In the last weeks of 1971, as the Pakistani army lost its hold on what had been East Pakistan, members of a militia called Al-Badr took away and killed hundreds of the country's intellectuals and professionals in Dhaka, most of them on or around December 14, two days before the army surrendered and Bangladesh became independent. Forty-three years later, a war crimes court in Dhaka found that the man with effective control over that militia had been Motiur Rahman Nizami, the president of Jamaat-e-Islami's student wing in 1971 and, by the time of his trial, the leader of the party itself and a former cabinet minister.
International Crimes Tribunal-1 convicted him on October 29, 2014 of crimes against humanity on eight of the sixteen charges against him. They covered the murder of about 450 civilians in three villages of Santhia in Pabna District in May 1971, further killings in the Pabna villages of Dhulaura, Karamja and Brishalikha, a group of freedom fighters held in Dhaka in August 1971, crimes at an army detention center in Dhaka and the extermination of intellectuals and professionals in December 1971. The tribunal sentenced him to death on four charges and to imprisonment for life on four more. On appeal, the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of Bangladesh acquitted him on three charges, upheld the death sentence on the other three that carried it, and kept two life terms. Nizami refused to ask the president for mercy, and he was executed in Dhaka on May 11, 2016. Through every stage he denied any part in the killings.
Nizami was born on March 31, 1943 in the village of Monmothpur, in Santhia upazila of Pabna District, in the northwest of what was then East Bengal. He went to the Boalmari madrasa in Santhia and passed its Fazil examination in 1961, then moved to Dhaka, where he took a Kamil degree in fiqh, Islamic jurisprudence, at the Madrasa-e-Alia in 1963. It was at the Alia madrasa that he went into student politics. He later graduated from Dhaka University as a private student in 1967.
Santhia and the villages around it stayed at the center of his life and of his case. Seven of the sixteen charges eventually brought against him concerned events in Pabna District, most of them within a few miles of the place where he was born.
In 1966 Nizami became president of Islami Chhatra Sangha, the student organization of Jamaat-e-Islami. The tribunal found that he led its East Pakistan branch for a period and then the all-Pakistan organization, from 1969 until September 1971. He was in that post when the political crisis of 1971 turned into war.
Nizami never denied that he had opposed the breakup of Pakistan. At his trial he said his opposition had been political and ideological, the stand of the head of a student organization, and that he had no part in any killing.
He spoke at meetings across the province that year, and five of the charges against him rested on those speeches and on his writing in the party newspaper. The tribunal acquitted him on every one of them. It found that the speeches did not amount to direct and public incitement against a particular group, though it later weighed them against him at sentencing.
The tribunal's central finding concerned Al-Badr. It found that the militia was first formed in Jamalpur after the Pakistani army entered that subdivision on April 22, 1971, that its members were drawn from the student wing Nizami led, and that it served the army as an auxiliary force. The tribunal called it a paramilitary force and, in its findings on the intellectuals, a criminal organization. It found that Jamaat-e-Islami and Islami Chhatra Sangha had worked during the war as communal and criminal organizations carrying out the plan of the Pakistani army.
Nizami, the tribunal held, was the ex-officio chief of Al-Badr. Because the organization was made up of members of his own student wing, it found, he was a civil superior in the full sense, with effective control over the men who carried out its crimes, and he did nothing to stop them. On that basis it held him criminally responsible as a superior under the war crimes law for what Al-Badr did. The defense accepted that he had led the student wing but denied that he had any connection with Al-Badr at all. The Appellate Division, hearing his appeal, found that the documents proved his role at the head of the militia.
Al-Badr was not the only force in the case. Several of the Pabna charges concerned what Razakars, members of another auxiliary force, and Pakistani soldiers did on his information or under his guidance.
The charge that weighed most in the end, charge 2, concerned three villages of Santhia police station in Pabna: Baushgari, Ruposhi and Demra. According to the charge, a meeting was held in Ruposhi on May 10, 1971. Four days later, on May 14, about 450 civilians in the three villages were killed.
The tribunal found that the meeting had prepared what followed and that Nizami had substantially contributed to the actual commission of the crimes. It found him guilty on the counts of conspiracy and murder as crimes against humanity, under the provision of the war crimes law that covers people acting together in a common plan, and it sentenced him to death. The Appellate Division upheld that conviction and that sentence.
Charge 6 concerned Dhulaura, a village in Pabna District, at the end of November 1971. According to the charge, a raid on the village began on November 27. About 30 villagers were killed, and 22 more people who had been captured were killed separately. Witnesses placed the killings on the day after the raid began.
The tribunal found that Nizami had been present and had directed his accomplices, and that his participation by abetting, facilitating and complicity in the murders had been proved beyond reasonable doubt. It convicted him of murder as a crime against humanity and sentenced him to death. The Appellate Division upheld this conviction and the sentence.
Two of the convictions concerned individual victims, and both survived the appeal with sentences of life imprisonment.
Charge 7 concerned Sohrab Ali, a resident of Brishalikha, a village in Pabna, who was taken on December 3, 1971 and killed. The tribunal found that Nizami supplied the information that led to his arrest, that he had direct complicity in the crimes against him, and that he had substantially contributed to them. It convicted him of abduction, torture and murder as crimes against humanity. The same village was the subject of charge 9, which accused him of genocide against its Hindu residents on the same date. The tribunal acquitted him on that charge because the four witnesses who spoke to it gave only hearsay.
Charge 8 concerned a group of young freedom fighters picked up in Dhaka in August 1971 and held by the army in the Nakhalpara area of the city. They included Badi, Rumi, Jewel and Azad. On August 30, 1971, all but one of those held were killed. The tribunal found no evidence identifying who carried out the killings, but it found that Nizami had substantially contributed to and taken part in the commission of the murders and the torture. He was convicted of murder as a crime against humanity.
The last charge, charge 16, was framed as genocide. It accused Nizami of responsibility for the abduction and killing of professionals and intellectuals in Dhaka, on or around December 14, 1971, in the final days before the surrender. Among those named in the evidence were Abdul Alim Chowdhury, Azharul Haque and Humayun Kabir. The tribunal referred to hundreds of unarmed intellectuals in all.
The tribunal did not convict him of genocide on this charge. It found him guilty of substantially contributing to the offense of extermination, a crime against humanity, as the superior of the men who carried it out, and it sentenced him to death. In its findings on this charge it held that Al-Badr was the criminal organization behind the crimes and that Nizami, as its ex-officio commander, had effective control over its members. The Appellate Division upheld the conviction and the death sentence.
When the Pakistani army surrendered on December 16, 1971, Nizami dropped out of sight. Accounts of the next years differ: one has him in hiding until 1975, another in the United Kingdom with Ghulam Azam, then the leader of Jamaat-e-Islami. After the assassination of Sheikh Mujibur Rahman in 1975 and the lifting of the ban on Jamaat under the government of Ziaur Rahman, he came back into public life. By 1978 he led the party's Dhaka city unit and sat on its central executive committee.
His rise through the party was steady. He was assistant secretary general from 1983 to 1988 and secretary general from December 1988. In 1991 he was elected to parliament for Pabna-1 and led Jamaat's members in the house until December 28, 1994. In 2000, when Ghulam Azam gave up the party post, Nizami succeeded him as ameer, the head of Jamaat-e-Islami. He took the party into an alliance with the Bangladesh Nationalist Party, and when that alliance won the 2001 election, Jamaat held government office for the first time. Nizami, elected again for Pabna-1, became minister of agriculture in October 2001 and minister of industries in May 2003, a post he held until the government left office in October 2006.
The government led by Sheikh Hasina set up the International Crimes Tribunal on March 25, 2010 to try crimes committed in 1971. Three months later, on June 29, 2010, Nizami was arrested in an unrelated case over hurting religious sentiments. A complaint against him was registered on July 21, 2010, and on August 2, 2010 he was shown arrested in the war crimes case. He remained in custody from then until his execution.
The prosecution submitted its formal charge on December 11, 2011. While the war crimes case was being built, a separate prosecution in Chittagong went ahead over a large smuggling seizure made there in 2004, and on January 30, 2014 a special tribunal in Chittagong sentenced Nizami to death in that case. He was still waiting for the war crimes verdict when it was handed down.
On May 28, 2012, International Crimes Tribunal-1 framed sixteen charges against him under the International Crimes (Tribunals) Act, 1973, and he pleaded not guilty. The charges ranged from crimes against humanity, including murder, extermination, torture, rape and persecution, to genocide and conspiracy.
His defense was that the prosecution had no direct evidence, that nothing proved a common plan or any command over Al-Badr, and that a student leader had no power to punish anyone.
The tribunal delivered its judgment on October 29, 2014. It found him guilty on eight charges: 1, 2, 3, 4, 6, 7, 8 and 16. Charge 1 concerned the arrest, detention and killing of three people in and around Pabna town in June 1971. Charge 3 concerned torture, murder and rape at a center in the Mohammadpur area of Dhaka that the Pakistani army had turned into a place of detention, and the tribunal found that he had conspired in and substantially contributed to those crimes as a regular visitor and planner. Charge 4 concerned killings and rapes in the village of Karamja in April and May 1971. The other five convictions are described above.
He was acquitted on the remaining eight. On charge 5, which concerned 21 civilians in two villages of Ishwardi, the prosecution produced no evidence at all. Charges 9 and 10, about Brishalikha and a single family in Sonatola, failed on hearsay. Charges 11 to 14, about his speeches, failed because the speeches did not amount to direct and public incitement. Charge 15, alleging a conspiracy at Santhia, failed for want of reliable evidence.
The tribunal sentenced him to death on charges 2, 4, 6 and 16 and to imprisonment for life on charges 1, 3, 7 and 8. As aggravating factors it listed his leadership of Al-Badr and the control he held over its members, his part as a fellow perpetrator in his subordinates' crimes, the vulnerability of the victims and the planned, large-scale killing of intellectuals, professionals and unarmed civilians. It found no mitigating factors. It ordered that if one death sentence was carried out, the others and the life terms would merge into it.
Nizami appealed to the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of Bangladesh, which gave its decision on January 6, 2016. The appeal was allowed in part. The court acquitted Nizami on charges 1, 3 and 4 for insufficient evidence, which set aside one of the four death sentences, the one for Karamja. It upheld the convictions and the death sentences on charges 2, 6 and 16, and the convictions and life terms on charges 7 and 8. The court held that no punishment short of death would be adequate, and it did not reduce the sentence on account of his age.
Nizami asked the Appellate Division to review its own judgment, and on May 5, 2016 the same bench dismissed the petition.
That left only the constitutional power of the president to pardon a condemned person. When the authorities asked Nizami whether he would seek mercy from President Abdul Hamid, he said no. He was executed in Dhaka on May 11, 2016, by the official account; one wire report, quoting a minister, placed the execution late on May 10.
Nizami denied to the end that he had any role in the killings of 1971. He accepted that he had led the student wing of Jamaat-e-Islami and had opposed independence, but he denied that he had led Al-Badr or had any link to it. His party maintained throughout that the charges were false and that the trials were a campaign to remove its leadership.
Doubts about the process were raised beyond the party: Amnesty International, which opposed the execution, said that it and the United Nations had raised serious questions about the fairness of the tribunal's trials that were never addressed, and other rights groups criticized the lack of international oversight.
The courts did not accept every charge. Eight of the sixteen failed at trial, among them the genocide charge concerning the Hindu residents of Brishalikha, and the Appellate Division set aside three more, including the death sentence for Karamja. The tribunal's finding that Nizami was the ex-officio chief of Al-Badr, rather than proof that he gave particular orders, carried the conviction on the intellectuals, and the convictions for the Pabna villages and the freedom fighters in Dhaka rested on his part in a common plan.
March 31, 1943: Born in Monmothpur, Santhia, Pabna.
1963: Takes a Kamil degree at the Madrasa-e-Alia, Dhaka.
1966: Becomes president of Islami Chhatra Sangha.
April 22, 1971: The Pakistani army enters Jamalpur, where Al-Badr is first formed.
May 14, 1971: About 450 civilians killed in Baushgari, Ruposhi and Demra (charge 2).
August 30, 1971: Freedom fighters held in Dhaka are killed (charge 8).
November 27, 1971: The raid on Dhulaura begins (charge 6).
December 3, 1971: The victim of charge 7 is taken in Brishalikha.
December 14, 1971: The intellectuals and professionals of Dhaka are killed on or around this date (charge 16).
December 16, 1971: The Pakistani army surrenders in Dhaka.
1991: Elected to parliament for Pabna-1.
2000: Becomes ameer of Jamaat-e-Islami.
October 2001: Becomes minister of agriculture.
May 2003: Becomes minister of industries, serving until October 2006.
March 25, 2010: The International Crimes Tribunal is established.
June 29, 2010: Arrested in a case over hurting religious sentiments.
August 2, 2010: Shown arrested in the 1971 crimes case.
December 11, 2011: Formal charge submitted.
May 28, 2012: Sixteen charges framed; trial begins.
January 30, 2014: Sentenced to death by a Chittagong special tribunal in a separate smuggling case.
October 29, 2014: Convicted on eight charges; sentenced to death on four and to life on four.
November 23, 2014: Files his appeal.
January 6, 2016: The Appellate Division upholds death on charges 2, 6 and 16 and acquits him on three charges.
May 5, 2016: Review petition dismissed.
May 11, 2016: Executed in Dhaka.