On the morning of Thursday, July 16, 2015, Mohammad Youssef Abdulazeez, a 24-year-old engineering graduate from Hixson, Tennessee, attacked two military facilities in Chattanooga: an armed forces recruiting office and the Navy Operational Support Center, which housed Navy and Marine Corps reservists. Four Marines died that day. A Navy sailor died two days later. A Marine recruiter and a Chattanooga police officer survived their injuries. Abdulazeez was killed by Chattanooga police officers before the morning was over, and he was never charged with any crime arising from the attacks, let alone tried for them.
Within a week the FBI said it was treating him as a "homegrown violent extremist" who had acted alone. On December 16, 2015, five months to the day after the attacks, the Secretary of the Navy announced that the FBI and NCIS had "determined that this attack was inspired by a foreign terrorist group." That finding, rather than any verdict, is the nearest thing the case has to a legal conclusion. Everything said about his motive rests on the investigation of a man who died before any court could examine the evidence.
Abdulazeez was born in Kuwait, grew up in the United States and became a naturalized American citizen. By 2015 he lived in Hixson, a few miles across the river from Chattanooga.
He went to Red Bank High School in Chattanooga, where he wrestled. In 2009 he won a mixed martial arts bout at a fight night in the city.
He enrolled at the University of Tennessee at Chattanooga and graduated in 2012 with a degree in electrical engineering. A few years before the attacks he had an internship with the Tennessee Valley Authority. In late May 2013 he worked for about ten days as a conditional employee at the Perry Nuclear Power Plant in Ohio, never entered its secured areas and was let go for not meeting minimum requirements. In the months before July 2015 he worked for about three months at Superior Essex, a wire and cable manufacturer.
The most closely examined period of his life was a stay in Jordan. He spent several months there in 2014, staying with his maternal uncle and helping with the uncle's mobile telephone business. He also passed through Qatar, where, according to its government, he did no more than change planes at the airport.
In April 2015 he was arrested in the Chattanooga area on a first-offense charge of driving under the influence. The case was still open when he died. Apart from that charge he had no criminal record.
He was not on the radar of federal law enforcement. A check of national terrorism databases after the attacks found nothing on him, and the Pentagon held no recruiting or applicant records in his name.
The four Marines who died on July 16 were attached to the reserve center. The sailor was a member of its staff.
Gunnery Sergeant Thomas J. Sullivan grew up in Springfield, Massachusetts. He had served in the Marine Corps for nearly 18 years, including two tours in Iraq, and had already been awarded the Purple Heart twice. At the time of his death he was serving with India Battery, 3rd Battalion, 12th Marines, a unit of the 4th Marine Division.
Staff Sergeant David A. Wyatt finished high school in Russellville, Arkansas, and earned the rank of Eagle Scout there. He enlisted in the Marine Corps in 2004, and the Pentagon listed him as coming from Burke County, North Carolina. In more than eleven years as a Marine he deployed three times, twice to Iraq.
Sergeant Carson A. Holmquist grew up in Grantsburg, Wisconsin, and graduated from Grantsburg High School in 2008, where he played cornerback on the football team. He loved to hunt and fish. He enlisted in January 2009 and completed two deployments with Operation Enduring Freedom. After boot camp he came back to visit his old high school in his dress blues.
Lance Corporal Squire K. Wells, known to everyone as Skip, came from Marietta in Cobb County, Georgia, and graduated in 2012 from Sprayberry High School, where he played clarinet in the marching band and belonged to the JROTC program. He enlisted in the Marine Corps in February 2014. He loved American history and flag football, and he hoped one day to become a drill sergeant.
Petty Officer 2nd Class Randall Smith, a Navy logistics specialist, came from Paulding, Ohio. He was a pitcher good enough to earn a baseball scholarship to Defiance College, but a shoulder injury ended that path and he joined the Navy instead. He had been stationed in Norfolk, Virginia, before his transfer to Chattanooga, where he served on the staff of the Navy Operational Support Center. He died early on Saturday, July 18, 2015, two days after the attacks, the fifth service member to die.
Chattanooga police officers ended the attacks, and the FBI's senior agent in Knoxville said the next day that all indications were that their fire had killed Abdulazeez. The FBI took charge of the case from the first day, led by its Knoxville field office, and the Naval Criminal Investigative Service joined the inquiry.
The first findings were negative. The National Counterterrorism Center had seen nothing linking Abdulazeez to a terrorist organization, and federal officials found no evidence that he had been directed by the Islamic State or any other foreign group. He had no extensive online presence. Investigators interviewed his friends and acquaintances, then a wider circle of contacts, and set out to establish whom he had met during his months in Jordan, what he had done there, and whether he had gone or tried to go anywhere else.
That line of inquiry reached Jordan within a day. On Friday, July 17, Jordanian authorities took his maternal uncle into custody, and he and other relatives were questioned in close coordination with American investigators. The uncle was not charged.
On July 22 the FBI gave its most detailed briefing of the summer. The bureau was treating Abdulazeez as a homegrown violent extremist, it was too early to say whether he had been radicalized, and there was no indication anyone else had helped him on the day.
On December 16, 2015, the FBI announced that it had investigated Chattanooga as a foreign terrorism case from the beginning and had concluded that the attacks were inspired and motivated by foreign terrorist organization propaganda. It named no specific group. The same day, the Secretary of the Navy announced the joint FBI and NCIS determination that the attack was inspired by a foreign terrorist group.
The determination did not make Abdulazeez a convicted man. He had died before any charge. No grand jury considered the evidence, no court tested it and no defense was ever offered. The conclusion that he was inspired by foreign terrorist propaganda is the finding of two federal investigative agencies, announced by the officials who led them.
Abdulazeez never faced a charge, so every account of his intent remains unexamined by a court. The FBI's December conclusion named no group, and no public statement described any contact between him and one. In the summer of 2015 federal officials said repeatedly that they had found nothing tying him directly to the Islamic State or any other foreign organization.
The importance of his months in Jordan remains unsettled. American and Jordanian investigators questioned relatives there, and the one relative held in custody was not charged. No public finding has said what, if anything, happened during that visit that bore on the attacks.
Who ended the attacks was also a matter of early uncertainty, until the FBI said the next day that all indications pointed to the Chattanooga police.
2009: Wins a mixed martial arts bout in Chattanooga.
2012: Graduates from the University of Tennessee at Chattanooga with a degree in electrical engineering.
May 2013: Works about ten days at the Perry Nuclear Power Plant in Ohio before being let go.
2014: Spends several months in Jordan with his maternal uncle.
April 2015: Arrested on a first-offense charge of driving under the influence; the case is open when he dies.
July 16, 2015: Attacks a recruiting office and the Navy Operational Support Center in Chattanooga; four Marines die; he is killed by Chattanooga police officers.
July 17, 2015: Jordanian authorities take his maternal uncle into custody for questioning; the Marine Corps names the four dead Marines.
July 18, 2015: The Navy sailor wounded at the reserve center dies.
July 22, 2015: The FBI says it is treating him as a homegrown violent extremist who acted alone.
December 16, 2015: The FBI says the attacks were inspired and motivated by foreign terrorist organization propaganda; the Secretary of the Navy announces the FBI and NCIS determination that the attack was inspired by a foreign terrorist group.