Nathan Gale

Victims
4 men killed at a Columbus concert, 2004; never tried. Police attributed the deaths to him; he was killed by an officer that night. 3 others wounded.
Years active
December 8, 2004
Location
Columbus, Ohio (killings and his death); Marysville, Ohio (residence); Camp Lejeune, North Carolina (military service).
Method
Shooting (police account; no court tested it).
Status
Never tried. Killed by a Columbus police officer at the Alrosa Villa, Columbus, Ohio, December 8, 2004.

Nathan Gale was 25 years old, a former Marine and a semi-professional football player from Marysville, Ohio, when the band Damageplan began its set at the Alrosa Villa in Columbus on the night of Wednesday, December 8, 2004, before a crowd of about 500 people. Within minutes, Columbus police said, he had killed four men: Darrell "Dimebag" Abbott, the band's guitarist and a founding member of Pantera; Erin Halk, a club employee who loaded band equipment; Nathan Bray, a fan who had come to hear the music; and Jeffery Thompson, the band's bodyguard. Three other people were wounded.

A Columbus police officer who had been on patrol nearby killed Gale inside the club. Because Gale died that night, he was never charged with any offense, no court ever heard the evidence, and the four deaths stand as killings attributed to him by the Columbus Division of Police. The investigation that followed ran to hundreds of witness interviews and a file of more than six hundred pages. It never established a motive.

Marysville sits about 25 miles northwest of Columbus, in Union County. Gale lived there, and the people who knew him remembered a big man, six foot three, with thick glasses, whom friends called Nate. He had had minor encounters with the town's police since 1997; the most recent entry on his record was a charge of driving with a suspended license the month before the killings.

He enlisted in the Marine Corps and served with the 2nd Marine Division at Camp Lejeune, North Carolina. He left the service in the fall of 2003, roughly two years into a four-year enlistment. The Marine Corps declined to explain the discharge, citing privacy rules. A former employer, who hired him at a Marysville auto service shop in October 2003, said Gale told him when he took the job that he had been diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia. Military records do not list mental illness as the reason for his discharge. Gale later left that job, saying he needed more money and better hours, and by October 2004 he was laying sod for a Marysville landscaping company.

He also played on the offensive line for the Lima Thunder, a semi-professional football team. His coach said he listened to Pantera through headphones before games to get himself ready to play.

Pantera had been one of the most popular metal bands of the early 1990s, and the guitarist and his brother, the band's drummer, were original members. The band recorded four albums between 1990 and 1996, and the third, "Far Beyond Driven," entered the charts at No. 1 in 1994. The brothers left Pantera in 2003 and formed Damageplan, whose first album, "New Found Power," came out in February 2004.

To the friends who drifted away from him, Gale's attachment to that music had become something stranger than devotion. One former friend said Gale had once been Pantera's No. 1 fan and listened to nothing else. Gale told people that Pantera had stolen his lyrics and was trying to steal his identity, and he said he intended to sue the band. When he brought pages of lyrics to a local band, one of its musicians refused to use them because, he said, the words had been copied from Pantera's own songs. The same friend said Gale had grown quiet and awkward, talked and laughed to himself, and once seemed to be holding a dog that was not there. He and another friend said they had pulled away from Gale because his behavior frightened them.

Others saw a quieter version of the same man. A young neighbor in Marysville described him as someone who kept to himself and seemed normal. Staff at a Marysville tattoo studio said he would linger for long stretches, stare at people and steer conversations toward heavy metal until customers grew uneasy. A short time before the killings, he asked an artist at the studio to order tattoo equipment for him. When the artist refused, Gale grew angry, raised his voice and left. The artist said it was the first time he had seen Gale lose his temper.

Damageplan had barely started its first song when the killings began. Police said that over the next few minutes Gale killed four men and wounded three others, among them the band's tour manager and a drum technician, who both survived. An officer of the Columbus Division of Police, on patrol close by, answered the call and killed Gale in the club.

The guitarist had grown up in the Dallas-Fort Worth area and lived in Dalworthington Gardens, a small town near Dallas. His aggressive style on the guitar had built a devoted following in the early 1990s, and his was the name most closely tied to the sound of the band he and his brother had started.

The club employee was at the Alrosa Villa that night to load the band's equipment. The young fan came from Grove City, south of Columbus, and was in the crowd for the music.

The bodyguard was born in Newport, Arkansas, and lived in Dallas, and he was on the road with the band that winter. Friends in Arkansas remembered a man with a strong personality and a love of the arts. He was devoted to Scottish traditions, took part in the Scarborough Faire Renaissance Festival in Waxahachie, Texas, and played the bodhran, the Irish frame drum, with a bagpipe band called The Rogues.

By the next day police had named the dead man as Nathan Gale of Marysville. Detectives eventually interviewed close to 300 people who had been in the club or were connected to the case: concertgoers, members of the band and crew, club employees, police officers and paramedics. Their summaries went into a 627-page investigative report that the Columbus Division of Police released in October 2005. The interviews showed how confused the minutes inside the club had been, and when the file was released no official reason for the killings had been established.

Because Gale died within minutes, before any arrest, no complaint was filed against him and no court ever ruled on what happened at the Alrosa Villa. The one formal legal proceeding to come out of the night concerned the officer, James D. Niggemeyer. The Franklin County prosecutor sent the shooting of Gale to a county grand jury for review, and on May 20, 2005, he announced that the grand jury had declined to indict the officer, clearing him of wrongdoing.

Gale's mental health was never established in any official setting. A former employer said Gale told him he had been diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia; the Marine Corps would not say why he was discharged, and his military records do not give mental illness as the reason.

His motive is unknown. Some witnesses said they heard him shout that the guitarist had broken up Pantera, and friends said he believed the band had stolen his lyrics and his identity. Police verified none of these accounts as the reason for the killings, and no official finding ever named one.

Timeline

1997: Gale's first minor encounters with the Marysville police.

2003: Pantera breaks up; the guitarist and his brother leave and form Damageplan.

Fall 2003: Gale leaves the Marine Corps, about two years into a four-year enlistment; in October 2003 he takes a job at a Marysville auto service shop.

February 2004: Damageplan releases its first album, "New Found Power."

October 2004: Gale is working for a Marysville landscaping company.

November 2004: Gale is cited in Marysville for driving with a suspended license.

December 8, 2004: Four men die at the Alrosa Villa in Columbus and three others are wounded; police attribute the killings to Gale, who is killed at the scene by a Columbus police officer.

December 9, 2004: Police identify Gale.

May 20, 2005: A Franklin County grand jury declines to indict the officer.

October 2005: Columbus police release a 627-page investigative file with summaries of close to 300 interviews; no motive is established.