Muhammad and Waqas Parvez

Victims
1 girl killed in Mississauga, 2007, by her father and brother. Both convicted of second-degree murder on guilty pleas, June 2010
Years active
December 10, 2007
Location
Mississauga and Brampton, Ontario, Canada
Method
Second-degree murder of a family member, a minor, committed by father and son together
Status
Life imprisonment, no parole eligibility for 18 years, imposed June 16, 2010 on a joint submission

On December 10, 2007, the youngest daughter of Muhammad Parvez died in Mississauga, Ontario, a suburb of Toronto where the family lived. The call that brought police came from her father. He was charged with murder within days. Her brother, Waqas Parvez, was charged first with obstructing police and, in June 2008, with first-degree murder. In June 2010, in the Ontario Superior Court of Justice at Brampton, father and son pleaded guilty to second-degree murder. On June 16, 2010, the court sentenced both men to life imprisonment and ordered that neither could apply for parole for 18 years.

Muhammad Parvez was first charged with second-degree murder. In June 2008 that charge was raised to first-degree murder, and later the same month police charged Waqas Parvez with first-degree murder as well. From that summer both men faced a trial in the Superior Court on the most serious charge of homicide in the Criminal Code.

The trial never took place. In June 2010 both men pleaded guilty to second-degree murder. The pleas were entered on an agreed statement of facts that set out the events of December 10 and the conflict behind them as both sides accepted them. That conflict, as the court accepted it, was the daughter's resistance to the limits her family placed on her freedom.

The prosecution and the defense made a joint submission on sentence: life imprisonment, which the law requires for second-degree murder, with 18 years before either man could apply for parole.

The judge accepted the joint submission and imposed it on June 16, 2010: life imprisonment for each man, with no eligibility for parole for 18 years, well above the ten-year minimum for second-degree murder.

The court found that the two men had killed her to avoid what they regarded as community embarrassment, and it treated that motive as a serious aggravating factor. It also weighed the father's breach of trust toward his own child, the fact that both men had used violence against a minor, and the principle of equality between men and women, which that motive offended. Each of those grounds, in the court's view, called for a significant increase above the minimum.

Muhammad Parvez served his sentence in the federal system run by the Correctional Service of Canada. He died in custody at a federal institution in Ontario on February 22, 2017, and the Correctional Service announced the death in a public release. His son received the same sentence.

Early public reports explained the death by a single dispute. The agreed facts placed before the court described a wider conflict, and the court's own finding was that the men acted to avoid community embarrassment.

Whether the case should be called an "honor" killing was contested at the plea hearing. The court framed the motive in terms of community embarrassment.

Timeline

December 10, 2007: Muhammad Parvez's youngest daughter dies in Mississauga, Ontario; he calls emergency services.

December 2007: Muhammad Parvez is charged in the death; Waqas Parvez is charged with obstructing police.

June 2008: The charge against Muhammad Parvez is raised from second-degree to first-degree murder; later that month Waqas Parvez is charged with first-degree murder.

June 2010: Both men plead guilty to second-degree murder in the Ontario Superior Court of Justice at Brampton.

June 16, 2010: Both are sentenced to life imprisonment with no parole eligibility for 18 years.

February 22, 2017: Muhammad Parvez dies in federal custody in Ontario.