For about seventeen days in the late spring of 1992, Miroslav Kvočka went to work at a camp outside the village of Omarska, in the municipality of Prijedor in northwestern Bosnia and Herzegovina. He was a professional police officer, a Bosnian Serb who had served at the Omarska police station since 1981. The camp where he now worked his shifts held non-Serb prisoners. Judges of the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia later found that more than 3,334 people passed through it between late May and about August 20, 1992, that almost all of them were mistreated, and that many did not leave it alive.
On November 2, 2001, Trial Chamber I of the tribunal convicted Kvočka, as a co-perpetrator of the joint criminal enterprise of Omarska camp, of persecutions on political, racial or religious grounds as a crime against humanity, and of murder and torture as violations of the laws or customs of war. He was sentenced to seven years' imprisonment. On February 28, 2005, the Appeals Chamber reversed part of the persecution conviction and two of the four murder findings, affirmed his conviction for the murders of two detainees, and left the seven-year sentence in place. A month later the tribunal's president granted him early release. He had been in the tribunal's custody, with one break, since April 1998.
Kvočka was born on January 1, 1957, in the village of Marićka, in Prijedor municipality, and the Trial Chamber recorded that he was of Serb ethnicity. In 1992 he lived in the village of Omarska with his wife, who was Muslim, and their two children. He told the court that he had never belonged to a nationalist party and that he had supported the Reformist Party.
He began working as a policeman in Omarska in 1981. The Omarska police station department was attached to the Public Security Service of Prijedor municipality, and Kvočka served there through the years before the war. The Trial Chamber accepted that he had kept law and order well before the camp existed. It also found that, even before the camp opened, he held a de facto position at the station that paralleled that of a deputy or assistant commander, although he had no formal rank.
The tribunal's findings set the events at Omarska inside a larger sequence. On April 30, 1992, Serb forces took control of the town of Prijedor. Muslims and Bosnian Croats were removed from positions of responsibility soon afterward. Many lost their jobs, their children were kept out of school, and the radio broadcast propaganda against Muslims and Croats. When the non-Serb communities resisted, Serb forces attacked. The village of Hambarine was taken on May 23, 1992, and the town of Kozarac the next day. A Muslim attempt to regain control of Prijedor failed on May 30.
Non-Serbs who might pose a threat were questioned and arrested, in particular anyone who held authority of any kind, moral, political or economic. Men were separated from women, children and the elderly. Those who had not left the region were gathered into three camps: Omarska, Keraterm and Trnopolje. The Trial Chamber found that Omarska was officially established on May 30, 1992, by Simo Drljača.
Omarska was planned to operate for about two weeks. It stayed open until about August 20, 1992. The Trial Chamber found that all those held there were interrogated, that almost all were abused, that the mistreatment was constant and widespread, and that there was no part of the camp where a prisoner could feel safe. Some of the roughly thirty-six women held there, many of them prominent in local affairs, were molested or raped. The camps, the Trial Chamber found, were neither an accident nor an improvisation: they were the product of an intentional policy to impose a system of discrimination against the non-Serb population of Prijedor.
Kvočka was called to the camp on about May 28 or 29, 1992, and the Trial Chamber found that he was given authority to call up reserve police officers to serve there as guards. He served as duty officer, a direct subordinate of the camp commander, Željko Meakić, with the task of carrying out Meakić's orders and supervising the guards. The guards worked in three shifts, and Kvočka was not one of the shift leaders.
The judges found that he held a position in the camp from about May 29 to June 23, 1992, with periods of official leave from June 2 to June 6 and from June 16 to June 19. That came to about seventeen days of service and about twenty shifts. He was not, the Trial Chamber held, a low-level official at the very bottom of the ladder. Detainees saw him as a superior, guards deferred to him, and he gave orders that the guards obeyed. Several former prisoners testified that the camp was calmer when he was present. The Trial Chamber found that his authority came mainly from his years of police experience, and that he acted as the functional equivalent of the deputy commander of the guard service, with some degree of authority over the guards.
The court did not find that he had planned the camps or decided to open them. It also found insufficient evidence that he had personally committed the crimes for which he was tried, although he was present when crimes were committed. On several occasions he intervened: he stopped one intruder from harming detainees, removed an intoxicated man from the compound, called for help, and obtained medical supplies. The judges weighed those acts and concluded that he could have done far more to relieve the conditions in the camp, and that the vast majority of the instances in which he helped involved relatives or friends.
Among the prisoners at Omarska were three of his wife's brothers. In about the third week of June 1992 Kvočka took them out of the camp. The Trial Chamber found that he was removed from his post on about June 22 or 23 as a result, and that on June 24 he was ordered to bring them back, which explained why witnesses saw him in the camp that day. Before he left, he asked two other men at the camp to look after his brothers-in-law. The judges described this as a personal request rather than a professional command, and noted that he took no comparable step for the detainees as a whole.
He was reassigned to the reserve police station at Tukovi on June 30, 1992, and served there until September. Kvočka told the court that he had been relieved because he was not regarded as sufficiently anti-Muslim. The Trial Chamber found no evidence that Serbs who tried to help detainees were punished, and noted that another man who left the camp of his own accord did not lose his job. Kvočka himself said that, had he been given the choice, he would have stayed at the camp until it closed. One of his brothers-in-law was later placed in a category marked for transfer to the Manjača camp and, Kvočka testified years afterward, avoided it through his own connections.
The murder count against Kvočka rested on deaths inside Omarska during the weeks he worked there. The Trial Chamber's findings, as the Appeals Chamber read them, covered four deaths. Two of those findings were reversed on appeal and form no part of his conviction. The two that stand are the core of his conviction for murder.
Mehmedalija Nasić was a detainee at Omarska. A surviving prisoner testified that a guard killed him inside the camp in the presence of other detainees, and that Kvočka was standing beside the guard. Kvočka accepted that the killing had happened, said he had been elsewhere, and told the court he had reported it to the camp commander. The Trial Chamber accepted the survivor's account, and the Appeals Chamber found that Kvočka had done no more than offer his own reading of the evidence in place of the trial judges'.
Bećir Medunjanin came from Kozarac. Before the attack on the town he sat in the Party of Democratic Action delegation that held talks with the Serbian Democratic Party in Prijedor. A witness at the tribunal's first trial, in 1996, recalled him speaking at one such meeting as the representative of Kozarac, questioning the demands the Serb side was putting to his community, and closing with a promise that the Bosniaks of Kozarac would not provoke them and that he would carry the Serb party's position back home. He was brought to Omarska in June 1992, and a witness placed his death there on June 16 or 17. Kvočka argued that he knew nothing of it and that he had been on leave when the death occurred. The Appeals Chamber held that he was responsible. A co-accused, Zoran Žigić, was also convicted of this murder, and that conviction too was affirmed on appeal.
The tribunal first indicted Kvočka on February 13, 1995, in an indictment that named nineteen men in connection with the Omarska camp, among them the camp commander, and charged him as a superior who knew or had reason to know what his subordinates were doing.
He remained at liberty in Bosnia for more than three years. On April 8, 1998, troops of the NATO-led Stabilisation Force, SFOR, detained him and another Omarska defendant, Mlađo Radić, a professional policeman who had been one of the camp's shift leaders. Both men were transferred to the tribunal the next day and taken into its Detention Unit in The Hague. At his initial appearance on April 14, 1998, Kvočka pleaded not guilty to all charges.
In November 1998 the Omarska and Keraterm indictments against the four men then in custody, Kvočka, Radić, Milojica Kos and Žigić, were consolidated, and the new indictment added a charge of persecutions of Bosnian Muslims, Bosnian Croats and other non-Serbs in the Prijedor area as a crime against humanity. Kvočka was now charged both as a superior and as an individual. A fifth accused, Dragoljub Prcać, a retired police crime technician who had served as an administrative aide to the camp commander, was detained by SFOR in March 2000, and his case was joined to the others.
The trial opened in The Hague on February 28, 2000, before Trial Chamber I, and after Prcać's arrest it resumed with five accused on May 2, 2000.
Early in the trial the judges took judicial notice, largely by agreement of the parties, that at the relevant times and places there was an armed conflict, that it included a widespread and systematic attack against the Muslim and Croat civilian population, and that the Omarska, Keraterm and Trnopolje camps and the mistreatment of their prisoners were connected to that attack. The defense did not, for the most part, dispute the legal character of what had happened in the camps. It contested the role of each accused.
On December 15, 2000, the Trial Chamber acquitted Kvočka and three of his co-accused of the crimes charged at Keraterm and Trnopolje, finding that no evidence had been offered of any role they had played in those camps. From then on the case against him concerned Omarska alone.
Kvočka testified. He told the Chamber that he had been a duty officer with no official function and no specific responsibility, that he had witnessed some acts of violence but had never taken part in them, and that he had tried to help people, his brothers-in-law above all. A recorded interview he had given to the prosecution was also admitted into evidence.
The Trial Chamber delivered judgment on November 2, 2001. It found that each of the five accused had known full well what was happening at Omarska and had taken part in the camp's system of persecution. On Kvočka it held that his participation "was not only knowing, it was willing," that his contribution to the functioning of the camp was "significant," and that he "had the intent to discriminate against the non-Serbs detained in the camp." It found him a co-perpetrator of the joint criminal enterprise of Omarska camp.
He was convicted of persecutions as a crime against humanity, and of murder and torture as violations of the laws or customs of war. His remaining charges were dismissed because they were subsumed in those convictions. The Chamber held that he did not bear superior responsibility, because it was not satisfied that he had effective control over the guards who committed particular crimes.
The Chamber accepted that Kvočka was normally of good character and treated his record as a capable officer as a mitigating factor; it treated the same experience as aggravating once he held a position of authority in the camp. It imposed a single sentence of seven years' imprisonment, with credit for the time he had spent in custody since April 8, 1998. The other sentences were six years for Kos, twenty for Radić, twenty-five for Žigić and five for Prcać. The prosecution did not appeal Kvočka's sentence.
Kvočka appealed against his conviction and sentence. On December 17, 2003, the Appeals Chamber granted him provisional release pending its judgment, on conditions that included a duty to return to the tribunal when ordered, and he left the Detention Unit two days later.
The Appeals Chamber delivered its judgment on February 28, 2005. It dismissed the grounds Kvočka shared with his co-appellants. It agreed that joint criminal enterprise had not been pleaded in the indictment, but found that the prosecution had given the defense timely, clear and consistent notice of the theory. It upheld the admission of his interview with the prosecution and rejected his challenge to the finding that he acted as a de facto deputy, holding that a formal place in the hierarchy was immaterial to his liability. It found that a reasonable trier of fact could infer that he shared the intent of the enterprise from his authority, his knowledge of the crimes and his continued participation.
On the murders the Appeals Chamber held that the Trial Chamber had limited his responsibility to crimes committed while he was employed at the camp, from about May 29 to June 23, 1992, whether or not he was physically present at a given moment, and that a participant in a joint criminal enterprise need not take part in each killing. Applying that limit, it found that the Trial Chamber had erred in holding him responsible for the death of Ahil Dedić, which the prosecution accepted may have occurred hours before he began his duties, and that no reasonable trier of fact could have held him responsible for the death of Ismet Hodžić. It reversed both findings and affirmed his murder conviction for the other two deaths.
On persecution, the Appeals Chamber held that harassment, humiliation and psychological abuse could amount to persecution, and that in his case the intent to contribute to the enterprise and discriminatory intent were one and the same. It found, though, that the Trial Chamber had not determined whether the rapes and sexual assaults on which it relied had occurred while he was employed at the camp, and it reversed his persecution conviction in so far as it related to rape and sexual assault. It affirmed the rest of the persecution conviction and dismissed his remaining grounds against conviction.
His appeal against sentence failed. The Appeals Chamber found that the Trial Chamber had taken his character, his professional standing and the help he gave his brothers-in-law into account, and that a comparison with sentences in other camp cases did not show error. It concluded that the reversals touched particular incidents rather than whole counts, and that the overall picture of his conduct had not changed enough to justify intervention, given the gravity of the offenses and his important role in supporting and furthering the enterprise. The seven-year sentence was affirmed.
Kvočka applied for early release after the appeal judgment. The tribunal's president granted the application on March 30, 2005, noting that he had served two-thirds of his sentence, and he was released from the Detention Unit in The Hague.
Kvočka returned to the tribunal in January 2014, this time as a defense witness for Radovan Karadžić, the wartime leader of the Bosnian Serbs, whose trial included the crimes in Prijedor. His written statement was admitted, and in it he described having worked as a policeman in Omarska since 1981 and having tried to protect Muslim acquaintances and his wife's brothers. Under cross-examination on January 20, 2014, he agreed that he had been tried, convicted and sentenced to seven years, and he accepted the figure of seventeen days at the camp. He told the court that the abuses at Omarska had been individual incidents rather than the rule, involving only a few guards, and that he had learned of the rapes and sexual abuse of women detainees only later. Confronted with the findings of his own trial and his earlier statements, which described abuse beginning as soon as the camp opened, he conceded that his knowledge of much of what happened came from talk among prisoners and guards, and that he could not say with certainty what was true of the period after he left.
His exact title at the camp was contested from the first indictment to the appeal. The 1995 indictment alleged that he had briefly commanded Omarska and then served as one of two deputy commanders, and survivors regarded him as the deputy commander. The defense said he had been an ordinary guard or a duty officer without authority, and that the camp had no formal commander and therefore no deputy. The Trial Chamber settled on the functional equivalent of the deputy commander of the guard service and declined to find him a superior.
The length of his service was also argued. The courts found about seventeen days and about twenty shifts; at the appeal hearing the defense counted about twelve shifts.
When he was detained in 1998, Human Rights Watch said that testimony it had gathered in 1992 identified him as one of three men chiefly responsible for torturing prisoners at Omarska. The Trial Chamber found insufficient evidence that he had physically committed any of the crimes charged, and his conviction for torture rests on his participation in the joint criminal enterprise.
In his 2014 testimony Kvočka maintained that the crimes at Omarska were not organized or permitted by the camp authorities. Both chambers of the tribunal had rejected that position and found the camp to be the product of an intentional policy of discrimination.
January 1, 1957: Born in Marićka, Prijedor municipality.
1981: Begins work as a policeman in Omarska.
April 30, 1992: Serb forces take control of Prijedor.
About May 28 or 29, 1992: Called to the Omarska camp.
May 30, 1992: Omarska camp officially established.
June 2 to June 6 and June 16 to June 19, 1992: On official leave from the camp.
About June 22 or 23, 1992: Removed from his post after taking his wife's brothers out of the camp.
June 30, 1992: Takes up duty at the Tukovi reserve police station.
About August 20, 1992: Omarska camp ceases to operate.
February 13, 1995: Named in the ICTY's Omarska indictment.
April 8, 1998: Detained by SFOR; transferred to The Hague the next day.
April 14, 1998: Pleads not guilty at his initial appearance.
November 1998: Consolidated indictment adds a persecution charge.
February 28, 2000: Trial opens before Trial Chamber I.
December 15, 2000: Acquitted of all charges concerning Keraterm and Trnopolje.
November 2, 2001: Convicted of persecutions, murder and torture; sentenced to seven years.
December 19, 2003: Provisionally released pending appeal.
February 28, 2005: Appeals Chamber reverses two murder findings and part of the persecution conviction and affirms the seven-year sentence.
March 30, 2005: Granted early release.
January 20, 2014: Testifies as a defense witness in the trial of Radovan Karadžić.