Mohammad Afzal Guru

Victims
9 killed in the 2001 attack on India's Parliament. Convicted of conspiracy to murder and waging war against India as a conspirator, not an attacker; executed 2013
Years active
December 13, 2001
Location
New Delhi, India (killings; trial; execution); Srinagar, Jammu and Kashmir, India (arrest); Sopore area, Baramulla district, Jammu and Kashmir, India (birthplace)
Method
Shooting and bombing by five attackers (court finding); he was convicted as a conspirator, not an attacker
Status
Sentenced to death December 18, 2002; upheld by Delhi High Court (2003), Supreme Court (2005); curative plea denied 2007; mercy plea rejected 2013. Executed in New Delhi, February 9, 2013.

On December 13, 2001, five men forced their way into the grounds of the Parliament of India in New Delhi while both houses were in session. By the time it was over all five were dead, and so were nine of the people on duty around the building, eight of them security personnel. Sixteen more were hurt.

Mohammad Afzal Guru was nowhere near the building that day. He was a former militant from the Kashmir Valley who worked between Srinagar and Delhi, and within two days he was in police custody. The prosecution's case was that he had been the attackers' link in the capital. A special court under India's new anti-terrorism law sentenced him to death in December 2002, and the Delhi High Court upheld that sentence in October 2003. On August 4, 2005, the Supreme Court of India confirmed it on a conviction for criminal conspiracy to murder and for waging war against the Government of India, while throwing out much of the rest of the case built against him and his co-accused. After more than seven years in which his mercy petition moved from one office to another, he was executed in New Delhi on February 9, 2013.

Afzal Guru came from a village near Sopore, a fruit-growing town in Baramulla district in the north of the Kashmir Valley. His exact date of birth is not on record. He finished his schooling in Sopore and began training as a doctor at a medical college in the valley, then left the course partway through.

By his own account to the trial court, he joined a militant outfit in 1989 or 1990, at the start of the armed uprising against Indian rule in Kashmir, and crossed the Line of Control to Muzaffarabad, on the Pakistan-administered side. The group was the Jammu Kashmir Liberation Front. He told the court that he later completed his graduation and surrendered to the Border Security Force. The Supreme Court's judgment calls him, in its own words, "a surrendered militant." By 2001 he was running a commission agency in fruit and traveling regularly between Srinagar and the capital.

The investigation fell to the Special Cell of the Delhi Police, and it moved fast. On December 15, 2001, Srinagar police detained Afzal Guru and his cousin, Shaukat Hussain Guru, and the Delhi Police took custody of both men the same day. The defense later disputed the timing and circumstances of the arrest, and Afzal Guru told the trial court that he had been arrested alone. The Supreme Court considered that dispute and accepted the arrest as proved.

Two more people were arrested in the same inquiry, a woman and a Delhi University lecturer; both were later acquitted. The police said Afzal Guru identified the five dead attackers. Charges under the Prevention of Terrorism Ordinance, the emergency measure that preceded the Prevention of Terrorism Act, were added within the week, and a senior officer of the Delhi Police recorded what the prosecution presented as his confession. It was that confession, more than anything else, that would be fought over for the next four years.

The prosecution alleged a conspiracy run through Jaish-e-Mohammed and Lashkar-e-Taiba, directed from outside India by men who were never brought to trial in India and were declared proclaimed offenders.

The trial opened in July 2002 before a Designated Court set up under the Prevention of Terrorism Act in New Delhi. It was the first case to reach judgment under the Act.

Afzal Guru had not engaged a lawyer, and the court appointed counsel for him at state expense. When he was examined under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the stage at which an accused answers the evidence in his own words, he accepted parts of the prosecution's account of his movements in Delhi and denied the rest. He said he knew nothing of the attack and denied any tie to Jaish-e-Mohammed or its leaders. He said that he had been tortured after he was brought to Delhi, that he had signed blank papers, and that he had made no confession to the officer who recorded it.

The court delivered its verdict on December 16, 2002, and passed sentence two days later. Afzal Guru, Shaukat Hussain Guru and the lecturer were convicted of waging war against the state, conspiring and preparing to do so, criminal conspiracy to commit murder and attempted murder, and offenses under the Prevention of Terrorism Act and an Act of 1908. All three were sentenced to death, and each was fined Rs 5 lakh, to be paid to the families of those killed. The fourth accused, the woman, was convicted only of concealing a design to wage war and sentenced to five years.

A division bench of the Delhi High Court heard the confirmation proceedings together with the appeals of all four accused and appeals by the state. It had already ruled that transcripts of intercepted telephone calls, a central part of the prosecution's case, could not be used, because the police had not followed the procedure the anti-terrorism law laid down.

On October 29, 2003, the bench dismissed the appeals of Afzal Guru and Shaukat Hussain Guru and confirmed their death sentences, and on the state's appeal added a death sentence for waging war. It acquitted the lecturer and the woman of all charges.

A bench of two judges of the Supreme Court decided the appeals on August 4, 2005, in a ruling that runs to more than a hundred pages.

The court dealt first with the confession. Under the anti-terrorism law, a confession made to a senior police officer could be used against the person who made it, but only if the law's safeguards had been observed. The court found that they had not. Afzal Guru had not been told of his right to consult a lawyer, no relative had been properly informed of his arrest, and after the confession he had been sent back to police custody rather than to judicial custody. The time he had been given to reflect before confessing was, in the court's words, "by all standards, utterly inadequate." It concluded that "it is not safe to act on the alleged confessional statement of Afzal," and set the confession aside entirely. It held, too, that one accused's confession could not be used against another. On the intercepted calls, it differed from the High Court and held that the evidence was not inadmissible.

With the confession out of the case, the court examined what it called "the circumstantial evidence against Afzal independent of and irrespective of the confession": witnesses who identified him, records connecting him with one of the attackers in the weeks before the attack, and his identification of the five dead men. Taken together, it held, those circumstances proved that he had been a party to the conspiracy.

It drew the limits of that conspiracy carefully. Without the confession, the judgment said, "there is no evidence that he is a member of a terrorist gang or a terrorist organization," and it set aside his conviction under Section 3(5) of the anti-terrorism law. It set aside his conviction under Section 3(2) and reduced his sentence under that law to life imprisonment under Section 3(3), for conspiracy. It set aside one of the two convictions under the 1908 Act and left the other. It upheld the convictions for conspiring to wage war and for waging war, and it upheld the death sentence for criminal conspiracy to murder under Section 120B read with Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code. "We dismiss the appeal filed by Mohd. Afzal," the judgment concluded, "and the death sentence imposed upon him is hereby confirmed."

His lawyers had also argued that he had been denied an effective defense at trial. The court found nothing to show that the advocates the trial court appointed were ineffective, and held that the right to legal aid did not extend to choosing which state-paid lawyer would represent him.

For Shaukat Hussain Guru the result was very different. The court acquitted him of conspiracy and of waging war and convicted him only of failing to report what he knew of the plan, with a sentence of ten years' rigorous imprisonment. It upheld both acquittals by the High Court.

On January 12, 2007, a bench of four judges headed by the Chief Justice of India dismissed his curative petition, the last remedy the Supreme Court allows once an appeal has been decided. With that order, the courts were closed to him.

The execution had by then already been ordered once. On September 26, 2006, a sessions court in New Delhi fixed it for October 20. A mercy petition was filed on his behalf with President A.P.J. Abdul Kalam in early October, and the date was put on hold.

The petition then waited. The Home Ministry referred it to the government of Delhi, where the crime had been committed, and the file stayed there for nearly four years before the Lieutenant Governor of Delhi sent it back in 2010. In 2008 Afzal Guru had himself asked the government to carry out the sentence rather than leave him waiting.

The file was still open when Pranab Mukherjee became President. On February 3, 2013, he rejected the petition, and Afzal Guru was executed in New Delhi six days later, on February 9, 2013.

Afzal Guru was tried under the Prevention of Terrorism Act, 2002, which replaced the ordinance and came into force on March 28, 2002, after the attack but before his trial. The Supreme Court found that bringing his case under the ordinance was not done in bad faith and that the sanction to prosecute was valid. The Act's exception to the ordinary rule that a confession to a police officer cannot be proved, the provision on which his confession depended, was the one whose safeguards the court found ignored. The Act was repealed in 2004.

Whether his trial and execution were fair was argued for years, by critics who pointed to his court-appointed defense and the secrecy of the execution, and by courts that rejected his complaints and upheld the conviction.

His own account at trial, that he had been tortured, had signed blank papers and had made no confession, was never accepted by any court. Neither was the prosecution's allegation that he belonged to Jaish-e-Mohammed: the Supreme Court found no evidence of membership once the confession was set aside. The men the prosecution described as the plot's directors were never tried in India.

Timeline

1989 to 1990: By his own account, joins a militant outfit and crosses to Muzaffarabad.

December 13, 2001: Five attackers enter the Parliament complex in New Delhi; nine people are killed and all five attackers die.

December 15, 2001: Arrested in Srinagar with Shaukat Hussain Guru and handed to the Delhi Police.

December 16, 2002: Convicted by the Designated Court in New Delhi of conspiracy to murder, waging war and other offenses.

December 18, 2002: Sentenced to death.

October 29, 2003: Delhi High Court confirms his death sentence and acquits two co-accused.

August 4, 2005: Supreme Court of India confirms the death sentence for criminal conspiracy to murder and sets aside parts of the conviction.

September 26, 2006: A sessions court fixes his execution for October 20, 2006.

October 2006: Mercy petition filed with the President; the execution is put on hold.

January 12, 2007: Supreme Court dismisses his curative petition.

February 3, 2013: President Pranab Mukherjee rejects the mercy petition.

February 9, 2013: Executed in New Delhi.