On January 4, 2011, a member of the Punjab Police Elite Force who had been posted to the security detail of the Governor of Punjab, Salmaan Taseer, turned on the man he was there to protect. The killing took place at Kohsar Market, in Islamabad. The guard, Malik Mumtaz Hussain Qadri, laid down his arms at once and was taken into custody where he stood. He never denied what he had done. Within days he had confessed before a court, and he went on admitting the act at every stage that followed, from his first remand hearing to his final appeal.
What he contested was its meaning in law. Qadri said he had acted because the governor had spoken against Pakistan's blasphemy laws and had taken up the cause of a Christian woman sentenced to death under them. An anti-terrorism court in Rawalpindi rejected that defense and on October 1, 2011, sentenced him to death twice, for murder under the Pakistan Penal Code and for terrorism under the Anti-Terrorism Act 1997. The Islamabad High Court upheld the murder conviction in March 2015 but set aside the terrorism count. In October 2015 the Supreme Court of Pakistan restored it, holding that the killing had been designed to intimidate the public and that calling for reform of a man-made law is not blasphemy. A review petition failed in December 2015, and the President of Pakistan rejected his plea for mercy. He was executed in Rawalpindi on February 29, 2016.
Qadri was 26 years old in January 2011. He had joined the Punjab Police and undergone Elite Force training in 2006 and 2007, and in 2008 he was posted to the Elite Force wing in Rawalpindi, the garrison city that adjoins the capital. His duties there included guarding the Governor of Punjab whenever the governor visited Islamabad. He had served at least once on the guard of the Prime Minister.
At one point he had been declared unfit for duty guarding very important persons. How a man under that bar came to be posted to the governor's squad became one of the first questions for investigators.
The Governor of Punjab had been a member of the Pakistan Peoples Party since his student days. On May 15, 2008, the government led by that party named him Governor of Punjab, the constitutional head of the province.
In the months before his death the governor had become one of the most prominent public voices against the blasphemy laws. He had visited in jail a Christian woman who had been sentenced to death for blasphemy and promised to seek a presidential pardon for her; a court order blocked the pardon. He had also criticized the blasphemy law itself in public. Those statements were the reason Qadri later gave for the killing, and they became the central issue at every stage of his case.
On Tuesday, January 4, 2011, the governor was at Kohsar Market with members of his security detail, Qadri among them. Qadri killed him there, then put down his arms and was taken into custody. The governor's death was confirmed that day.
The federal Interior Minister named the guard that evening. Whether Qadri had acted alone, or as part of a conspiracy, was the question the investigation set out to answer.
The Interior Minister set up a joint investigation team headed by a deputy inspector general of the Islamabad police, with officers from the Inter-Services Intelligence, the Intelligence Bureau and the Special Branch. A second Islamabad team, formed by the capital's chief commissioner under the same officer, set out to establish whether any of Qadri's colleagues had known of his intentions or helped him. The governor's whole security squad was questioned, and 25 police personnel, together with the Elite Force clerk who had prepared the duty roster, were held and moved to Islamabad for investigation.
The formal complaint, the first information report, was lodged at the Kohsar police station by the governor's son. It named no other suspect. Qadri's own position never moved. He told investigators and then the court that he had acted alone, and that no political, religious or militant organization had been involved.
On January 5, Qadri was brought before a special magistrate, who granted a one-day transit remand. The next day an anti-terrorism court in Rawalpindi heard the police request for a long period of physical remand, to establish whether he had acted at anyone's urging, and granted five days.
Before the five days ran out, at a closed hearing in Rawalpindi, Qadri recorded a formal confessional statement. In it he said he had killed the governor on his own and that no religious or militant organization had been involved.
The police charge sheet booked Qadri under section 7 of the Anti-Terrorism Act 1997 and under sections 302 and 109 of the Pakistan Penal Code, the provisions on murder and on abetment. Section 109 had been applied to two clerics, and on February 1, 2011, the court acquitted both. On February 14, 2011, the Anti-Terrorism Court II of the Rawalpindi Division formally indicted Qadri on charges of terrorism and murder. For security reasons the trial was held inside a Rawalpindi jail rather than in an open courtroom.
The formal trial began on February 26, 2011, with police and medical witnesses for the prosecution. Its case rested on that evidence and on Qadri's own confession. Qadri did not deny the act. His defense was justification. In a written statement of about 40 pages, filed under section 265-F(5) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, he argued that the governor's support for the Christian woman convicted of blasphemy and his remarks on the law had provoked him. His counsel also applied under section 23 of the Anti-Terrorism Act to have the terrorism charge removed from the case.
The court delivered its judgment on Saturday, October 1, 2011, inside the jail and in camera. The trial judge convicted Qadri on both counts. Under section 302(b) of the Pakistan Penal Code he was sentenced to death and ordered to pay compensation to the governor's heirs. Under section 7(a) of the Anti-Terrorism Act he was again sentenced to death and fined. The judge held that the accused had confessed and that the law did not entertain the arguments he had offered for the killing.
In October 2011 Qadri's lawyers filed two applications in the Islamabad High Court: one against the death sentence for murder, and one asking the court to set aside the conviction under section 7 of the Anti-Terrorism Act. The appeal remained pending for more than three years.
On Monday, March 9, 2015, a division bench of two judges dismissed the appeal against the murder conviction and upheld the death sentence under section 302 of the Pakistan Penal Code. The same bench accepted Qadri's application on the second count and set aside his conviction and death sentence under section 7 of the Anti-Terrorism Act. Qadri stood convicted of murder, but no longer of terrorism.
The distinction carried weight beyond the label. A murder conviction under the Penal Code alone left the offense compoundable, which meant the death sentence could, with the court's approval, be set aside if the victim's heirs pardoned the convicted man, as could not happen under a terrorism conviction. The federal government appealed against the part of the judgment that removed the terrorism count, and Qadri appealed against the murder conviction that remained.
The two appeals were heard together by a three-judge bench of the Supreme Court of Pakistan, against the High Court's judgment of March 9, 2015. Qadri's counsel asked for a lesser sentence and contended that the killing was not premeditated but the product of sudden and grave provocation that took it outside section 302(b). The state argued that the confession established the offense and showed that it was terrorism.
On Wednesday, October 7, 2015, the court dismissed Qadri's appeal and allowed the state's. The conviction and sentence imposed by the trial court were restored in full, on both counts. The judgment is reported as PLD 2016 SC 17.
The court took the defense point by point. Under Article 121 of the Qanun-e-Shahadat Order 1984, the burden of proving provocation lay on the accused, and the court held that he had not met it: the press clippings he relied on carried no dates or times, no evidence supported any confrontation, and the remarks attributed to the governor did not amount to blasphemy under section 295-C of the Penal Code. Criticism of the blasphemy law, the court held, is not blasphemy; seeking improvement of a man-made law on a religious matter does not in itself amount to criticizing the religious side of that law, and citizens may object to laws they regard as unjust. The court rejected the argument that Qadri had acted under a mistake of fact within section 79 of the Penal Code. His error, it held, was one of law, and he had not acted in good faith because he relied on hearsay.
The court also declined to rule on questions of religious law, holding under Articles 175(2) and 203G of the Constitution that it lacked jurisdiction to do so and was bound to decide the case under the law of the land as it stood. That law, the court held, did not permit an individual to set himself up as the complainant in such a matter and act on it himself, and to allow it would open the door to vigilantism.
On the terrorism count the court read section 6 of the Anti-Terrorism Act as two parts: the act, causing death under section 6(2)(a), and the design behind it under section 6(1)(b). It relied on Qadri's own statement that the killing was meant as a warning to others, and held that the act was "surely designed to intimidate or overawe the public." The High Court's order on that count was reversed, and with it went the possibility of a pardon by the heirs.
Qadri asked the Supreme Court to review its judgment, and the same three-judge bench heard the petition. It refused a request to refer the case to a larger bench. On Monday, December 14, 2015, it dismissed the review, noting that Qadri had confessed at every stage and had been arrested at the scene, and holding that the petition had shown no error in the judgment. His last avenue was a plea for mercy to the President of Pakistan. The President rejected it.
Mumtaz Qadri was executed in Rawalpindi on Monday, February 29, 2016. Protests followed in several cities, and his supporters went on marking the anniversary until, in February 2017, the authorities said they would stop such rallies.
Early in the investigation, police sources said Qadri had told investigators that some of his colleagues on the governor's detail knew of his intentions. That claim was never established. The two clerics booked as abettors were acquitted on February 1, 2011, the complaint named no other suspect, and Qadri himself maintained from his confession onward that he had acted alone.
The financial penalties imposed at trial appear in two forms: as a single fine of Rs 200,000, and as Rs 100,000 in compensation to the heirs under the Penal Code count with a further Rs 100,000 fine under the terrorism count.
2006 to 2007: Qadri receives Punjab Police Elite Force training.
2008: Posted to the Elite Force wing in Rawalpindi.
May 15, 2008: The future victim is appointed Governor of Punjab.
January 4, 2011: Qadri kills the governor at Kohsar Market, Islamabad, and is taken into custody; a joint investigation team is formed.
January 5, 2011: One-day transit remand before a special magistrate.
January 6, 2011: Anti-terrorism court in Rawalpindi grants five days' physical remand.
January 2011: Qadri records a confessional statement at a closed hearing in Rawalpindi.
February 1, 2011: Two clerics booked as abettors are acquitted.
February 14, 2011: Qadri is indicted under section 7 of the Anti-Terrorism Act and sections 302/109 of the Penal Code.
February 26, 2011: The formal trial opens inside a Rawalpindi jail.
October 1, 2011: Convicted on both counts and sentenced to death twice.
October 2011: Appeals filed in the Islamabad High Court.
March 9, 2015: The High Court upholds the murder conviction and death sentence and sets aside the terrorism conviction.
October 7, 2015: The Supreme Court dismisses Qadri's appeal, allows the state's appeal and restores both convictions.
December 14, 2015: The Supreme Court dismisses the review petition.
February 29, 2016: Qadri is executed in Rawalpindi.
February 2017: The authorities say they will stop rallies commemorating him.