On April 6, 1997, three members of a family from Powell, Tennessee, died in Greene County, in the northeast corner of the state: Vidar and Delfina Lillelid, and a young girl, Tabitha, who lived until the following day. A small boy of the same family survived. Six young people from the Paintsville area of eastern Kentucky were charged with the killings, and within a year all six had pleaded guilty. Natasha Wallen Cornett, who was 18 at the time, admitted three counts of first-degree murder and one count of attempted first-degree murder. A judge in Greene County sentenced her to three terms of life in prison without the possibility of parole and a further twenty-five years, all to run one after another.
Cornett did not personally kill any of the victims. That point was accepted at every stage of the case. Her sentence rested on something else: the trial court's finding that she had been the one who set the group in motion, and the appellate court's conclusion that her part in the events of April 6 was major enough, and her state of mind reckless enough, for the law to hold her as responsible as the people who carried out the killings. In February 2000 the Court of Criminal Appeals of Tennessee affirmed every one of her sentences.
Cornett was born in Kentucky in 1979. By the spring of 1997 she was living in the Paintsville area of eastern Kentucky, and her residence had become a place where the six who would later stand together in a Tennessee courtroom met.
The group ranged widely in age. The oldest was a 20-year-old man. Two others were 19 and 18; Cornett herself was 18. The two youngest were a 17-year-old girl and a 14-year-old boy, who as minors were held apart from the adults after the arrests. The trial court found that Cornett was at the center of the plan to leave Kentucky together in April 1997, and the appellate court, reviewing the same evidence, noted that she may have been the most influential of the six. Cornett herself argued that her part had been small. The courts did not accept that.
The family who died that Sunday had no connection with the six. They lived in Powell, a community just north of Knoxville, and were traveling back to Powell when their path crossed the group's in Greene County. The two adults died that evening. The girl died on Monday, April 7. The boy survived.
The indictment later returned in Greene County charged, alongside the murder and kidnapping counts, each of the six with theft of property worth more than $1,000.
The six were found two days later, far to the west. On Tuesday, April 8, 1997, agents of the U.S. Customs Service took all of them into custody in Arizona.
The adults were booked into the Cochise County jail in Bisbee, Arizona, and the two minors into a juvenile detention center. The six made their first court appearance by video before a justice of the peace in Douglas, Arizona, who ordered all of them held without bond and said he would appoint public defenders. By then each had been charged with three counts of murder, and the six had been publicly named, Cornett among them, listed as 18.
The defendants were returned to Greene County, Tennessee, where the case would be decided.
A Greene County grand jury indicted all six on the same nine counts: three counts of first-degree murder, one count of attempted first-degree murder for the surviving child, two counts of especially aggravated kidnapping, two counts of aggravated kidnapping, and one count of theft over $1,000. The State of Tennessee gave notice that it would seek the death penalty against each of the four defendants who had been adults when the crimes were committed, Cornett among them. The two juveniles faced no such notice. For Cornett, that notice set the terms of everything that followed.
The case never went to a jury trial on guilt. The State and the six defendants reached agreements under which each would plead guilty and the State would withdraw its requests for the death penalty. Cornett pleaded guilty to three counts of first-degree murder and one count of attempted first-degree murder. The other five entered pleas to the same four offenses.
The agreements left the length of the sentences open. Each defendant also gave up the right to have a jury decide punishment, leaving the sentences, and whether the terms would run together or one after another, to the trial judge alone.
The law that governed the judge's choice was narrow. When a defendant who was not a juvenile was convicted of first-degree murder in a case where the State sought death, Tennessee law allowed three sentences: life imprisonment, life imprisonment without the possibility of parole, or death. Whoever imposed the sentence had to weigh the aggravating circumstances the State proved against the mitigating circumstances the defense offered. The agreements took death off that list. What remained was the weighing, and it now belonged to one judge.
In February 1998 the Criminal Court for Greene County held a single consolidated sentencing hearing for all six defendants. It lasted about a week. Cornett's lawyers asked for a separate hearing of her own, arguing that a joint proceeding would blur the differences between her conduct and that of the others. The trial court refused. All but two of the six defendants testified at the hearing, and Cornett was one of those who took the stand.
The evidence about the killings themselves left one question unanswered. The trial judge said he did not know who all of those who carried out the killings were, only that there had been more than one. He found the youngest defendant to be one of them. Each of the other defendants claimed that the youngest had killed every victim; the youngest blamed the 20-year-old and the 19-year-old. The court found no proof that the 17-year-old had personally killed anyone, and it accepted that Cornett had not.
What the court did find about Cornett concerned what came before. It found that she had been the instigator and organizer of the journey that ended in the deaths of the three victims, and that she had taken an active part in the kidnapping of the family. Cornett told the court that she had tried to stop the others. She expressed remorse.
The defense also put mitigating evidence before the court. The trial court treated that evidence, including her mental disturbance and her remorse, as mitigating circumstances, and then found them outweighed by the aggravating circumstances the State had proved. In the trial court's words, the mitigating circumstances were "rebutted by the facts of this case."
At the end of the hearing the trial court sentenced each defendant to life in prison without the possibility of parole for each of the three murders, and to twenty-five years for the attempted murder of the surviving child. For Cornett and four of the others, the court ordered all four sentences to run consecutively.
For each of the three murders the trial court found statutory aggravating circumstances against Cornett. For all three, it found that the murders had been committed to avoid arrest or prosecution, under section 39-13-204(i)(6) of the Tennessee Code, and that the defendant had committed mass murder, under section 39-13-204(i)(12). For the murders of the mother and the child, it added the circumstance in section 39-13-204(i)(5). For the child's death it added section 39-13-204(i)(1), which applies when the victim was under twelve and the defendant was 18 or older.
All six appealed their sentences to the Court of Criminal Appeals of Tennessee, sitting at Knoxville. The appeals were heard together, and on February 29, 2000, a three-judge panel issued one opinion deciding all of them. The presiding judge wrote it, and the other two judges joined it without separate opinions.
One statute governed the review of this kind of sentence. A term of life without the possibility of parole, it provided, "shall be considered appropriate" if the State had proved at least one statutory aggravating circumstance beyond a reasonable doubt and the sentence had not otherwise been imposed so arbitrarily as to amount to a gross abuse of discretion. Section 39-13-207(g) of the Tennessee Code set that test, and every argument Cornett made had to clear it. She asked the court to replace each of her murder sentences with life with the possibility of parole.
Cornett raised four main complaints. On the first, the refusal of a separate sentencing hearing, the court held that the trial judge had not abused his discretion. Cornett had been free to present evidence about her own conduct, the court said, and her real objection was to the length of her sentence, not to the form of the hearing.
On the second, the aggravating circumstances, the court accepted most of the trial court's findings and corrected one. The circumstance for avoiding arrest or prosecution applied to each murder, and the circumstance for a victim under twelve applied to the child's death. The appellate court held that the circumstance in section 39-13-204(i)(5) applied to two of the murders. But the mass murder circumstance, the court held, requires that the defendant personally commit the killings, and Cornett had not. The trial court had been wrong to apply it to her. The error did not change the result. The Tennessee Supreme Court had held in State v. Harris that misapplying an aggravating circumstance in a life-without-parole case is not a constitutional violation, because no death sentence is involved, and that where a valid circumstance remains the error is not reversible unless the defendant shows a gross abuse of discretion by the arbitrary imposition of the sentence. Each of Cornett's murder sentences rested on at least one valid circumstance, and the court held the misapplication harmless as to all three.
The court then turned to the central question of her appeal: whether a person who did not personally kill could be held to the full measure of the punishment.
The Court of Criminal Appeals measured her against the test set by two decisions of the Supreme Court of the United States, Enmund v. Florida (1982) and Tison v. Arizona (1987): a defendant who did not kill must have been a major participant in the felony and must have acted with reckless indifference to human life.
She failed it on both counts. Although she had not personally killed any of the victims, the court found that her participation in the events had been major and her state of mind, in its view, extremely reckless. It pointed to her leading role in planning the journey, to her residence as the group's meeting place, to her presence when the family was taken and when the killings were carried out, and to her flight west with the others afterward. Her claim that her role had been minor was not borne out by the record.
On the third complaint, Cornett pressed on appeal the same mitigating case she had made at the hearing, adding that her remorse was considerable and her part relatively small. The appellate court accepted the trial court's handling of it. The trial judge had considered the mitigating evidence and found it outweighed and rebutted, and the appellate court saw no reason to disturb that weighing. It called her sentences "entirely appropriate" and held that they had not been arbitrarily imposed.
The fourth complaint concerned consecutive sentencing. Cornett relied on State v. Gordon to argue against stacking the terms. The court gave it no weight: the Tennessee Supreme Court had concurred only in the result of that case, so it lacked value as precedent.
The governing law lay elsewhere. Tennessee's sentencing statute allowed consecutive terms for a dangerous offender, one "whose behavior indicates little or no regard for human life, and no hesitation about committing a crime in which the risk to human life is high." The Tennessee Supreme Court's decision in State v. Wilkerson added two conditions: the aggregate term had to be reasonably related to the severity of the offenses, and it had to be necessary to protect the public from further criminal acts. The court found that the evidence did not preponderate against classifying Cornett as a dangerous offender. She could properly be described, it said, as an offender who "without hesitation, participated in crimes where the risk to human life was high." A lengthy sentence would protect the public, and the terms were not too severe for the crimes. Her sentences were affirmed in full.
The same opinion disposed of the appeals of the other five, each of whom had pleaded guilty to the same three murders and the attempted murder.
The 17-year-old girl's sentences were affirmed. So were those of the 14-year-old boy, the youngest of the six, whose sentences for all four crimes stood. The 19-year-old man's sentences for all four crimes were affirmed, as were those of the 20-year-old man, the oldest of the group; for him, as for Cornett, the court found that any misapplication of the mass murder circumstance was harmless and that he qualified as a dangerous offender.
Only one defendant obtained relief. The court found that the 18-year-old woman's involvement had been vicarious and relatively minor, and that the evidence did not support consecutive sentences for her. It upheld her three sentences of life without parole and the refusal to try her separately, but ordered all of her sentences, including the twenty-five years for the attempted murder, to run concurrently. For the other five, including Cornett, the consecutive terms remained.
Cornett's case did not end with the Court of Criminal Appeals. By 2006 it had reached the federal courts, in a case brought in her name against the warden of the Tennessee prison that held her. The United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit decided that case on October 20, 2006, and denied rehearing on January 30, 2007.
On April 24, 2007, Cornett petitioned the Supreme Court of the United States for a writ of certiorari, with a motion for leave to proceed in forma pauperis, the route for a petitioner without the means to pay the Court's costs. The petition was docketed as No. 06-11006. On May 22 the warden waived the right to respond. The papers were distributed for the justices' conference of June 21, 2007, and on Monday, June 25, 2007, the Court's order list carried the case under the heading "Certiorari Denied." The denial ended the petition, and the sentences imposed in Greene County in 1998 stood.
In 2017, twenty years after the killings, all six defendants were still in prison, and Cornett was serving her sentence in Tennessee.
Who carried out each of the three killings was never settled in court. The trial judge said he could not identify everyone who had done so, and found only that more than one person had and that the youngest defendant was among them. The defendants' own accounts contradicted one another. Cornett's convictions do not depend on the answer: she pleaded guilty to first-degree murder as a participant, and the appellate court upheld her sentences on the basis of her role in planning the journey and her presence for the kidnapping and the killings.
Cornett's own account, that she tried to stop the others, was put to the trial court and rejected as a description of a minor role. The appellate court found that the evidence supported a more culpable one.
1979: Natasha Wallen Cornett is born in Kentucky.
April 1997: Six young people from the Paintsville area of eastern Kentucky leave the state together.
April 6, 1997: Three members of a family from Powell, Tennessee, are killed in Greene County, Tennessee; a small boy of the family survives.
April 7, 1997: The young girl of the family dies.
April 8, 1997: U.S. Customs Service agents arrest all six in Arizona; each is charged with three counts of murder.
1997: A Greene County grand jury indicts the six on three counts of first-degree murder, attempted first-degree murder, kidnapping and theft; the State gives notice that it will seek the death penalty against the four adult defendants.
February 1998: The Criminal Court for Greene County holds a week-long consolidated sentencing hearing after all six plead guilty and waive a sentencing jury.
1998: Cornett is sentenced to three consecutive terms of life without parole plus twenty-five years.
February 29, 2000: The Court of Criminal Appeals of Tennessee affirms Cornett's sentences and modifies only one co-defendant's sentences to run concurrently.
October 20, 2006: The United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit decides Cornett's case against the warden; rehearing is denied on January 30, 2007.
April 24, 2007: Cornett petitions the Supreme Court of the United States for a writ of certiorari (No. 06-11006).
June 25, 2007: The Supreme Court denies certiorari.
2017: All six remain in prison in Tennessee.