Mohammed Salameh

Victims
6 people killed in the 1993 World Trade Center attack. Convicted on all counts (conspiracy and federal destruction offenses), March 4, 1994.
Years active
February 26, 1993
Location
Manhattan, New York, New York (killings at the World Trade Center); Jersey City, New Jersey (residence and arrest); Manhattan, New York, New York (trial); Colorado (prison)
Method
Bombing (explosives in a rented van; court record).
Status
240 years (May 24, 1994), vacated 1998; 1,403 months on resentencing, affirmed as modified 2001; cut again in 2020 or 2021. In federal custody, Colorado, as of 2021.

On February 26, 1993, an attack at the World Trade Center in lower Manhattan killed six people and injured more than a thousand others. Mohammed A. Salameh, a young Palestinian man living in Jersey City, New Jersey, had rented the van used in the attack. Within a week FBI agents had traced the vehicle to him, and on March 4, 1993, they arrested him when he went back to the rental agency to collect his deposit. A year later to the day, a federal jury in Manhattan found him and three co-defendants guilty on all counts. He was sentenced to 240 years in prison.

The case did not end with the verdict. The federal appeals court in New York upheld the convictions in 1998 but threw out every sentence, because the four men had not properly waived their right to a lawyer at the sentencing hearing. On resentencing in 1999 Salameh received 1,403 months, a term set to expire one month before his projected death, and the appeals court affirmed it in 2001. Two decades later a ruling of the U.S. Supreme Court led the courts to drop one part of his convictions and shorten the term again.

Little about Salameh's life before 1993 entered the court record. He was Palestinian, and he was 26 when he was sentenced in May 1994. By the winter of 1992 he was living in Jersey City, across the Hudson River from lower Manhattan. When Ramzi Yousef, the man the government later identified as the plot's chief organizer, arrived in the New York area, Salameh took him in. Within the group Yousef went by the name "Rashed."

Salameh's part in the conspiracy, as the government proved it and the appeals court later set it out, was largely practical. He and Nidal Ayyad opened a joint bank account that paid for the plot, and he rented a storage unit in Jersey City that investigators later tied to the conspiracy.

On February 23, 1993, three days before the attack, Salameh rented a van from a Ryder dealership in Jersey City. He used his own name. He then went to the Jersey City police and reported the van stolen, showing them papers that carried its true identification number. Accounts of when he made the report differ, from a full day before the attack, as his own appeal put it, to the afternoon of the attack itself.

The attack came on a Friday. It killed six people, injured more than a thousand and caused more than $500 million in damage to the complex. Investigators suspected terrorism within minutes. That evening Ramzi Yousef and Eyad Ismoil, a second man later convicted in the case, left the United States on false passports.

John DiGiovanni was born in Brooklyn and lived in Valley Stream, on Long Island. People who knew him remembered him as meticulous, a man who cleaned his car with a toothbrush.

Robert Kirkpatrick lived in Suffern, New York. He was handy with carpentry, plumbing and locks.

Stephen Knapp was born on Staten Island and lived there all his life. He liked fishing from his boat, an afternoon at the racetrack or a ballgame, and time with family and friends, and he liked playing with his children and their friends.

William Macko, known as Bill, lived in Bayonne, New Jersey. He enjoyed fishing and cooking.

Wilfredo Mercado was born in Lima, Peru, and lived in East New York, Brooklyn.

Monica Rodriguez Smith was born in Manta, Ecuador, immigrated to the United States and lived in Seaford, on Long Island. Friends remembered her as outgoing and energetic, a natural mother figure to the people around her.

The FBI took charge of the inquiry. On February 28, two days after the attack, investigators recovered two fragments of a vehicle that carried an identification number. The FBI traced the number to the Ryder agency in Jersey City and learned the renter's name: Mohammed Salameh.

Salameh had already been back to the agency, asking for the $400 he had left as a deposit. By the time he called again, FBI agents were working with the agency's staff, and a time was set for him to come in. On March 4, 1993, he returned to the rental office for the money, and FBI agents arrested him there. The appeals court later noted that the arrest came the day before he planned to leave the country.

The arrest opened the rest of the case. A telephone number Salameh had given when he rented the van led agents to an address in Jersey City, and on March 5 they searched the storage unit he had rented. Nidal Ayyad was arrested on March 10, and Mahmud Abouhalima and Ahmad Mohammad Ajaj were taken into custody in the weeks that followed. A sixth man, interviewed and released in the first days of the inquiry, later left for Jordan; he was indicted and has never been brought to trial. Yousef and Ismoil were by then abroad.

On March 17, 1993, a federal grand jury in Manhattan indicted Salameh and Ayyad, and the case later grew to cover six defendants, two of them fugitives. Although the attack was plainly an act of terrorism, it was handled from the start as a criminal case, to be proved before a jury in an ordinary federal courtroom. No count charged murder. Salameh faced ten counts under federal law: conspiracy, the destruction offenses themselves, the assault of federal officers, and two counts that carry mandatory consecutive terms for conduct during a crime of violence.

The trial of the four men in custody opened on October 4, 1993, in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, and ran for about six months. The government's case against Salameh rested on paper and on people: the van lease in his own name, the storage unit, the joint bank account, the telephone number on the rental papers, and photographs of him found in his briefcase. A gas station attendant who had seen him picked him out of photo arrays and again in court. Before trial his lawyers had tried and failed to suppress the search of the storage unit.

In his summation Salameh did not deny that the attack had taken place as the government described it. His defense was that he had been an unwitting dupe of Ramzi Yousef. His lawyers pointed to conduct they said no knowing conspirator would have engaged in. He had used his true name on the lease. He had volunteered the names and telephone numbers of friends. He had shown the Jersey City police documents bearing the van's real identification number. The jury rejected the defense.

The jury returned its verdicts on March 4, 1994, a year to the day after Salameh's arrest. All four defendants were found guilty on every count against them, Salameh on all ten.

Before sentencing, all four men dismissed their trial lawyers. On May 24, 1994, the judge imposed the same term on each: 240 years in prison, without parole. He reached the figure by adding together the years of life lost by the six people killed, a total of 180 years, and then adding 30 years on each of the two counts that required consecutive terms.

On August 4, 1998, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit rejected nearly every claim the four men raised, among them Salameh's challenges to the storage unit search and to the eyewitness identification. It found the evidence sufficient against each man and affirmed all four convictions. The sentences were another matter. A defendant who gives up his lawyer must do so knowingly, intelligently and voluntarily, and the record of the May 1994 hearing did not show such a waiver by any of the four. The court vacated all four sentences and sent the case back to the same judge.

On resentencing in 1999 the judge again imposed the two consecutive 30-year terms, 720 months in all. On the other counts he found that the federal guideline for murder applied and called for life. Because the law in force at the time of the crime allowed a life term only if the jury directed it, and this jury had not, he set each man's term to run out one month before his projected death, using life expectancy for his year of birth and assuming the maximum credit for good conduct. Salameh's total came to 1,403 months. Each man was also ordered to pay a $250,000 fine and $250 million in restitution.

On August 6, 2001, the Second Circuit affirmed. It held that any error in the life-expectancy method was harmless, because the men had been exposed to a life term all along. With the parties' agreement, it modified the judgments so that the fines and restitution would fall due only if the defendants received income from accounts of the crime. As modified, the sentences stood.

Ramzi Yousef was captured in Pakistan on February 5, 1995, and returned to New York. He and Eyad Ismoil were convicted on all counts on November 12, 1997, and each was sentenced to about 240 years; the Second Circuit affirmed their convictions on April 4, 2003. Ayyad, Abouhalima and Ajaj shared every stage of Salameh's case, from the verdict of 1994 to the affirmance of 2001. The sixth man indicted in the case has never been captured.

Salameh went on litigating from federal custody. In 2019 a court ordered federal authorities to return $2,615 in United States currency and 32 dinars, money he said had been taken from him after his arrest, to his prison account. In February 2021 the money still had not reached him, and neither had the $400 deposit on the van.

By then the sentences of all four men had been cut again. In the year before February 2021, each won a reduction after one part of his convictions was dropped to bring the judgments into line with a recent ruling of the U.S. Supreme Court. Salameh, then 53, could be freed if he lived to 100. All four face deportation if they are ever released. As of 2021 he was held in federal custody in Colorado. All four of the 1994 defendants have maintained that they are innocent.

Salameh has never accepted the verdict. His account, that he was a dupe who did not know what Yousef intended, was put to the jury and rejected on every count, and the appeals court found the evidence sufficient against him. The conduct he offered as proof of innocence, above all the theft report he made to the Jersey City police before the attack, was read by the government the other way: as a false report meant to distance him from the van. The jury accepted the government's reading.

His later legal challenges shortened his sentence but have not disturbed the convictions.

Timeline

February 23, 1993: Salameh rents a Ryder van in Jersey City, New Jersey, in his own name.

February 26, 1993: The attack at the World Trade Center kills six people and injures more than a thousand; Yousef and Ismoil leave the United States that evening.

February 28, 1993: Investigators recover a vehicle identification number and trace it to the Jersey City rental agency.

March 4, 1993: FBI agents arrest Salameh at the rental agency in Jersey City.

March 5, 1993: Agents search the storage unit he rented.

March 10, 1993: Nidal Ayyad is arrested.

March 17, 1993: A federal grand jury in Manhattan indicts Salameh and Ayyad.

October 4, 1993: The trial of the four defendants in custody opens in Manhattan.

March 4, 1994: The jury convicts all four on all counts.

May 24, 1994: Each is sentenced to 240 years in prison.

February 5, 1995: Yousef is captured in Pakistan.

November 12, 1997: Yousef and Ismoil are convicted.

August 4, 1998: The Second Circuit affirms the convictions and vacates the sentences.

1999: Salameh is resentenced to 1,403 months.

August 6, 2001: The Second Circuit affirms the new sentences as modified.

April 4, 2003: The Second Circuit affirms the convictions of Yousef and Ismoil.

2019: A court orders money seized at his arrest returned to Salameh's prison account.

2020 to February 2021: His sentence is reduced after one part of his convictions is dropped.