Mohammed Saleem

Victims
1 daughter murdered in Sarezzo, Italy, 2006. Convicted of aggravated murder in Brescia, 2007; 30 years, upheld on appeal 2008 and by the Court of Cassation 2010
Years active
August 11, 2006
Location
Sarezzo (Ponte Zanano district), province of Brescia, Lombardy, Italy (killing); Brescia, Italy (trial and appeal); Rome, Italy (Court of Cassation)
Method
Stabbing (as reported in wire coverage of the arrest and trial)
Status
30 years (November 13, 2007), upheld on appeal (December 5, 2008) and by the Court of Cassation (February 18, 2010). Imprisoned in Italy as of November 2018.

On August 11, 2006, in Sarezzo, a small town in the Trompia valley north of Brescia, Mohammed Saleem killed his daughter, Hina Saleem. She had lived in Italy for several years, spoke Italian well and had made her own life: she had refused the marriage her family arranged for her and had moved in with an Italian partner she had chosen herself. Her father, a Pakistani immigrant legally resident in Italy since 1989, worked in a factory and also ran a kebab stand. He was arrested within days. In November 2007 a judge in Brescia convicted him of murder with aggravating circumstances and sentenced him to 30 years in prison. Two of his sons-in-law were convicted with him, and an uncle of the young woman was convicted of a lesser offense connected with her death.

The case went all the way to Italy's Court of Cassation, which in February 2010 made the father's sentence final.

The Carabinieri of Gardone Val Trompia and the Brescia prosecutor's office investigated her death as murder. The father was in custody by August 15, 2006. When he was first questioned he told police that he had killed his daughter. After that he stopped talking, and in formal interrogations he refused to repeat what he had said or to answer questions. The uncle was questioned at the same time and taken into custody with him.

The inquiry widened over the next ten days. Investigators set out to establish whether the killing had been planned, and in the course of that work the father's two sons-in-law came under suspicion. One of them surrendered to the authorities in the last week of August. By the end of the month four men faced charges: the father, the uncle and the two sons-in-law, all accused of premeditated murder and of a further offense connected with the death.

All four chose the abbreviated procedure, the rito abbreviato, under which the judge of the preliminary hearing decides the case on the evidence already gathered in the investigation file, and under which a life term is replaced by 30 years. The case therefore came not before a jury court but before a single judge in the Palace of Justice in Brescia, where the hearing opened on June 28, 2007, and the young woman's partner was admitted as a civil party. In October the prosecution asked for 30 years for the father and for each son-in-law, and two years for the uncle on the lesser charge alone. The charge against the three main defendants carried two aggravating circumstances, premeditation and futile motives.

On Tuesday, November 13, 2007, the judge gave her decision. She convicted Mohammed Saleem of the murder of his daughter and sentenced him to 30 years in prison, the most the procedure allowed. She convicted the two sons-in-law of the murder and gave each of them 30 years as well. The uncle was convicted of the lesser offense and sentenced to two years and eight months.

The appeal was decided on Friday, December 5, 2008. The appeal court upheld the father's 30 years in full. It reduced the terms of the two sons-in-law to 17 years each, though they remained convicted of the murder, and the uncle's sentence stood.

The father then took his case to the Court of Cassation in Rome, Italy's highest court on points of law, and the sons-in-law challenged their convictions too. The First Criminal Section decided the appeals in judgment no. 6587, filed on February 18, 2010, and dismissed them. The father's 30 years and the 17-year terms became final.

The judgment did more than confirm the sentences. It found that the father had acted out of "a pathological and distorted relationship of parental possession" toward his daughter, a young woman who did not accept his wishes, claimed her own autonomy and had departed from the customs of the family. On that basis it confirmed that the motive was abject, which in Italian law is an aggravating circumstance of murder. It held, too, that the aggravation for abuse of a family relationship and the separate aggravation for killing a descendant could apply together, because they rest on different grounds. It rejected the father's request for mitigating circumstances.

The court also refused to strip the young woman's partner of his award of moral damages. Their life together, it found, had been a stable cohabitation of some length, visible to the outside world, in which they had shared their lives and he had supported her both materially and morally. That was enough to make him one of the people who had lost her.

The convictions have been final since February 2010. In August 2016, ten years after the killing, the father was serving his sentence in an Italian prison, and in November 2018 he was still in custody in Lombardy.

The original charge was premeditated murder, and whether the killing was planned was the point the father's defense contested at trial: it argued that he had acted suddenly after a quarrel. The trial judge, the appeal court and the Court of Cassation all upheld his conviction and his 30-year term. His first statement to police, in which he said he had killed his daughter, was followed by silence in every formal interrogation; his guilt rests on the findings of the courts at three levels of jurisdiction.

Timeline

1989: Mohammed Saleem becomes a legal resident of Italy.

August 11, 2006: His daughter is killed in Sarezzo, province of Brescia.

By August 15, 2006: He is in custody; he first tells police he killed her, then stops answering questions.

Late August 2006: A son-in-law surrenders; four men are charged with premeditated murder and a further offense.

June 28, 2007: The preliminary hearing under the abbreviated procedure opens in Brescia.

November 13, 2007: The father and the two sons-in-law are convicted of murder and sentenced to 30 years each; the uncle receives two years and eight months.

December 5, 2008: On appeal, the father's 30 years is upheld; the sons-in-law's terms are cut to 17 years.

February 18, 2010: The Court of Cassation, First Criminal Section, judgment no. 6587, makes the sentences final and confirms the abject motive.

August 2016: He is serving his sentence in an Italian prison.

November 2018: He remains in custody in Lombardy.