WHEN THE WRONG MAN WENT DOWN

Every one of these cases began with a file marked closed. A detective had a confession, a prosecutor had a verdict, and a judge had signed a sentence. In each, the person held responsible was later cleared or freed, and the crime was tied instead to a man already in custody, or under suspicion, for other killings. Some of the wrongly convicted walked out of prison. One died on death row. Three were executed. Their cases run from a Soviet mining town in 1978 to a Chicago appellate court in 2013, and they share a single, uncomfortable feature: the mistake came to light only after the other man had been caught for something else.

Shijiazhuang: Nie Shubin and Wang Shujin

In August 1994 a woman was killed in the western suburbs of Shijiazhuang, the capital of Hebei province. Police detained Nie Shubin, a young factory worker, on October 1, 1994; he confessed on the sixth day of questioning, according to a case study by the U.S.-Asia Law Institute at New York University. On March 15, 1995, the Shijiazhuang Intermediate People’s Court convicted him of intentional homicide and rape and sentenced him to death. The Hebei High People’s Court upheld the sentence on April 25, and he was executed on April 27, 1995. The South China Morning Post reported in 2013 that no DNA tests had been carried out and that the conviction rested on his own statements.

Ten years later, in January 2005, police in Henan province questioned Wang Shujin, a farmer wanted in Guangping County since 1995. He confessed to six cases, and one of them was the Shijiazhuang killing. The Chinese press called it "one case, two killers." The Handan court convicted Wang in 2007 of killings in Guangping, but prosecutors left the Shijiazhuang case out of the indictment, and in 2013 the Hebei High People’s Court ruled that Wang had not committed it. Forty lawyers signed an open letter in protest.

Nie’s mother petitioned for more than two decades. In December 2014 the Supreme People’s Court sent the case to the Shandong High People’s Court for review, the first such cross-provincial review, and on December 2, 2016, the court’s Second Circuit, sitting in Shenyang, declared Nie Shubin not guilty. The facts relied on at his trial were unclear and the evidence insufficient, the court said, and The Christian Science Monitor, citing Xinhua, reported that it also held his confession might have been obtained by torture. His parents received 2.68 million yuan in state compensation in March 2017.

Wang was resentenced in 2020 after a retrial on new evidence in one of the Guangping killings and was executed on February 2, 2021. To the end he said he had killed the woman in Shijiazhuang. The Supreme People’s Court cleared Nie without naming anyone else, and no one stands convicted of her death.

Hohhot: Hugjiltu and Zhao Zhihong

On April 9, 1996, a woman surnamed Yang was killed in Hohhot, the capital of Inner Mongolia. Police arrested Hugjiltu, an 18-year-old ethnic Mongolian who worked at a cigarette factory. Agence France-Presse reported that he was questioned for 48 hours before he confessed. On May 17, 1996, the Hohhot Intermediate People’s Court sentenced him to death for intentional homicide; the regional high court rejected his appeal on June 5, and he was executed on June 10, 1996, 61 days after the killing, as Xinhua later described it.

In October 2005 police arrested Zhao Zhihong, who confessed to more than 20 crimes and told investigators that the Hohhot killing of April 9, 1996, was the first of its kind he had committed. Prosecutors left that killing out of the charges; Zhao raised the omission himself at a closed hearing in November 2006, China News Service reported, and the hearing was adjourned. His case was not heard again until 2015. The Paper, a Shanghai news site, reported that he wrote from detention asking to "pay with his life" for the 1996 crime.

On December 15, 2014, the Inner Mongolia Higher People’s Court declared Hugjiltu not guilty. The facts were unclear, it said, and the evidence insufficient. His parents received 2,059,621.40 yuan in compensation; money could not bring back a life, they told Xinhua. In February 2016 the authorities in Inner Mongolia announced that 27 people had been held responsible: the former deputy police chief who had led the 1996 investigation was dealt with under criminal law, and 26 others from the police, the procuratorate and the courts received Party or administrative discipline. Hugjiltu’s mother told Radio Free Asia the handling had been too hasty.

Zhao was convicted in 2015 and executed on July 30, 2019. When the Supreme People’s Court approved his death sentence it confirmed 17 crimes, including six killings, and declined to confirm four others. One of the four was the killing of Yang: his account of the time, of what she was wearing and of other details conflicted with the evidence, the head of the court’s Fifth Criminal Division said. Hugjiltu had been acquitted because the evidence against him was insufficient, the judge added, not because Zhao claimed the crime. The 1996 killing is legally unsolved.

Shakhty: Aleksandr Kravchenko and Andrei Chikatilo

On December 22, 1978, Yelena Zakotnova, a nine-year-old second-grader known as Lena, was killed in Shakhty, in the Rostov region of southern Russia. Police arrested Aleksandr Kravchenko, a 25-year-old local man with a previous conviction for killing a girl. He confessed, retracted, and was eventually sentenced to death. Rossiyskaya Gazeta, reporting an interview the investigator Amurkhan Yandiev gave to TASS in September 2026, said Kravchenko was shot on July 5, 1983, and that Yandiev later learned a cellmate had tormented him into taking the blame. Radio Svoboda noted that he was 29.

Andrei Chikatilo, a former teacher and factory supply agent, was arrested in November 1990. Among the killings he described was that of a girl in Shakhty in 1978, a file closed for years by Kravchenko’s execution. Kravchenko’s verdict was overturned in 1990. The Rostov Regional Court convicted Chikatilo of 52 murders in October 1992, including Lena Zakotnova’s. In 1993 the Supreme Court of Russia struck nine of them from the verdict for insufficient evidence, among them the Shakhty killing, and upheld the death sentence on the remaining 43. He was shot at Novocherkassk on February 14, 1994.

Novaya Gazeta wrote in 2002 that an innocent man had been executed for Chikatilo’s crimes and that the state had never acknowledged the error. Yandiev, who does not believe Kravchenko was guilty, told TASS that had the investigation turned to Chikatilo in 1979, more than 50 lives could have been saved. No court now holds either man responsible for Lena Zakotnova’s death.

South Los Angeles: David Allen Jones and Chester Turner

Between September and December 1992, four women died near the 97th Street Elementary School in South Los Angeles. In late December police arrested David Allen Jones, a 32-year-old janitor with an intellectual disability, who confessed to all four after questioning, according to the National Registry of Exonerations. On April 14, 1995, a jury convicted him of the rape and murder of Mary Edwards and of manslaughter in the deaths of Tammie Christmas and Debra Williams, and acquitted him in the fourth death. He was sentenced to 36 years to life.

In 2002 the Post Conviction Assistance Center took his case under California’s new law on post-conviction DNA testing. Two of the four sets of evidence had been destroyed. The two that survived, from the Williams and Edwards cases, excluded Jones and matched Chester Dewayne Turner, already in custody on a rape charge. On March 4, 2004, Jones’s convictions were vacated and he was released. Los Angeles paid him 720,000 dollars in 2006, and the state added 74,600 dollars. "It was a long time coming," his lawyer said, as reported by the Associated Press.

The Los Angeles Police Department announced in October 2004 that DNA tied Turner to a series of killings. A jury convicted him in April 2007 of the first-degree murders of ten women, and in June 2014 a second jury convicted him of four more, among them Mary Edwards and Debra Williams. He was sentenced to death in both cases. The Salt Lake County District Attorney charged him in June 2024 with aggravated murder in a 1998 Utah case. He has not been charged in the death of Tammie Christmas, one of the three for which Jones was convicted.

Fort Lauderdale: Jerry Frank Townsend, Frank Lee Smith and Eddie Lee Mosley

Eddie Lee Mosley was never convicted of killing anyone. He was charged with murder in 1987, declared incompetent to stand trial and committed to a state psychiatric hospital, where he stayed until his death in 2020, Florida Bulldog reported. Yet DNA testing in 2000 and 2001 linked him to killings of Black women and girls in northwest Fort Lauderdale for which two other men had been sent to prison.

The first was Jerry Frank Townsend, arrested in September 1979 at 27. The National Registry of Exonerations gives his IQ as 58. Over five days of questioning he implicated himself in about 20 killings; no physical evidence linked him to any of them. In July 1980 a Broward jury convicted him of first-degree murder in two 1973 deaths, including that of Naomi Gamble, 15, and he later pleaded no contest or guilty to further killings in Broward and Miami-Dade, for six murder convictions in all. His arrest, Florida Bulldog wrote in 2012, ended the public search for the killer. Mosley stayed free.

The second was Frank Lee Smith, convicted on January 31, 1986, of first-degree murder, with other charges, in the death of eight-year-old Shandra Whitehead in April 1985, and sentenced to death. Mosley was a cousin of the girl’s mother, according to the Registry, the Innocence Project and FRONTLINE. In 1989 a key trial witness signed an affidavit identifying Mosley’s photograph as the man she had seen; the trial court rejected her recantation, and in 1998 a judge denied DNA testing. Smith was diagnosed with pancreatic cancer on January 1, 2000, and died on death row on January 30, at 52. On December 15, 2000, the FBI laboratory reported that the evidence was consistent with Mosley, and Smith’s convictions were vacated and the charges dismissed, eleven months after his death.

On April 27, 2001, Broward Sheriff Ken Jenne announced that DNA linked the deaths of Naomi Gamble and Terry Jean Cummings to Mosley and excluded Townsend. Townsend’s convictions in both counties were vacated between April and June 2001, and he was released on June 16, 2001, at 49, after about 22 years. The sheriff apologized to him. None of the killings linked to Mosley was ever tried against him.

Tustin: a Marine’s conviction and Gerald Parker

In 1979 a pregnant woman in Tustin, California, survived an attack in her home and lost the full-term daughter she was carrying. Her husband, a Marine, was charged in April 1980, and on October 1, 1980, a jury convicted him of second degree murder for the death of the baby, attempted murder and assault with a deadly weapon. He was sentenced to 15 years to life. The prosecution’s case rested mainly on his wife’s testimony, according to the Innocence Project; Behind the Badge, a site serving Orange County police agencies, reported in 2015 that blood typing had placed both men in the same group. The California Court of Appeal upheld the convictions in 1992. He always said he was innocent.

In 1996 Orange County investigators ran DNA profiles from unsolved cases against California’s offender database. In June the laboratory reported matches to Gerald Parker, a former Marine staff sergeant already in prison on an unrelated parole violation. The Tustin evidence matched him too. On June 20, 1996, an Orange County Superior Court judge set aside the husband’s convictions and dismissed the case, and he was freed that day after 16 years, the National Registry of Exonerations records. St. Louis Public Radio, interviewing him in 2003, described him as the 35th person in the United States exonerated by DNA.

Parker was convicted in 1998 of six counts of first degree murder, five women and girls killed in Anaheim, Costa Mesa and Tustin in 1978 and 1979, and the Tustin couple’s unborn daughter. He was sentenced to death on January 21, 1999. The California Supreme Court affirmed in June 2017, Patch reported, and the U.S. Supreme Court declined review in February 2018.

Buffalo: Anthony Capozzi and Altemio Sanchez

Anthony Capozzi, a Buffalo man diagnosed with schizophrenia, was arrested on September 13, 1985, after a series of attacks in Delaware Park. Three women picked him out of a photo lineup, and one of them said she had first chosen someone else. On April 6, 1987, a jury convicted him of two counts of first-degree rape and two counts of sodomy for attacks in April and July 1984, and acquitted him of a third. The Appellate Division upheld the verdict in 1989, and his mother spent the next two decades fighting for his release.

He was still in custody in January 2007, when an Erie County task force arrested Altemio Sanchez, a Cheektowaga factory worker and father of two, after a DNA match to a string of attacks around Buffalo. Investigators asked whether he had committed the Delaware Park attacks as well. Evidence from the 1984 cases, long believed lost, was located at Erie County Medical Center in March 2007; DNA excluded Capozzi and matched Sanchez, the Erie County district attorney said. On April 2, 2007, at a hearing that lasted seven minutes, Judge Shirley Troutman vacated Capozzi’s convictions and dismissed the charges, WBFO reported. He had been in custody about 22 years.

Sanchez pleaded guilty on May 16, 2007, to three counts of second-degree murder: Linda Yalem, 22, in 1990, Majane Mazur, 32, in 1992, and Joan Diver, 45, in 2006. He was sentenced on August 14, 2007, to 75 years to life. The rapes linked to him could not be prosecuted because New York’s statute of limitations had run. In June 2010 the state settled Capozzi’s claim for 4.25 million dollars. "He will never get back 20 years of his life," his lawyer, Thomas D’Agostino, told WBFO. Sanchez died in state custody on September 22, 2023.

Milwaukee: Chaunte Ott, William Avery and Walter Ellis

Jessica Payne was 16 when she was killed in Milwaukee in August 1995. In March 1996 a jury convicted Chaunte Ott, 21, of first-degree murder and attempted robbery in her death, and he was sentenced to life. No physical evidence tied him to the crime; the case rested on two men who said they had been with him, both of whom later said their testimony was false. A DNA test in 2002 excluded Ott, and in 2007 the same unknown profile was linked to two other unsolved killings on the city’s north side. With the Wisconsin Innocence Project, Ott won a new trial on December 23, 2008, and the charges were dismissed on June 5, 2009. He had served 13 years. Milwaukee agreed in 2015 to pay him 6.5 million dollars, the Associated Press reported.

Maryetta Griffin, 39, was killed in February 1998. William Avery was convicted of reckless homicide in her death on March 9, 2005, and sentenced to 40 years, largely on the word of three inmates who said he had confessed to them, according to the National Registry of Exonerations. A DNA test he requested in 2010 excluded him. He was released in May 2010, and his conviction was vacated on September 23. A federal jury awarded him a million dollars in 2015.

Both profiles led to Walter E. Ellis, arrested in September 2009. In February 2011 he pleaded no contest to seven homicides of women killed in Milwaukee between 1986 and 2007 and received seven consecutive life terms without parole. The Payne and Griffin deaths, linked to him by DNA, were not among the charges. Ellis died in custody in South Dakota in December 2013, the Associated Press reported.

Arlington: David Vasquez and Timothy Wilson Spencer

Carolyn Hamm, a 32-year-old lawyer, was killed in Arlington, Virginia, in January 1984. Police focused on David Vasquez, a former school janitor with an IQ the Registry places below 70. Biological evidence did not match his blood type. On February 3, 1985, the day before trial, he entered an Alford plea to second-degree murder and burglary, accepting that the evidence could convict him without admitting guilt, and was sentenced to 35 years.

In 1988 Timothy Wilson Spencer was convicted in Arlington of the capital murder of Susan Tucker, in what Arlington Magazine and other sources describe as the first capital murder conviction in the United States built on DNA evidence. He was later convicted of three more capital murders in Richmond and Chesterfield County. Arlington detectives and the FBI concluded that the man who killed Susan Tucker had also killed Carolyn Hamm. The Hamm evidence was too degraded to test, so there was no court remedy. Governor Gerald Baliles granted Vasquez an absolute pardon on January 4, 1989, and he was freed that day after about four years. The General Assembly voted him 117,000 dollars in 1990. Spencer was never charged with the Hamm killing. He was executed at Greensville Correctional Center on April 27, 1994.

Lansing: Claude McCollum and Matthew Macon

Carolyn Kronenberg, a Lansing Community College professor, was killed in January 2005. Two days later police arrested Claude McCollum, a 26-year-old student with significant learning disabilities who was homeless and often slept on campus. Detectives asked him how he might, hypothetically, have done it, and prosecutors put his answers to the jury as a confession. A forensic scientist testified that the DNA in the case came from an unidentified man, not McCollum. On February 14, 2006, the jury convicted him of rape and murder, and he was sentenced to life without parole.

In August 2007 Lansing police arrested Matthew Macon, a 27-year-old parolee, in a series of killings of women that summer. Over three sessions with detectives, City Pulse later reported, he described seven killings going back to 2004, Carolyn Kronenberg’s among them, and said he had been relieved when McCollum was convicted. The prosecutor reopened the Kronenberg case in September 2007. Analysis of campus video placed McCollum in a different building at the time of the killing. A state police detective had reached the same conclusion before the 2006 trial and written a report; prosecutors said it went to the defense, and McCollum’s trial lawyer said he never saw it, the National Registry of Exonerations records. The Michigan Court of Appeals ordered a new trial, McCollum was released on October 16, 2007, and the charges were dismissed later that month. The lead prosecutor in his case was fired, and in 2010 McCollum settled his lawsuit for 2 million dollars.

Macon was convicted in May 2008 of the first-degree murders of Sandra Eichorn and Karen Delgado-Yates and sentenced to life without parole. On March 1, 2010, Ingham County Prosecutor Stuart Dunnings III said he believed Macon was responsible for five more deaths, Kronenberg’s included, and would not charge him because no further sentence was possible, WKAR reported.

Portland: two convictions and Keith Hunter Jesperson

Taunja Bennett, 23, was killed near Portland, Oregon, in January 1990. A 57-year-old woman, L.P., told detectives that she and her boyfriend, J.S., had done it; the National Registry of Exonerations says she saw the case as a way to end a relationship she described as abusive. Both were arrested in February 1990. In January 1991 a Multnomah County jury convicted L.P. of felony murder, despite her recantation at trial, and in March 1991 J.S., fearing a death sentence, pleaded no contest to murder and kidnapping. Each received a life sentence.

In 1994, newspapers and authorities in Oregon began receiving anonymous letters from a man who said he had killed Bennett, the National Registry of Exonerations records. In March 1995 Keith Hunter Jesperson, a long-haul trucker, was arrested for the killing of Julie Winningham in Washington, and he confessed to Bennett’s death, giving details only the killer and the police knew. "I had been worried about this for a long time. I wanted to get those two people out of prison," he said, as ABC News reported. He pleaded no contest to Bennett’s murder in November 1995. On November 27, 1995, a Marion County Circuit judge ordered L.P. and J.S. released. J.S.'s conviction was set aside; the Registry says the judge declined to vacate L.P.'s, though it lists both as exonerated. Jesperson has since been convicted, on his own pleas, of murders in several states, and in August 2026 the Riverside County District Attorney reported him serving multiple life sentences in Oregon.

Lawrenceville: Julie Rea and Tommy Lynn Sells

Joel Kirkpatrick, 10, was killed on October 13, 1997, in Lawrenceville, Illinois, while staying with his mother, Julie Rea. She told police an intruder had been in the house. They did not believe her. She was indicted in 2000, and on March 4, 2002, a jury convicted her of her son’s murder; she was sentenced to 65 years, according to the National Registry of Exonerations.

In 2004, the Registry records, Tommy Lynn Sells, by then on Texas death row, confessed to the killing, and the Downstate Illinois Innocence Project at the University of Illinois at Springfield gathered evidence that he had been in the area at the time. An appellate court reversed Rea’s conviction on a point of state law, and at her retrial in 2006 the jury heard the taped confession, which prosecutors called false, and acquitted her. She received a certificate of innocence on November 29, 2010. Sells was never charged with Joel Kirkpatrick’s death. He had been convicted in Texas of the capital murders of Kaylene Harris, 13, and Mary Bea Perez, 9, and he was executed at Huntsville on April 3, 2014, according to the Texas Department of Criminal Justice.

Aurora Township: L.L. and Edward Tenney

Virginia Johannessen was killed in Aurora Township, Kane County, Illinois, in 1993. Four men were arrested in January 1994; three were acquitted, and the fourth, L.L., was convicted and sentenced to 60 years. In May 1995 Donald Lippert confessed to taking part in three killings with his cousin, Edward Tenney, and the Johannessen case was one of them. On May 24, 1995, the Kane County prosecutors moved to vacate L.L.'s conviction and dismiss the case, and the judge granted it. "It looks like we have a failure in the system," he said, as recorded by the National Registry of Exonerations, which lists L.L. as exonerated in 1995.

Tenney was convicted of the murder of Mary Jill Oberweis in 1997 and of Virginia Johannessen in 1998. The Illinois Supreme Court reversed the Johannessen verdict in 2002 because the jury had not been allowed to hear L.L.'s own statement about the crime, and a second jury convicted Tenney again in September 2007, the Daily Herald reported. A DuPage County jury convicted him of the murder of Jerry Weber in 2010 and sentenced him to death, a sentence commuted to life without parole when Illinois abolished capital punishment in 2011.

Perth: John Button, Darryl Beamish and Eric Edgar Cooke

Eric Edgar Cooke was hanged at Fremantle Prison on October 26, 1964, the last person executed in Western Australia, for one wilful murder: John Sturkey, 18, shot at Nedlands in January 1963. He confessed to many more killings, and two of them were crimes for which other men were already in prison.

Darryl Beamish, a young deaf man unable to speak, was convicted in 1961 of the wilful murder of Jillian Brewer, 22, killed at Cottesloe in December 1959. He was sentenced to death, a sentence commuted to life. John Button, then 19, was convicted of the manslaughter of his girlfriend, Rosemary Anderson, 17, who died after being struck by a car in Shenton Park on February 9, 1963. Button later told the Central Western Daily that detectives had beaten him until he confessed. Shortly before he was hanged, Cooke reportedly swore on a Bible that he had killed both women, ABC News reported. Nothing changed for either man in his lifetime.

The cases were reopened through the work of a Perth journalist, Estelle Blackburn. On February 25, 2002, the Court of Criminal Appeal quashed Button’s conviction, almost 40 years after it was entered; Attorney General Jim McGinty said the Chief Justice had stated plainly that there had been a miscarriage of justice, and in 2003 the state paid Button 460,000 dollars. Beamish’s conviction was quashed on April 1, 2005. In June 2011 the government awarded him an ex gratia payment.

Belinsky: a local man and Alexander Bychkov

In September 2010, after deaths of men in Belinsky, a small town in Penza Oblast, police arrested a local man with a childhood disability and a mental disorder. NEWS.ru reported that in December 2011 a court relieved him of criminal liability over one of the deaths and ordered compulsory treatment. In January 2012 police detained Alexander Bychkov, 23, over a shop burglary. He confessed to killings, and a diary at his home recorded them. In March 2012 a spokeswoman for the Investigative Committee in Penza said investigators could neither confirm nor deny that the wrong man had been held responsible, Amitel reported.

On March 22, 2013, the Penza Regional Court convicted Bychkov of nine murders and a theft and sentenced him to life in a special regime colony, PenzaInform reported, and the Supreme Court of Russia left the verdict unchanged. NEWS.ru wrote in 2024 that the first man was freed only after Bychkov confessed; the outlet 360 wrote in 2025 that he was amnestied, and that a criminal case against the investigator who obtained his confession was closed.

Englewood: Hubert Geralds and Andre Crawford

In November 1997 a Cook County jury convicted Hubert Geralds of murdering six women in the Englewood neighborhood of Chicago, on the strength of confessions given under police questioning, and in January 1998 he was sentenced to death. The first of the six was Rhonda King, 18, who died in December 1994. The National Registry of Exonerations describes Geralds as having "the mind of an eight-year-old."

In January 2000 police arrested Andre Crawford, who confessed to a series of killings in the same neighborhood, CBS News reported, and on January 29 he told a prosecutor about Rhonda King. On February 10, 2000, the State moved to vacate Geralds’s conviction and death sentence for her murder. The Registry lists Geralds as exonerated in that case, with a false confession as a contributing factor, even though he is still serving sentences for five murders; the Illinois Department of Corrections listed him at Hill Correctional Center in October 2026. A jury convicted Crawford in December 2009 of killing 11 women, King among them. The Illinois Appellate Court upheld that verdict in 2013 and called the history of the King case "extraordinarily troubling."

Keansburg: J.B. and Robert Zarinsky

Robert Zarinsky stands convicted of one killing, the first degree murder of Rosemary Calandriello, 17, in 1969. A jury in Elizabeth acquitted him in 2001 of the 1958 shooting of Rahway police officer Charles Bernoskie. Jane Durrua, 13, was killed in Keansburg, New Jersey, on November 4, 1968. In 2004 a man, J.B., was charged with her murder, WABC-TV reported, but the charges were dropped after a laboratory mix-up raised the possibility that DNA evidence had been contaminated. Zarinsky was later indicted in the Durrua killing and pleaded not guilty. He died in prison in November 2008, before trial, and neither man was ever tried in her death.

A closed file

Read together, the cases share a pattern. A confession, often from a young man with a disability, closed the file. Nie Shubin confessed on the sixth day of questioning, Hugjiltu after 48 hours, David Allen Jones after detectives questioned him about all four deaths, Jerry Frank Townsend over five days of interviews in which, the Registry says, the tape was sometimes stopped. Once a court had accepted that confession, the investigation ended, and the man the evidence would later point to was no longer being sought.

Florida Bulldog put a number on that cost in Fort Lauderdale. Ten women and children died between Townsend’s arrest in 1979 and Mosley’s confinement in 1987, the paper reported in 2009, and each death was later linked to Mosley by DNA testing or other means. In Russia, the investigator Amurkhan Yandiev said in 2026 that if Chikatilo rather than Kravchenko had been held responsible in 1979, more than 50 lives could have been saved.

What reopened the files was seldom the system that had closed them. A mother’s petitions in Hebei, a journalist in Perth, a sheriff’s DNA tests in Broward, a university innocence project in Illinois, a killer’s own letters in Oregon. In three of these cases, in Shijiazhuang, Hohhot and Shakhty, the man wrongly convicted had already been executed, and in a fourth, in Fort Lauderdale, he had died on death row.

Timeline

• 1961: Darryl Beamish is convicted of the wilful murder of Jillian Brewer.

• 1963: John Button is convicted of the manslaughter of Rosemary Anderson.

• October 26, 1964: Eric Edgar Cooke is hanged at Fremantle Prison.

• December 22, 1978: Lena Zakotnova, 9, is killed in Shakhty; Aleksandr Kravchenko is later arrested.

• July 1980 to December 1982: Jerry Frank Townsend is convicted of six murders in Broward and Miami-Dade counties.

• October 1, 1980: A Tustin Marine is convicted of second degree murder and attempted murder.

• July 5, 1983: Kravchenko is executed.

• February 3 to 4, 1985: David Vasquez enters an Alford plea and is sentenced to 35 years.

• January 31, 1986: Frank Lee Smith is convicted of first-degree murder, with other charges; sentenced to death on May 6.

• April 6, 1987: Anthony Capozzi is convicted of two counts of first-degree rape and two of sodomy.

• January 4, 1989: Governor Gerald Baliles pardons Vasquez.

• 1990: Kravchenko’s verdict is overturned.

• January and March 1991: L.P. is convicted of felony murder in the Taunja Bennett case; J.S. pleads no contest to murder and kidnapping.

• April 14, 1995: David Allen Jones is convicted in Los Angeles.

• April 27, 1995: Nie Shubin is executed in Hebei.

• May 1995: L.L.'s conviction in the Johannessen case is vacated on the prosecutors' motion.

• November 27, 1995: L.P. and J.S. are released after Keith Hunter Jesperson’s confession.

• March 1996: Chaunte Ott is convicted in the death of Jessica Payne.

• June 10, 1996: Hugjiltu is executed in Hohhot.

• June 20, 1996: The Tustin Marine’s convictions are set aside after a DNA match to Gerald Parker.

• November 14, 1997: Hubert Geralds is convicted of six murders in Chicago.

• January 30, 2000: Frank Lee Smith dies on death row.

• February 10, 2000: The State moves to vacate Geralds’s conviction for the murder of Rhonda King.

• December 15, 2000: DNA results clear Smith; his convictions are vacated.

• June 16, 2001: Townsend is released.

• February 25, 2002: Button’s conviction is quashed.

• March 4, 2002: Julie Rea is convicted of her son’s murder.

• March 4, 2004: Jones is released after DNA matches Chester Turner.

• 2004: J.B. is charged in the 1968 Durrua killing; the charges are later dropped.

• January 2005: Wang Shujin confesses to the Shijiazhuang killing.

• March 9, 2005: William Avery is convicted of reckless homicide.

• April 1, 2005: Beamish’s conviction is quashed.

• February 14, 2006: Claude McCollum is convicted of rape and murder.

• 2006: Rea is acquitted on retrial.

• April 2, 2007: Capozzi’s convictions are vacated.

• October 16, 2007: McCollum is released.

• June 5, 2009: The charges against Ott are dismissed.

• September 23, 2010: Avery’s conviction is vacated.

• December 2011: A Belinsky man is relieved of criminal liability and ordered into compulsory treatment.

• March 22, 2013: Alexander Bychkov is sentenced to life for nine murders.

• December 16, 2013: The Illinois Appellate Court upholds Andre Crawford’s conviction for the King murder.

• December 15, 2014: Hugjiltu is declared not guilty.

• December 2, 2016: Nie Shubin is declared not guilty.

• July 30, 2019: Zhao Zhihong is executed; the Supreme People’s Court has declined to confirm the 1996 killing against him.

• February 2, 2021: Wang Shujin is executed.