Mohammad Sidique Khan

Victims
52 people unlawfully killed in the July 7, 2005 London attacks. Inquest verdicts, May 6, 2011; six of them at Edgware Road. Never tried
Years active
July 7, 2005
Location
Edgware Road, London, England, United Kingdom (killings, July 7, 2005); Leeds, West Yorkshire, England (birth); Dewsbury, West Yorkshire, England (residence)
Method
Bombing (explosions on the London transport network; inquest medical cause of each death: injuries caused by an explosion)
Status
Never tried; inquest verdicts of unlawful killing for all 52 (May 6, 2011); his own inquest not resumed. Died untried, by suicide in the attack at Edgware Road, London, July 7, 2005.

Mohammad Sidique Khan was the oldest of the four men who carried out coordinated attacks on London's public transport on the morning of Thursday, July 7, 2005. Fifty-two members of the public died. Khan, a 30-year-old former learning mentor at a primary school in Leeds, died in the attack at Edgware Road, in west London, where six of the 52 were killed. The other three men were Shehzad Tanweer, 22, Hasib Hussain, 18, and Jermaine Lindsay, 19. All four died that morning, and none of them ever faced a court.

The legal record of the case was settled not by a criminal trial but by inquests. Between October 2010 and March 2011 a senior judge, sitting without a jury as Assistant Deputy Coroner for Inner West London, heard five months of evidence at the Royal Courts of Justice. On May 6, 2011, she returned verdicts of unlawful killing in respect of each of the 52 people who died. In a separate report issued the same day she named Khan, Tanweer, Lindsay and Hussain as the four men responsible and described the evidence against them as overwhelming. She declined to resume the inquests into the deaths of the four men themselves.

Khan was the group's ringleader, with Tanweer as his second in command. Before the attacks he had crossed the paths of West Yorkshire Police and MI5 several times, most significantly in February and March 2004, when surveillance officers watched him meet members of a separate group then planning attacks in Britain. MI5 judged him a peripheral contact and never made him a target of surveillance. Whether that judgment was reasonable became the central question of two parliamentary reviews and of the inquests themselves.

Khan was born in Leeds on October 20, 1974, and grew up in Beeston, in south Leeds. He went to Matthew Murray school, which later became South Leeds High School. In 1997 he began studying at Leeds Metropolitan University, converting a business diploma into a degree, and in the same period he did youth mentoring work in the community. From March 2001 until December 2004 he worked as a learning mentor at Hillside Primary School in Beeston, earning about 17,000 pounds a year. He later lived in Batley and then Dewsbury, both in West Yorkshire.

His first entry in any official file was small. In 1993 a man named Sidique Khan was arrested by West Yorkshire Police for assault and given an official caution; a record was created and a photograph taken. It was a routine police matter with no national security element, and none of it was shared with MI5.

In 2001 West Yorkshire Police watched a group of about 40 men attend a training camp organized by two known extremists. Stills taken from video footage of the camp were shown to sources, and nine of the 40 were identified. Khan was not among the nine. Only after July 2005, when police went back through their files, did they find that one of the images, a clear shot, was of him.

Between July and September 2001 Khan traveled to Pakistan with another man from Beeston, who later admitted at his own trial that the two of them had received terrorist training during the trip. In July 2003 Khan made a second journey to Pakistan with another Beeston man, who later testified that Khan used the name Ibrahim on the trip. In Pakistan they met Omar Khyam, later at the center of the Crevice investigation, and a man who became an informant and later gave evidence that Khan and Khyam had both attended a terrorist training camp in the Malakand area. The 2009 parliamentary review concluded that Khan had trained in Pakistan on at least two occasions and possibly in Afghanistan.

For a short time Khan and Tanweer also served as trustees of the Iqra bookshop in Beeston, a registered charity set up as a learning and community center. Khan withdrew from it, probably in early 2003. The coroner later found no evidence that the bookshop had been a base for unlawful activity.

On April 14, 2003, a joint West Yorkshire Police and MI5 surveillance team following a known extremist saw him given a short lift in a car registered to a Sidique Khan. The contact was not thought significant, and the surveillance report was not passed on to MI5. During 2003 a mobile telephone linked to the suspected leader of an al-Qaeda support network in Luton was also used to call a number registered to a Siddique Khan; MI5 could not match the name to anyone in its records, and the calls were filed as routine.

Early in 2004 MI5 was running Operation Crevice, an investigation into a group around Omar Khyam, at first thought to be a courier for a network supporting al-Qaeda in Pakistan. On February 2, 2004, surveillance officers watched Khyam meet three men the service had not seen before. The officers photographed the three and followed their car back to West Yorkshire. The three were filed as unidentified males C, D and E. E was Khan; D was Tanweer.

Within days the picture of Khyam changed. MI5 learned that he had both the intent and the capability to mount an attack in Britain, and he became the service's top priority. Over the following six weeks the Crevice group was seen in contact with more than 4,000 telephone contacts and more than 1,100 vehicles. Among them, on February 28 and March 23, 2004, were Khan and Tanweer. After the attacks it also emerged that Khan had met the group on February 21, 2004, a meeting MI5 did not see at the time.

What MI5 heard on those occasions shaped everything that followed. Khan and Tanweer talked about fraud and about travel to Pakistan; they did not discuss attacks in Britain. MI5 categorized them as "desirable" rather than essential targets: worth identifying when resources allowed, not worth diverting officers from men known to be planning attacks. Checks on the car produced the name Sidique Khan, a Batley address and his date of birth, and those details were run against MI5 and police databases without result. In all, Khan's name had turned up in different spellings, linked to different addresses, phones and cars, in several separate records, and nobody connected them.

Members of the Crevice group were arrested in March 2004. On August 12, 2004, the informant, by then a detainee, was shown a set of surveillance photographs that included the men MI5 called D and E. He did not name either of them. The clearest image MI5 held of Khan, a color photograph taken in February 2004, was never shown to him in full.

In November 2004 Khan and Tanweer flew to Pakistan together. Khan was expected back in January 2005; the two returned in February. A later review found no evidence that Khan and Tanweer had been directly involved in the Crevice plot.

Between January and March 2005, MI5 received reliable intelligence about two men from Batley, one called Saddique and the other Imran, who were said to have trained in Afghanistan in the late 1990s or early 2000s. MI5 believed Saddique had a different surname from Khan. No investigative steps were taken to identify him after March 1, 2005, partly because of his low profile and partly for operational reasons that cannot be disclosed. In April 2005 MI5 opened another operation to identify the two men the informant had called Ibrahim and Zubair; it had produced nothing by July.

On the morning of July 7, 2005, four attacks on the London transport network killed 52 people and injured more than 700.

Six people died at Edgware Road, where Khan himself died: Michael Stanley Brewster of Derby, Jonathan Downey of Milton Keynes, David Foulkes of Oldham, Colin Morley of Finchley, Jennifer Nicholson of Reading and Laura Webb of Islington. The coroner later concluded, on the balance of probabilities, that none of the 52 could have been saved whatever time the emergency services had reached them.

The four men were identified within a week. Evidence gathered in the first two days linked Khan and Tanweer to the attacks by name, and on July 9 a check of intelligence databases found that the name Mohammed Sidique Khan had appeared during Operation Crevice. On July 11 Khan, Tanweer and Hussain became the principal suspects, and police searched premises in West Yorkshire under the Terrorism Act. Lindsay was linked to the others the following day. By July 16 the evidence had established where each man died; for Khan, it was Edgware Road. On July 14 the informant who had failed to name Khan from the surveillance photographs identified him from a press photograph as the man he had known in Pakistan as Ibrahim.

Three men from Beeston were later charged with conspiring with the four; after a first jury at Kingston Crown Court failed to agree in 2008, a retrial jury acquitted all three of that charge on April 28, 2009, though two were convicted of a separate count of conspiring to attend a place used for terrorist training.

The second review by Parliament's Intelligence and Security Committee, "Could 7/7 Have Been Prevented?," presented in May 2009, set out every known contact between the authorities and Khan, from the 1993 caution to the 2004 meetings. It found that with the time and resources to do so, MI5 could have connected the scattered references to Khan, but that it would still have had nothing to show he was planning attacks in Britain, and it judged the decisions of 2004 and 2005 understandable and reasonable on the information then held.

The inquests were the first public examination of the attacks and the events leading up to them. Their verdicts, returned on May 6, 2011, named no one: each of the 52 had been unlawfully killed. Khan is named in the coroner's report under Rule 43 of the Coroners Rules 1984, issued the same day. She explained that she named the four men there because they were dead and no proceedings could be prejudiced, because the question of preventability could not be examined without stating that they were responsible, and because the evidence was overwhelming. She dismissed suggestions that the four had been falsely implicated, and found that they were full and knowing parties to the plot, possibly aided by an unidentified individual in Pakistan, with no evidence that anyone else in Britain had been involved on the day.

On MI5, the coroner found that the evidence did not justify the conclusion that any failings of any organization or individual had caused or contributed to the deaths, and that there was no evidence that MI5 knew of the attacks and failed to prevent them. She also found that the 2009 parliamentary report contained significant errors, including its statement that the 2005 intelligence about Saddique could not be corroborated or investigated.

Khan was never tried, and the findings against him are those of a coroner's report and of two parliamentary reviews, not of a criminal court. The coroner nevertheless found the evidence that he and the other three carried out the killings overwhelming and rejected every theory that they had been framed.

No court found that anyone else in Britain helped the four men; the three Beeston men accused of doing so were acquitted of that charge. The coroner found that an unidentified man in Pakistan may have aided the plot; he has never been identified.

Whether MI5 could have stopped Khan remains contested in emphasis rather than in fact. The 2009 parliamentary review found the decisions of 2004 and 2005 reasonable; the coroner found no failing that caused or contributed to the deaths but identified errors in that review.

Timeline

October 20, 1974: Khan is born in Leeds.

1993: A man named Sidique Khan receives a police caution for assault in West Yorkshire.

1997: Khan begins studying at Leeds Metropolitan University.

March 2001: He starts work as a learning mentor at Hillside Primary School, Beeston.

2001: West Yorkshire Police observe a training camp attended by about 40 men; Khan, later found among them, is not identified.

July to September 2001: Khan travels to Pakistan with a Beeston man who later admitted they received terrorist training.

April 14, 2003: A car registered to a Sidique Khan is seen during a joint police and MI5 surveillance operation.

July 2003: Khan travels to Pakistan, using the name Ibrahim, and meets Omar Khyam.

February 2, 21 and 28, and March 23, 2004: Khan meets members of the Crevice group; MI5 sees three of the meetings.

August 12, 2004: A detainee shown surveillance photographs does not name Khan.

November 2004: Khan and Tanweer fly to Pakistan; they return in February 2005.

December 2004: Khan leaves his post at Hillside Primary School.

January to March 2005: MI5 receives intelligence about a man called Saddique from Batley; no steps are taken to identify him after March 1.

July 7, 2005: Fifty-two people are killed in the London attacks; Khan dies at Edgware Road.

July 9, 2005: A database check links Khan's name to Operation Crevice.

July 14, 2005: The informant identifies Khan from a press photograph as Ibrahim.

April 28, 2009: Three Beeston men are acquitted at retrial of conspiring with the four.

May 2009: The Intelligence and Security Committee publishes "Could 7/7 Have Been Prevented?"

October 11, 2010: Evidence begins at the inquests into the 52 deaths.

May 6, 2011: Verdicts of unlawful killing are returned for all 52; the coroner issues her Rule 43 report naming the four men.