned a master's degree in social work at the University of Puerto Rico and worked as a social worker for the island's Department of Social Welfare. By 1964 he was directing a medical research project for the Puerto Rico Department of Health, and he later served as an administrator of the island's only leprosy hospital. He went back to the birds as well, and in 1963 he published Birds of Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands. Leopold died in San Juan on August 29, 1971, at the age of sixty-six.
Which of the two men did the killing has never been settled. Each named the other in his confession, and neither ever admitted to it. Loeb is thought the more likely, but no court made a finding on the point, because the guilty pleas made one unnecessary.
How well the two knew the boy is uncertain, and their own account of how he came to be chosen was never tested at trial.
1904: Nathan Leopold is born in Chicago.
1920: Leopold and Loeb meet at the University of Chicago.
May 21, 1924: The two kidnap and kill a boy in Chicago, and a ransom demand goes to his family.
May 22, 1924: The boy is identified; no ransom is paid.
Late May 1924: Leopold and Loeb are questioned and both confess.
June 5, 1924: A Cook County grand jury indicts both for murder and kidnapping.
July 21, 1924: Defense counsel withdraws the pleas of not guilty and enters pleas of guilty.
July 23, 1924: The sentencing hearing opens in the Criminal Court of Cook County.
September 10, 1924: Each defendant is sentenced to life for murder and 99 years for kidnapping and is taken to the penitentiary at Joliet.
1936: Loeb is killed by a fellow inmate at the state penitentiary near Joliet.
1953: Leopold is refused parole.
Late February 1958: The Illinois parole board approves Leopold's fourth application by a split vote.
March 13, 1958: Leopold is paroled to work at the Brethren Service Commission hospital in Castañer, Puerto Rico.
1963: Leopold's parole supervision ends; he publishes Birds of Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands.
August 29, 1971: Leopold dies in San Juan, Puerto Rico.