On January 25, 1993, two men died outside the headquarters of the Central Intelligence Agency in Langley, Virginia, and three more were wounded. Both of the dead were employees of the agency. The man later convicted of the killings, Mir Aimal Kasi, was a Pakistani national who had been living a few miles away in Reston and driving for a courier service. He left the United States the next day. For four and a half years he was out of reach, most of that time in Afghanistan, while the FBI kept him on its list of the Ten Most Wanted Fugitives and the State Department offered a reward of $2 million for him.
FBI agents took him into custody in Pakistan on June 15, 1997, and flew him to Virginia. On the flight he waived his rights and confessed. In November 1997 a jury in the Circuit Court of Fairfax County convicted him on all ten counts of the indictment, among them capital murder and first-degree murder, and fixed his punishment at death. The Supreme Court of Virginia affirmed the convictions and the sentence in 1998. Federal courts rejected his challenge to the way he had been brought to the United States, and the United States Supreme Court refused to stop the execution. He was executed at Jarratt, Virginia, on November 14, 2002, aged 38.
Kasi came from Quetta, in the Pakistani province of Balochistan, and held a master's degree in English from Balochistan University.
The spelling of his name followed him through the case. He was known in the United States as Mir Aimal Kansi, and that was the name on the FBI's wanted list and in the first news of his arrest. The indictment named him Mir Aimal Kasi, and he signed his confession "Kasi." He later said the version on his visa had been a misprint. The courts used Kasi throughout.
By early 1993 he was living in Reston, in Fairfax County, sharing quarters with a friend from Pakistan and working as a driver for a local courier service.
Frank Darling had grown up in southeastern Pennsylvania, where he served as a volunteer firefighter and rose to the rank of lieutenant. He spent four years of his working life overseas, in Europe and the Middle East. Colleagues described him as an adviser, a confidant and a leader, a man with an "uncanny ability to solve complex problems." He had married shortly before his death.
Dr. Lansing Bennett had volunteered for the Marine Corps in 1944 and spent thirteen months on Guam. In Duxbury, Massachusetts, where he spent more than two decades, he chaired the town's conservation commission and helped secure more than 1,200 acres of conservation land and a bylaw protecting its wetlands. Friends from his college years remembered a whimsical streak and a love of sailing; he cruised the New England coast for years in his yawl, the Wind Chimes. He spent much of his later life in postings abroad.
Three other men were wounded. All three survived.
The killings took place outside the main entrance to the agency's grounds, in the part of Fairfax County known as Langley. The Supreme Court of Virginia later described the act as deliberate, and the FBI and the CIA never found evidence that tied Kasi to any organized group. The next day, January 26, 1993, he flew out of the United States to Pakistan.
Within weeks, investigators had a name. On February 8, 1993, police acting with the consent of the man Kasi had lived with recovered evidence from their quarters in Reston that matched the killings. On February 16 a Fairfax County grand jury indicted him for capital murder, murder, malicious wounding and offenses under the state's arms law, and a federal warrant charged him with unlawful flight to avoid prosecution. The FBI added him to its Ten Most Wanted list, and on April 7, 1993, the United States asked Pakistan to extradite him. Nothing came of the request. For the next four and a half years Kasi moved between Pakistan and Afghanistan, spending most of the period in and around Kandahar.
On June 15, 1997, FBI agents took him into custody in Dera Ghazi Khan, in the Pakistani province of Punjab, and two days later he was flown to Virginia.
On the flight he signed a written waiver of his rights and then gave the lead FBI agent an oral statement and afterward a written one, admitting the killings. He said that he had acted out of anger at American policy toward Muslim countries.
Before trial the judge refused to suppress the confession or to move the trial out of Northern Virginia. He granted the defense one point: the prosecution could not call Kasi a terrorist in front of the jury, because there was no evidence linking him to any terrorist group.
The trial began in Fairfax in early November 1997. Kasi pleaded not guilty to every charge. The prosecution's case rested on the evidence recovered in Reston, his flight the next day and the confession he had signed on the plane. On November 10 the jury found him guilty on all ten counts: capital murder of one of the dead men, as the willful, deliberate and premeditated killing of more than one person as part of the same act or transaction; first-degree murder of the other; malicious wounding of each of the three survivors; and five counts of use of a firearm in the commission of a felony.
Two days later four Americans were killed in Karachi, and the jurors told the judge they feared for their safety. He sequestered them and refused a defense motion for a mistrial. He questioned the jurors as a group and then one juror on her own, after she said she had heard part of a radio report; she told him it would not affect her judgment.
The same jury then heard the case on punishment. Under Virginia law it could return a death sentence only on a finding that the defendant posed a future danger to society or that his conduct had been vile, and both questions went to it. The defense called medical experts who testified that Kasi had lesions on his brain, and it argued that he was mentally ill and should not be put to death. The widow of one of the dead men, who had testified at the guilt stage, testified again about the effect of her husband's death.
The jury fixed the punishment for the capital murder at death on the ground of vileness alone. It did not find that Kasi posed a future danger. For the remaining counts it fixed life imprisonment and a $100,000 fine for the first-degree murder, twenty years and a $100,000 fine on each count of malicious wounding, and two years on one firearm count and four years on each of the other four. The trial judge imposed the sentences the jury had fixed, final judgment on all counts was entered on February 4, 1998, and Kasi was moved to Virginia's death row.
On November 6, 1998, the Supreme Court of Virginia affirmed the convictions and the death sentence, rejecting his challenges to the confession, to his removal from Pakistan without extradition and to the refusal to move the trial, among others. The United States Supreme Court declined to review the case in 1999. The Supreme Court of Virginia dismissed his petition for habeas corpus, and in 2000 the United States Supreme Court again declined review. The United States District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia dismissed his federal habeas petition in 2002. On August 15, 2002, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit dismissed his appeal, finding that the Virginia courts had not unreasonably applied federal law to his abduction, his subpoenas to the FBI and the CIA, or the jury.
The government of Pakistan asked the Governor of Virginia to commute the sentence to life imprisonment. On November 12, 2002, the Lahore High Court dismissed a petition asking it to stay the execution. On November 14 the United States Supreme Court refused to block the execution, and the Governor denied clemency the same day. Mir Aimal Kasi was executed later that day at Jarratt, Virginia. He was 38.
How Kasi was found remains partly unexplained. Pakistan never acknowledged a part in the capture, the United States never said who had helped or whether the reward was paid, and the record before the courts did not disclose what role any foreign government had played.
His mental state was argued but never resolved in his favor. The defense presented evidence of brain lesions at the penalty stage, and his lawyers had suggested an insanity defense, but no court found him insane or incompetent, and the jury, which heard the medical evidence, chose death.
No court found that he belonged to any organized group. Accounts also differ on when in November 1997 the penalty hearing began and the death verdict came, and on whether the judge imposed sentence in January 1998 or on February 4, 1998, the date of the final judgment.
January 25, 1993: Two men killed and three wounded outside CIA headquarters in Langley, Fairfax County, Virginia.
January 26, 1993: Kasi leaves the United States for Pakistan.
February 8, 1993: Police recover evidence in Reston with the consent of his roommate.
February 16, 1993: A Fairfax County grand jury indicts him; a federal flight warrant follows.
April 7, 1993: The United States asks Pakistan to extradite him.
June 15, 1997: FBI agents take him into custody in Dera Ghazi Khan, Pakistan.
June 17, 1997: Flown to Virginia; confesses on the flight.
November 10, 1997: Found guilty on all ten counts.
November 12, 1997: Jury sequestered after four Americans are killed in Karachi.
November 1997: The same jury fixes death on the vileness finding.
February 4, 1998: Final judgment entered on all counts.
November 6, 1998: The Supreme Court of Virginia affirms.
1999: The United States Supreme Court denies review of the direct appeal.
2000: The United States Supreme Court denies review of the state habeas ruling.
2002: The federal district court dismisses his habeas petition.
August 15, 2002: The Fourth Circuit dismisses his appeal.
November 12, 2002: The Lahore High Court dismisses a petition to stay the execution.
November 14, 2002: The United States Supreme Court refuses a stay; clemency denied; executed at Jarratt, Virginia.