Every criminal case is built to answer one question, and it is not the one the public asks. A court decides whether a person did a thing and whether it can be proved. Why is a separate matter. Prosecutors may offer a theory, a defendant may offer an account, a coroner may record a verdict, and a judge may say what she makes of the person in the dock. But the law can convict, sentence and close a file without ever settling the reason, and sometimes no one can.
The seven cases that follow run from the 1940s to the 2010s, across four countries. In three of them a court reached a verdict or accepted a plea, and the reason was still never established. In the other four the person responsible died on the same day, and the investigations that followed could account for almost everything except the one thing the families most wanted to know.
Nocona General Hospital was among the smallest hospitals in Texas, a single hallway in a North Texas town of a few thousand people. In December 2000 and January 2001, hospital officials later told the Associated Press, deaths there ran at about twice the usual rate, and they traced the rise to a single shift. The nurse on duty for most of those deaths was Vickie Dawn Jackson, a licensed vocational nurse who had grown up in Nocona and was regarded there as a quiet, dependable caregiver. She was dismissed in February 2001.
On July 16, 2002, a Montague County grand jury indicted her on two counts of capital murder, each count covering the deaths of two patients, and she was arrested in Bowie, where she was working at a grocery store. In January 2004 a second indictment added three more capital counts, accusing her of six more deaths. The prosecution’s case was that she had given patients a drug that stopped their breathing.
Her trial was moved to San Angelo, about 330 miles from Nocona, because of the publicity in North Texas. On October 3, 2006, with the jury questionnaires completed and testimony days away, she told the court that she would plead no contest. "Frankly, I’ve never been so surprised in a case in my life," the district attorney, Jack McGaughey, told the Associated Press. Two days later State District Judge Roger Towery sentenced her to life in prison. News reports described the case as covering the deaths of ten patients. Jackson waived her right to appeal.
A no contest plea is not an admission. "She has never admitted guilt and she was never convicted by a jury," her lawyer, Bruce Martin, said, adding that her adult daughter, who was on the state’s witness list, had been spared from testifying against her.
The state did offer a reason, though only as testimony at sentencing. FBI Special Agent David Burns told the court that Jackson grew angry with patients when other nurses showed them kindness or joked with them, and that the patients who died had come in with minor complaints and were close to going home, which left them anxious and more demanding. The Texas Monthly writer Skip Hollandsworth, who interviewed Jackson in jail and in prison, came to a related view: that she was taking revenge for slights, real or imagined, that she had suffered in the town, and that she may have enjoyed being noticed for the first time. Neither theory was ever tested before a jury. Jackson herself denied everything. "I would never kill anyone, Mr. Hollandsworth," she told him, and at their last meeting, "I was a compassionate person."
The count was never settled either. Investigators suggested that she may be linked to as many as 24 deaths at the hospital, the Bowie News reported in 2015, a figure no court has examined. That year Jackson sought a new trial through a habeas corpus application in Montague County; both sides filed proposed findings in August 2015. As of that month she was serving her life sentence.
In the Johannesburg High Court in February 2000, Judge Geraldine Borchers began reading a judgment on 133 charges against Cedric Maupa Maake, a 36-year-old man from La Rochelle in the south of the city, married and the father of four. The Sapa news agency reported that he stood trial for the murders of 35 people. The crimes, committed in 1996 and 1997, fell into two broad groups. One was centered on the Wemmer Pan recreation area and the suburb of La Rochelle. The other was in central Johannesburg, where, according to the Cape Argus, many of those killed were older men who ran small businesses: tailors, shoemakers, traders in fresh produce. On the first day of the judgment, IOL reported, the court had still to decide whether Maake was responsible for the series against Johannesburg tailors at all.
It decided that he was. When the judgment was complete, Maake stood convicted of 27 murders, 26 attempted murders, 41 armed robberies and a number of further counts. On the first day alone the court’s findings covered the deaths of Muntu Hlatshwayo in April 1997, Ralph Ngwenya in June 1997 and Jerry Khanya Naidoo in July 1997, together with two women who were with Hlatshwayo and Ngwenya.
He had denied everything and told the court that the state had conspired against him. Judge Borchers called the state’s case "extremely strong," judged him evasive and argumentative, and rejected his evidence. The investigating officer, Captain Piet Byleveld, attended the trial; the prosecutor was Yolanda du Plessis.
On March 15, 2000, the judge imposed a life sentence for each of the 27 murders, a total reported with the other counts as 1,340 years and three months, to run concurrently. She described him as a dangerous man who would kill without compunction and said he had to be removed from society permanently.
The trial never produced a reason. The defense, arguing for mitigation, raised the death of Maake’s father when he was a high school student. A man who survived the series dismissed the point outside court: his own father, he told IOL, had died when he was a year old, and he had not gone on to kill anyone. A pensioner who had watched most of the trial asked a different question, about a suspended sentence a magistrate had given Maake a few months before the killings began. The offense behind that sentence was not reported. Relatives of Jacob Nkabinde, one of the men killed, traveled from Ladysmith and Newcastle for the sentencing and said they were glad he would be gone from society for good. No appeal was reported.
To her extended family in Sydney, Caroline Grills was "Aunty Carrie," the relative who visited. Born Caroline Mickelson, probably in 1888, at Balmain, she married in 1908 and raised a family in a series of rented houses before inheriting her father’s home at Gladesville after his death in 1948.
By 1953 Sydney was living through what the Australian Dictionary of Biography calls a thallium panic. Between March 1952 and Grills’s arrest there were 46 reported cases of thallium poisoning in the city, ten of them fatal. On May 11, 1953, Grills was arrested and charged with attempting to murder her sister-in-law and the sister-in-law’s daughter, both of Redfern, both of whom recovered. Police went on to charge her with four murders, all of in-laws except one, a friend of her mother, and with a further attempted murder. They speculated that the poisoning had begun in 1947 with the death of her stepmother.
The Crown went ahead with only one charge. In the Central Criminal Court in October 1953, Grills insisted she was innocent, accused the police of pressing her relatives to testify against her, and told the court that she had "helped to live, not kill." At times she laughed in the dock. On October 15, 1953, the jury convicted her of the attempted murder of her sister-in-law, and she was sentenced to death. The Court of Criminal Appeal dismissed her appeal in April 1954, and the sentence was commuted to life imprisonment. The public now knew her as "Aunt Thally."
She spent about six and a half years at the State Reformatory for Women. In October 1960 she was taken to Prince Henry Hospital in Sydney, where she died of peritonitis on October 6. The four murder charges never reached a jury. As for why, her biographer Stephen Garton wrote that whatever envy, anger or revenge might have driven her could only be guessed at.
On the afternoon of August 19, 1987, Michael Ryan, a 27-year-old from Hungerford, a market town in southern England, shot people in Savernake Forest and in his own town over the course of the afternoon. The Chief Constable of Thames Valley Police, Colin Smith, reported to the Home Secretary that the day resulted in the deaths of seventeen people and injuries to fifteen more. Ryan’s mother was among the dead. The Christian Science Monitor, writing at the end of the month, put the toll at sixteen. Ryan took his own life in Hungerford that evening.
Smith’s report described an only child who had lived with his mother since his father’s death, left school at sixteen, and moved between short-term jobs as a gardener and handyman. He was out of work for most of 1986 and spent April to July 1987 on a government environmental scheme. People who knew him called him a loner. He had no criminal record and no known record of medical or mental problems. Under the law of the time he was licensed throughout: a shotgun certificate from 1978, renewed in 1984 and 1987, and a firearms certificate granted in December 1986, varied in April 1987 and extended to rifles in July 1987. He belonged to two shooting clubs and bought five firearms between December 1986 and August 1987.
What the report could not supply was a motive. Its header reads "Motive unknown." Of the opening events it said that his intentions were "open to conjecture because of a lack of eyewitnesses." During the hours of negotiation that followed, Ryan shouted that "none of this would have happened" if a police constable had not arrived on the scene, and the report recorded that he "appeared rational." The inquest, held at Hungerford in late September 1987 before the West Berkshire coroner, Charles Hoile, made a single recommendation: that semi-automatic weapons should not generally be available, and that no individual should be allowed unlimited arms and ammunition.
The Monitor reported that Margaret Thatcher supported new restrictions and that the Home Secretary, Douglas Hurd, was expected to bring legislation in the next session of Parliament. Smith’s report recommended banning the ordinary sale and home possession of self-loading full-bore rifles and shotguns, limiting stored ammunition and tightening checks on certificate holders. The Firearms (Amendment) Act 1988 created a category of specially dangerous weapons and tightened the controls on shotguns.
Mary Ann Holder was 36 and lived in Guilford County, North Carolina, near Greensboro. On a Sunday in November 2011 she shot members of her family, a family friend and a former partner, and then took her own life. Her son Robert Dylan Smith, 17, died that day. Over the following days her younger son, Zachary Lee Smith, 14; her niece, Hannaleigh Suttles, 8; Makayla Leigh Woods, 15, a friend of the family who was her son’s girlfriend; and her nephew, Richard Brian Suttles, 17, died as well. With Holder herself, WRAL reported, the death toll reached six. The former partner survived.
There was a background, and Sheriff B.J. Barnes described it. Holder and the man had had an affair that ended; there had been restraining orders, an alienation-of-affection lawsuit brought against Holder by the man’s wife, and, WBTV reported, a payment of $10,000 shortly before the shootings. Barnes said that "some things got out of hand." Holder left notes accepting responsibility and apologizing. According to WRAL, they gave no motive, and investigators did not state one. "I don’t think we’ll ever know what was going through that lady’s mind when she did this," Major Tom Sheppard of the sheriff’s office told WBTV.
In March 2013, four deaths came to light in Mesquite, a suburb east of Dallas: Angelica Vazquez, 43; her husband, Marcelo, 44, a long-haul truck driver; their daughter, Paulina, 21, a University of North Texas student studying criminal justice who had come home for spring break; and their son, Alejandro, a second-semester student at Eastfield College known to his friends as Alex. Mesquite police and the Dallas County Medical Examiner ruled the deaths a murder-suicide, with Angelica Vazquez as the one who took her own life.
Neighbors called them a sweet family. Angelica had worked in an elementary school cafeteria from 2005 until she resigned at the end of the 2011 to 2012 school year, according to the Mesquite school district. Police said detectives were still trying to establish a motive. A day later CBS Texas reported that there was still none, and that the police had told reporters there was no note explaining what had happened. The family was to be buried in Mexico.
In September 2013 five deaths came to light outside Rice, a small town in Navarro County, Texas, about 40 miles southeast of Dallas: Guadalupe Ronquillo-Ovalle, 33; her husband, Israel Alvarez, 33; and their three sons, aged 4, 8 and 10. Sheriff Elmer Tanner announced that, according to the preliminary autopsies, the children and Alvarez had died of homicidal violence from gunshot wounds, and that Ronquillo-Ovalle "died from a self-inflicted gunshot wound." The sheriff’s office identified her as the person who fired the shots.
Less than two weeks earlier, on September 11, Alvarez had been arrested on a misdemeanor family violence charge after his wife told police that he had pushed her. He pleaded no contest, paid a $367 fine and was released. According to the Associated Press, as carried by KERA, no motive had been determined.
Laid side by side, the seven cases show how much the legal process can establish without reaching the question of why. Jackson’s plea, Maake’s verdicts and Grills’s conviction settled responsibility in court, and in each a theory of motive was offered, or none was, without a finding. In Hungerford a chief constable’s report and a coroner’s inquest examined Ryan’s life, his licenses and every hour of the day, and wrote "Motive unknown." In Guilford County, Mesquite and Rice, investigators could say who fired, and in one case they could describe a quarrel. The notes, where there were notes, did not say why.
• 1947: Death of Caroline Grills’s stepmother, the point at which police later speculated the poisonings began (never tried).
• May 11, 1953: Grills arrested in Sydney and charged with attempted murder.
• October 15, 1953: Grills convicted of attempted murder and sentenced to death; commuted to life after her appeal failed in April 1954.
• October 6, 1960: Grills dies at Prince Henry Hospital, Sydney.
• August 19, 1987: Michael Ryan’s shootings in Savernake Forest and Hungerford; he dies the same day.
• Late September 1987: Inquest at Hungerford.
• 1988: Firearms (Amendment) Act 1988.
• 1996 to 1997: The crimes for which Cedric Maake was later convicted, in Johannesburg.
• February 29, 2000: Judge Geraldine Borchers begins judgment on 133 charges against Maake.
• March 15, 2000: Maake sentenced to 27 life terms.
• December 2000 to January 2001: Deaths at Nocona General Hospital, Texas, run at about twice the usual rate; Jackson is dismissed in February 2001.
• July 16, 2002: Vickie Dawn Jackson indicted on two counts of capital murder.
• October 3, 2006: Jackson pleads no contest in San Angelo; sentenced to life on October 5.
• November 2011: Mary Ann Holder’s shootings in Guilford County, North Carolina; six dead, Holder among them.
• March 2013: Four deaths in the Vazquez family come to light in Mesquite, Texas.
• September 2013: Five deaths come to light near Rice, Navarro County, Texas.
• August 2015: Proposed findings filed on Jackson’s habeas corpus application.