Momcilo Krajisnik was the most senior Bosnian Serb politician after Radovan Karadzic during the 1992 to 1995 war in Bosnia and Herzegovina. As president of the Bosnian Serb Assembly, and as a regular participant in the wartime presidency that ran the self-declared Bosnian Serb Republic, he helped build the party and state machinery through which, the Yugoslav tribunal in The Hague later found, Bosnian Muslims and Bosnian Croats were driven from large areas of the country in 1992. Peacekeepers arrested him in April 2000. Six years later a trial chamber convicted him of persecution, extermination, murder, deportation and forced transfer as crimes against humanity, acquitted him of genocide and complicity in genocide, and sentenced him to 27 years.
The judgment did not survive appeal intact. In March 2009 the Appeals Chamber reversed the murder and extermination convictions in their entirety, finding that the trial judges had never established when those crimes became part of the shared plan they attributed to him. What remained were convictions for deportation, forcible transfer and persecution based on those acts, committed against several thousand civilians in nine municipalities between April and December 1992, and a sentence of 20 years. He served the balance in Britain, was released early in August 2013, and died in Banja Luka in September 2020.
Krajisnik was born on January 20, 1945, in Zabrđe, in the Novi Grad municipality of Sarajevo. He studied economics and worked as an economist for several Sarajevo companies, among them Energoinvest, then the largest company in Bosnia, where he rose to an executive post. He met Radovan Karadzic, the psychiatrist who would lead the Bosnian Serbs through the war, in 1983. The two became close associates, and the trial chamber later described them as the core of the Bosnian Serb leadership.
He came to politics late, and quickly. On July 12, 1990, he joined the Serbian Democratic Party, the SDS, which he and Karadzic had helped found as the party of Bosnia's Serbs. Bosnia and Herzegovina held its first multiparty elections on November 18, 1990. The three national parties, the SDS, the Croatian Democratic Union and the Party of Democratic Action, the main party of the Bosnian Muslims, won most of the seats and divided posts in government and public institutions among themselves by quota. Krajisnik became a deputy in the republic's assembly that year, and on December 20, 1990, he became its president.
The power-sharing arrangement did not hold. Mistrust between the three communities grew through 1991, and each side began to organize armed groups. On October 15, 1991, the Bosnia and Herzegovina Assembly passed a resolution on the sovereignty of the republic over the strong opposition of its Serb deputies. Ten days later the SDS formed a separate Bosnian Serb Assembly, with Krajisnik as its president, and the new assembly began creating government structures that ran parallel to those of the republic.
The new assembly adopted a constitution for a Bosnian Serb Republic on February 28, 1992. It had 82 deputies, most of them SDS members, and Krajisnik presided over its sessions. On March 27, 1992, the assembly created a National Security Council, chaired by Karadzic, on which Krajisnik sat by virtue of his office. The council met jointly with the Bosnian Serb government to take military, political and administrative decisions, and it sent instructions to local Territorial Defense units and municipal authorities.
On May 12, 1992, the assembly replaced the council with a three-member presidency of Karadzic, Nikola Koljevic and Biljana Plavsic, and on the same day it established the Bosnian Serb Army, the VRS, under General Ratko Mladic. Krajisnik was never formally a member of the presidency. The trial chamber found, however, that he attended all but possibly one of its sessions between May and December 1992, that he was responsible for the economy and later for coordinating the war commissioners the presidency sent to run municipalities, and that the other members treated him as one of them. In practice, the judges held, the presidency had five members from its first day. It held more power than the constitution gave it: the interior and justice ministers took their instructions from it, and Mladic consulted it regularly on military matters.
The chamber also examined what Krajisnik allowed and said in the assembly he chaired. Transcripts of its sessions showed that during the indictment period he never once rebuked a deputy for insults aimed at other national groups, and that on occasion he used that kind of language himself. His authority as speaker, the judges found, made it easy for him to spread views on ethnic separation.
International recognition of Bosnia and Herzegovina's independence in early April 1992 was followed by the seizure of power in municipality after municipality by Bosnian Serb forces. The trial chamber found that from March 18, 1992, there was an attack directed against the Bosnian Muslim and Bosnian Croat civilian population of the 35 municipalities named in the indictment. It began with curfews, checkpoints at which members of those groups were stopped as a matter of routine, and dismissals from work. From April, Serb forces moved against towns, villages and hamlets, most of them undefended and holding no military target. Men were taken to detention centers. Women and children were driven out of their houses and either detained or forced out of the municipality. Their property was looted, destroyed or taken over by Serb authorities, and mosques, churches and other monuments of importance to the two communities were destroyed.
On the whole of that record the chamber held that, as crimes against humanity, murder had been committed in 28 of the municipalities, extermination in 14, deportation in 17, forced transfer in 25, and persecution in all 35.
The chamber used Zvornik, a municipality with a Muslim majority on the Drina, to illustrate the pattern. Serb forces took over the town in April 1992 and then emptied the surrounding villages. In late May, between 400 and 500 Muslims from the village of Divič, among them women, children and elderly people, were put on buses and expelled. In June the villagers of Kozluk were made to sign over their property, and a convoy organized by Serb forces carried about 1,800 people out of the municipality. By early June, Serbs were moving into villages whose Muslim residents had been expelled. Zvornik became one of the three municipalities where the deportation conviction survived the appeal.
The trial chamber treated joint criminal enterprise as the form of liability best suited to the facts and did not go on to rule on the others charged. It found that such an enterprise existed throughout the territory of the Bosnian Serb Republic. Its core was a leadership group in Pale, the Bosnian Serb capital in the hills above Sarajevo, that included Krajisnik, Karadzic and other leaders; its rank and file worked in the regions and municipalities and kept close ties with Pale.
The common objective, in the chamber's words, was to ethnically recompose the territories targeted by the Bosnian Serb leadership by drastically reducing the proportion of Bosnian Muslims and Bosnian Croats through expulsion. Deportation and forced transfer were the original crimes of that objective. The chamber found that Krajisnik gave the go-ahead for the expulsion program at a session of the Bosnian Serb Assembly, when he called on the deputies to put into effect on the ground the ethnic division that had been agreed. In the trial judges' view the means soon widened to include other forms of persecution, murder and extermination.
His contribution, the chamber held, was to help establish and keep in place the SDS party and state structures through which the crimes were committed, and to use his political skills at home and abroad to advance the objective. He knew of and intended the mass detention and expulsion of civilians, had the power to intervene, and showed no concern for the people detained and expelled. He was never found to have carried out or ordered any crime himself; his guilt rested on his part in the shared plan, a doctrine his lawyers later challenged on appeal without success.
Krajisnik stayed at the center of Bosnian Serb politics for the rest of the war and was among the Bosnian Serb leaders at the Dayton peace talks in November 1995. In September 1996, in the first elections after the war, he was elected the Serb member of Bosnia and Herzegovina's three-member collective presidency, and he held the seat until 1998.
The tribunal's indictment against him was confirmed under seal in February 2000. On April 3, 2000, SFOR, the NATO-led stabilization force in Bosnia, detained him in Pale, and he was transferred to the United Nations Detention Unit in The Hague the same day. He was the most senior political figure the tribunal had yet taken into custody. At his initial appearance on April 7, 2000, he pleaded not guilty to all counts.
In 2001 the tribunal joined his case with that of Biljana Plavsic, the former member of the wartime presidency and later president of the Republika Srpska. The consolidated indictment charged that between July 1, 1991, and December 30, 1992, the two of them, with Karadzic, Mladic and others, took part in a joint criminal enterprise to persecute the Bosnian Muslim, Bosnian Croat and other non-Serb populations of 37 municipalities. Krajisnik was charged both as a participant in that enterprise and as a superior who failed to prevent or punish crimes by those under him, on eight counts: genocide, complicity in genocide, five crimes against humanity (persecution on political, racial and religious grounds, extermination, murder, deportation and inhumane acts) and murder as a violation of the laws or customs of war. Plavsic pleaded guilty in October 2002 to one count of persecution as a crime against humanity and was sentenced to 11 years. Krajisnik was tried alone.
His trial opened on February 3, 2004, before Trial Chamber I and ran for 314 trial days. The prosecution dropped two municipalities for lack of evidence, leaving 35. Krajisnik testified in his own defense, and after both sides had rested the chamber called six witnesses of its own, Plavsic among them.
The chamber delivered its judgment on September 27, 2006. Krajisnik was found not guilty of genocide and complicity in genocide. The judges accepted that acts amounting to the physical elements of genocide had taken place in the municipalities, but found the evidence insufficient to show that the perpetrators intended to destroy the Bosnian Muslim or Bosnian Croat group as such, and found no evidence that genocide had ever formed part of the enterprise's objective or that Krajisnik had the specific intent the crime requires. He was also acquitted of murder as a violation of the laws or customs of war, because the chamber had already classified every killing as murder or extermination under the crimes against humanity article.
He was convicted on five counts: persecution, extermination, murder and deportation as crimes against humanity, and forced transfer as an inhumane act and a crime against humanity. On sentence, the chamber found that the crimes had inflicted immense suffering and had profound consequences for the Muslim and Croat communities of Bosnia and Herzegovina, and that his positions had given him the authority to enable the military, police and paramilitary groups to carry out the enterprise's objective. It gave very slight weight in mitigation to his lack of prior convictions, his good conduct in detention, the long wait before his trial and his limited efforts during the war to help individual non-Serbs, and imposed a single sentence of 27 years, with credit for the time served since his arrest.
Both sides appealed, the prosecution seeking a life term. In May 2007 the Appeals Chamber allowed Krajisnik to represent himself and appointed an amicus curiae, an outside lawyer, to argue points on his behalf. At the appeal hearing in August 2008 he denied knowing of the crimes committed against Muslims and Croats in 1992, described his wartime role as that of a speaker and negotiator, denied that he had ever been a member of the presidency in law or in fact, and asked to be acquitted. Karadzic, arrested in July 2008 after more than a decade as a fugitive, appeared at an evidentiary hearing that November as a defense witness, called to show that Krajisnik had not been a senior decision-maker.
The Appeals Chamber gave judgment on March 17, 2009. It rejected the claim that the trial had been unfair, though it noted that aspects of its conduct had not been free from defects and may have created an appearance of unfairness. It rejected Krajisnik's argument that he and his colleagues had merely carried out lawful duties under the constitution, and it held that political speeches can, as a matter of law, be a contribution to a criminal enterprise. Karadzic's evidence, it found, was not enough to undermine the extensive evidence of Krajisnik's place in the leadership.
On the central question the appeal judges sided with the amicus curiae. The trial chamber had found that Krajisnik shared the intent to commit deportation, forcible transfer and persecution based on those acts from the start, and that finding stood. But it had made only scarce findings, if any, on when murder, extermination and the other forms of persecution became part of the common plan, and on what basis they could be laid at his door. Neither an appeal court nor an accused, the judges said, could be required to speculate about so central an element. They reversed the murder and extermination convictions in their entirety and the persecution conviction except where it rested on deportation and forcible transfer.
The cuts went further. The trial judges had often failed to link the men who carried out the expulsions to members of the enterprise, so the appeal judges kept only the expulsions for which that link had been found: deportation and forcible transfer in Bijeljina, Bratunac, Zvornik, Bosanska Krupa, Sanski Most, Trnovo, Sokolac, Banja Luka and Prnjavor. For three of those municipalities, Bijeljina, Bratunac and Sanski Most, the deportation findings also fell, because the trial chamber had not established that the people expelled were forced across a border. Deportation was upheld for Zvornik, Banja Luka and Prnjavor, where civilians were driven across state borders.
The Appeals Chamber declined to order a retrial, concluding that it was not in the interests of justice where convictions for persecution, deportation and forcible transfer survived and their gravity required a severe and proportionate sentence. It dismissed the prosecution's appeal for a life term and sentenced Krajisnik to 20 years, with credit for the time he had spent in custody since April 3, 2000.
On September 7, 2009, he was transferred to the United Kingdom to serve his sentence. He was held first in high-security conditions and from November 2011 in a lower-security Category C prison in Wales. Decisions on early release for tribunal prisoners belonged to the tribunal's president, whose practice was to consider release only after two-thirds of a sentence had been served. Krajisnik's applications were refused in July 2010, July 2011 and November 2012. In the last of those decisions the president accepted prison reports of exemplary behavior and a low risk of reoffending, but found that his crimes had caused widespread displacement of the non-Serb population and great suffering, and that he had not yet reached the two-thirds point. The tribunal also rejected his claim that he had given the prosecution substantial help before his arrest.
On July 2, 2013, the president granted early release, citing prison reports that described him as a model prisoner and finding that his good behavior showed some rehabilitation. Because two-thirds of his sentence would not be served until about August 3, 2013, release was ordered after that date. It took effect on August 30, 2013, and he flew home to Bosnia the same day.
Momcilo Krajisnik died in Banja Luka on September 15, 2020.
The tribunal never found Krajisnik guilty of genocide or of any killing that stands today. The trial chamber acquitted him of genocide and complicity in genocide, and the Appeals Chamber reversed his convictions for murder and extermination without ordering a retrial. The trial chamber's findings that killings, extermination and other persecution took place in the municipalities were not overturned; what fell was the finding that he was criminally responsible for them.
Krajisnik himself denied knowing of the crimes and denied membership of the presidency. Both claims were rejected at trial and on appeal. His later letters to the tribunal accepted the forcible transfer judgment while maintaining that he was seeking its review; no review judgment in his favor followed. His assertion that he had helped the prosecution before his arrest was rejected in three early release decisions.
January 20, 1945: Born in Zabrđe, Novi Grad municipality, Sarajevo.
1983: Meets Radovan Karadzic.
July 12, 1990: Joins the Serbian Democratic Party (SDS).
December 20, 1990: Becomes president of the Bosnia and Herzegovina Assembly.
October 25, 1991: Becomes president of the newly formed Bosnian Serb Assembly.
February 28, 1992: The Bosnian Serb Assembly adopts a constitution for a Bosnian Serb Republic.
May 12, 1992: A three-member presidency and the Bosnian Serb Army are created; he attends nearly every presidency session through December.
April to December 1992: Deportations and forcible transfers in the nine municipalities of the final conviction.
November 1995: Among the Bosnian Serb leaders at the Dayton peace talks.
September 1996: Elected Serb member of the presidency of Bosnia and Herzegovina; serves until 1998.
April 3, 2000: Detained in Pale by SFOR and transferred to The Hague.
April 7, 2000: Pleads not guilty to all charges.
February 3, 2004: Trial opens.
September 27, 2006: Convicted of five crimes against humanity; acquitted of genocide, complicity in genocide and murder as a war crime; sentenced to 27 years.
March 17, 2009: Murder and extermination convictions reversed; persecution, deportation and forcible transfer upheld in part; sentence cut to 20 years.
September 7, 2009: Transferred to the United Kingdom.
July 2, 2013: Early release granted.
August 30, 2013: Released.
September 15, 2020: Dies in Banja Luka.