Mohammed Saeed Alshamrani was a 21-year-old second lieutenant in the Royal Saudi Air Force who had come to the United States to learn to fly with the U.S. Navy. On Friday, December 6, 2019, federal investigators found, he carried out an attack at Naval Air Station Pensacola, Florida, the base where he was training. Three American sailors died and eight other people were injured, two of them Escambia County sheriff's deputies. Deputies killed Alshamrani at the base that morning. He was never charged with any crime and never stood trial, because he did not survive the day.
What is known of his responsibility comes from the investigators who reconstructed it. On January 13, 2020, the Attorney General of the United States announced that the attack was an act of terrorism, motivated by jihadist ideology, and that Alshamrani had acted alone. Four months later, on May 18, 2020, the Attorney General and the Director of the FBI went further. Evidence the bureau had recovered, they said, showed that Alshamrani had been radicalized as early as 2015, before he ever came to the United States, and that he had been in contact with al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula, the Yemen-based branch of al-Qaeda, in the period before the attack. A Navy investigation released in November 2020 agreed that his self-radicalization was the primary cause, while reaching a different conclusion about when his intent had formed. No court ever weighed any of it.
Alshamrani was one of hundreds of members of foreign militaries training at Pensacola, where the Navy routinely instructs officers from allied countries. He was there under a training program sponsored by the Pentagon as part of a security cooperation arrangement with Saudi Arabia. When the attack came, more than 850 Saudis were in the United States for military training, and more than 5,000 students from 153 countries were in American military training programs of one kind or another.
His own program began in August 2017 and was scheduled to run until August 2020. It took him through English-language training, basic aviation instruction and initial pilot training. FBI officials later placed the start of his time on American bases in 2017, about two years after the point at which, by their account, his radicalization had begun. He spent his last 18 months in Florida at Naval Air Station Pensacola, and in that time he reported to five separate commands. The Navy's investigators later found that the constant handoffs limited what any one commander knew about him and kept information about him isolated within each command.
The Navy's investigation found one documented point of friction in his training. In April 2019 a contracted instructor gave Alshamrani a derogatory nickname, and Alshamrani filed a formal equal opportunity complaint against him. The instructor received a corrective action memo and apologized, but the matter took almost 40 days to resolve, and Alshamrani considered the apology inadequate. At a face-to-face meeting in May 2019 he refused it. At a later meeting he began a remark about wanting something to happen to the instructor; witnesses believed he was about to make a threat, but he did not finish the sentence. The offices that should have been told of his complaint were never notified.
The same investigation described a poor climate for every student at the Naval Aviation Schools Command. Personnel in its international military training office subjected foreign students to derogatory and sometimes abusive comments and to humiliating public reprimands, and the military and civilian leaders who knew of the complaints did not step in. The country liaison officer responsible for discipline among the Saudi students left in September 2019, and the post was not filled again until January 2020. The Navy's investigators recorded a marked decline in the Saudi students' military discipline in the months between.
The three men who died were all students at the Naval Aviation Schools Command, each at the start of a career in naval aviation.
Ensign Joshua Kaleb Watson came from Enterprise, Alabama. He had graduated from the U.S. Naval Academy in May 2019, where he spent four years on one of the academy's varsity teams and captained it in his final year. Becoming a Navy pilot had been his ambition for a long time, and he had reported to Pensacola for flight training only two weeks before the attack.
Airman Mohammed Sameh Haitham came from St. Petersburg, Florida. He had been a standout track and field athlete in high school and joined the Navy after graduating. He finished recruit training in September 2019 with the Navy Basic Military Training Honor Graduate Ribbon, and he was in flight crew training at Pensacola, due to graduate later in December. He had been looking forward to receiving his flight jacket at Christmas.
Airman Apprentice Cameron Scott Walters came from Richmond Hill, Georgia, outside Savannah. He joined the Navy in September 2019, went through boot camp at Great Lakes, Illinois, and graduated from recruit training in November, only weeks before he arrived in Florida. Friends remembered a young man who was rarely without a smile, who made friends quickly, even with strangers, and who was intensely loyal to the people he cared about. Christmas was his favorite time of year, and the holiday would have been his first trip home since he enlisted.
The attack took place on the morning of Friday, December 6, 2019, inside the Navy's training complex at Pensacola. Two Escambia County sheriff's deputies responded, and Alshamrani died at the hands of the deputies. Three sailors were dead and eight more people were injured, among them both deputies, who were expected to recover. Four people had died in all, counting Alshamrani. The base was closed to all but mission-essential personnel through the weekend.
The FBI's Jacksonville field office took the lead. By Sunday, December 8, about 80 FBI special agents were at work, alongside investigators from the Navy and other federal agencies, and the bureau announced that it was proceeding on the presumption that the attack was an act of terrorism. Investigators assessed that one man had carried it out. No one had been arrested, and every international student on the base had been accounted for.
The Saudi students who knew Alshamrani were cooperating with investigators. Their Saudi commanding officer ordered them to remain together at one location on the base, and by Saturday, December 7, ten Saudi students were being held on the base for questioning. U.S. officials sought the help of Saudi authorities in piecing together who Alshamrani was and why he had acted, and the Saudi government pledged full cooperation. The Navy halted training for about 300 Saudi aviation students at three Florida bases.
On January 13, 2020, the Attorney General announced the results of the investigation so far. The attack, he said, was an act of terrorism, motivated by jihadist ideology. Alshamrani had acted alone. The early reports that fellow Saudi cadets had arrived at the training complex with him and filmed the attack were not accurate; he had arrived by himself. Investigators had found no evidence that any of his friends or fellow trainees from Saudi Arabia knew in advance what he intended.
The inquiry had, however, turned up what the Justice Department called derogatory material on 21 Saudi military trainees in the United States, none of whom was accused of advance knowledge of the attack. Saudi Arabia concluded that the material showed conduct unbecoming an officer, and all 21 were removed from training and sent home. The kingdom agreed to review each of them for military discipline and to return any of them the United States decided should face charges.
Some months after the attack, the group al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula released a video claiming it. On May 18, 2020, the Attorney General and the FBI Director announced what the bureau had since established. Evidence it had recovered showed that Alshamrani's ties to the group went beyond inspiration. He had been radicalized overseas by 2015, the officials said, and had joined the Royal Saudi Air Force in order to carry out what they called a "special operation." In the months before the attack he had been in contact with the group's operatives, coordinating with them and giving them the opportunity to take credit for it. The officials stopped short of saying the group had directed the attack.
In November 2020 the Navy released its own investigation of the attack, a report of more than 260 pages led by the commander of Naval Air Force Atlantic. It named Alshamrani's self-radicalization as the primary cause. It found that his own behavior, together with the organization of the aviation training pipeline, had likely increased the probability of an insider attack. Military leaders, government and contract employees, fellow students and civilians had each known of isolated events and indicators, but no one had the full picture before December 6, and the investigators could not conclude that any single person should have recognized him as a threat under the policies then in place.
The report also found that the Naval Aviation Schools Command had failed to take responsibility for the security of its own facilities, and that mental health screening was required of international military students neither in their home countries nor in the United States.
The federal investigators and the Navy's investigators disagreed about when Alshamrani's intent took shape. The FBI and the Attorney General said in May 2020 that he had been radicalized by 2015 and had joined the Saudi air force for the purpose of an attack. The Navy's report found that he had not come to the United States for terrorist reasons, judging from his time in the country and the many earlier opportunities he had to act.
The early accounts that other Saudi trainees accompanied him and recorded the attack were rejected by the Attorney General in January 2020. No finding has been published that al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula directed the attack, as opposed to coordinating with Alshamrani and claiming it afterward.
August 2017: Alshamrani begins a U.S. military training program running to August 2020, starting with English-language training.
2017: FBI officials place the start of his training on U.S. bases in this year.
April 2019: He files an equal opportunity complaint against a contracted instructor at Pensacola.
May 2019: He refuses the instructor's apology at a face-to-face meeting.
September 2019: The Saudi students' country liaison officer leaves Pensacola; the post stays empty until January 2020.
December 6, 2019: Attack at Naval Air Station Pensacola, Florida; three sailors die and eight people are injured; Escambia County sheriff's deputies kill Alshamrani.
December 8, 2019: The FBI says it is proceeding on the presumption of terrorism and that one man carried out the attack.
January 13, 2020: The Attorney General declares the attack an act of terrorism and announces that 21 Saudi trainees are being sent home.
May 18, 2020: The Attorney General and FBI Director announce Alshamrani's links to al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula.
November 2020: The Navy releases its investigation, naming his self-radicalization as the primary cause.