Naser Orić was 25 years old when a gathering of armed men in a hamlet outside Srebrenica elected him their commander in May 1992. For the next three years he led the Bosnian Muslim forces in and around the besieged town in eastern Bosnia, and for more than two decades after the war he stood at the center of two criminal cases about what happened to Serbs held captive there. Neither case ended in a conviction that stands.
The first case was heard by the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia in The Hague. Prosecutors there never alleged that he had killed or harmed anyone with his own hands. They charged him as a superior: a commander who, they said, knew or had reason to know that men under his authority were abusing and killing Serb prisoners at the Srebrenica police station and a building behind the municipal offices, and who failed to stop them. In June 2006 the Trial Chamber convicted him on that basis for a narrow window of time, from December 1992 to March 1993, and sentenced him to two years. In July 2008 the Appeals Chamber reversed both convictions and found him not guilty, holding that the trial judges had never made two findings the law required.
The second case began in Switzerland in 2015, when he was detained on a warrant from Serbia, and moved to Sarajevo, where the Court of Bosnia and Herzegovina tried him on a charge that he had killed three Serb prisoners of war in villages near Srebrenica in 1992. A trial panel acquitted him in October 2017. The court's appeals chamber revoked that verdict in June 2018 and heard the case again. On November 30, 2018, it acquitted him a second time, in a judgment that could not be appealed. In the eyes of the law he is not guilty of any of the deaths for which he was tried.
Orić was born on March 3, 1967, in Potočari, a village in the municipality of Srebrenica, about four kilometers northeast of the town. He did his compulsory service in the Yugoslav People's Army in the mid-1980s, joined the police in Belgrade, trained for special police work and was posted in the early 1990s to a special operations unit of the Interior Ministry in Kosovo. When war came to Bosnia and Herzegovina in the spring of 1992 he left Serbia and made his way to Srebrenica.
Before the war about three quarters of the 37,000 people in Srebrenica municipality were Bosnian Muslims and one quarter were Bosnian Serbs. In the early months of 1992, the ICTY trial judges later found, Serb paramilitaries arrived in the area and, with the help of the Yugoslav army, began handing out military equipment to the local Serb population. On April 18, 1992, Bosnian Serb forces took Srebrenica after most of its Muslim inhabitants had fled. Small groups of Muslim men kept up a scattered resistance, and after one of the Serb leaders was killed in an ambush on May 8, 1992, the Serb forces withdrew. The Muslim population came back to a town that was now surrounded.
On May 20, 1992, an informal group of Bosnian Muslim men who had already formed their own fighting groups met in the hamlet of Bajramovići and set up what they called the Srebrenica Territorial Defense Staff. Orić was present, and they elected him commander. The chief of the Supreme Command Staff of the Army of the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina and the President of Bosnia and Herzegovina later confirmed the appointment. On September 3, 1992, the staff was renamed the Srebrenica Armed Forces Staff, and on November 4, 1992, a sub-region was proclaimed with Orić as its commander, meant to bring the fighters of Srebrenica, Bratunac, Vlasenica and Zvornik under one roof. He later held the formal command of the 28th Division of the Bosnian army and reached the rank of brigadier.
On paper, then, he commanded every Muslim armed group in the Srebrenica area. The trial judges found that the reality was very different. The sub-region never took shape. Local leaders had been chosen for their courage and their standing in their own villages, and several of them insisted on their independence from the start and never gave it up. Fighters mostly lived with their families or in makeshift shelters, communication within the enclave and beyond it was crippled by the lack of electricity and equipment, and the force as a whole lacked the characteristics of an organized army. The chamber found that Orić had effective control over his own fighting group from Potočari. Over the other groups, it found insufficient evidence that he exercised control in fact.
Between June 1992 and March 1993 Srebrenica and the scattered pockets of Muslim-held land around it were under repeated Serb military assault. Tens of thousands of refugees poured into the town in the second half of 1992 and early 1993 and lived crammed inside it. The judges described the conditions as dire and horrid: a constant shortage of food that bordered on starvation, appalling sanitation, and people living in the open in freezing winter temperatures. Every pre-war authority had left the town by the day it fell in April 1992, and in the judges' words society in Srebrenica broke down, including law and order.
The local authorities that emerged tried to restore some order. On July 1, 1992, the Territorial Defense Staff created a military police force in Srebrenica, and on the same day a War Presidency was established to take over the powers of the pre-war municipal assembly. Many men sat on both the War Presidency and the armed forces staff, and the line between civilian and military authority was never clear. The judges found that it became generally accepted that the War Presidency was the highest authority in the town, while the armed forces staff gradually asserted its own jurisdiction.
During this period Muslim fighters, followed by crowds of civilians, raided a number of Serb villages and hamlets, mainly to obtain food and also to acquire military equipment. In late January or early February 1993 the Bosnian Serbs launched a major offensive that took many villages and sharply reduced the size of the enclave. In March 1993 a United Nations Protection Force delegation succeeded in halting most of the fighting and bringing in some humanitarian relief, and in April 1993 the United Nations Security Council declared Srebrenica a Safe Area. In the spring of 1995 Orić was called to Tuzla, and he did not return. The town fell to Bosnian Serb forces in July 1995, and more than 8,000 Bosniak men and boys were killed in the days that followed, a crime international judges have found to be genocide. Those events were not part of the case against him.
The criminal case that followed Orić for the rest of his life began with the Serbs who were captured in the fighting. The ICTY judges found that a number of Serbs were taken by Muslim fighters and held in Srebrenica during two periods: from September 24 to October 16, 1992, at the town's police station, and from late December 1992 to March 20, 1993, at the police station and at a building behind the Srebrenica municipal offices. The detainees lived in the same appalling conditions as everyone else in the town, and the judges found that the maltreatment they suffered on top of those conditions made their situation far worse.
The judges were satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that five of the men held there died in circumstances that met every element of murder. The first, Dragutin Kukić, was captured on September 24, 1992, and died at the police station the next day. The other four were held at the police station and the building from December 1992 or January 1993: Kostadin Popović died on or about February 6, 1993; Milisav Milovanović died in early February 1993; Dragan Ilić died on an unspecified date between February 9 and March 20, 1993; and Branko Sekulić died on or about March 19, 1993. A sixth detainee, brought to Srebrenica in January 1993 after months of confinement elsewhere, was last seen alive on March 21, 1993. The judges found the evidence about his fate too vague to establish that he was killed while in custody.
Ten other prisoners survived. Five were held in a small cell at the police station in the autumn of 1992 and five at the police station and the building in early 1993, and all were eventually exchanged. The judges found that what each of them endured was serious enough to amount to cruel treatment under the laws or customs of war and that it was inflicted deliberately. Much of it happened at night, by guards and by men who came into the buildings from outside, and on occasion fighters took part.
The judges named some of the men who inflicted the harm only by nickname, and none of those they could identify was shown to be a member of the military police. They found nonetheless that both groups of prisoners were held under the responsibility of the Srebrenica military police, and that the military police, through its two successive commanders, was responsible for what happened to them. The first commander, they found, did not supervise the guards and even took part in the cruel treatment himself. He was replaced on November 22, 1992, after an inquiry into his alleged killing of a prisoner. His successor brought no improvement: no witness and no document placed him in either building, and more killings and cruel treatment took place on his watch.
The Office of the Prosecutor interviewed Orić as a suspect in 2001. The indictment against him was confirmed on March 28, 2003. On April 10, 2003, the NATO-led Stabilisation Force arrested him in Tuzla, and the next day he was transferred to the tribunal's detention unit in The Hague. On April 15, 2003, he pleaded not guilty to every count.
The indictment alleged that he commanded all units operating in his area of responsibility, including the military police who held Serb prisoners in Srebrenica, and that he exercised both legal and actual control over them. It charged him under the tribunal's statute with two kinds of responsibility. As a superior, he was accused of failing to prevent or punish murder, cruel treatment, wanton destruction and plunder by his subordinates. As an individual, he was accused of instigating and aiding and abetting wanton destruction of cities, towns or villages not justified by military necessity, and plunder. The destruction counts concerned attacks between June 1992 and January 1993 on Serb villages in the municipalities of Srebrenica and Bratunac, among them Ratkovići, Brađevina, Ježestica, Fakovići, Bjelovac, Kravica and Šiljkovići. The indictment alleged that Muslim armed units burned or otherwise destroyed at least 50 mainly Serb villages and hamlets in the area and that thousands of Serbs fled. Every count was charged as a violation of the laws or customs of war.
The trial opened on October 6, 2004, before Trial Chamber II. On June 8, 2005, after the prosecution had closed its case, the chamber ruled on whether there was a case to answer and acquitted him of both plunder counts. The indictment had accused him of the plunder of cattle, furniture and television sets, and the judges found very little evidence about the furniture and television sets. As for the several hundred head of cattle taken during or right after the attacks, they found that any criminal responsibility was offset by necessity: Srebrenica was isolated, its starving population was swelling with refugees, and taking the cattle had become indispensable to survival. They also found no evidence capable of supporting a conviction for the alleged murder of one man and the cruel treatment of another, or for destruction in two of the villages named in the indictment. The defense case ran until February 2006.
The Trial Chamber delivered its judgment on June 30, 2006. On the prisoners, the judges began with what Orić knew. On the evidence of two former detainees and his own 2001 interview, they found that he had visited the police station at least twice between September 24 and October 16, 1992, and that he had actual knowledge of the first death there and of the cruel treatment of the Serbs then held. But they also found no evidence of how, if at all, he controlled the military police before November 22, 1992, so he could not be held responsible as a superior for what happened in that first period. From that date, when the new military police commander began reporting to the chief of staff of the armed forces, who reported to Orić, the judges found that he did exercise effective control.
There was no reliable evidence that he ever visited either place of detention between December 1992 and March 1993, and no evidence that anyone kept him informed about the condition of the prisoners. The trial judges reasoned that, because he knew of the earlier death and cruel treatment, he was on notice that Serbs detained afterward were at risk, and that delegating responsibility for the prisoners to others did not by itself discharge a commander's duty. They rejected the defense argument that nothing could have been done for lack of means, pointing to the inquiry and the replacement of the first military police commander as proof that action was possible. Two years later the Appeals Chamber held that the trial judges had never made two findings the law required for a conviction.
The duty to punish came out differently. That duty, the judges held, requires that crimes have in fact been committed and that the superior was aware of enough to assume they had occurred. For the period in which he had control, they had found only that he had reason to know crimes might happen, and that was not enough.
On wanton destruction, the chamber found that the elements of the crime were made out for the burning of property by Muslim fighters and civilians in Ratkovići and Gornji Ratkovići on June 21, 1992, in Brađevina on June 27, 1992, and in Ježestica on August 8, 1992, and January 7 and 8, 1993. For Fakovići, Divovići, Bjelovac, Sikirić, Kravica and Šiljkovići, it found the evidence did not establish that Muslim forces had wantonly destroyed property on a large scale, since much of the damage may have come from the fighting itself and from Serb counterattacks. Orić himself had taken part in the attacks on Fakovići, Bjelovac and Kravica. The judges had no doubt that he was generally aware that Serb property was destroyed, mostly by civilians who followed the fighters, but found no reliable evidence that he encouraged it; the evidence indicated that he opposed it. They found that he could not have stopped the masses of civilians who came with every attack and who were beyond anyone's control, and that his own group had no involvement in the destruction at Ježestica. Because he controlled only his own fighters from Potočari, not the other groups, he was not responsible as a superior for any of the destruction.
The judgment convicted him on two counts, on the basis of superior criminal responsibility: failure to discharge his duty as a superior to take necessary and reasonable measures to prevent the occurrence of murder, and of cruel treatment, between December 27, 1992, and March 20, 1993. He was acquitted of everything else, including the counts for the autumn of 1992, every count of failing to punish, and every destruction count.
In sentencing, the judges found the vulnerability of the victims to be the only aggravating factor. In mitigation they listed some cooperation with the prosecution, some expressions of remorse, his stated readiness to surrender if indicted, his youth at the time, his family circumstances, acts of consideration toward Serb detainees, cooperation with the Stabilisation Force, his attitude toward the proceedings and, above all, the conditions in Srebrenica. They noted that he had become commander at 25 with no relevant military or administrative experience, leading poorly trained volunteers with very little equipment and no effective link to the army or the government, and relying on local leaders some of whom scorned his authority. They described his responsibility as uniquely limited and sentenced him to two years' imprisonment. By then he had been in custody for three years, two months and 21 days, and the chamber ordered his immediate release. He left the United Nations Detention Unit on July 1, 2006.
Both sides appealed in July 2006. The prosecution argued among other things that he should also have been convicted for the autumn of 1992 and for failing to punish. The Appeals Chamber gave judgment on July 3, 2008.
It began with the grounds that went to the foundation of the conviction. To convict a superior, the chamber explained, the prosecution must prove beyond reasonable doubt that a subordinate is criminally responsible, that a superior-subordinate relationship existed, that the superior knew or had reason to know that the subordinate was about to commit a crime or had done so, and that he failed to take necessary and reasonable measures. None of the men found to have inflicted the harm was a member of the military police or directly under Orić. The only culpable subordinate the trial judges had identified was the second military police commander. Yet the judgment never said on what legal basis that man was criminally responsible, and it never found whether Orić knew or had reason to know of that man's conduct. The trial judges had looked only at his knowledge of the crimes themselves. Knowledge of crimes and knowledge of a person's criminal conduct, the appeals judges held, are distinct matters in law and in fact, and the failure to decide the second was an error of law.
The prosecution argued that the conviction could stand on another footing, through the guards. The Appeals Chamber rejected that because no such relationship had been pleaded in the indictment. It dismissed the prosecution's main ground of appeal in full. On the autumn of 1992, it held that holding a formal command gives rise to no presumption of effective control to the detriment of an accused and is only some evidence of it, and it upheld the trial finding that he lacked effective control over the military police at that time. It declined to revisit the tribunal's earlier ruling that a commander cannot be held responsible for failing to punish crimes committed before he took command, because the only military policeman identified for that period had never been found to be his subordinate, so the question could not affect the result.
Neither side asked for a retrial, and when asked, the prosecution could point to no evidence on the record that would support the missing findings. The chamber concluded that sending the case back would serve no purpose. It reversed both convictions and found him not guilty on those counts. The judges added that, like the Trial Chamber, they had no doubt that grave crimes were committed against Serbs held at the police station and the building between September 1992 and March 1993, and that the defense had not disputed it. Proof that crimes occurred, they said, was not enough to convict an individual of them.
After the war Orić left the army, went into private business and became president of the veterans' association of the 28th Division. In 2014 Serbia issued an international warrant for him over the killing of Serbs near Srebrenica in 1992.
On June 10, 2015, he was detained at Thônex, in the canton of Geneva, near the French border, on the orders of the Swiss Federal Office of Justice. Serbia wanted him for war crimes and crimes against humanity. He was held pending extradition. Bosnia's state prosecution, which had its own war crimes investigation under way, asked Switzerland to send him to Bosnia and Herzegovina instead. At a hearing on June 25, 2015, Orić agreed to be extradited to Bosnia and Herzegovina. The Swiss authorities approved the transfer at once in simplified proceedings, citing two reasons: the acts behind both requests had been committed in Bosnia and Herzegovina, and he was a Bosnian citizen. He had spent 18 days in extradition custody.
The Court of Bosnia and Herzegovina confirmed the state prosecution's indictment on September 9, 2015. It accused Orić of killing three Bosnian Serb prisoners of war, Slobodan Ilić, Mitar Savić and Milutin Milošević, in 1992 in the villages of Zalazje, Lolići and Kunjerac, in the Bratunac and Srebrenica area. A second man, a former Bosnian army fighter described as his subordinate, was indicted with him for the same alleged crimes. The court did not hold Orić in custody but barred him from traveling. Unlike the case in The Hague, this indictment accused him of taking part in the killings himself. He denied the charges.
His lawyers argued that he could not be tried twice for the same crimes and asked the Mechanism for International Criminal Tribunals, the body that took over the remaining work of the ICTY, to halt the Bosnian case. On December 10, 2015, a judge of the Mechanism refused, holding that the Bosnian murder charges differed from the Hague charges in their victims and in the nature, time and place of the alleged crimes, and in February 2016 the Mechanism's president refused leave to appeal.
The trial opened in Sarajevo on January 26, 2016. The prosecution's key witness was protected under the code O-1.
On October 9, 2017, the trial panel acquitted both men. It found that the prosecution had not proved their guilt beyond reasonable doubt and had built its whole case on the word of O-1, whose accounts did not hold together on any of the three counts: on one, he had not mentioned the village or the accused during the investigation; on another, an expert's findings did not match his description; on the third, he had said nothing at first and then told the court he had witnessed all of it.
The prosecution appealed, and in early June 2018 the court's appellate chamber revoked the acquittal and ordered a new trial before itself.
On November 30, 2018, the appellate panel acquitted Orić and his co-accused again. It found O-1 neither reliable nor credible and held that the prosecution had not proved the two men killed the three prisoners. His testimony before the two chambers had differed significantly on decisive facts, and he had given no valid reason for leaving one of the killings out of his account during the investigation. The defense also showed that O-1 had been seriously injured on December 11, 1992, three days before the operation in Kunjerac, and the panel found he could not realistically have taken part in it. The judgment was final and could not be appealed. It was the second time a court had acquitted him at the end of a trial, ten years after the first.
No court has found Naser Orić guilty of any death. The ICTY Trial Chamber's 2006 conviction was for a failure to prevent crimes by others, never for committing them, and the Appeals Chamber reversed it in full in 2008. The Court of Bosnia and Herzegovina acquitted him of the three killings with which he was personally charged, first in 2017 and, after the retrial, in a final judgment in 2018.
What the courts did establish concerned the crimes, not his guilt. Both chambers in The Hague accepted that grave crimes were committed against Serbs held at the Srebrenica police station and the building behind the municipal offices between September 1992 and March 1993, and the defense did not contest it. The trial judges found that the military police, through its two commanders, bore responsibility for what happened to the prisoners. Neither commander was tried by the tribunal, and the Appeals Chamber held that the trial judges had never said on what legal basis the second commander was responsible.
The trial judges also found that Muslim fighters and civilians wantonly destroyed property in several Serb villages in 1992 and early 1993, while holding that Orić could not be held responsible for it and that the evidence showed he opposed it. Their findings on other villages, including Kravica, did not establish wanton destruction by Muslim forces on a large scale. One detainee's death in 1993 was alleged but not proved.
March 3, 1967: born in Potočari, Srebrenica municipality, Bosnia and Herzegovina.
April 18, 1992: Bosnian Serb forces take Srebrenica; they withdraw after May 8.
May 20, 1992: elected commander of the Srebrenica Territorial Defense Staff at Bajramovići.
July 1, 1992: Srebrenica military police and War Presidency established.
1992: alleged killings of three Serb prisoners of war near Srebrenica, later charged against him in Bosnia; acquitted, final 2018.
September 24 to October 16, 1992: first period of detention of Serb prisoners at the Srebrenica police station; one detainee dies.
November 4, 1992: proclaimed commander of the Srebrenica sub-region.
November 22, 1992: the first military police commander is replaced; the trial chamber later dates Orić's effective control of the military police from this date.
December 27, 1992, to March 20, 1993: second period of detention; four detainees die.
April 1993: Srebrenica declared a United Nations Safe Area.
Spring 1995: called to Tuzla; he does not return to Srebrenica.
2001: interviewed as a suspect by the ICTY Office of the Prosecutor.
March 28, 2003: ICTY indictment confirmed.
April 10, 2003: arrested in Tuzla by the Stabilisation Force; transferred to The Hague the next day.
April 15, 2003: pleads not guilty to all counts.
October 6, 2004: trial opens before Trial Chamber II.
June 8, 2005: mid-trial decision acquits him of plunder and narrows the case.
June 30, 2006: convicted at trial of failure to discharge his duty as a superior to prevent murder and cruel treatment by others between December 27, 1992, and March 20, 1993; two years; release ordered.
July 1, 2006: released from the United Nations Detention Unit.
July 3, 2008: Appeals Chamber reverses both convictions and finds him not guilty.
2014: Serbia issues an international warrant for his arrest.
June 10, 2015: detained at Thônex, Geneva canton, Switzerland.
June 25, 2015: agrees to extradition to Bosnia and Herzegovina; Switzerland approves it.
September 9, 2015: Court of Bosnia and Herzegovina confirms the indictment for the killing of three Serb prisoners of war.
December 10, 2015: a judge of the Mechanism for International Criminal Tribunals rejects his double-jeopardy challenge.
January 26, 2016: trial opens in Sarajevo.
October 9, 2017: acquitted at first instance.
June 2018: appellate chamber revokes the acquittal and orders a retrial.
November 30, 2018: acquitted at retrial by the appellate panel; the judgment is final.