Mohamed Merah

Victims
7 people killed in Toulouse and Montauban, 2012; never tried. He died March 22, 2012; his older brother was convicted on appeal in 2019 of complicity in the seven murders
Years active
March 11 to March 19, 2012
Location
Toulouse and Montauban, Haute-Garonne and Tarn-et-Garonne, France
Method
Seven murders, attributed; treated by French courts as terrorist crimes
Status
Died March 22, 2012, untried. Brother: 30 years' réclusion criminelle on appeal (2019), final 2020

Over eight days in March 2012, seven people died in Toulouse and the nearby garrison town of Montauban, in southwestern France. Three were soldiers. The other four, three children and a teacher, all of them Jewish, died at a school in Toulouse on March 19. The deaths are attributed to Mohamed Merah, a 23-year-old from Toulouse who had been known to the police since his teens and to the domestic intelligence service for more than two years.

Merah never stood trial. He died in Toulouse on March 22, 2012, three days after the school deaths, and with his death any case against him came to an end. What courts did decide came later, and it concerned someone else: his older brother, who was tried twice in Paris before a special assize court of professional judges. The first court, in 2017, convicted the brother of terrorist conspiracy and acquitted him of complicity in the killings. The appeal court, in 2019, convicted him of complicity in all seven murders, and that judgment became final in April 2020. It is the closest the French justice system came to a ruling on the man held responsible for the deaths.

Mohamed Merah was born in Toulouse on October 10, 1988, a French citizen. He grew up in Les Izards, a neighborhood in the north of the city, where he played football. He trained in car bodywork and mechanics.

He had served two short prison terms between 2007 and 2009.

Twice he tried to join the armed forces. In January 2008, at 19, he applied to the French army in Lille and passed the tests, but was turned away after an inquiry into his criminal record. In 2010 he went to the Foreign Legion's recruitment center in Toulouse, spent a night there and left of his own accord the next day.

After his last prison term, Merah traveled widely, to the Middle East and, twice, to Afghanistan and Pakistan. The domestic intelligence service first flagged him as a possible threat in December 2009, in a period when he was in regular contact with his older brother, then living in Egypt. In November 2011, officers of the service interviewed him after his return from Afghanistan.

The first death came on Sunday, March 11, 2012, in Toulouse. Imad Ibn Ziaten, a staff sergeant in the 1st Parachute Transport Regiment, died that day in the city.

Four days later, on Thursday, March 15, two more soldiers died in Montauban, north of Toulouse: Abel Chennouf and Mohamed Legouad. A third soldier was wounded and survived. Both men who died in Montauban served in the 17th Parachute Engineer Regiment, whose garrison is in the town.

On Monday, March 19, four people died at a school in Toulouse: a teacher, Jonathan Sandler, and three children, Arié, Gabriel and Myriam. A teenage boy was wounded and survived. All four who died were Jewish.

By March 21, 2012, Merah had been named as the suspect, and the Paris prosecutor said the inquiry would examine whether anyone else had been involved in preparing the killings. He died in Toulouse on March 22, 2012, at 23. His older brother was arrested in the days that followed.

With his death, the case against the man held responsible for the seven deaths could go no further. The investigation that remained concerned the people around him.

His older brother was charged in Paris on March 25, 2012, and held in custody. In November 2017 the cour d'assises spéciale de Paris convicted him of "association de malfaiteurs terroriste criminelle" and acquitted him of complicity in the murders, sentencing him to 20 years of réclusion criminelle with a two-thirds security period; on April 18, 2019, ruling on appeal, the same court convicted him of "complicité" in the seven murders and sentenced him to 30 years of réclusion criminelle with a two-thirds security period, a judgment made final when the Cour de cassation rejected his appeal on April 22, 2020.

The appeal court's finding is the only judicial statement on the seven deaths. In convicting the brother as an accomplice, it treated the murders as committed in March 2012 by Mohamed Merah, and it held that the brother had been fully informed of the criminal plans. That finding was made in the brother's case, not after any trial of Merah himself.

No court ever tried Mohamed Merah, and no verdict was ever passed on him. The seven deaths are attributed to him by the investigation and, indirectly, by the 2019 appeal judgment that convicted his brother of complicity in murders it treated as his. The two courts that heard the brother's case reached opposite conclusions on complicity: in 2017 the judges found insufficient material evidence that he knew the murders would be committed, and in 2019 the appeal judges found that he did. At his first trial the brother denied knowing of the plans. The appeal ruling stands as the final word in law.

Timeline

October 10, 1988: Mohamed Merah is born in Toulouse.

2007 to 2009: He serves two short prison terms.

January 2008: The French army turns down his application in Lille over his criminal record.

December 2009: The domestic intelligence service first flags him as a possible threat.

2010: He spends one night at the Foreign Legion's recruitment center in Toulouse and leaves.

November 2011: Intelligence officers interview him after a trip to Afghanistan.

March 11, 2012: A soldier dies in Toulouse.

March 15, 2012: Two soldiers die in Montauban; a third is wounded.

March 19, 2012: A teacher and three children die at a school in Toulouse; a teenage boy is wounded.

March 21, 2012: Merah is named as the suspect in all three incidents.

March 22, 2012: Merah dies in Toulouse, untried.

March 25, 2012: His older brother is charged in Paris and held in custody.

November 2, 2017: The cour d'assises spéciale de Paris convicts the brother of terrorist criminal conspiracy, acquits him of complicity, and sentences him to 20 years.

March 25, 2019: The appeal trial opens in Paris.

April 18, 2019: On appeal, the brother is convicted of complicity in the seven murders and sentenced to 30 years.

April 22, 2020: The Cour de cassation rejects the brother's appeal, and the judgment becomes final.