NINE DRIVERS WHOSE ROUTE WAS THEIR DEFENSE

Every one of these cases began with a death that a single police department could see and a pattern that it could not. The men behind them drove trucks, and the trucks carried them through counties and states, and in one case across most of Western Europe, faster than any file could follow. By the time a court sat in judgment, the evidence had been divided among prosecutors who had often never met, and the verdicts that came out of those courtrooms were narrower, slower and stranger than the lives they described.

The road did not make these men invisible. It made them hard to add up.

The logbooks in Bond County

Robert Ben Rhoades was an over-the-road trucker from Houston. Trucking records described by The Texas Observer in 2012 showed him passing regularly through 22 states. His career on the road ended in the early hours of April 1, 1990, at Casa Grande, Arizona, when Officer Mike Miller of the Arizona Department of Public Safety arrested him. Arizona later convicted him of aggravated assault, with other charges, in the case of a woman who survived; the Associated Press listed the convictions in 2012, and the Illinois Appellate Court described the Arizona charges differently.

Arizona had a living complainant. It did not have a homicide. That belonged to Illinois. Regina Kay Walters, 14, had run away from Pasadena, Texas, early in 1990, and her death came to light in Bond County, Illinois, that September. The case that Bond County prosecutors built rested in part on paper. The Tucson Weekly and The Texas Observer reported that anonymous calls to her father had been traced to Oklahoma City and to Ennis, Texas, and that Rhoades’s trucking logs put him in both places on the days the calls were made. The logs also placed him on Interstate 70 in Bond County in February or March 1990, the Illinois court recorded. On September 11, 1992, he pleaded guilty to first degree murder under a negotiated agreement that took the death penalty off the table, and he was sentenced to natural life. The parties agreed that the court could take judicial notice of the grand jury evidence as the factual basis for the plea, and the trip logs were part of that record.

Two more deaths waited in two more states. Douglas Scott Zyskowski, from the Seattle area, died in Texas; his death came to light near Ozona in January 1990, and he was not identified until 1992. His young wife, Patricia Candace Walsh, 24, went unnamed for thirteen years after her death came to light in Millard County, Utah, in October 1990. When Millard County detectives finally identified her in 2003, Utah charged Rhoades with murder and aggravated kidnapping. Then, on September 11, 2006, Utah dropped its case. Utah could try only her death; Texas, where the couple’s journey with him had begun, could try both. "It’s in the best interest of justice and the victims' families," said Brent Berkley, the chief deputy Millard County attorney, adding that the witnesses were the same and that the family preferred one prosecution to several.

Texas took six more years. In March 2012 Rhoades pleaded guilty to two counts of capital murder in exchange for the state not seeking death, and received two life sentences with no parole, giving up his rights to appeal. He was serving life sentences in Illinois in February 2019, APTN News reported. FBI Agent Mark Young told the Tucson Weekly in 1996 that analysts had compared Rhoades’s routes with unidentified deaths in places he had passed through, and that investigators could not rule out about 50 such cases nationwide. No court has heard any of them. No charge has been reported in the disappearance of Regina’s companion, Ricky Lee Jones, 18.

Five states, eight names

Keith Hunter Jesperson, a Canadian-born long-haul driver, telephoned a Clark County, Washington, sheriff’s detective on March 24, 1995, and confessed to killing Julie Ann Winningham, whose death had come to light in Clark County that month. He was arrested in Cochise County, Arizona. In a letter to his brother he wrote that he had killed eight people in five years, and the Associated Press reported in August 1995 that authorities had sent a nationwide advisory asking other agencies to check unsolved killings along his travel routes. Sixteen jurisdictions expressed interest.

The prosecutions came not as one case but as a relay that ran for nearly three decades. Washington took his guilty plea to the Winningham murder in October 1995. Oregon took the next case, and it carried a lesson of its own. Taunja Bennett, 23, had died outside Portland in January 1990, and two Portland residents, L.P. and J.S., had been convicted of her murder in 1991, she after a false confession and he on a no contest plea. Jesperson’s account, including details Multnomah County District Attorney Michael Schrunk said only the killer could have known, freed them. A judge ordered both released on November 27, 1995. The National Registry of Exonerations lists both cases. A local investigation, with no way to see the driver passing through, had closed a case on the wrong people.

Jesperson pleaded no contest to Bennett’s murder in November 1995, according to the registry, and a second Oregon life sentence followed for another killing. Wyoming wanted him for the death of Angela Subrize, 21, and sought the death penalty; he was extradited in December 1997 and pleaded guilty to first-degree murder after prosecutors dropped the capital demand. California came next, twice: a guilty plea in Santa Clara County in July 2007 for the death of a woman named in 2022 as Patricia Skiple, and another in Riverside County on January 8, 2010, for a woman he knew only as Claudia.

Florida was the last. Jesperson had admitted in February 1996 to the death of a woman in Okaloosa County, Sheriff Eric Aden said, but she had no name, and without a name there was no case. Genetic genealogy finally identified her as Suzanne Kjellenberg in October 2023, and he was charged that day, WJHG reported. In April 2024 he pleaded guilty to second-degree murder before Judge John Jay Gontarek and was sentenced to life, Mid Bay News reported. On August 27, 2026, the Riverside County District Attorney’s Office announced that Claudia was Lydia Jane Wade McWhorter, who had disappeared from Texas, and said her identification closed the final case tied to his convictions. He was then serving multiple life sentences in Oregon.

He has at times claimed far more killings, reported as many as 160. Investigators have confirmed eight.

One confession, four states

John Fautenberry had driven trucks cross-country for a Portland company until November 1990, when he told a supervisor the hours were too long and quit. Over the next four months, by his own confessions, five people died in four states. Donald Nutley, whom he had met in Portland, died in Oregon in November 1990. Gary Farmer, a fellow truck driver, died in Hunterdon County, New Jersey, in early February 1991. Joseph Daron Jr., 46, a Cincinnati-area father of two young children whom the Supreme Court of Ohio called "a devoted father and religious man," died in Hamilton County, Ohio, on February 17, 1991. Christine Guthrie, of Portland, died in Oregon later that month. Jefferson Diffee of Juneau died in Alaska on March 13, 1991.

Alaska arrested him shortly afterward, and he did what few men in these cases did: he talked. He gave four statements to different officers, describing each killing and where it took place, and law enforcement witnesses later told an Ohio court that he cooperated and confessed to all five deaths. The single set of confessions then had to be carried into four separate legal systems, and each produced a different result. Alaska took his guilty plea to first-degree murder and imposed 99 years. New Jersey convicted him of manslaughter in Farmer’s death and sentenced him to life, the Associated Press reported. In Oregon, no charge has been reported for either death.

Ohio produced the only death sentence. Fautenberry waived a jury, and on July 23, 1992, a three-judge panel in Hamilton County accepted his no contest pleas to two counts of aggravated murder with specifications, aggravated robbery and two theft counts. On September 14, 1992, the panel unanimously sentenced him to death. One of the aggravating circumstances the panel cited was a course of conduct involving the purposeful killing of two or more people, and the state’s law enforcement witnesses testified to all five deaths. The Supreme Court of Ohio affirmed on July 5, 1995, writing that Daron "lost his life because he stopped to offer appellant some assistance." After further state and federal review, and a failed bid in 2009 for a new mental examination, Fautenberry was executed by lethal injection at the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility in Lucasville on July 14, 2009. He was 45.

Atlantic City, more than twenty years on

Dellmus Colvin was a long-haul truck driver from Toledo. On September 15, 1987, the death of Donna Lee White, 27, of Somers Point, came to light in Atlantic City, New Jersey. An autopsy ruled the death accidental, and the case was closed, although Colvin had been charged at the time with hindering and tampering with evidence, WPVI reported. What became of those charges has not been reported.

Ohio caught up with him first. A DNA sample taken in 2004 in connection with a separate complaint in Toledo was linked in 2005 to the deaths of Melissa Weber and Jackie Simpson, and he was charged with their murders. In 2006, as his trial neared its end, he offered to plead guilty to those two deaths and to the deaths of Valerie Jones, Jacquelynn Thomas and Lily Summers, and prosecutors agreed not to seek the death penalty. WNWO later described the October 2006 plea as an admission that he killed four women and helped murder a fifth. He was sentenced to life, reported as two life sentences, and WNWO said in 2010 that he would be eligible for parole in 2072. He later admitted the death of a sixth Toledo woman, Dorothea Wetzel, 40, according to WFTV; no charge in her death has been reported.

The New Jersey file reopened only because of Ohio. In 2009, WPVI reported, Atlantic City detectives learned that Colvin was under investigation in Toledo, and they compared notes with investigators there. By June 2010 he had been indicted in White’s death. On April 8, 2011, he pleaded guilty and admitted killing her, and a judge sentenced him to 30 more years. A death recorded as accidental in one state had become a homicide on the strength of a confession in another.

In 2020, held at Lebanon Correctional Institution in Ohio, Colvin told a podcast interviewer that he had killed as many as 52 women across the country between 1987 and 2005, WFTV reported. No charge has followed from that claim.

The DNA that waited for a name

Clark Perry Baldwin, a long-haul trucker from Nashua, Iowa, is the clearest case in which the road delayed justice by decades rather than months. Pamela Rose Aldridge McCall, 32, of Topping, Virginia, was pregnant when her death came to light in Spring Hill, Tennessee, on March 10, 1991. The deaths of two women came to light in Wyoming the following spring, in Sweetwater County on March 1, 1992, and in Sheridan County on April 13, 1992. For years nobody knew who either woman was.

The science arrived in pieces, and in different states. The Wyoming State Crime Laboratory developed a male DNA profile in one of its cases in January 2007 and, in April 2012, matched it to the other, linking both Wyoming deaths to one unknown man, the Green River Star reported from court documents. Tennessee’s evidence was not tested until 2019, when Tommy Goetz, an investigator with the 22nd Judicial District Attorney’s Office, reopened the McCall case at the request of the Spring Hill police. In May 2019 the national DNA index reported that the Tennessee profile matched Wyoming’s. Three deaths in two states now pointed to one man, and information in the Tennessee file suggested he drove a truck.

Investigative genetic genealogy produced the name. In April 2020 investigators collected items he had discarded in Waterloo, Iowa, and the Wyoming laboratory reported a match. On May 6, 2020, FBI agents, Wyoming investigators and Tennessee prosecutors' investigators arrested him in Waterloo, the Iowa Department of Public Safety announced. He was charged with first-degree murder in both Wyoming counties and with two counts of first-degree murder in Tennessee.

The states agreed that Tennessee would go first. It had "a known victim, and known victim’s family," Sweetwater County Attorney Dan Erramouspe told the Green River Star. The trial did not begin for nearly five years. A Maury County jury convicted Baldwin of the first-degree murder of Pamela McCall in May 2025, and he was sentenced to life; the count for her unborn child was not carried to a verdict, Cowboy State Daily reported. Meanwhile the Wyoming women regained their names: Irene Vasquez in 2022, and Cindi Arleen Estrada, 21, on July 17, 2025. Baldwin died in a hospital on July 18, 2025, two days after a heart attack, with his motion for a new trial unheard and no extradition hearing scheduled. "We know what happened to Irene. And we know who did it," Erramouspe said. No Wyoming court ever heard the evidence, and Baldwin was never convicted of either Wyoming death.

A camera in Catalonia

Volker Eckert, born in Plauen, East Germany, in 1959, lived in Hof, Bavaria, and drove for a haulage company headquartered in Wesseling, near Cologne. His routes ran through several European countries. On November 2, 2006, the death of Miglena Petrova, 20, from Dobrich, Bulgaria, came to light at Hostalric, in the Catalan province of Girona. Her relatives said she was pregnant.

The Mossos d’Esquadra, the Catalan police, examined footage from a company security camera that had recorded a truck, The Olive Press and the Sofia News Agency reported, and traced it to the haulage firm and to its driver. A judge in Girona signed a European arrest warrant, and on November 17, 2006, German officers from Hof and agents sent from Catalonia arrested Eckert at his employer’s headquarters. Within days he confessed, by the prosecutor’s account reported by NacióDigital, to Petrova’s death and to four other killings of women in Spain and France, deaths that came to light at Chermignac and Reims in France and at Maçanet de la Selva and Sant Sadurní d’Osormort in Catalonia. He later told German police of a sixth: a 14-year-old schoolmate in Plauen in 1974.

The Catalan police sent his details to forces across Europe and asked them to compare their unsolved killings of women with his routes. A special commission in Hof set to work verifying the confessions. Then, on July 2, 2007, Eckert died by suicide in his cell at Bayreuth while awaiting trial. He was 48. No court ever ruled on any of the six killings he confessed. Diario UNO reported in 2019 that by the time German police closed the inquiry in December 2007, investigators had linked as many as 19 deaths to him, in Germany, France, Spain, Italy and the Czech Republic. None of those further deaths was charged.

The Wild One

Sean Patrick Goble of Asheboro, North Carolina, drove a black Peterbilt with "The Wild One" painted across the cab for a long-distance firm with a terminal in Winston-Salem, the Associated Press reported in 1995. A co-owner of the firm told the AP he ranked in the top 15 percent of the drivers he had hired. In the winter of 1995 three women died. The death of Brenda Kay Hagy, 45, of Bloomington, Indiana, came to light in Washington County, Virginia, on January 23. The death of Sherry Mansur, 34, of Clearwater, Florida, came to light in Guilford County, North Carolina, in February. The death of Alice Rebecca Hanes, 36, of Columbus, Ohio, came to light in Kingsport, Tennessee, in March.

Three deaths came to light in three states, though the killings themselves, as later reported, had happened in two: Hagy’s and Hanes’s in Tennessee, Mansur’s in North Carolina. Goble was arrested on April 13, 1995, on a Virginia warrant, when he drove into his company’s terminal in Winston-Salem, and that day he gave an FBI agent a written statement about Hagy. The AP reported the next day that her death fit a pattern of killings in at least seven states, and that since 1991 the FBI and several states had run a task force on unsolved highway slayings. "We may be hearing from some other states," said Ron Barker, the sheriff of Forsyth County. By April 22, homicide investigators from North Carolina and about 10 other states were working to build a profile of him.

Virginia’s warrant brought him in, but Tennessee tried the Hagy case. On December 15, 1995, in Greene County Criminal Court in Greeneville, Tennessee, Goble pleaded guilty to two counts of first-degree murder, for Hagy and Hanes, and Judge James E. Beckner imposed two consecutive life sentences. In North Carolina he pleaded guilty to second-degree murder in Mansur’s death; The Greeneville Sun described that sentence as another life term. No charge in any other state has been reported.

Twenty years later Goble asked a Tennessee court for DNA testing of evidence in the Hagy case, saying it had never been compared with his profile. The Court of Criminal Appeals held in 2018 that the request was not barred by time and sent it back. On remand, Judge Alex E. Pearson denied it on August 13, 2018, and on September 13, 2019, the appeals court affirmed. A match to Goble’s DNA, the court wrote, would "merely confirm" what he had told the FBI agent on the day of his arrest. At the time of the 2018 ruling he was held at the Northeast Correctional Complex in Mountain City, with earliest parole eligibility in 2056, according to state records cited by The Greeneville Sun.

The brothers who stayed home

Anthony and Nathaniel Cook both worked as long-haul truck drivers, the Associated Press and WTOL reported. Their case is the counterexample. The killings they confessed happened in and around Toledo, in a single county, between 1973 and 1981, and still the file took twenty years to close.

Anthony Cook was arrested in the fall of 1981, after an informant’s tip, for the September 18, 1981, shooting death of Peter Sawicki, a Toledo-area real estate developer. He was convicted of Sawicki’s murder in March 1982. Because the killing predated Ohio’s current death penalty law, he received a term that left him eligible for parole. For the next sixteen years police suspected the brothers in other deaths but could not charge them.

DNA changed that. In 1997 Lucas County Prosecutor Julia Bates asked whether evidence preserved from a May 1980 case, in which Tom Gordon was shot dead, could be tested. It could, and in 1998 it pointed to both brothers. Nathaniel was arrested in early 1998. Facing evidence nearly twenty years old, Bates and the victims' families accepted a bargain: if both brothers confessed fully to their crimes in Lucas County and passed polygraph examinations, Nathaniel would be released after 20 years. On April 3, 2000, the brothers described nine killings on videotape. Anthony pleaded guilty to the aggravated murder of Tom Gordon and received a second life term. Nathaniel pleaded guilty to charges in the 1980 case reported by the Associated Press and WNWO as attempted murder and kidnapping, and confessed to taking part in three of the killings: those of Tom Gordon, Connie Sue Thompson and Dawn Rene Backes, 12. Prosecutors agreed not to pursue charges for the others. Nathaniel Cook has never been convicted of murder.

On August 9, 2018, Judge Linda Jennings of the Lucas County Court of Common Pleas ordered him released under the agreement. She told him she had tried to find a legal basis to keep him in prison and could not. She placed him on five years of community control, with a duty to register his address every 90 days. Anthony was denied parole in February 2015, WNWO reported. A hearing set for December 5, 2024, was moved to March 2025 after he declined to meet the board, and he was still in prison that December. Because the brothers drove trucks across the country, police have said there may be victims elsewhere, WTOL reported. No charge has followed.

Linkage blindness

The pattern in these cases had a name long before the FBI built a program around it. Steve Egger, a criminology professor at the University of Houston and a former homicide detective, called it "linkage blindness," the failure of separate agencies to recognize that their cases are connected, The Texas Observer reported in 2012. In the Houston and Galveston area, the magazine noted, nine law enforcement agencies shared jurisdiction over a long series of killings of women and did not identify a pattern. Texas, it reported, had no centralized cold-case unit and more than a thousand local agencies.

The federal answer arrived in 2004, when an analyst with the Oklahoma Bureau of Investigation noticed a pattern in killings of women across the Interstate 40 corridor in Oklahoma, Texas, Arkansas and Mississippi. The analyst and a colleague from the Grapevine, Texas, police referred the cases to the FBI’s Violent Criminal Apprehension Program, and analysts there identified similar cases elsewhere. On April 6, 2009, the FBI announced the Highway Serial Killings Initiative. Its analysts had built a matrix of more than 500 highway-related murder victims and a list of about 200 possible suspects, most of them long-haul truck drivers, and they checked submitted names by building timelines from reliable sources. The bureau said the offenders' mobility, the distances involved, the number of jurisdictions and the scarcity of witnesses made the cases hard to solve. Special Agent Ann Todd said in 2009 that such cases were "almost impossible to solve using conventional investigative techniques," The Texas Observer reported.

The program’s method is a timeline, and a timeline is what the logbooks gave Bond County in 1992. The difference is that the FBI set out to assemble the timeline nationally, before the arrest, rather than one county at a time after it.

What the borders cost

Only Rhoades was stopped on the night itself, by an officer checking a parked truck. The others were reached later: through a telephone confession, through DNA that sat unmatched for years, through a security camera in Catalonia, through an informant’s tip, or through a prosecutor’s idea at a conference. Most of the nine talked once they were caught. Fautenberry confessed to five deaths; Goble gave a written statement the day of his arrest; Jesperson confessed before anyone had arrested him; Eckert confessed within days; the Cook brothers confessed as the price of a bargain.

The distance did its work afterward. It split cases among courts, so that Utah stepped aside for Texas, Wyoming waited on Tennessee, and California and Florida waited decades for names. It let one state record a death as accidental while another held the confession that changed it. It left Baldwin dead with two Wyoming charges untried and Eckert dead with no verdict at all. In almost every case the men were stopped long before the legal record caught up with them. For Eckert, and for Baldwin’s Wyoming cases, it never did.

Timeline

• December 20, 1973: Vicki Small dies in Toledo, Ohio; Anthony Cook confessed to the killing in 2000.

• Fall 1981: Anthony Cook is arrested in the death of Peter Sawicki; convicted of murder in March 1982.

• September 15, 1987: The death of Donna Lee White comes to light in Atlantic City, New Jersey.

• January 1990: The deaths of Taunja Bennett (outside Portland, Oregon) and Douglas Scott Zyskowski (near Ozona, Texas) come to light.

• April 1, 1990: Robert Ben Rhoades is arrested at Casa Grande, Arizona.

• September 1990: Regina Kay Walters’s death comes to light in Bond County, Illinois.

• October 1990: Patricia Candace Walsh’s death comes to light in Millard County, Utah; she is identified in 2003.

• November 1990 to March 13, 1991: Five deaths in Oregon, New Jersey, Ohio and Alaska later confessed by John Fautenberry.

• March 10, 1991: Pamela McCall’s death comes to light in Spring Hill, Tennessee.

• March 1, 1992, and April 13, 1992: Two deaths come to light in Sweetwater and Sheridan counties, Wyoming.

• September 11, 1992: Rhoades pleads guilty to first degree murder in Bond County and is sentenced to natural life.

• September 14, 1992: A three-judge panel in Hamilton County, Ohio, sentences Fautenberry to death.

• January to March 1995: The deaths of Brenda Kay Hagy, Sherry Mansur and Alice Rebecca Hanes come to light in Virginia, North Carolina and Tennessee.

• March 24, 1995: Keith Hunter Jesperson confesses by telephone to a Clark County, Washington, detective.

• April 13, 1995: Sean Patrick Goble is arrested in Winston-Salem, North Carolina.

• October and November 1995: Jesperson pleads guilty in Washington and no contest in Oregon; the two people wrongly convicted of Bennett’s murder are ordered released on November 27.

• December 15, 1995: Goble pleads guilty to two counts of first-degree murder in Greene County, Tennessee.

• December 1997: Jesperson is extradited to Wyoming, where he pleads guilty to first-degree murder.

• 1998: DNA testing links Anthony and Nathaniel Cook to a 1980 case; Nathaniel is arrested.

• April 3, 2000: The Cook brothers confess to nine killings on videotape under a plea agreement.

• 2004: An Oklahoma analyst’s referral starts the work that becomes the FBI’s Highway Serial Killings Initiative.

• 2006: Dellmus Colvin pleads guilty in Toledo in exchange for prosecutors not seeking death.

• September 11, 2006: Utah dismisses its charges against Rhoades in favor of Texas.

• November 17, 2006: Volker Eckert is arrested in Wesseling, Germany, on a Spanish warrant.

• July 2, 2007: Eckert dies by suicide in his cell at Bayreuth before trial.

• July 2007 and January 8, 2010: Jesperson pleads guilty in Santa Clara and Riverside counties, California.

• April 6, 2009: The FBI announces the Highway Serial Killings Initiative.

• July 14, 2009: Fautenberry is executed at Lucasville, Ohio.

• April 8, 2011: Colvin pleads guilty in New Jersey to the 1987 killing of Donna Lee White.

• March 2012: Rhoades pleads guilty in Texas to two counts of capital murder.

• April 2012: The Wyoming State Crime Laboratory links the two Wyoming deaths to one DNA profile.

• August 9, 2018: Nathaniel Cook is ordered released under the 2000 agreement.

• September 13, 2019: The Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals affirms the denial of Goble’s DNA petition.

• May 6, 2020: Clark Perry Baldwin is arrested in Waterloo, Iowa.

• April 2024: Jesperson pleads guilty in Okaloosa County, Florida, to the second-degree murder of Suzanne Kjellenberg.

• December 5, 2024: Anthony Cook’s parole hearing is moved to March 2025.

• May 2025: A Maury County, Tennessee, jury convicts Baldwin of first-degree murder.

• July 18, 2025: Baldwin dies before any Wyoming trial.

• August 27, 2026: Riverside County names the last of Jesperson’s eight victims as Lydia Jane Wade McWhorter.